Volume 270,
Number 7,
Issue of February 17, 1995 pp. 2993-3000
©1995 by The American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Inc.
Glutamic Acid 327
in the Sheep
1 Isoform of
Na
,K
-ATPase Stabilizes a
K
-induced Conformational Change (*)
(Received for publication, October 5, 1994; and in revised form, December 1, 1994)
Theresa A.
Kuntzweiler (§), ,
Earl T.
Wallick
(1),
Carl
L.
Johnson
(1),
Jerry B
Lingrel (¶)
From the Department of Molecular Genetics, Biochemistry, and
Microbiology Department of Pharmacology and Cell
Biophysics, University of Cincinnati, College of Medicine, Cincinnati,
Ohio 45267-0524
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
RESULTS
DISCUSSION
FOOTNOTES
REFERENCES
ABSTRACT
By combining the tools of site-directed mutagenesis and
[
H]ouabain binding, the functional role of
glutamic acid 327 in the fourth transmembrane domain of the sheep
1 isoform of Na
,K
-ATPase was
examined with respect to its interactions with ouabain,
Na
, K
, Mg
, and
inorganic phosphate. Using site-directed mutagenesis, this glutamic
acid was substituted with alanine, aspartic acid, glutamine, and
leucine. The mutant proteins were constructed in a sheep
1 protein
background such that [
H]ouabain binding could be
utilized as a highly specific probe of the exogenous protein expressed
in NIH 3T3 cells. Na
competition of
[
H]ouabain binding to the mutant forms of
Na
,K
-ATPase revealed only slight
alterations in their affinities for Na
and in their
abilities to undergo Na
-induced conformational changes
which inhibit ouabain binding. In contrast, K
competition of [
H]ouabain binding to all
four mutant forms of Na
,K
-ATPase
displayed severely altered interactions between these proteins and
K
. Interestingly, [
H]ouabain
binding to the mutant E327Q was not inhibited by the presence of
K
. This mutant was previously reported to be
functionally able to support cation transport with a 5-fold reduced K
for K
-dependent ATPase
activity (Jewell-Motz, E. A., and Lingrel, J. B.(1993) Biochemistry 32, 13523-13530; Vilsen, B.(1993)
Biochemistry 32,
13340-13349). Thus, it appears that this glutamic acid in the
fourth transmembrane domain may be important for stabilizing a
K
-induced conformation within the catalytic cycle of
Na
,K
-ATPase that is not rate-limiting
in the overall ATPase cycle but that displays a greatly reduced
affinity for ouabain.
INTRODUCTION
The Na
,K
-ATPase (
)is an integral membrane protein found in nearly all
eukaryotic cells that utilizes energy from the hydrolysis of
intracellular ATP to transport three sodium ions out of the cell and
two potassium ions into the cell (1, 2, 3) .
The enzyme is composed of an
subunit containing 8-10
transmembrane domains and a
subunit which has one transmembrane
segment. The catalytic cycle of
Na
,K
-ATPase involves an acid-stable
phosphorylated form of the protein, a characteristic shared by other
active cation transporters such as the sarcoplasmic reticulum
Ca
-ATPase, the plasma membrane
Ca
-ATPase,
H
,K
-ATPase, and
Mg
-ATPase(4, 5, 6, 7) .
Unlike other ATPases, Na
,K
-ATPase is
inhibited by cardiac glycosides such as ouabain.
In recent years,
structure-function studies of
Na
,K
-ATPase have focused on
identifying the amino acids involved in binding and translocating
Na
and K
ions. Both chemical
modification studies and site-directed mutagenesis studies have
targeted anionic amino acid residues located in the transmembrane
domains of the
subunit. These residues contain negatively charged
side chains which are thought to neutralize the cations during
transport through the hydrophobic lipid bilayer. Six oxygen-containing
residues in the transmembrane domains of the sarcoplasmic reticulum
Ca
-ATPase have been implicated as essential amino
acids for Ca
transport using site-directed
mutagenesis(8) . Three of these residues contain carboxylic
acid side chains. These negatively charged residues are conserved in
the Na
,K
-ATPase and include
Glu
, Glu
, and Asp
in the
sheep
1 isoform.
N,N`-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) labels
Na
,K
-ATPase in a K
protectable manner and blocks cation occlusion upon
modification(9) . Hence, DCCD is thought to bind to a residue
essential for potassium occlusion. By combining DCCD labeling and
limited proteolytic digestion, two sites of DCCD modification have been
located within the transmembrane domains (10) . Glutamic acid
953 in the COOH-terminal half of the sheep
1 protein has been
identified as one site of modification and glutamic acid 327 is
hypothesized to be another site of modification. Site-directed
mutagenesis studies, involving Glu
and a neighboring
glutamic acid residue, Glu
, have demonstrated that
altering the charged side chains at these positions does not
dramatically change the cation-dependence properties of ATP hydrolysis
by Na
,K
-ATPase(11) .
Therefore, it is possible that the residue labeled by DCCD in the
NH
-terminal half of the enzyme, Glu
, is the
carboxyl group important for cation occlusion.
Glutamic acid 327 is
located in the fourth transmembrane domain of the
Na
,K
-ATPase and is highly conserved
throughout the amino acid sequences of related
ATPases(4, 5, 6, 7) . Previously,
site-directed mutagenesis was employed to change Glu
to
Gln, Leu, Ala, and Asp(12, 13, 14) . These
mutagenesis studies utilized similar expression schemes which take
advantage of species-specific variations in ouabain sensitivity to
examine the effects of the mutation on cell viability and on the
cation-dependent ATPase activity. These schemes involve introducing the
mutation into a cDNA which encodes a ouabain-resistant isoform of
Na
,K
-ATPase (K
= 1
10
M; i.e. rat
1, sheep
1(RD) (
)or rat
2*(
)), expressing this mutant in a cell line containing
a ouabain-sensitive endogenous form of the ATPase (K
= 1
10
M; COS-1
or HeLa) and selecting for cells expressing the ouabain-resistant
protein by growing the cells in the presence of ouabain (0.2, 1, or 5
µM). An active
Na
,K
-ATPase is essential for the
survival of mammalian cells due to its role in the establishment and
maintenance of the electrochemical gradient across the cell membrane.
By growing these transfected cells in the presence of ouabain, the
endogenous Na
,K
-ATPase is inhibited,
and only the exogenous ATPase can produce the essential cation
gradient. Only if the transfected cDNA encodes for an active enzyme
will cells be viable in ouabain. The mutant forms of
Na
,K
-ATPase, E327Q and E327L, were
able to transport cations, produce an electrochemical gradient, and
maintain cell viability. The mutants E327D and E327A were unable to
support cell viability in the presence of ouabain. The
cation-dependence of Na
,K
-ATPase
activity was examined in the presence of 1
10
M ouabain for mutant proteins E327L and E327Q. The
mutant E327L demonstrated a 4-fold higher K
for
Na
and a 2-fold higher K
for
K
than the wild type protein. The mutant E327Q
displayed a 2-fold higher K
for Na
and a 3-6-fold higher K
for
K
than the wild type ATPase. From these small changes
in the K
values, it was concluded that the
charge of this glutamic acid side chain was not essential for ATPase
activity. However, based on the cell viability results, the length of
the side chain was suggested to be important sterically in the
enzymatic cycle. Although these original site-directed mutagenesis
studies revealed some important facts about the glutamic acid at
position 327, the mechanistic step (i.e. cation binding or
conformational changes) that the substitutions E327D and E327A disrupt
was not identified, since these mutant enzymes were inactive and could
not be examined.
In order to study both inactive and active mutant
enzymes, we have examined the cation-enzyme interactions of
Na
,K
-ATPase by observing the effects
of Na
and K
on ouabain binding to the
enzyme. The affinity of the
Na
,K
-ATPase for cardiac glycosides is
closely linked to enzyme cycling. Two assay environments which are
known to induce high affinity ouabain binding to the enzyme are
Mg
, ATP, and Na
or Mg
and P
(15, 16) . Both of these
conditions promote formation of a phosphorylated form of the enzyme (E2-P) which is cation-sensitive. Thus, the role specific
amino acids play in binding cations during the catalytic cycle of
Na
,K
-ATPase may be probed by studying
the effects of cations on [
H]ouabain binding to
mutant forms of the Na
,K
-ATPase.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
Materials
Molecular biology reagents were
purchased from New England Biolabs, Amersham Corp., Pharmacia, Promega,
and Qiagen. Cell culture supplies were obtained from Life Technologies,
Inc. and Fisher. [
H]ouabain was purchased from
DuPont NEN. The specific radioactivity of the
[
H]ouabain was determined as described
previously(17) . Scintillation fluid was purchased from
Research Products International Corp. All other reagents (NaCl, KCl,
Tris base, HCl, phosphoric acid, MgCl
, and ouabain) were of
the highest quality available.
Site-directed Mutagenesis
Eukaryotic expression
vectors, pKC4, containing either the wild type sheep
Na
,K
-ATPase cDNA or a mutant cDNA
were constructed as described previously(18) . Briefly, a
cassette from the coding region of the sheep
Na
,K
-ATPase
1 subunit cDNA was
subcloned into the bacteriophage M13. The cassette contained an
847-base pair (bp) XbaI-PstI fragment including the
region encoding amino acid resides 230-512. The Kunkel (19) method of site-directed mutagenesis was used to introduce
the desired mutations into the cassette. Cassettes containing the
appropriate mutations were sequenced in their entirety to screen for
unwanted mutations. These cassettes were subcloned back into the
context of the wild type sheep
Na
,K
-ATPase
1 subunit cDNA in
the pKC4 expression vector. Final constructs were analyzed by
restriction analysis, as well as by sequencing across the mutated site.
All plasmids were purified on Qiagen columns prior to their use for
transfection.
Transfection of NIH 3T3 Cells
NIH 3T3 cells were
maintained in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium containing
10% calf serum as described elsewhere(18) . Cotransfection of
NIH 3T3 cells with 20 µg of plasmid DNA containing a 20:1 molar
ratio of pKC4 vector to pSKNeoA was performed using a modified calcium
phosphate procedure(20) . Two days after transfection the cells
were split 1:100 and selected in 400 µg/ml G418. After 10 days, 10
colonies for each mutant form of sheep
1 were isolated and
expanded into stable cell lines.
Sequence Analysis of Genomic DNA Isolated from Clonal NIH
3T3 Cell Lines
Genomic DNA was isolated from the
neomycin-resistant cell lines cotransfected with pKC4 containing the
mutant sheep
1 cDNAs and pSKNeoA. A polymerase chain reaction
(PCR) was used to amplify an 821-bp fragment containing the mutated
codon at position 1258-1260 bp. The primers utilized in the PRC
reactions were designed to span a region which contains exons
8-11 in the genomic sequence of
Na
,K
-ATPase. Thus, a product of the
appropriate size (821 bp) was generated from the exogenous sheep
1
Na
,K
-ATPase cDNA and not from the
endogenous mouse DNA. The PCR fragments were sequenced on an Applied
Biosystems model 373 DNA sequenator (Applied Biosystems, Inc., Foster
City, CA) using the Taq DyeDeoxy Sequencing protocol with dye-labeled
terminators.
Isolation of Crude Plasma Membranes from NIH 3T3
Cells
Crude plasma membranes were isolated from transfected NIH
3T3 cells as described by Schultheis et al.(21) .
Thirty confluent 150-mm tissue culture dishes were used for each NaI
preparation. Between five and eight preparations of two clonal lines of
each mutant were required to complete the
[
H]ouabain binding studies presented here. A
modified Lowry procedure was used to determine the protein
concentration of each membrane preparation(22) .The crude
plasma membrane preparations from NIH 3T3 cell lines were analyzed by
Western immunoblotting. The proteins contained in the membrane
preparations were resolved on a 10% SDS-polyacrylamide gel,
electrophoretically transferred onto nitrocellulose, and stained with
the monoclonal antibody M7-PB-E9 and an antimouse horseradish
peroxidase-conjugated secondary antibody. M7-PB-E9 was raised against
lamb kidney Na
,K
-ATPase and is
subunit specific such that it distinguishes the transfected sheep
1 isoform from the endogenous mouse
1
subunit(23, 24) . M7-PB-E9 was a generous gift from
the laboratory of Dr. W. J. Ball (University of Cincinnati).
[
H]Ouabain Binding to Crude
Membrane Fragments
All ouabain binding studies were conducted
under the following conditions unless otherwise indicated in the figure
or table legends: 5 mM MgCl
, 5 mM Tris-phosphate, 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4) in a final volume
of 0.5 ml. The samples were incubated for 6 h at 37 °C. The amount
of protein used was dependent on the specific activity of the membrane
preparation. Typically, 20-100 µg of total protein was
present in each assay tube. Experiments were carried out in disposable
plastic tubes. For the competition curves with unlabeled ouabain, eight
concentrations of unlabeled ouabain (including zero) were examined in
triplicate. The concentrations of unlabeled ouabain are indicated on
the x axis of Fig. 2. The concentration of
[
H]ouabain was set at approximately 3
nM; however, aliquots of the reaction mixtures were taken with
each experiment to determine the exact concentration of
[
H]ouabain used. Ligand and enzyme concentrations
were adjusted such that no more than 10% of the added ouabain was
bound. Thus, the free ligand concentration was essentially equal to the
added ouabain concentration in all of the experiments presented, and
the total concentration of ouabain was used in place of the free
concentration in the equations used to analyze the competition data.
Following incubation, the samples were aspirated onto glass fiber
filters using a Brandel M24R cell harvester. The filters were washed
four times with 5 ml of cold water. Filters were placed in RPI
Budget-solve and counted in a Packard 2000 CA Scintillation counter
with an efficiency of 42%. Monovalent cation inhibition experiments
were conducted under the same incubation conditions described above
unless otherwise indicated in the figure legends. Eleven to 15
concentrations of each cation (including zero) were used in duplicate
to define the inhibition curves. The [
H]ouabain
concentration in the cation competition experiments was set at
approximately 10 nM; however, the exact concentration was
measured for each experimental mix and adjusted in the curve fits. Data
were plotted and fit to either a simple Hill equation (n
, n
, and AC
values) or to a cooperative model (K
and K
values) (see figure legends) using KaleidaGraph
by Abelbeck Software. The results presented in Fig. 2Fig. 3Fig. 4have been normalized such that
the maximum binding in the absence of competitor (unlabeled ouabain,
Na
, or K
, respectively) was set at
100% to account for varying expression levels of the proteins.
Figure 2:
Ouabain competition curves.
[
H]Ouabain binding was measured in the absence
and presence of various concentrations of unlabeled ouabain as shown on
the x axis. The symbols represent the mean of triplicate
determinations. The error was calculated for each point and is shown
unless it is smaller than the symbol size. Assay conditions were as
described under ``Experimental Procedures,'' except for E327D
which was assayed in the presence of 15 mM Tris-P
and 10 mM MgCl
. Symbol representation is as
follows:
, wild type sheep
1;
, E327Q;
,
E327D;
, E327L; and
, E327A. The data were fit to a
simple self-competition model:

where [I] is the
concentration of unlabeled ouabain, E
is
the amount of enzyme, [O] is the concentration of
[
H]ouabain, and NS is the
proportionality constant for nonspecific binding. Three adjustable
parameters were calculated for each curve and include K
(dissociation constant), E
and NS. The fitted parameters
were calculated: wild type sheep
1 (K
= 1.51 ± 0.18 nM; E
= 0.106 ± 0.003
nM; NS = 0.000343 ± 0.000012); E327Q (K
= 4.06 ± 0.35
nM; E
= 0.130 ±
0.004 nM; NS = 0.000322 ± 0.0000096); E327D (K
= 12.5 ± 0.8
nM; E
= 0.268 ±
0.009 nM; NS = 0.000379 ± 0.0000146); E327L (K
= 2.87 ± 0.31
nM; E
= 0.142 ±
0.004 nM; NS = 0.000470 ± 0.0000143); E327A (K
= 1.67 ± 0.13
nM; E
= 0.110 ±
0.004 nM; NS = 0.000365 ±
0.000012).
Figure 3:
Na
competition curves.
[
H]Ouabain binding was measured for isolated
membranes in the absence and presence of various concentrations of NaCl
as shown on the x axis. The symbols represent the mean of
duplicate determinations. The error bars represent the range of the
duplicate determinations and are not shown if smaller than the symbol
size. The assay conditions were as described under ``Experimental
Procedures,'' except for E327D which was assayed in the presence
of 15 mM Tris-P
and 10 mM MgCl
. The symbol representation is as follows:
, wild type sheep
1;
, E327Q;
, E327D;
, E327L; and
, E327A. The curves displaying the data of
E327Q and the wild type were fit to a competitive model involving three
Na
sites:

where K
is the dissociation constant for ouabain obtained from the
ouabain competition experiments (Fig. 2) and [O] is
the concentration of [
H]ouabain. E327D, E327L,
and E327A were fit to a similar competitive equation involving two
Na
sites such that the fourth term in the denominator
of this equation was eliminated. The two adjustable parameters
calculated were: K
, (Na
inhibition constant) and E
(amount
of ouabain-binding sites). The fitted values obtained were: wild type
sheep
1 (K
= 15.7 ±
0.1 mM; E
= 0.241
± 0.003 nM); E327Q (K
= 20.8 ± 0.3 mM; E
= 0.167 ± 0.003 nM); E327D (K
= 7.51 ± 0.16
mM; E
= 0.359 ±
0.008 nM); E327L (K
=
19.2 ± 0.4 mM; E
=
0.106 ± 0.002 nM); and E327A (K
= 24.2 ± 0.4 mM; E
= 0.289 ± 0.003
nM).
Figure 4:
K
-Induced effects on
ouabain binding. [
H]Ouabain binding was measured
in NaI-treated membranes in the presence of various concentrations of
KCl as shown on the x axis. The symbols represent the mean of
duplicate determinations. The error bars represent the range
of the duplicate determinations and are not shown if smaller than the
symbol size. The assay conditions were (5 mM P
and
5 mM Mg
) as described under
``Experimental Procedures.'' The assay conditions for the inset data were the same with the exception that the
Mg
concentration was 10 mM and the
Tris-P
concentration was 15 mM. The symbol
representation is as follows:
, wild type sheep
1;
,
E327Q;
, E327D;
, E327L; and
, E327A. The amount
of bound [
H]ouabain (B) as a function of
K
concentration was calculated with the following
equation:

where E
is the total enzyme concentration,
[O] is the concentration of [
H]ouabain,
is the interaction factor of inhibition, and NS is the
proportionality constant for nonspecific binding. Fitted parameters for
the inhibition phase were: wild type sheep
1 (at 5 mM P
and 5 mM Mg
) (K
= 1.02 ± 0.03
mM; E
= 0.115 ±
0.002 nM;
= 10.1 ± 0.2); E327A (at 5
mM P
and 5 mM Mg
) (K
= 0.879 ± 0.009
mM; E
= 0.117 ±
0.003 nM;
= 2.76 ± 0.11); E327L (at 5
mM P
and 5 mM Mg
) (K
= 1.18 ± 0.07
mM; E
= 0.139 ±
0.003 nM;
= 3.35 ± 0.11); wild type sheep
1 (at 15 mM P
and 10 mM Mg
) (K
=
1.17 ± 0.06 mM; E
= 0.112 ± 0.002 nM;
=
12.9 ± 0.3). Fitted parameters for the activation phases: E327A (K
= 84 ± 28 mM;
= 1.40 ± 0.31); E327D (at 5 mM P
and 5 mM Mg
) (AC
=
2.71 ± 0.54 mM); E327D (at 15 mM P
and 10 mM Mg
) (AC
= 2.23 ± 0.51 mM). K
values for E327A were calculated by fitting both the
inhibition and the activation phase of these data to the following
equation:

where
is the
interaction factor of activation. Data describing the KCl effects on
E327Q were not fit to any activation or inhibition models, and a smooth
curve was drawn through the data.
[
H]Ouabain Binding to Whole NIH 3T3
Cells
Neomycin-resistant cell lines were distributed onto
24-well plates with approximately 2.5
10
cells/well. Six wells of each cell line were plated and allowed
to grow for 2 days prior to [
H]ouabain binding.
[
H]ouabain binding to transfected 3T3 cells was
measured by incubating the cells in 0.5 ml of
K
/Ca
-free buffer containing 60
nM [
H]ouabain (for total binding) or 60
nM [
H]ouabain plus 1 µM unlabeled ouabain (for nonspecific binding) at 37 °C for 30
min. The details of this procedure have been described
elsewhere(25) .
RESULTS
Expression of Glu
Mutants
Previous
site-directed mutagenesis studies have produced conflicting conclusions
concerning the importance of Glu
in the mechanism of
Na
,K
-ATPase(11, 12, 13, 14) .
Based solely on the inability of E327A and E327D to support cell
viability, it might be concluded that Glu
is functionally
essential. However, E327Q and E327L yield active enzymes suggesting
that this residue may not be essential. In order to compare all 4
Glu
substitutions in the same system, each mutant was
remade in a ouabain-sensitive protein and characterized with respect to
its ability to interact with Na
and K
using [
H]ouabain binding as a probe. This
system of characterizing the mutant proteins is not dependent on the
Na
,K
-ATPase being catalytically
active.The mutations were constructed in a sheep
1 cDNA which
encodes a ouabain-sensitive enzyme, and these cDNAs were transfected
into NIH 3T3 cells containing an endogenous protein with a low affinity
for ouabain. The exogenous proteins bind ouabain with a 1000-fold
higher affinity than the endogenous enzyme. Thus, at the low
concentrations of [
H]ouabain utilized in these
experiments, there is no interference from the binding of
[
H]ouabain to the endogenous
Na
,K
-ATPase(21) . Since the
exogenous protein is ouabain sensitive, no selectable function is
conferred to the cells upon expression of these cDNAs; therefore, an
alternative to ouabain selection was required. The mutated cDNAs were
cotransfected with a gene which codes for a neomycin resistance protein
and selected in 400 µg/ml of G418. cDNAs encoding all four
substitutions (E327A, E327D, E327Q, and E327L) were transfected into
NIH 3T3 cells, and clonal cell lines were established for each mutant.
Western analysis of crude membrane preparations from these cell lines
indicated that the sheep
1 proteins (wild type and mutants) were
being expressed. To establish that the transfected cDNAs were
integrated into the cell genome, genomic DNA was isolated from each
clonal cell line. Using sheep
1-specific primers, PCR was employed
to amplify a region of the DNA which encodes amino acids 230-512
of the exogenous DNA. The DNA fragment from each cell line was
sequenced and revealed a single altered codon which encoded the desired
amino acid at position 327. No additional mutations were detected in
the DNA fragment surrounding the mutated codon.
[
H]Ouabain binding to intact 3T3 cells was
performed to establish that the mutant sheep
1 enzymes were
located in the plasma membrane. Fig. 1presents the amount of
[
H]ouabain (60 nM) bound/mg of total
protein for untransfected NIH 3T3 cells and for two clonal cell lines
of each mutant and wild type sheep
1
Na
,K
-ATPase. The nonspecific binding
(NS) of [
H]ouabain (60 nM) to each cell
line was measured in the presence of 1 µM unlabeled
ouabain. From these data, one can see that the cell lines which express
sheep
1 proteins (mutant or wild type) bind 5-10-fold more
[
H]ouabain/mg of total protein than the
untransfected 3T3 cells and at least 4-fold more than nonspecific
binding. The presence of [
H]ouabain binding in
the mutant cell lines reveals that at least some of the translated
mutant sheep
1 protein is located in the plasma membranes of these
clonal cell lines. Moreover, the [
H]ouabain
binding to intact cells indicates that the mutant proteins are
assembled with an extracellular protein conformation sufficiently
similar to the native sheep
1 protein to permit ouabain binding.
The variation in maximum binding levels for each mutant cell line may
be due to different expression levels, secondary to variable
insertional sites of the transfected cDNAs in the genomic DNA. It is
interesting to note that E327L has the lowest expression level in 3T3
cells as measured by [
H]ouabain binding to whole
cells, yet it is translated at high enough levels in HeLa cells to
support viability. Thus, it does not appear that the lower expression
levels of the mutant sheep
1 proteins are the result of the amino
acid substitution interrupting the protein processing steps of
Na
,K
-ATPase.
Figure 1:
[
H]Ouabain
binding to intact NIH 3T3 cells. The amount of
[
H]ouabain/mg of total protein is displayed for
the clonal 3T3 cells expressing wild type sheep
1 protein (WT), untransfected NIH 3T3 cells (3T3), and clonal
3T3 lines expressing E327A, E327Q, E327D, and E327L. The maximum values
represent the amount of 60 nM [
H]ouabain
bound to intact cells in the presence of
K
/Ca
-free buffer with respect to the
total protein within these cells. Nonspecific binding (NS) to
the intact 3T3 cells was also measured in identical conditions with the
addition of 1 µM unlabeled ouabain. WT-NS, A-NS, Q-NS, D-NS, and L-NS display
the nonspecific binding observed for the clonal cell lines expressing
wild type sheep
1 Na
,K
-ATPase,
E327A, E327Q, E327D, and E327L, respectively. The values were obtained
by averaging the amounts bound from three separate experiments
performed in triplicate for two clonal cell lines of each
mutant.
Ouabain Competition Curves in Glu
Mutants
In the presence of Mg
and
P
, the wild type
Na
,K
-ATPase maintains a protein
conformation which binds ouabain with high affinity. Monovalent cations
(Na
and K
) inhibit ouabain binding
under these conditions, presumably by inducing a conformational change
in the enzyme that results in a markedly reduced affinity for ouabain.
Prior to studying these cation-induced conformational changes, the
affinity of each mutant for ouabain was determined in the presence of
Mg
and P
. Competition curves were carried
out using [
H]ouabain and unlabeled ouabain and
the data were fit to a simple self-competition model. Fig. 2shows a comparison of the ouabain competition curves for
one membrane preparation from each Glu
mutant and the
wild type isoform. The mean K
values obtained for
three different preparations of wild type and three different mutant
membrane preparations for each substitution are presented in Table 1. Under these binding conditions, the E327A mutation did
not significantly affect the affinity of the enzyme for ouabain.
However, the amino acid substitutions E327L, E327Q, and E327D increased
the K
of the enzyme for ouabain by 1.6-, 2.9-, and
2.1-fold, respectively. Nonspecific binding expressed as a percentage
of total binding was less than 1.26 ± 0.34% for all membrane
preparations. This nonspecific binding was due to
[
H]ouabain binding to the filters and was
independent of the enzyme concentration in the binding study. These
initial studies demonstrated that all the mutants are able to form a
protein conformation which has a high affinity for ouabain in the
presence of Mg
and P
.
Sodium Inhibition Curves for Wild Type and Glu
Mutant Forms of
Na
,K
-ATPase
In the presence of
Mg
and P
,
[
H]ouabain binding to sheep
1
Na
,K
-ATPase (expressed in 3T3 cells
or purified from sheep kidney) is decreased to the same extent by
saturating concentrations of Na
as by saturating
concentrations of unlabeled ouabain(16) .
Na
-induced inhibition curves for the Glu
mutants are presented in Fig. 3. These data represent a
single curve for one membrane preparation from each mutant cell line
and one from a wild type sheep
1 cell line. Na
competition experiments were conducted with at least three
different membrane preparations of each mutant. Na
inhibition data were initially fit to a simple Hill equation from
which a Hill coefficient for Na
was determined for
each mutant. These coefficients reflect the number of Na
ions which interact with the proteins to inhibit the binding of
[
H]ouabain and, thus, were used to define the
number of Na
terms utilized in the competition models.
Na
inhibition data from E327A, E327L, and E327D were
fit to a competition equation involving two Na
ions
whereas data from E327Q and the sheep
1 wild type were fit to a
competition model involving three Na
ions (see legend
to Fig. 3). E327A, E327L, and E327Q all demonstrated a slight
increase in K
values for Na
inhibition of [
H]ouabain binding as
compared to the wild type enzyme (Table 1). In contrast, E327D
displayed a slightly lower K
value for
Na
effects on [
H]ouabain binding
than that observed for the sheep
1 enzyme. All curves exhibited a
complete inhibition of [
H]ouabain binding at
saturating concentrations of Na
. Thus, it appears that
all of the Glu
mutant proteins have relatively unaltered
affinities for Na
(K
values
increased only 2-fold) and are able to undergo
Na
-induced conformational changes which reduce ouabain
binding (all display apparent simple competitive inhibition).The
effects of increasing ionic strength on
[
H]ouabain binding were examined in a series of
equilibrium binding assays with increasing concentrations of choline
chloride. Similar to previous studies(26) , choline chloride
concentrations above 150 mM inhibited
[
H]ouabain binding to both mutant and wild type
Na
,K
-ATPase membrane preparations
(data not presented). IC
values obtained from fitting
these data to a simple Hill equation were approximately 195-210
mM for both the wild type and the mutant forms of the ATPase.
Therefore, the effects of Na
and K
observed at cation concentrations
100 mM can only be
explained through specific interactions of these monovalent cations
with the enzyme and do not reflect inhibition due to elevated ionic
strength.
Potassium Competition Curves for Wild Type and
Glu
Mutant Forms of
Na
,K
-ATPase
The wild type
sheep
1 protein (expressed in 3T3 cells or purified from sheep
kidney) was previously demonstrated to have a reduced affinity for
[
H]ouabain when K
was present in
the Mg
-P
medium(16, 26) . An example of the effects of
K
on [
H]ouabain binding to the
Glu
mutants is presented in Fig. 4. The
K
-induced effects range from inhibition to activation
of ouabain binding. The data presented are from one membrane
preparation of each mutant; however, these K
curves
were repeated eight times with at least four different membrane
preparations and two separate clonal cell lines. The
K
-effects presented in Fig. 4are highly
reproducible and reflect the effects of the amino acid substitutions on
the interaction between Na
,K
-ATPase
and ouabain. The nonspecific binding was similar to that described
under the ouabain competition results.Previously, a partially
competitive model for K
effects on
[
H]ouabain binding to wild type sheep
1
protein was used to describe the incomplete inhibition of ouabain
binding at saturating K
concentrations(26) .
The data obtained for the wild type sheep
1 enzyme and for the
K
inhibition phase of E327L and E327A fit this model
(see Fig. 4legend). The Hill coefficients and the K
values characterizing the K
inhibition of ouabain binding to E327L and E327A are presented in Table 1. The potassium K
values are
approximately 1 mM for E327L and E327A, similar to the K
value for the wild type
Na
,K
-ATPase. Unlike the wild type and
E327L proteins, higher concentrations of K
(
10
mM) stimulate [
H]ouabain binding to the
mutant E327A protein. This increase in [
H]ouabain
binding is characterized by a K
value of 84
± 28 mM and a Hill coefficient of 0.97 ± 0.35.
Generally, it appears that both E327A and E327L bind low concentrations
of K
in a manner similar to the wild type (similar K
values) and undergo a K
-induced
conformational change which reduces their affinity for
[
H]ouabain.
In contrast to the results with
E327A and E327L, K
did not inhibit
[
H]ouabain binding to the E327Q and E327D
mutants. The effect of K
on E327Q was not fit to any
model. The data describing K
interactions with E327D
demonstrated an increase in [
H]ouabain binding
with increasing concentrations of K
and were fit to a
simple Hill equation yielding a Hill coefficient of 1.9 ± 0.3
and an AC
of 3.14 ± 0.19 mM. Overall, it
appears that either the ability of E327D and E327Q to bind K
has been altered or that these mutants do not undergo the
K
-induced conformational change which normally reduces
the affinity of the enzymes for [
H]ouabain.
Stimulation of [
H]Ouabain Binding
by Mg
and P
Activation of
[
H]ouabain binding to
Na
,K
-ATPase was examined with respect
to Mg
and P
concentrations to ensure that
the amino acid substitutions did not dramatically alter the affinity of
the enzyme for these components. If the enzyme affinity for either
Mg
or P
had been drastically reduced, the
amount of [
H]ouabain bound in the absence of
inhibitor (unlabeled ouabain, Na
, or
K
) would not be dependent solely on the level of
expressed enzyme but also on the number of occupied Mg
or P
sites. As can be seen in Table 1, the
apparent AC
values for Mg
stimulation of
[
H]ouabain binding in the presence of 5 mM P
were between 0.20 and 0.85 mM. The cation
competition curves presented in Fig. 3and Fig. 4were
performed in the presence of 5 mM Mg
. Thus,
all Mg
activation site(s) were saturated in the
absence of monovalent cations.Apparent AC
values for
P
stimulation of [
H]ouabain binding
in the presence of 5 mM Mg
are also
presented in Table 1. These values range from 0.08 to 1.25
mM. Cation competition data presented in Fig. 3and Fig. 4were obtained in 5 mM P
. Thus, all
the inorganic phosphate site(s) which stimulate ouabain binding were
occupied for the mutant proteins E327A, E327L, and E327Q in the absence
of monovalent cations. The E327D mutant demonstrated the largest change
in its AC
value for P
which was approximately
10-fold higher than the wild type
Na
,K
-ATPase. The ouabain,
Na
, and K
competition curves were
therefore repeated in the presence of 15 mM P
and
10 mM Mg
for the E327D mutant enzyme, and
these calculated kinetic constants are reported in Table 1. The
K
competition constants were not significantly changed
by the higher P
and Mg
concentrations for
either the E327D or wild type proteins (see inset of Fig. 4). This is consistent with the concept that the inhibition
of K
is a direct effect and not an indirect effect due
to a change in the degree of saturation by Mg
and/or
P
. Additional K
and Na
inhibition curves at various Mg
and P
concentrations must be done to fully understand the interaction
of all these ions (monovalent or divalent cations or P
)
with the Na
,K
-ATPase. Since all
Mg
and P
activation sites were saturated
in the absence of monovalent cations under these equilibrium condition,
we conclude that the inhibition and activation of
[
H]ouabain binding observed in Fig. 2Fig. 3Fig. 4were due to ouabain,
Na
, and K
, respectively.
DISCUSSION
The exact role that glutamic acid 327 plays in the sheep
1 Na
,K
-ATPase is unknown. ATPase
activity studies characterizing proteins containing amino acid
substitutions at this site have been limited by the nonfunctional
character of some of the mutants. In this work, the cation-protein
interactions of four mutant proteins, E327Q, E327D, E327L, and E327A,
were examined using Na
and K
inhibition of [
H]ouabain binding. This
radiolabeling technique can in principle detect any mutation in the
Na
,K
-ATPase which alters either the
number of cations associated with the enzyme or which alters the
stability of an intermediate within the
Na
,K
-ATPase pathway which is normally
sensitive to cation binding.
Effects of Substitutions on
Na
,K
-ATPase Affinity for
Ouabain
The affinity of
Na
,K
-ATPase for ouabain is slightly
altered by the mutations at Glu
as shown by the ouabain
competition curves. The higher K
values for
ouabain associated with the mutants may reflect small structural
rotations of the H
transmembrane domain. Previously,
tyrosine 308 in the extracellular loop between H
and
H
was shown to alter the affinity of
Na
,K
-ATPase for ouabain(27) .
The substitutions at Glu
may change this putative contact
point of the ouabain receptor site and weaken ouabain binding.
Substitutions of other transmembrane amino acid residues (i.e. Cys
, Tyr
, and Thr
) also
reduce the affinity of Na
,K
-ATPase
for ouabain(12, 28, 29) . Any mutation which
disrupts the three-dimensional orientation of the transmembrane domains
may allosterically influence other residues that compose the binding
site for ouabain and thus affect the affinity of
Na
,K
-ATPase for the drug.
Na
Inhibition of
[
H]Ouabain Binding
Na
inhibits ouabain binding to all four mutants in the presence of
Mg
and P
. Three mutants, E327A, E327D,
and E327L, display an apparent reduction in the number of Na
ions which interact with the enzyme to inhibit ouabain binding (i.e. Hill coefficient
2 rather than 3 as in the case of
wild type and E327Q). This does not correlate with the ability of the
mutants to support cell life. For example, E327L demonstrates a Hill
coefficient of two as probed by inhibition of
[
H]ouabain binding, yet supports viability of
HeLa cells. Thus, it appears that disrupting one inhibitory site for
Na
does not seriously disturb the binding of the
remaining two sodium ions or their inhibitory effect on
[
H]ouabain binding. These observed alterations in
the Hill coefficients may be reflective of altered cation stoichiometry
for the mutant proteins as previously demonstrated under acidic
conditions for purified
Na
,K
-ATPase(30, 31) .
However, it is possible that the reduced number of Na
ions which inhibit ouabain binding does not directly relate to
the number of Na
ions being transported by the mutant
enzymes but simply describes the number of Na
ions
which influence ouabain binding.In addition to altered Hill
coefficients, the K
values for Na
inhibition of ouabain binding were increased nearly 2-fold for
E327L, E327A, and E327Q. Previously, Na
interactions
with E327Q and E327L were investigated using cation-dependent ATPase
assays in the presence of ATP, Mg
, and saturating
concentrations of K
(13, 14) . The K
values for the Na
dependence
of ATPase activity for E327Q and E327L were reported to be 2-fold
higher than that of the wild type ATPase. This similar increase in K
values and K
values for
Na
is consistent with the concept that the
Na
sites which activate the ATPase activity may be
identical to the Na
sites which inhibit ouabain
binding. It appears that substitution of the carboxyl side chain of
Glu
disrupts Na
binding to the enzyme by
either reducing the number of Na
inhibition sites
(E327D, E327L, and E327A) or by increasing the inhibition constant of
Na
(E327Q, E327L, and E327A). No correlation exists
between the inability of E327A and E327D to support cell viability and
their ability to interact with Na
as measured by
inhibition of ouabain binding.
K
Effects on
[
H]Ouabain Binding
Two aspects of the
K
inhibition of [
H]ouabain
binding to native Na
,K
-ATPase were
previously observed(32, 33, 34) and must be
emphasized when interpreting the data on E327L, E327D, E327Q, and
E327A. First, in contrast to the situation with Na
,
even at high concentrations of K
, complete inhibition
of ouabain binding does not occur (i.e. K
never decreases [
H]ouabain binding to
nonspecific levels). This characteristic suggests that ouabain can
bind, albeit with low affinity, to a K
-complexed
ATPase (but not to a Na
-complexed ATPase). Second, the
calculated K
value for K
inhibition of ouabain binding to the wild type sheep
1
protein is consistent with the apparent K
values
for the expressed rat
isoforms as determined by measuring
K
dependence of
Na
,K
-ATPase activity(35) .
This similarity in the values of K
and K
supports the concept that K
inhibition of Mg
-P
supported
ouabain binding is mediated by K
binding to the same
high affinity binding sites utilized by the native enzyme under enzyme
turnover conditions (i.e. in the presence of
Na
, K
, ATP, and
Mg
).The K
inhibition profile for
E327L is similar to that observed for wild type
Na
,K
-ATPase. The inhibition constant
for K
is approximately 2-fold higher than the K
value for K
inhibition of the
wild type and is similar to the K
value
determined for this mutant by K
-dependent ATPase
measurements (K
= 1.24 ± 0.05
mM, K
= 1.25 ± 0.13
mM)(13) . When the K
inhibition data
for E327L was fit to the partially competitive equation (see legend of Fig. 4), the interaction factor (
) was determined to be
3-fold lower than the
for wild type. This change in the
interaction factor is evident in the K
inhibition
profile of E327L as a higher level of [
H]ouabain
is bound at saturating K
concentrations. This is
consistent with the concept that the K
-complexed
mutant enzyme has a higher affinity for ouabain than does the
K
-complexed wild type
Na
,K
-ATPase. Thus, upon the
association of two K
ions with E327L, the mutant
undergoes only a portion of the conformational changes normally induced
by K
and retains an extracellular surface to which
ouabain can bind more readily than to the wild type. E327L with two
K
ions bound also retains sufficient structural
integrity in the membrane such that this mutant can support cell
viability, possibly because other ligand-enzyme interactions compensate
for the defect in the K
-induced conformational change.
For example, E327L exhibits a 5-fold decrease in the K
constant for ATP. (
)
[
H]Ouabain binding to E327Q is
not inhibited by K
. Previously, it was reported that
E327Q demonstrated a 3-6-fold increase in its K
value for K
-stimulated ATPase activit