![]()
|
|
||||||||
(Received for publication, June 3, 1996, and in revised form, July 26, 1996)
From the Medical Service and GRECC, Veterans Affairs Palo Alto
Health Care System and Department of Medicine, Stanford University
School of Medicine, Palo Alto, California 94304
Loss of imprinting of insulin-like growth
factor-II gene (IGF2) and/or loss of heterozygosity at the
11p15 loci have been postulated to be responsible for IGF2
overexpression in Wilms' tumor. In order to delineate the mechanism of
IGF2 overexpression in Wilms' tumors, we have genotyped
the 11p15-11p13 chromosomal region and determined allelic expression
of IGF2 and H19 in both tumor tissue and in
normal adjacent kidney tissue from 40 patients with Wilms' tumor. In
five of the eight subjects informative for the ApaI
IGF2 polymorphism, loss of imprinting of IGF2
was observed in both normal and tumor tissues. A significant increase
(>5-fold) in IGF2 expression in tumor tissues compared to
the normal adjacent kidney tissue was observed regardless of the
IGF2 imprinting or the chromosome 11p15 heterozygosity
status. In each case, the overexpression of IGF2 in the
tumors was accompanied by activation of all four IGF2
promoters. Our data indicate that alterations of IGF2
imprinting occurred in normal adjacent kidney tissue before
tumorigenesis and that the IGF2 overexpression in Wilms'
tumor tissue occurs through a loss of heterozygosity- or loss of
imprinting-independent process.
Wilms' tumor, one of the most common childhood tumors (1:10000,
8% of childhood tumors), is associated with abnormalities in the short
arm of human chromosome 11 (1). Somatic chromosomal events leading to
the loss of constitutional heterozygosity
(LOH)1 of this chromosomal region occur in
30-57% of Wilms' tumors (1, 2, 3). Among the cluster of genes residing
at this chromosomal region that have been implicated in tumorigenesis
are IGF2 and H19. These genes are located within
200 kilobases of each other on chromosome 11p15.5, and both genes are
imprinted. IGF2, spanning ~30 kilobases at this region,
codes for a 67-amino acid mitogenic peptide that plays an important
role in fetal growth and development (4). In most normal human tissues
except for liver and CNS, IGF2 is transcribed exclusively
from the paternally derived allele (5, 6). A number of malignant
tumors, including Wilms' tumor, have been shown to contain abnormally
high levels of IGF2 mRNA, and loss of IGF2
imprinting, where both paternal and maternal alleles are transcribed,
has been observed in many of these tumors (7, 8). The regulation of
IGF2 expression in Wilms' tumor has been studied
extensively as a model system for examining mechanisms of genomic
imprinting and loss of imprinting.
In an earlier study, we quantitated the allelic and promoter-specific
expression of IGF2 in Wilms' tumor, comparing tumors in
which imprinting was lost (LOI) with those in which imprinting was
maintained (MOI, maintenance of imprinting). We demonstrated that while
the normal imprinting of IGF2 is promoter-specific and may
fluctuate during early development, all four IGF2 promoters
are expressed biallelically when there is LOI in Wilms' tumors (9).
Coordinate LOI of all four IGF2 promoters in tumor has also
reported by others (10, 11). IGF2 may act as an autocrine or
paracrine growth factor when it is produced by tumors, potentially
maintaining and enhancing tumor growth (12, 13). It has been suggested
that the increased expression of IGF2 observed in some of
these tumors is associated with, or caused by, the relaxation of
genomic imprinting and the subsequent biallelic expression of the gene.
In theory, biallelic IGF2 expression should lead to
increased mRNA and protein synthesis.
H19 is a gene which is highly expressed during development
in a number of fetal tissues but not in most adult tissues (14, 15, 16). It
is thought that H19 exerts its effects as an RNA molecule
and not as a protein, since there is no significant open reading frame
in the gene (17). In contrast to IGF2, only the maternal
allele of the H19 gene is transcribed (18). Alterations in
H19 imprinting have also been reported in Wilms' tumor (7,
8). Interestingly, loss of imprinting of IGF2 has been
linked to reduced expression and abnormal methylation of H19
in Wilms' tumors (19, 20). A similar linkage of overexpression and LOI
of IGF2 has been found in children with
IGF2-induced overgrowth disorder (21).
In this report we have compared the allelic expression of
IGF2 and H19 in 40 sets of Wilms' tumor
specimens. In order to ascertain the role of LOI and LOH in the
overproduction of IGF2 in Wilms' tumor, we quantitated
IGF2 mRNA levels in the two groups of Wilms' tumors:
LOH and non-LOH (LOI and MOI groups). IGF2 expression was
measured in tumor and in normal adjacent kidney tissue (NAT) from the
same patient. We demonstrate that LOI can be observed in some NAT
samples and that IGF2 expression is increased in all
categories of Wilms' tumor tissues compared to NAT, suggesting that
mechanisms other than LOI and LOH with consequent biallelic expression
of IGF2 can result in increased IGF2 mRNA
abundance in Wilms' tumors.
Forty pairs of
fresh frozen Wilms' tumors and their normal adjacent kidney tissues
were obtained from the Cross Cancer Institute Northern Alberta Cancer
Program. Total nucleic acid (TNA, containing RNA and DNA) was extracted
from fresh frozen tissues as described previously (9). From the TNA
preparations, RNA and DNA were prepared using RNA-DNA STAT (Tel-Test,
Friendswood, TX). RNA was also prepared by simply removing DNA from TNA
using DNase I treatment (9). cDNA was synthesized by RNA reverse
transcription and diluted 10-fold before PCR amplification as described
previously (9).
Eight polymorphisms involving
five genes on chromosome 11 were examined. They were TH-CATT
repeat (22), INS-HphI (23) INS-PstI (24),
IGF2-AluI (25), IGF2-ApaI (26),
H19-AluI (27), H19-RsaI (17), and
WT1-HinfI (28) (see Fig. 1). PCR reaction, restriction
enzyme digestion, electrophoresis, and quantitation analysis were
performed using established methodology as described previously (9, 29,
30). Briefly, PCR amplification for polymorphism determination was
performed in 96-well microtiter plates (MJ Research Inc., Boston, MA),
each 3-µl reaction containing 10-20 ng of DNA for genotyping or
cDNA for examining allelic expression, 50 µM dNTP,
0.2 µM corresponding primers, 0.1 µCi of
[
To
quantitate relative mRNA levels of IGF2 and
H19 in tumors and normal tissues, we simultaneously
amplified cDNAs derived from IGF2, H19, and
18 S rRNA in a multiplex PCR reaction. Variation among PCR reactions
and sampling was therefore minimized. We used a mixture of two sets of
primers of IGF2 (p23-p24) and H19 (p11-p12) at a
0.08 µM final concentration, and an internal control 18 S
rRNA (18SF and 18SR) at a 0.04 µM concentration. The
IGF2 and H19 primers were designed to amplify DNA
crossing intron-exon borders to differentiate genomic DNA and cDNA
products. Amplification and analysis of PCR products were performed as
described above, omitting the restriction digestion.
To compare IGF2
promoter usage in tumor tissues versus NAT, we utilized a
multiplex PCR (9). Tumor and NAT cDNAs were amplified with four
promoter-specific 5 The oligonucleotide primers were:
p1 (5134), 5 LOH in
Wilms' tumor has been located within the 11p15 and 11p13 regions (1,
3). To identify LOH in our 40 subjects with Wilms' tumor, we
determined the allelic genotypes of tyrosine hydroxylase
(TH), insulin (INS), IGF2, and
H19 at 11p15.5, and WT1 at 11p13 in the 40 Wilms' tumor samples and in their paired normal adjacent kidney
tissues (Fig. 1). For each DNA polymorphic site,
undigested alleles were designated as A and digested allele as B. The
TH gene has five major alleles, designated as A (121 bp), B
(117 bp), C (113 bp), D (109 bp), and E (105 bp) (Fig.
2).
Table I shows the DNA polymorphisms found within these
five genes in the 40 pairs of Wilms' tumor and normal adjacent
tissues. Heterozygous specimens were informative for further analysis
of loss of heterozygosity and imprinting status. Among the eight DNA
markers, the most informative site was the TH-CATT repeat
site at which 65% (26/40) of cases were shown to be heterozygous, and
the least informative site was INS-PstI, where only 20%
(8/40) were informative (Table II). We observed eight
paired specimens to be heterozygous for the ApaI
polymorphism of IGF2, and eight pairs for the
H19-AluI polymorphism, which were thus informative for
further examination of genomic imprinting (Table I).
Genotypes of 40 pairs of Wilms' tumor and their norlmal adjacent
tissues
Allele frequency and loss of heterozegosity in 40 pairs of Wilm's
tumors
Volume 271, Number 44,
Issue of November 1, 1996
pp. 27863-27870
©1996 by The American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Inc.

Human Tissue and Nucleic Acid Preparation
-32P]dCTP (Amersham Corp.), 0.125 units of Tfl DNA
polymerase (Epicentre Technologies Corp., Madison, WI) with a hot-start
PCR. The PCR reaction solution was covered with Chill-out 14 liquid wax
(MJ Research) and then heated to 98 °C for 2 min, amplified for
30-35 cycles at 95 °C for 30 s (or 96 °C for 20 s for
INS-PstI and H19-RsaI polymorphisms), and
65 °C for 90 s, followed by a 5-min extension at 72 °C. PCR
products were then digested with a corresponding restriction enzyme
(0.5 unit) in a 10-µl volume at 37 °C for 4 h. Each digested
product was detected or quantitated by PhosphorImager 445SI (Molecular
Dynamics, Sunnyvale, CA) after electrophoresis in a 5% polyacrylamide
urea gel. To quantitate deletion-duplication of LOH, TH-CATT
repeat or IGF2-ApaI, the DNA target, and 18 S fragment were
amplified simultaneously using their 5
primers end-labeled with
[
-32P]ATP in the PCR reaction.
Fig. 1.
Diagrammatic representation of the
TH-INS-IGF2-H19-WT1 region on human chromosome 11 demonstrating restriction enzyme polymorphisms in them and the location
of oligonucleotide primers used for PCR analysis. Primers are
indicated by numbered arrowheads.
[View Larger Version of this Image (26K GIF file)]
primers (p17, p18, p19, and p20) and a common 3
primer (p22) end-labeled with [
-32P]ATP. In the PCR
reaction, the four promoter-specific 5
primers compete with each other
for the one end-labeled 3
primer, thereby reflecting the relative
abundance of the promoter-specific derived transcripts (31). The PCR
conditions were the same as those used for quantitation analysis.
-GGT ATC TGG GCT CTG GGG TGA TTC-3
, p2 (5135), 5
-GGT CAC
AGG GAA CAC AGA CTC CAT G-3
; p3 (5155), 5
-GCC ATC AAG CAG GTC TGT TCC
AAG-3
; p4 (5255), 5
-CTT GGG TGT GTA GAA GAA GCC TCG-3
; p5 (3836),
5
-CCT GCA GAA GCG TGG CAT TGT GGA-3
; p6 (3741), 5
-GCT GGT TCA AGG
GCT TTA TTC CAT C-3
; p7 (4375), 5
-GGG CCG AAG AGT CAC CAC CGA GC-3
;
p8 (4376), 5
-GCT GGC AGC GAT TCA GAG CCC TG-3
; p9 (3039), 5
-CTT GGA
CTT T(GT)A GTC AAA TTG GC-3
; p10 (3072), 5
-GCG GTA CGA GCG ACG TGC
CCA C-3
; p11 (2839), 5
-CTT TAC AAC CAC TGC ACT ACC TGA C-3
; p12
(2838), 5
-GAT GGT GTC TTT GAT GTT GGG CTG A-3
; p13 (2530), 5
-GGA GTT
GTG GAG ACG GCC TTG AGT-3
; p14 (2490), 5
-CCA GTC ACC CGG CCC AGA TGG
AG-3
; p15 (3232), 5
-TAA ATC AGA GAG CAA GGC ATC GGG-3
; p16 (3392),
5
-TCT ATA CAG AGG TAC TGG TTA GTT CT-3
; p17 (3490), 5
-CAG TCC TGA
GGT GAG CTG CTG TGG C-3
; p18 (1871), 5
-ACC GGG CAT TGC CCC CAG T(TC)T
CC-3
; p19 (1872), 5
-CGT CGC ACA TTC GGC C(TC)C (CT)GC GAC T-3
; p20,
(1873), 5
-TCC TCC TC(TC) TCC (AT)GC CCC AGC G-3
; p21 (1608), 5
-CGA
CTT CCC CA(TC) TGG GAT (TC)CC CAT-3
; p22 (1605), 5
-CAG CAA TGC AGC
AC(GA) AGG CGA AGG C-3
; p23 (3038), 5
-TGG CCC TCC TGG AGA C(GA)T ACT
GTG C-3
; p24 (2384), 5
-TTG GAA GAA CTT GCC CAC GGG GTA TC-3
; 18SF
(3967): 5
-ATC CTG CCA GTA GCA TAT GCT TGT CT-3
; 18SR (3968), 5
-TTA
TCC AAG TAG GAG AGG AGC GAG C-3
. Mixed bases in parentheses were
designed for both human and mouse.
Genotyping of TH, INS, IGF2, H19, and WT1 Genes
Fig. 2.
PCR analysis of polymorphisms in the
TH, INS, IGF2, H19, and
WT1 genes in Wilms' tumor and their normal adjacent
tissues. PCR products from each DNA polymorphic site were cleaved
with indicated restriction enzymes and viewed by PhosphorImager after
electrophoresis. Letters on top indicates the allelic genotypes.
[View Larger Version of this Image (44K GIF file)]

Patient no. and
tissuea
DNA polymorphismb
THCATT
INS-Hph1
INS-PstI
IGF2AluI
IGF2ApaI
H19-AluI
H19-RsaI
WT1HinfI
a N, adjacent normal tissue; T, tumor
tissue.
b Boxes indicate the sites showing LOH, and circles,
MOH in LOH group. Specimens informative for IGR2-ApaI and
H19-AluI are underlined.
Polymorphism
sites
Tissue
Genotypes
Allele
frequency
LOH/informative in tumor (%)
AA
BB
AB
A
B
TH-CATTa
N
T
9 /26 (34.6)
INS-Hph1
N
11
18
11
0.41
0.59
T
12
22
6
0.38
0.62
5 /11 (45.5)
INS-PstI
N
30
2
8
0.85
0.15
T
30
3
7
0.84
0.16
1 /8 (12.5)
IGF2-AluI
N
12
12
16
0.50
0.50
T
17
13
10
0.55
0.45
6 /16 (37.5)
IGF2-ApaI
N
2
26
12
0.18
0.82
T
5
27
8
0.23
0.77
4 /12 (33.3)
H19-AluI
N
10
14
16
0.45
0.55
T
15
17
8
0.48
0.52
8 /16 (50.0)
H19-RsaI
N
7
18
15
0.36
0.64
T
11
22
7
0.35
0.65
8 /15 (53.3)
WT1-HinfI
N
19
4
17
0.69
0.31
T
21
7
12
0.68
0.32
5 /17 (29.4)
Total
14 /37 (37.8)
a
Frequency of five alleles, a, b, c, d, and e, in
normal tissues for TH were 37.5%, 25.5%, 7.5%, 52.5% and 40%,
respectively.
To determine the presence or absence of LOH at chromosome 11p, we compared genotypes in the tumors with those in their paired normal tissues. When LOH was observed in one polymorphic site, all other sites, if informative, also showed LOH, suggesting that the LOH in the Wilms' tumor DNA extended from the TH through the WT1 locus except for patient 10, in which LOH did not involve 11p13 (WT1); these findings are consistent with previous studies (2, 32, 33). Considering all of the cases which were informative for these eight DNA markers, 14/37 (37.8%) of Wilms' tumors demonstrated LOH for the short arm of chromosome 11. Because of the strong association of LOH of these genes across the region from 11p15.5 to 11p13, we classified tissues showing LOH in any of the eight DNA markers into the LOH group. There were 14 cases of LOH and 23 cases of maintenance of heterozygosity (MOH); three cases could not be classified due to a lack of informative sites available in any of these eight DNA markers (Table I).
Gene expression in tumor demonstrating loss of heterozygosity was
quantified by densitometric analysis. The average ratio of the density
of the remaining allele bands in eight tumors with LOH for
H19-AluI and five tumors with LOH for WT1-HinfI
to that of the two allele bands in their corresponding normal tissues
was 0.96 ± 0.07 and 1.24 ± 0.13, respectively, suggesting
that the loss of one allele was accompanied by the duplication of the
other allele (isodisomy). To confirm the presence of LOH with
deletion-duplication in tumors as previously reported (34), we used
end-labeled primers and an internal control 18 S ribosomal RNA to
assess gene duplication in the LOH samples at TH-CATT and
IGF2-ApaI sites (Fig. 3). The normalized
ratio revealed that the intensity of the band of the one remaining
allele in the tumor was equal to the total density of the two alleles
seen in normal adjacent tissue DNA (p = 0.84),
confirming the presence of a deletion-duplication in LOH (35).
-32P-end-labeled primers of
TH-CATT repeat and IGF2-ApaI with
the 18 S internal control. T, Wilms' tumor tissue;
N, normal adjacent kidney tissue.
Loss of Imprinting of IGF2 Predisposes to Tumorigenesis
Allelic expression of IGF2 and
H19 was investigated using primers flanking the polymorphic
IGF2-ApaI (p9, p10) and H19-AluI (p11, p12)
sites, respectively (Fig. 4). Among eight informative
cases for IGF2, monoallelic expression of IGF2
was found in two paired tissues (patients 15 and 20), while the other
six tumors showed biallelic expression of IGF2 (LOI).
Interestingly, LOI was also observed in five of the six normal tissues
adjacent to the tumors that showed LOI for IGF2 (Table
III). To exclude possible contamination of the cDNA
samples with genomic DNA, cDNAs from these samples were subjected
to PCR using primers spanning intron 8 of IGF2 (p23 and p24,
see Fig. 4, IGF2). Reverse transcription PCR with these
primers produced only the 115-bp fragments characteristic of the
cDNA without any detectable band derived from genomic DNA (408 bases, data not shown). Tumor tissue contamination of the NAT was not
considered likely because the genotyping data of LOH patients clearly
showed that the normal tissues differed from tumor tissues (for
polymorphism heterozygosity analysis see Table I). In addition, the
analysis of IGF2 abundance argues against the possibility of
tissue cross-contamination in our specimens (see below). Thus, these
data indicate that LOI frequently occurs in tissue adjacent to Wilms'
tumors, suggesting the possibility that LOI leads to a proclivity
for tumorigenesis.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
As shown in Table III, of the eight tissue pairs informative for the H19-AluI polymorphism, only one tumor (patient 15) displayed biallelic expression of H19; there was maintenance of IGF2 imprinting in this case. H19 was monoallelically expressed in all remaining tumors and in all normal adjacent tissues including subjects 30, 31, and 32, where there was a loss of IGF2 imprinting, suggesting a lack of association or concordance between IGF2 and H19 genomic imprinting.
Overexpression of IGF2 in Wilms' TumorsWe next examined the
relative abundance of IGF2 and H19 transcripts in
the 40 pairs of Wilms' tumors and adjacent normal tissues using
quantitative reverse transcription PCR. To exclude interference from
genomic DNA contamination during PCR transcription quantitation, we
used specific primers which cross exon/intron borders for each gene.
The PCR products derived from cDNA and DNA are therefore of
different sizes (Fig. 4). We have optimized our PCR conditions to
amplify simultaneously the transcripts of IGF2,
H19, and 18 S ribosomal RNA (as an internal control) in a
quantitative manner in the same tube and subsequently evaluate them in
the same gel lane (Fig. 5).
As shown in Table III, a significantly increased abundance of
IGF2 mRNA was observed in 40 tumors regardless of their
imprinting or heterozygosity status (average 5.26 ± 0.76-fold
increase; p < 0.0001) compared to their NAT. No
consistent changes in H19 gene expression could be
discerned. Twenty- eight of the 40 tumors showed decreased (
1.0-fold)
expression of H19 and 12 displayed an increase (>1.0 fold)
in H19 abundance when compared to their normal adjacent
tissue. The average H19 abundance in Wilms' tumors was 90%
relative to the normal tissues, but there was no significant difference
between them (p > 0.05).
To determine the effects of LOH and LOI on the expression of IGF2 and H19 in Wilms' tumor, we analyzed the quantitation data by subgroups according to allelic expression analysis (Table III) and genotype data (Table I). Tumors which demonstrated LOH had a significant increase of IGF2 expression (6.74 ± 1.66-fold compared to normal tissues) than did tumors which maintained heterozygosity (4.04 ± 0.51-fold compared to normal tissues), indicating that LOH and isodisomic reduplication contributed to the overexpression of IGF2 in tumors. There was a significant decrease in H19 abundance in Wilms' tumors with LOH (29%, p < 0.05) and in those tumors which demonstrated loss of IGF2 imprinting (26%, p < 0.05) when compared with their normal adjacent tissues. No consistent changes in H19 gene expression could be discerned in the other MOH tumor group, confirming previous work which showed that the decrease of H19 in Wilm's tumors was related to LOH and LOI of IGF2 (19, 20, 36). However, we did not observe any relationship between the increase in IGF2 or the decrease in H19 in Wilms' tumors with their LOI/MOI imprinting status. In summary, these data suggest that the overexpression of IGF2 in Wilms' tumor cannot be directly or solely attributable to LOI or LOH mechanisms.
Activation of IGF2 Promoters in TumorigenesisThe
IGF2 gene has four promoters (37). Previously we observed
that transcripts from promoters P1-P4 are derived from both alleles in
Wilms' tumors with LOI. In contrast, in tumors with MOI, transcripts
from P2-P4 originate from only one allele, while P1 transcripts were
from one or both alleles (9). To see which promoter contributes to the
increase of IGF2 expression in Wilms' tumors, we examined
the promoter usage of IGF2 using the competitive PCR with
end-labeled primers (Fig. 4, IGF2). Using this methodology,
transcript products from only promoters P3 and P4 were observed in
tumors or in normal tissues. Transcripts derived from promoters P1 and
P2 were not detectable in either normal or malignant of tissues (Fig.
6A), confirming that P3 and P4 were dominant
promoters in both normal and malignant kidney tissues (9, 37). The
expression of P3-derived IGF2 transcripts was 6.42 ± 1.0-fold higher in tumors than in the normal tissues, while expression
from P4 was 3.48 ± 0.83-fold higher in tumors. A similar trend
was observed in tumors with either LOI (patients 11, 30, and 31) or MOI
(patients 15 and 20) (Fig. 6A).
primers (p17, p18, p19, and p20) and one common 3
primer (p22) 32P-end labeled (see Fig. 4). Only transcripts
from P3 and P4 were observed. B, transcripts from each
promoter in Wilms' tumor and their adjacent normal tissues of patient
15 separately examined by a standard PCR assay using a single set of
corresponding primers with a 18 S primer set, showing activation of
four promoters of IGF2 in Wilms' tumor. The same primers
were used as above except for amplification of promoter P2 (p17-p21).
T, Wilms' tumor; N, normal adjacent
kidney.
To focus on whether promoter P1 and P2 were activated in Wilms' tumors, we examined each promoter by a more sensitive PCR analysis using single primer sets. As we have previously shown, IGF2 transcripts derived from P1 and P2 were observed in Wilms' tumors, but these transcripts could not be detected in normal adjacent tissues (Fig. 6B). The contribution of promoters P1 and P2 to the overexpression of IGF2 in Wilms' tumors was much less than the contribution from promoters P3 and P4.
IGF-II is a mitogenic peptide which is overexpressed in many types of tumors, and it has been speculated that the peptide can act in an autocrine or paracrine manner to initiate and/or maintain oncogenesis and tumor growth (12, 13). The recent observation that IGF2 imprinting is lost in a majority of Wilms' tumors appears to have provided one potential mechanism for the increased abundance of IGF2 in such tumors since biallelic gene expression would presumably lead to twice the amount of mRNA as would be transcribed from an imprinted gene (7, 8, 35, 38). In this study, we have characterized 40 sets of Wilms' tumors and their normal adjacent tissues. We confirm earlier findings that LOH is accompanied by reduplication of the remaining (presumably paternal) allele and by increased expression of the normally maternally imprinted IGF2 (1, 39). Moreover, we have shown that the abundance of IGF2 was >5 times greater in the tumor tissue than in the normal kidney tissue. This increased IGF2 expression occurred in tumor tissue irrespective of imprinting or heterozygosity status. Even NATs which demonstrated loss of IGF2 imprinting contained less IGF2 than did the tumor tissue which also manifested LOI, suggesting that loss of IGF2 imprinting may not directly alter IGF2 gene expression (or mRNA abundance) in Wilms' tumor. Instead, it appears that other mechanisms not associated with imprinting must contribute to the overexpression of IGF2.
In Wilms' tumors, LOH was restricted to the short arm of chromosome 11 (2). LOH can be detected at 11p15 to 13 in 30-57% of informative samples of Wilms' tumor (1, 2, 3). In this study, we identified LOH in 37.8% (14 of 37) informative tumors, and we found linkage of LOH at 11p13 to 11p15. Due to the limited number of samples which were informative at each polymorphic site, the frequency of LOH that we determined at each polymorphic site might not reflect the exact incidence of LOH at these loci in Wilms' tumors. For example, the apparent low LOH rate at INS-PstI site (1/8, 12.5%) was probably due to the relatively few patients who were informative (i.e. heterozygous) at this site because another polymorphic site (HphI) of the INS gene displayed a higher incidence of LOH (5/11, 45.5%). LOH was restricted to the Wilms' tumors and was not observed in any of normal adjacent tissues. By contrast, LOI of IGF2 did occur in both tumor and normal tissues.
LOI of IGF2 has been reported in a variety of cancers including Wilms' tumor (7), rhabdomyosarcoma (40), uterine leiomyosarcoma (29), lung cancer (41), breast cancer (42), and testicular cancer (43). In the present study we confirmed that LOI of IGF2 occurs in Wilms' tumor, but surprisingly, we also observed LOI of IGF2 in the adjacent normal tissues, suggesting that LOI can occur prior to tumorigenesis. There are several reasons to believe that the normal tissues displaying LOI of IGF2 were not contaminated by their adjacent tumor tissues. First, LOH occurred only in the tumor tissues and not in any of the adjacent normal tissues; second, there was a significant difference in the abundance of IGF2 and of H19 transcripts between the normal and the malignant tissues, even when both tissues demonstrated LOI of IGF2; and finally, there were also significant differences in the expression of the WT1, DNA methyltransferase, and glypican-3 genes when comparing the normal tissues to the tumor tissues (data not shown).
In previous studies, increased IGF2 expression was observed in Wilms' tumors demonstrating LOI or LOH, but no statistically significant difference could be discerned because of the wide range of expression of IGF2 among the tumors in each group (20, 36). By examining 40 paired Wilms' tumors/NAT samples, we were able to observe a highly significant increase of IGF2. Furthermore, our data also revealed a significant increase in the expression of IGF2 in tumor groups which maintained heterozygosity as well as imprinting. In each case, the overexpression of IGF2 in the malignant tissue was due to activation of all four promoters of IGF2, regardless of their LOI/MOI status. In our previous study (9), we demonstrated that, in every tumor that demonstrates LOI of IGF2, expression from promoter P1 as well as from the normally imprinted promoters P2-P4 was biallelic, but we did not examine promoter-specific gene expression in the NAT samples.
LOH at chromosome 11p15 in Wilms' tumor is a result of a loss of the maternal chromosome (39, 44). Since H19 is paternally imprinted, LOH should result in elimination of expression of H19. Previous studies have shown little or very low expression of H19 in tumors with LOH, although these studies did not report the measurement of H19 in paired normal tissues (20, 36). We observed reduced (71% of the NAT) expression of H19 in 14 tumor specimens with LOH (Table III), suggesting that while LOH may have been responsible for the reduction in the abundance of H19 RNA in the tumor, some expression of H19 from the paternal chromosome (loss of H19 imprinting) may also have occurred. Similar results have previously been reported (19). The association of LOI of IGF2 with a down-regulation of H19 expression has been reported by others (19, 20). However, our data showed that the abundance of IGF2 transcripts was not related to H19 expression in Wilms' tumor. While numerous studies have shown that H19 may control IGF2 imprinting (20, 36, 45), we could not confirm that H19 regulates the abundance of IGF2 mRNA in Wilms' tumor.
It is unclear what mechanism(s) is involved in enhancing the expression of IGF2 in Wilms' tumors since it appears that this activation is independent of LOH or LOI. Differential DNA methylation has been proposed as a candidate for epigenetic marking of the parental alleles. Recently, it has been shown that genes at the 11p15 locus were hypermethylated regardless of the specificity of the methylation pattern at the IGF2/H19 locus (36). We recently showed that treating cultured human and mouse astrocyte cells with DNA demethylating agents resulted in an increase in IGF2 expression by activating the normally imprinted maternal allele (30). In mutant mice that were deficient in DNA methyltransferase activity, the expression of IGF2 gene was undetectable, whereas the normally silent paternal allele of the H19 gene was activated, suggesting that a normal level of DNA methylation was required for controlling differential expression of the paternal and maternal alleles of imprinted genes (46). In agreement with these results, we found a significant increase in the level of DNA methyltransferase RNA in these Wilms' tumors comparing their normal adjacent tissues, suggesting a similar pattern of methylation in Wilm's tumor (data not shown).
A number of putative tumor suppresser genes, such as WT1 (47), p53 (48), igf2r (49), and GPC3 (50) can regulate IGF2 mRNA or IGF-II protein levels. WT1 interacts directly with the IGF2 promoter and represses gene expression during nephrogenesis (47). Since mutations in the WT1 gene are frequently found in Wilms' tumors (51), it has been suggested that the functional loss of WT1 transcriptional repressor activity may result in increased synthesis of IGF2 in the tumor (47). Thus, it is possible that WT1 may contribute to the unregulated growth of Wilms' tumor through transcriptional activation of the IGF2 gene.
A number of studies have focused on the expression of IGF2 and H19 in Wilms' tumor and have examined the roles of LOH and LOI in tumorigenesis (2, 7, 20, 36). Our findings support the previous observations indicating that LOH, LOI, and altered expression of IGF2 and H19 occur in Wilms' tumors, but our data show that overexpression of IGF2 was a consistent common feature for Wilms' tumor regardless of heterozygosity or imprinting status. The elucidation of the mechanism activating IGF2 gene overexpression may help us to understand the general molecular basis for Wilms' tumor oncogenesis.
To whom correspondence should be addressed: Medical Service (111),
VA Medical Center, 3801 Miranda Ave., Palo Alto, CA 94304. Tel.:
415-858-3930; Fax: 415-856-8024; E-mail:
hoffman{at}camis.stanford.edu.
We thank the Cross Cancer Institute Northern Alberta Cancer Program for Wilms' tumor samples, Dr. Ji Fan Hu for technical assistance and valuable discussions, and Dr. Simon Bennett for information concerning INS-HphI polymorphism.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. W. Brown, F. Power, B. Moore, A. K. Charles, and K. T.A. Malik Frequency and Timing of Loss of Imprinting at 11p13 and 11p15 in Wilms' Tumor Development Mol. Cancer Res., July 1, 2008; 6(7): 1114 - 1123. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
|
|