![]()
|
|
||||||||
Volume 272, Number 47, Issue of November 21, 1997
pp. 29399-29402
From the Verna and Marrs McLean Department of Biochemistry,
Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas 77030
The folding protein (and protein folder) is
beset with a number of problems in translating the simple instructions
encoded by DNA into the complex, three-dimensional structure of a
correctly folded protein. Nature has solved these problems in an
adequate, if not elegant, fashion, but we are just beginning to
understand the variety of strategies that cells use to ensure efficient
protein folding. This minireview will focus on several of the more
general principles of assisted folding using the folding catalyst,
protein disulfide isomerase
(PDI),1 as an example. This
remarkable resident of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) inserts
disulfides into folding proteins and provides a mechanism to correct
errors in disulfide pairing when they occur. At high concentrations, it
functions as an ATP-independent chaperone that inhibits aggregation;
yet, at lower concentrations, it can also participate in an unusual
interaction with substrate that leads to PDI-facilitated aggregation
(anti-chaperone
behavior2).
Proteins Fold in Different Environments Assisted protein folding occurs in at least three intracellular
compartments, the cytosol, mitochondria, and the lumen of the ER. PDI
is a resident of the endoplasmic reticulum, a specialized folding
environment, replete with a variety of folding catalysts and chaperones
(1-3). Folding in the ER is specialized to accommodate the structural
features of membrane and secreted proteins, including glycosylation and
disulfide formation (4-6). As proteins are synthesized and inserted
into the ER, the sequence is presented vectorially to the ER lumen so
that folding may begin as the protein emerges from the ribosome
(7-10). A glutathione redox buffer (a mixture of GSH and GSSG at a
ratio of approximately 1:1-3:1) holds the redox state of the ER more
oxidizing than that of the cytosol to allow disulfides to form and
rearrange (11).
Folding catalysts such as PDI (12-14) and peptidylprolyl isomerase
(15, 16) accelerate slow chemical steps that accompany folding.
Disulfide formation can occur quite rapidly, even before the completion
of synthesis (17, 18), but for some proteins such as hCG- PDI Has Unique Structural and Functional Features During protein folding in the ER, PDI catalyzes disulfide
formation and rearrangement by thiol/disulfide exchange (22). A member
of the thioredoxin superfamily (14), PDI has two independent (23) but
non-equivalent (24) active sites, each with two cysteines (CGHC) that
cycle between the dithiol and disulfide oxidation states. One
thioredoxin domain is positioned near the N terminus, and another is
poised near the C terminus (25). An NMR structure of the N-terminal
thioredoxin domain shows that the backbone fold is comparable with that
of thioredoxin (26). The active site disulfide is a good oxidant (27,
28) that directly introduces disulfides into protein substrates (29,
33). The dithiol redox state is essential for catalyzing disulfide
rearrangements. The necessity of having oxidized and reduced active
sites for catalysis of different steps results in a redox optimum (24).
The individual thioredoxin domains of PDI have been expressed alone,
and they are catalytically active oxidants. However, neither isolated
domain exhibits significant isomerase activity despite the fact that the chemical properties (reactivity and redox potential) are near those
found for wild-type PDI (30).
PDI is an essential gene in yeast (31, 32), and the isomerase activity
is the critical feature (33). Overexpression of thioredoxin itself will
not rescue PDI-null strains, but a mutant of thioredoxin in which the
active site sequence (CGPC) has been changed to the PDI sequence (CGHC)
can support yeast growth (34) even though this mutant thioredoxin
(P34H) has only 10% of the isomerase activity of PDI in
vitro (35).
Protein folding is error-prone. For some proteins like bovine
pancreatic trypsin inhibitor, folding intermediates are dominated by
native pairings of cysteines; however, the disulfides are formed in the
"wrong" temporal order and must be rearranged before folding can
proceed (36). In other cases such as RNase (37, 38) or hirudin (39),
disulfides are formed randomly in early folding intermediates. Thus,
protein folding is a process of trial and error (40). PDI corrects
these mistakes by catalyzing rearrangements to replace wrong disulfides
with correct ones, a process that eventually leads to a "native"
structure that is resistant to further rearrangement (41, 42).
So far, no evidence has surfaced that PDI or other folding assistants
directly guide the folding protein into a specific structure (21, 43).
PDI simply accelerates the formation and breaking of disulfides,
providing cycles of PDI-catalyzed rearrangements to correct the
frequent mistakes that occur. Turnover numbers for PDI-catalyzed
disulfide isomerization are slow by normal enzyme standards (~1
min Disulfide rearrangements are initiated by the attack of the active site
thiol of reduced PDI on a substrate disulfide (45). The choice of which
substrate disulfide to attack will depend on the kinetic reactivity and
accessibility of the various substrate disulfides that are available.
The formation of a PDI-substrate covalent intermediate disrupts one of
the substrate disulfides, creating a free sulfhydryl in the substrate.
This intermediate can be resolved by three alternative reactions (Fig.
1). If PDI is displaced by reforming the
same disulfide that was attacked initially, no disulfide rearrangement
results. Rearrangement can occur by an intramolecular reaction of the
newly created substrate thiol on another substrate disulfide or by
reduction of the original disulfide followed by oxidation to form
different disulfides (42). The second cysteine in the active site can
serve as a clock to invoke reduction of the disulfide and escape from
the complex if a substrate-PDI complex fails to rearrange or reverse in
a timely fashion (Fig. 1). The offending substrate disulfide is reduced
and released for further attempts at rearrangement or reduction. If
reductive escape is inhibited by mutating the second active
site cysteine to serine, PDI accumulates in mixed disulfide complexes with substrate, and the isomerization activity drops precipitously (<1% of wild type) (29), suggesting that
reduction/reoxidation is the dominant mechanism of disulfide
rearrangement for RNase. The initial scanning of the substrate
disulfides by PDI and the subsequent reactions of the
PDI-substrate intermediate should favor the trial and error
replacement of reactive disulfides of the substrate by less
reactive ones (42), a process similar to that suggested for
repeated cycles of folding and unfolding catalyzed by
ATP-dependent chaperones such as GroEL/ES (40).
[View Larger Version of this Image (21K GIF file)]
Folding Catalysts Recognize Many Substrates In keeping with the lack of obvious sequence cues that specify
disulfide connectivity, PDI can catalyze thiol/disulfide exchange reactions involving a wide range of substrates, including proteins, peptides and low molecular weight thiols and disulfides (46). PDI
interacts relatively weakly with peptides (Kd = 50-1000 µM) with no obvious correlation between binding
and peptide charge, sequence, or hydrophobicity (47, 48). A
peptide-based photoaffinity probe labels one site near the C terminus
and inhibits catalytic activity (49). In contrast to glutaredoxin (50),
PDI does not exhibit any special affinity for glutathione as a
substrate (27). However, the dominant mechanism of
PDI-dependent oxidation of small peptide substrates
involves the formation of peptide-glutathione mixed disulfides (51),
and protein-glutathione mixed disulfides are good PDI substrates (52,
53). Although mutants of PDI with a single, more N-terminal cysteine
might be expected to catalyze oxidation by glutathione-mixed disulfide
formation, they do not (29). In addition, substrate oxidation occurs
rapidly in the absence of a redox buffer, where stoichiometric amounts
of PDI supply all of the oxidizing equivalents (44). Although
glutathione mixed disulfide formation does occur, it is not an obligate
oxidation pathway.
Aggregation Is a Major Complication to Productive Folding Folding intermediates with a less organized and more exposed
hydrophobic core have an increased tendency to aggregate, sometimes imposing stingy limits on solubility (54). At least for some proteins,
aggregation can occur from specific folding intermediates through
specific associations (55, 56). Yet hydrophobic aggregation can also be
nonspecific, involving the interaction of multiple proteins (57). PDI
has two somewhat paradoxical roles in substrate aggregation. It can
behave as a chaperone and inhibit aggregation, or under certain
conditions, it can behave as an anti-chaperone and facilitate the
formation of aggregates.
As a chaperone, PDI inhibits substrate aggregation by two mechanisms,
rapid disulfide formation and a chaperone-buffer effect. At
concentrations near 10 µM, reduced, denatured hen egg
white lysozyme tends to aggregate (58), compromising the yield during refolding. If present when lysozyme is diluted into solution, high
concentrations (near 100 µM) of catalytically active PDI are required to inhibit aggregation, suggesting that very rapid disulfide formation can divert substrate molecules onto productive folding pathways and decrease the amount of aggregation (59, 60).
However, PDI also inhibits the aggregation of proteins that do not form
disulfides (61-63). Peptides inhibit the chaperone activity suggesting
that the peptide/protein binding site(s) of PDI may interact with the
substrate protein and prevent its aggregation by forming soluble,
non-covalent complexes that mask aggregation-prone sites (64).
One of the more surprising features of PDI-assisted folding is that PDI
can, under certain conditions, actually facilitate aggregation, a
behavior that has been called anti-chaperone activity (59, 60, 63).
Under reducing conditions, adding low concentrations of PDI to a
solution of unfolded, reduced lysozyme causes large, insoluble
aggregates to form that contain both lysozyme and PDI (59). PDI at low
concentrations accelerates the aggregation of alcohol dehydrogenase
during thermal denaturation, but higher concentrations of PDI suppress
aggregation (63). This paradoxical change of a folding assistant from
anti-chaperone to chaperone has an analogy in the classical
immunoprecipitation of a bivalent antigen by a population of bivalent
antibodies (Fig. 2) (59). For a protein
that has some intrinsic tendency to self-associate into aggregates,
multivalent interactions with PDI can provide an additional mechanism
for aggregates to increase in size. At some optimal concentration,
comparable with the equivalence point in an immunoprecipitation curve,
the maximum number of cross-links is formed leading to maximum
insolubility, and PDI behaves as an anti-chaperone. At higher PDI
concentrations, analogous to conditions of antibody excess, it becomes
more likely that an unfolded protein will bind to a PDI that is not
already bound to another unfolded protein, decreasing the extent of
cross-link formation, increasing solubility, and favoring chaperone
behavior. The interactions that mediate anti-chaperone-facilitated
aggregation are relatively specific. PDI is specifically
co-precipitated with the unfolded protein in a defined ratio,
approximately 5-10 unfolded proteins per PDI (59, 63). Another ER
chaperone, BiP, also exhibits chaperone/anti-chaperone behavior, and it
too is incorporated into large aggregates at a defined ratio and in
competition with PDI (65).
[View Larger Version of this Image (31K GIF file)]
Aggregation is generally viewed as a folding disaster, and facilitated
aggregation is obviously a complication to using the folding assistants
in refolding strategies. However, there are circumstantial indications
that switches between chaperone/anti-chaperone behavior could be useful
to the stressed cell as a mechanism to retain unfolded proteins in the
ER when the stoichiometric chaperone capacity is exceeded or to protect
unfolded proteins from degradation. In contrast to the irreversible
aggregation so often observed in vitro, aggregation can be
reversible in the cell (66). The inhibition of disulfide formation in
cells by including dithiothreitol in the medium results in the
accumulation of large, chaperone-associated aggregates that are
retained in the ER. When the dithiothreitol is washed out, these
aggregates are salvaged, correctly folded, and released from the ER as
soluble proteins (67, 68). The chaperone-associated aggregates may
involve multiple substrate proteins and multiple ER-chaperones (69)
although it is not known whether these are heterogeneous complexes or
mixtures of homogeneous complexes. The normal folding of thyroglobulin
induced in HepG2 cells by thyroid hormone and the assembly of
procollagen (70) proceeds through large, chaperone-associated
aggregates (71, 72), and mutants of human chorionic gonadotropin can also be retained in the ER as large, chaperone-associated aggregates that go on to fold productively, albeit at a slower rate (73).
PDI and other folding catalysts and molecular chaperones provide
the cell with an effective solution to the protein folding problem. The
overall efficiency of folding can be enhanced by increasing the rate of
slow chemical steps that limit conformational transitions, by
preventing the formation of non-productive aggregates, and perhaps by
protecting the folding protein through the formation of transient
aggregates. The challenge in the near future will be to understand
assisted folding at the molecular and structural levels and to discover
how assisted folding "pathways" are orchestrated in the cell.
MINIREVIEW:
Protein Disulfide Isomerase and Assisted Protein Folding*

INTRODUCTION
Proteins Fold in Different Environments
PDI Has Unique Structural and Functional Features
Mistakes Occur during Folding
Folding Catalysts Recognize Many Substrates
Aggregation Is a Major Complication to Productive Folding
Conclusions
FOOTNOTES
REFERENCES
and
influenza virus hemagglutinin (19), disulfide formation is delayed and
occurs posttranslationally. Because of the high reactivity of the
active site disulfide of PDI (20), the delay in disulfide formation may
be due to protection of certain cysteines against oxidation by folding
of the nascent chain or by protection with other ER chaperones (19).
However, Ruddon and co-workers (21) have mapped the order of disulfide
formation for human hCG-
during folding in the ER and for the same
reaction in vitro, catalyzed by PDI. No differences were
observed in the identity and order of disulfide formation suggesting,
at least for hCG-
, that ER chaperones are not necessary for the
inhibition of disulfide formation during folding (21) and that
catalyzed and uncatalyzed folding proceeds by similar mechanisms.
1), but given the high local concentration of PDI in
the ER (about 0.2 mM) (44), this low turnover number is
sufficient to make PDI-catalyzed folding kinetically competent in the
cell. The value of Km for disulfide isomerization of
protein substrates is near 10 µM (43, 44).
Fig. 1.
PDI-catalyzed disulfide rearrangements.
Attack of reduced PDI on a substrate disulfide leads to the formation
of a covalent PDI-substrate complex. The resolution of this complex may
occur through three competing pathways. The red pathway
represents reforming the original substrate disulfide. Disulfides that
are resistant to attack or which reform very rapidly would avoid
rearrangement. The green pathway represents intramolecular
rearrangements involving substrate thiols and disulfides. This pathway
would have a tendency to replace more reactive substrate disulfides
with less reactive ones. The blue pathway represents
rearrangement by reduction of one or more disulfides and reoxidation in
a new orientation. This pathway also provides PDI with a mechanism to
escape from covalent complexes that rearrange or reverse slowly
(adapted from Ref. 42 with permission).
Fig. 2.
The chaperone/anti-chaperone behavior of PDI
may be analogous to a classical immunoprecipitation. At low
concentrations (left region), increasing concentrations of
PDI can lead to decreased solubility by providing additional ways to
cross-link the substrate protein into aggregates. When the ratio of PDI
to substrate is "optimal," the maximum number of cross-links will
form, the complex will show minimum solubility, and PDI will behave as
an anti-chaperone (middle region). At higher PDI
concentrations (right region), cross-link formation by
self-association will be inhibited by PDI, and PDI will behave as a
chaperone.
*
This minireview will be reprinted
in the 1997 Minireview Compendium, which
will be available in December, 1997. This work was supported by National Institutes of
Health Grant GM-40379.
To whom correspondence should be addressed: Dept. of Biochemistry,
Baylor College of Medicine, One Baylor Plaza, Houston, TX 77030. Tel.:
713-798-5880; Fax: 713-796-9438; E-mail:hgilbert{at}bcm.tmc.edu.
1
The abbreviations used are: PDI, protein
disulfide isomerase; ER, endoplasmic reticulum; hCG, human chorionic
gonadotropin.
2
At a recent Keystone Symposium on Protein
Folding and Secretion, there was discussion of the use and misuse of
the terms "chaperone" and "anti-chaperone." A variety of terms
for replacement of "anti-chaperone" were suggested. However, given
the lack of a suitable replacement term, we would suggest that the term
"anti-chaperone" be reserved to describe facilitated
aggregation.
Volume 272, Number 47,
Issue of November 21, 1997
pp. 29399-29402
©1997 by The American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Inc.
![]()
CiteULike
Complore
Connotea
Del.icio.us
Digg
Reddit
Technorati What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
X.-Y. Wan and J.-Y. Liu Comparative Proteomics Analysis Reveals an Intimate Protein Network Provoked by Hydrogen Peroxide Stress in Rice Seedling Leaves Mol. Cell. Proteomics, August 1, 2008; 7(8): 1469 - 1488. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Jain, L. W. McGinnes, and T. G. Morrison Thiol/Disulfide Exchange Is Required for Membrane Fusion Directed by the Newcastle Disease Virus Fusion Protein J. Virol., March 1, 2007; 81(5): 2328 - 2339. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Faurobert, C. Mihr, N. Bertin, T. Pawlowski, L. Negroni, N. Sommerer, and M. Causse Major Proteome Variations Associated with Cherry Tomato Pericarp Development and Ripening Plant Physiology, March 1, 2007; 143(3): 1327 - 1346. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. D. Austin, X. Wen, L. Gazzard, C. Nelson, R. H. Scheller, and S. J. Scales Oxidizing potential of endosomes and lysosomes limits intracellular cleavage of disulfide-based antibody-drug conjugates PNAS, December 13, 2005; 102(50): 17987 - 17992. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
B. Wilkinson, R. Xiao, and H. F. Gilbert A Structural Disulfide of Yeast Protein-disulfide Isomerase Destabilizes the Active Site Disulfide of the N-terminal Thioredoxin Domain J. Biol. Chem., March 25, 2005; 280(12): 11483 - 11487. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Tan, Y. Lu, and J. C. A. Bardwell Mutational Analysis of the Disulfide Catalysts DsbA and DsbB J. Bacteriol., February 15, 2005; 187(4): 1504 - 1510. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Xiao, B. Wilkinson, A. Solovyov, J. R. Winther, A. Holmgren, J. Lundstrom-Ljung, and H. F. Gilbert The Contributions of Protein Disulfide Isomerase and Its Homologues to Oxidative Protein Folding in the Yeast Endoplasmic Reticulum J. Biol. Chem., November 26, 2004; 279(48): 49780 - 49786. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. M. Smith, J. Chan, D. Oksenberg, R. Urfer, D. S. Wexler, A. Ow, L. Gao, A. McAlorum, and S.-G. Huang A High-Throughput Turbidometric Assay for Screening Inhibitors of Protein Disulfide Isomerase Activity J Biomol Screen, October 1, 2004; 9(7): 614 - 620. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. Pandhare and V. Deshpande Both chaperone and isomerase functions of protein disulfide isomerase are essential for acceleration of the oxidative refolding and reactivation of dimeric alkaline protease inhibitor Protein Sci., September 1, 2004; 13(9): 2493 - 2501. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Solovyov, R. Xiao, and H. F. Gilbert Sulfhydryl Oxidation, Not Disulfide Isomerization, Is the Principal Function of Protein Disulfide Isomerase in Yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae J. Biol. Chem., August 13, 2004; 279(33): 34095 - 34100. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Miki, N. Okada, and H. Danbara Two Periplasmic Disulfide Oxidoreductases, DsbA and SrgA, Target Outer Membrane Protein SpiA, a Component of the Salmonella Pathogenicity Island 2 Type III Secretion System J. Biol. Chem., August 13, 2004; 279(33): 34631 - 34642. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Solovyov and H. F. Gilbert Zinc-dependent dimerization of the folding catalyst, protein disulfide isomerase Protein Sci., July 1, 2004; 13(7): 1902 - 1907. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Cemazar, S. Zahariev, S. Pongor, and P. J. Hore Oxidative Folding of Amaranthus {alpha}-Amylase Inhibitor: DISULFIDE BOND FORMATION AND CONFORMATIONAL FOLDING J. Biol. Chem., April 16, 2004; 279(16): 16697 - 16705. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. S. Trombetta The contribution of N-glycans and their processing in the endoplasmic reticulum to glycoprotein biosynthesis Glycobiology, September 1, 2003; 13(9): 77R - 91R. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. L. McManaman and D. L. Bain Structural and Conformational Analysis of the Oxidase to Dehydrogenase Conversion of Xanthine Oxidoreductase J. Biol. Chem., June 7, 2002; 277(24): 21261 - 21268. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
O. Ben-Zeev, H. Z. Mao, and M. H. Doolittle Maturation of Lipoprotein Lipase in the Endoplasmic Reticulum. CONCURRENT FORMATION OF FUNCTIONAL DIMERS AND INACTIVE AGGREGATES J. Biol. Chem., March 15, 2002; 277(12): 10727 - 10738. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. P. Li, A. Nakanishi, S. W. Clark, and H. Kasamatsu Formation of transitory intrachain and interchain disulfide bonds accompanies the folding and oligomerization of simian virus 40 Vp1 in the cytoplasm PNAS, January 17, 2002; (2002) 32668699. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Chang, R. Grant, and A. Aronson Regulation of the Packaging of Bacillus thuringiensisdelta -Endotoxins into Inclusions Appl. Envir. Microbiol., November 1, 2001; 67(11): 5032 - 5036. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
C. Ruiz, C.-Y. Liu, Q.-H. Sun, M. Sigaud-Fiks, E. Fressinaud, J.-Y. Muller, P. Nurden, A. T. Nurden, P. J. Newman, and N. Valentin A point mutation in the cysteine-rich domain of glycoprotein (GP) IIIa results in the expression of a GPIIb-IIIa ({alpha}IIb{beta}3) integrin receptor locked in a high-affinity state and a Glanzmann thrombasthenia-like phenotype Blood, October 15, 2001; 98(8): 2432 - 2441. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Zuber, J.-y. Fan, B. Guhl, A. Parodi, J. H. Fessler, C. Parker, and J. Roth Immunolocalization of UDP-glucose:glycoprotein glucosyltransferase indicates involvement of pre-Golgi intermediates in protein quality control PNAS, September 4, 2001; (2001) 191359198. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Goldstone, P. W. Haebel, F. Katzen, M. W. Bader, J. C. A. Bardwell, J. Beckwith, and P. Metcalf DsbC activation by the N-terminal domain of DsbD PNAS, August 1, 2001; (2001) 171315498. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Kadokura, M. Bader, H. Tian, J. C. A. Bardwell, and J. Beckwith Roles of a conserved arginine residue of DsbB in linking protein disulfide-bond-formation pathway to the respiratory chain of Escherichia coli PNAS, September 26, 2000; 97(20): 10884 - 10889. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Q. Wang, H. T. Keutmann, A. L. Schneyer, and P. M. Sluss Analysis of Human Follistatin Structure: Identification of Two Discontinuous N-Terminal Sequences Coding for Activin A Binding and Structural Consequences of Activin Binding to Native Proteins Endocrinology, September 1, 2000; 141(9): 3183 - 3193. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
F. Shao, M. W. Bader, U. Jakob, and J. C. A. Bardwell DsbG, a Protein Disulfide Isomerase with Chaperone Activity J. Biol. Chem., April 28, 2000; 275(18): 13349 - 13352. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. A. Bennett, B. S. Edwards, L. A. Sklar, and S. Rogelj Sulfhydryl Regulation of L-Selectin Shedding: Phenylarsine Oxide Promotes Activation-Independent L-Selectin Shedding from Leukocytes J. Immunol., April 15, 2000; 164(8): 4120 - 4129. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. Kajino, C. Ohto, M. Muramatsu, S. Obata, S. Udaka, Y. Yamada, and H. Takahashi A Protein Disulfide Isomerase Gene Fusion Expression System That Increases the Extracellular Productivity of Bacillus brevis Appl. Envir. Microbiol., |