![]()
|
|
||||||||
J Biol Chem, Vol. 273, Issue 45, 29545-29553, November 6, 1998
From the Friedrich Miescher-Institut, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland
and the Specific cell adhesion in the marine sponge
Microciona prolifera is mediated by an extracellular
aggregation factor complex, whose main protein component, termed MAFp3,
is highly polymorphic. We have now identified MAFp4, an ~400-kDa
protein, from the aggregation factor that is translated from the same
mRNA as MAFp3. The existence of multiple potential sites for
N-glycosylation and calcium binding suggests a direct
involvement of MAFp4 in the species-specific aggregation of sponge
cells. The deduced partial polypeptide consists of a 16-fold reiterated
motif that shows significant similarity to a repeat in an endoglucanase
from the symbiontic bacterium Azorhizobium caulinodans and
to the intracellular loop of mammalian Na+-Ca2+
exchangers. Restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis indicated
that the genomic variability of MAFp4 is high and comparable to that of
MAFp3. Their combined polymorphism correlates with allogeneic responses
studied in a population of 23 sponge individuals. Peptide mass
fingerprinting of tryptic digests of the polymorphic MAFp3 bands
observed on polyacrylamide gels after chemical deglycosylation of the
Microciona aggregation factor revealed that the variability detected on Southern blots at least partially reflects the individual variability of aggregation factor protein components. Polyclonal antibodies raised against MAFp3 strongly cross-reacted with a 68-kDa
protein localized in sponge cell membranes. Immunohistochemical use of
the anti-MAFp3 antibodies strongly stained a cell layer along the line
of contact in allogeneic grafts. We show that the transcription level
of the MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA in sponge allo- and isografts is clearly
increased in comparison with non-grafted tissue. These data are
discussed with respect to a possible evolutionary relationship between
cell adhesion and histocompatibility systems.
Species-specific cell recognition in sponges is mediated by
proteoglycan-like extracellular complexes termed aggregation factors (AFs),1 unidentified so far
in other phyla, although Northern blots suggested the existence, in
several human tissues, of proteins related to those found in the AF of
the marine sponge Microciona prolifera (1). Cell adhesion in
this species is mediated by calcium-dependent carbohydrate
interactions of homologous Microciona AF (MAF) molecules via
N-linked glycans. A proposed model suggested that species specificity could be at least partially provided by the different spacing of glycosaminoglycan chains on the protein core (2), thus
postulating the existence of a different AF core protein in each
species. Unexpectedly, an extraordinarily high intraspecific variability was found for the MAF core protein (1), suggesting that AFs
might also be involved in individual specificity.
The immune and cell adhesion systems are clearly related, as deduced
from phylogenetic relationships between molecules of both groups (3)
and as expected from the fact that the cells of the immune system
depend on regulated interactions with other cells to be activated (4).
An evolutionary connection between cell adhesion and
histocompatibility, however, has yet to be demonstrated. Presumably, it
was around the time when metazoans appeared that the primitive
machinery regulating cell interactions had to evolve and diversify into
the whole array of molecules that allowed the far more complex
structures leading to multicellularity first and then to tissues and
organs. A second possibility is that the cell adhesion system of higher
animals appeared de novo, and therefore, vertebrate and
invertebrate histocompatibility would be the result of convergent
evolution rather than of a common ancestry. The finding, in an ever
increasing number of invertebrates including sponges, of Ig-like
domains (5, 6) and of extracellular matrix components common to all
pluricellular animals (7) suggests that the latter view is less likely.
A surprising characteristic of sponges, considering their phylogenetic
position as the most primitive extant metazoans, is that they possess a
highly evolved histocompatibility system. When tissues from different
individuals of a given sponge species are brought into contact, they
either fuse or reject through cellular events similar to those observed
in vertebrate grafts, which include (i) an inflammation-like massive
migration of certain cell types toward the region of contact (8), (ii)
phagocytosis and/or cytotoxic reactions (9, 10), and (iii) the layering
of a collagen barrier separating the apposed tissues (8). Any grafting between two genetically different sponge individuals is almost invariably incompatible in the many species investigated (1, 9, 11,
12), exhibiting a variety of transitive qualitatively and
quantitatively different responses, which can only be explained by the
existence of an extensive genetic polymorphism at the locus or loci
controlling graft acceptance and rejection. In the protochordate Botryllus schlosseri, contact between two genetically
distinct individuals leads to the resorption of one of them by the
other through a phenomenon that is controlled by highly polymorphic loci (13). The frequency of resorption in Botryllus is
comparable to that of rejection in sponges, suggesting that both might
be analogous manifestations of a sophisticated histocompatibility system in invertebrates that would have been an ideal building block
for the vertebrate major histocompatibility complex. And yet, despite
the relevant cytological and genetic studies outlined above, there is
an absolute lack of sequence and evolutionary data concerning
invertebrate molecules involved in allorecognition.
Individual variability of sequences related to the main protein of MAF
(MAFp3) matched the elevated sponge alloincompatibility (1), although
from Southern blot results, it could not be established whether such
variability resided in the AF proteins themselves or if it also
represented sequence-related molecules not belonging to the AF. MAFp3
and another protein suspected to belong to the AF seemed to be
translated together as a longer polypeptide from the same mRNA (1,
14). Here, we characterize this new component and start studying the
significance of the variability in MAFp3. We also present the first
attempts to study what role, if any, AFs might play in sponge histocompatibility.
Sponges, Cell Membrane Preparation, and Western Blots--
Live
specimens of the red beard sponge (M. prolifera) were
collected in the Woods Hole area by staff of the Aquatic Resources Division of the Marine Biological Laboratory. To isolate cell membranes, dissociated sponge cells obtained during AF preparation (see
below) were washed twice with cold phosphate-buffered saline and
incubated on ice for 10 min in hypotonic salt solution (5 mM KCl, 1 mM EDTA, and 10 mM HEPES,
pH 7.5). Cells were then opened with 10 strokes in a Dounce homogenizer
(type B pestle). The suspension was cleared for 5 min at 400 × g, and the resulting supernatant was spun at 100,000 × g for 20 min. The pelleted membranes were resuspended in
storage buffer (1 mM MgCl2, 1 mM
CaCl2, 10% glycerol, and 20 mM HEPES, pH 7.5)
and stored at cDNA Sequencing and Polyclonal Antibodies--
To extend
sequences in the 5'-direction, rapid amplification of cDNA ends
(RACE) was performed using two different templates. Preexisting
cDNA libraries yielded short 5'-RACE products with primer T3 and a
gene-specific primer corresponding to an antisense oligonucleotide
close to the 5'-end of the longest sequences available (1). Based on
Northern blot results, total RNA samples were then chosen for their
content of the largest forms of the MAFp3 mRNA.
Poly(A)+ RNA was selected with standard methods (16) and
used to construct oligo(dT) cDNA libraries with the
MarathonTM cDNA amplification kit
(CLONTECH). 5'-RACE products were obtained with
antisense gene-specific primers and the adaptor primer supplied by the
manufacturer. Polymerase chain reaction amplifications were done with
the ExpandTM Long Template PCR system (Boehringer
Mannheim). The products were analyzed on 1% agarose gels and excised,
and the DNA was extracted (QIAEX II gel extraction kit, QIAGEN Inc.),
subcloned in pCRTM II (TA cloning kit, Invitrogen), and
sequenced with an automated laser fluorescent sequencer (Amersham
Pharmacia Biotech) using fluorescein-labeled primers. Between the
gene-specific primer 3'-end and the 5'-end of the region to be
extended, a stretch of at least 25 bases was left for comparison, only
accepting those new sequences that showed a 100% match. Chicken
polyclonal IgYs against the recombinant 170-amino acid N-terminal
region of MAFp3 were produced and purified according to standard
protocols (17, 18). The fusion protein was generated with the
glutathione S-transferase gene fusion system (Amersham
Pharmacia Biotech). For the purification of the specific antibodies
against MAFp3, the fusion protein was cross-linked with dimethyl
pimelimidate to glutathione-Sepharose 4B as described (18). The
preparation eluted from the antigen affinity column was monitored for
purity by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and for its
antigen-binding activity, and finally, it was quantitated. According to
all these controls, we had an extremely pure specific antibody, which
was able to detect its antigen on Western blots at a concentration of
<1 ng of purified antibody/ml.
Southern and Northern Blots and in Situ
Hybridization--
Sponge genomic DNA was isolated as described (14),
DraI-digested, electrophoresed, transferred to a membrane,
and hybridized with probes labeled with alkali-labile digoxigenin as
specified before (1). Probes I and III (both ~1 kb; defined in the
legend to Fig. 1) were polymerase chain reaction-amplified from
subcloned regions lacking DraI sites. Probe I was derived
from an intronless cDNA sequence, and probe III from a genomic DNA
sequence containing at least one intron. Before reprobing, the
membranes were treated twice with 1.5 M NaCl and 0.3 M NaOH for 10 min each and reequilibrated with 1.5 M NaCl, 1 M Tris-HCl, pH 7.4, and 2× SSC for
10 min each. To establish grafts, 1-cm-long sponge papillae were pushed
together on a 0.5-mm-thick stainless steel insect pin until the contact between the tissues was as intimate as possible. During these operations, the sponge tissue was always kept under seawater. The pins
were stuck into the underside of a Styrofoam rack left to float on a
tank with running seawater at 20 °C for the times indicated. Total
RNA from grafted tissues was prepared using standard protocols (19).
Briefly, the grafted papillae with a mean volume of 125 mm3
were removed from the pins and gently squeezed with flat-tip forceps
for 30 s in 1 ml of Ca2+- and Mg2+-free
artificial seawater at 0 °C in order to release the cells, which
were immediately pelleted for 1 min at 200 × g. 0.9 ml
of the cleared supernatant was then removed, and the cell pellet was
quickly but gently resuspended in the remaining 100 µl before adding
6 volumes of 4 M guanidinium thiocyanate, 25 mM
sodium citrate, pH 7, 0.5% sarcosyl, and 0.1 M
2-mercaptoethanol. The viscous solution was gently mixed until it
became homogeneous, and the pH was then lowered with 0.1 volume of 2 M sodium acetate, pH 4. The proteins were extracted with 1 volume of phenol equilibrated with 0.2 M sodium acetate, pH
4, chloroform, and isoamyl alcohol (200:40:1). After 1 h on ice,
the samples were centrifuged at 20,000 × g for 30 min,
and the RNA contained in the water phase was precipitated with 0.2 volume of isopropyl alcohol, washed twice with 80% ethanol, and
resuspended in diethyl pyrocarbonate-treated H2O. For
Northern blotting, 5 µg of total RNA were loaded per lane on
denaturing 0.8% agarose gels containing formaldehyde. RNA probes were
labeled with the digoxigenin RNA labeling kit (Boehringer Mannheim) as
described (14). In situ hybridization of 20-µm-thick
sections was performed as described (20) without prior desilicification
of the tissue.
Immunohistochemistry--
Grafted tissues were fixed with 3.7%
formaldehyde in artificial seawater at the indicated times after being
pinned together. Without removing the needle, grafts were immersed in
the fixing solution and incubated overnight at 4 °C. To dissolve the
spicules, grafted tissues were desilicified according to Humason (21). Grafts were washed twice with artificial seawater and then with progressively increasing amounts of ethanol in artificial seawater (from 30 to 70%), with a final wash in 70% ethanol in water. Spicules were then removed by treatment with 1.5 N hydrofluoric acid
in 70% ethanol for 4-7 h at room temperature. Grafts were stored in
70% ethanol at 4 °C until processing. Tissues were processed routinely with Richard-Allan dehydrants, cleared in xylene, and embedded in Fisher PARAPLAST®X-TRA paraffin. The needles
were removed once the paraffin hardened. 6-µm sections were
deparaffinized, rehydrated, and washed twice with Tris/NaCl buffer (30 mM Tris-HCl and 0.9% NaCl, pH 7.5). After a wash in 0.1 mM citrate buffer, pH 6.0, the sections were incubated in
0.3% H2O2 for 30 min and washed again with
Tris/NaCl buffer before blocking with 1.5% normal goat serum (Vector
Laboratories, Inc., Burlingame, CA) in Tris/NaCl buffer for 30 min. The
chicken polyclonal antibody Bertha 1 against MAFp3 or the mouse
monoclonal antibody Block 2 against a carbohydrate epitope in MAF was
applied overnight at 4 °C in the blocking solution at a final
concentration of ~1 µg/ml. Subsequently, the sections were washed
twice, incubated with second antibodies (biotinylated goat anti-chicken
and goat anti-mouse, respectively; Vector Laboratories, Inc.) at a
final concentration of ~10 µg/ml for 30 min, rinsed with Tris/NaCl
buffer, and incubated for 30 min with avidin/biotinylated peroxidase
according to the instructions in the VECTASTAIN® ABC kit
(Vector Laboratories, Inc.). After washing with Tris/NaCl buffer, the
sections were incubated with the peroxidase substrate diaminobenzidine
(DAB single solution, Zymed Laboratories, Inc., South
San Francisco, CA) for 1-5 min at room temperature before stopping the
reaction in H2O. The sections were finally mounted with
Kaiser's glycerol gelatin (Merck, Darmstadt, Germany).
Peptide Mass Fingerprinting and Amino Acid Sequencing--
The
AF isolated as described (22) was deglycosylated with
trifluoromethanesulfonic acid according to standard procedures (23).
After reduction and alkylation with iodoacetamide, the proteins were
analyzed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Selected Coomassie
Blue- or Alcian blue-stained bands were excised, and the protein
therein was trypsinized. Tryptic peptides were analyzed by LC-MS as
described (24) using a Rheos 5000 separation system equipped with a
Vydac C8 column (1 × 2500 mm). Peptides were eluted in a linear
gradient of 5-50% buffer B (0.045% trifluoroacetic acid and 80%
acetonitrile in H2O) in buffer A (0.05% trifluoroacetic acid and 2% acetonitrile in H2O) at a flow rate of 50 µl/min. An aliquot of 10% of the effluent was directed on-line to an
API 300 triple quadrupole mass spectrometer (PE Sciex, Concord,
Canada), and 90% was collected for further analysis. The ion spray
voltage of the mass spectrometer was set to 5000 V, and a mass range of 300-2400 Da was scanned with a step size of 0.5 Da and a dwell time of
0.75 ms/mass. Sequence analysis was carried out on a Model 477A protein
sequencer (Applied Biosystems, Inc., Foster City, CA) according to the
recommendations of the manufacturer.
A New Protein Component of MAF--
Of the several
cDNA-derived forms described for the main protein of MAF, we
decided to elongate, in the 5'-direction, MAFp3C and MAFp3D as
representatives of two distinct groups identified by sequence
relatedness (1). The sequences shown in Fig.
1a could not be extended
further due to mismatches between the existing and newly obtained
sequences. We interpret this result as a consequence of the variability
of these proteins, which reduces the probability of amplifying the same
form used to generate the antisense gene-specific primers.
Chemical deglycosylation of MAF yielded, as the main product, MAFp3,
whose first identified cDNA predicted a polypeptide of 35 kDa (14),
beginning with Pro-1883 in MAFp3C. Since this residue is immediately
preceded by Asp, and the Asp-Pro bond is especially sensitive to
acidic conditions (25) such as those of the deglycosylation reaction,
the possibility exists that MAFp3 could be the result of chemical
cleavage of a bigger protein rather than an independent entity in
vivo. However, 36 other Asp-Pro bonds are present in the
sequences from Fig. 1a, although we never detected any
peptides arising from cleavage at those positions. This supports the
view that our deglycosylation conditions do not cause extensive damage to the protein backbone, and therefore, MAFp3 is likely to be translated as part of a single peptide, which is then processed into at
least two proteins. Later in this work, we confirm that the cDNA
sequences extended in the 5'-direction correspond to a longer mRNA
coding for a new protein component of MAF that we will term MAFp4.
MAF-mediated species-specific cell adhesion depends on polyvalent
interactions between N-linked glycans (2, 26). The high
number of NX(S/T) consensus sequences found on MAFp4
confirms the expectation of extensive N-glycosylation, a
hypothesis backed by the sequencing of several tryptic peptides that
yielded a blank instead of a potentially glycosylated Asn (see Figs.
3b and 5c) as result of the inefficient cleavage
by trifluoromethanesulfonic acid of protein-bound GlcNAc (23), which
accounts for ~20% of the total carbohydrate content of MAF (22). MAF
self-interaction is Ca2+-dependent, unlike its
binding to the cell receptor (27). The abundant potential
Ca2+-binding sites of the type DXD (28) that are
present in MAFp4 indicate that self-interaction might not involve only
the acidic glycans, but also the protein core. MAFp4 contains a
reiterated motif of a mean length of 117 residues (Fig. 1b).
Data base searches revealed two significant matches (Fig.
1c). As already described by us (14), the MAFp4 repeat
shares an ~30% identity with a stretch of the intracellular loop of
the Na+-Ca2+ exchanger protein from mammals. In
addition to this, we have now identified an 8-fold reiterated motif in
a cDNA-deduced endoglucanase gene from the symbiontic bacterium
Azorhizobium caulinodans ORS571 sharing a similar degree of
identity with the MAFp4 repeats. The bacterial repeats are ~115 amino
acids long and were also described to show significant similarity to
the Na+-Ca2+ exchangers (29).
MAFp4 Is Highly Polymorphic--
Allogeneic rejection in
Microciona is clearly identified after ~6 h with the naked
eye due to a yellowish line originating from the massive migration to
the region of contact of gray cells, which have been suggested to be
the functional immunocytes of sponges (8). We studied allogeneic
reactions in a population of 23 M. prolifera individuals
with the result that, besides the control autografts, only individuals
14 and 15 did not reject each other (1). To test the genomic
variability of MAFp4, the DraI-digested genomic DNA of this
population was subjected to restriction fragment length polymorphism
analysis using probes I and III, corresponding to MAFp3 and MAFp4,
respectively. The result shown in Fig. 2
reveals an elevated variability in both regions. Individuals 14 and 15 are the only individuals sharing identical fingerprints on Southern
blots using MAF-related probes. In our studies, we considered a sponge
individual all the substance contained by a continuous pinacoderm, the
epithelial cell layer. This assumption, which until now was supported
only by studies of the sponge structure and function (30), is confirmed
by our observation that DNA isolated from cells of different areas
within a continuous pinacoderm yielded an identical restriction
fragment length polymorphism pattern (data not shown).
Anti-MAFp3 Antibodies--
We raised polyclonal antibodies against
the amino-terminal half of MAFp3 and tested them on
trifluoromethanesulfonic acid-deglycosylated MAF. As shown in Fig.
3a, anti-MAFp3 antibody
recognized all major bands between 60 and 30 kDa that were stained with
Coomassie Blue. This region of the gel had been already described to
contain MAFp3 (14). Immunostaining was also observed in a wide region
between 400 and 200 kDa and especially at the origin of the gel, where aggregated material was retained. These two areas were stained also
with Alcian blue, indicating that they still contained carbohydrate. Based on standard protein and carbohydrate determination, however, the
glycan content of the deglycosylated protein was <2%. Trypsin digestion of the weak Alcian blue-stained band of ~400 kDa, whose amino terminus was blocked, yielded complex LC-MS chromatograms (data
not shown). 10 out of 11 of the most prominent peptides could be
assigned to MAFp4C (Figs. 1a and 3b). The few
mismatches are probably a reflection of the variability of the
protein.
When anti-MAFp3 antibody was used to decorate Western blots of M. prolifera cell membranes, in ~20% of the individuals tested, a
strong cross-reactivity was observed with a 68-kDa protein (Fig. 3c). Together with its scarcity, the apparent sensitivity of
the 68-kDa protein to standard storage conditions prevented further analysis. Coomassie Blue or Amido Black staining indicated that the
protein exists in very little amounts, and therefore, it is unlikely
that the strong signal observed on Western blots results from
unspecific binding to a totally unrelated protein. Whereas the 68-kDa
protein was not detected on our Western blots after it had been
freeze-thawed a few times, deglycosylated MAFp3 was not affected by
this procedure, thus reinforcing the view that both proteins are
different entities. A 43-kDa protein was also immunodetected by
anti-MAFp3 antibody on Western blots of sponge cell membranes and in a
fraction obtained upon incubation of the sponge cells in 70 mM NaCl. This protein could be easily isolated from
SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis fractionation of the hypotonic
salt-released proteins and in-gel digested with trypsin, and the
resulting peptides were analyzed by LC-MS. Sequencing of the most
prominent peptides confirmed that the 43-kDa protein was actin. As
expected, sequence comparisons established its closest known relatives
among echinoderm actins (Fig. 3d). Polyclonal rabbit
antibodies raised against squid actin strongly cross-reacted with its
sponge homolog (Fig. 3c). Although its finding in a
hypotonic fraction that was supposed to contain external peripheral
membrane proteins suggests that actin might be present extracellularly in sponges, we believe it is more likely that some cells burst during
the exposure to 70 mM NaCl, releasing cytosolic proteins. However, the existence of extracellular actin has been reported in
several cases (for a review, see Ref. 31), and therefore, it would not
be surprising that a small fraction of actin molecules play some
extracellular function in sponges. According to Coomassie Blue and
Amido Black staining, actin is the most abundant protein in both cell
membranes and 70 mM NaCl fractions, a circumstance that
favors its apparent cross-reactivity with the purified anti-MAFp3 antibodies.
To investigate the existence of any structural features revealed by
antibodies raised against MAF epitopes, 6-µm sections of allogeneic
and isogeneic M. prolifera grafts were incubated either with
anti-MAFp3 antibody or with the monoclonal antibody Block 2, raised
against a carbohydrate epitope of MAF (2). Anti-MAFp3 antibody clearly
revealed a thin layer of cells all along the line of contact of
allogeneic grafts after several hours of grafting (Fig.
4a). This reaction was not
observed in isogeneic grafts (Fig. 4b). Allogeneic grafts at
times under 10 h did not show such a pattern (Fig. 4c),
indicating that the staining does not come from a mere apposition of
epithelial cell layers that might be expressing the epitope before
contact. On the contrary, the pinacoderm was not particularly stained
by anti-MAFp3 antibody (Fig. 4, b-d). 24 h after
grafting, the border line of cells was still easily identified (Fig.
4d), although the time interval during which the signal
persisted was found to depend on the individual combination of the
grafted tissues. The staining observed with anti-MAFp3 antibody was not
due to the accumulation of MAF, as indicated by routine controls done
with monoclonal antibodies raised against carbohydrate epitopes of MAF
(Fig. 4e). Additional controls were performed with sections
prepared as those for in situ hybridization, which were not
treated with hydrofluoric acid. The results were identical to those
obtained with desilicified sections (data not shown), thus indicating
that the treatment with diluted hydrofluoric acid, which is a
deglycosylating agent, did not significantly remove the carbohydrate
epitope recognized by Block 2 from fixed tissue.
Different MAFp3 Forms in AFs of Different Individual
Origin--
To investigate the possibility that MAFs of different
origin might have different core proteins, we proceeded to chemically deglycosylate MAF preparations obtained from different individuals. A
series of protein bands between 38 and 52 kDa were detected (Fig.
5, a and b).
Samples of different individual origin treated in parallel reproducibly
revealed specific combinations of bands, indicating that the observed
polydispersity is a reflection of the in vivo situation
rather than an artifact of deglycosylation. Anti-MAFp3 antibody
decorated all bands with an intensity proportional to that of Coomassie
Blue staining, suggesting that all the forms shared a significant
degree of homology. To confirm this, we separately excised single bands
from SDS gels, digested them with trypsin, and performed LC-MS
analysis. The chromatograms shown in Fig. 5c confirm the
existence of multiple related proteins. cDNA-deduced MAFp3 forms
had been identified whose molecular masses differ between 1 and 5.4 kDa, mainly due to different carboxyl-terminal ends (1), a region for
which we could not obtain peptide sequences from our trypsin digests.
It is likely that major variability in this region will be responsible
for the differences in electrophoretic mobility observed.
Amino-terminal analysis of the 39-, 46-, 49-, 51-, and 52-kDa bands
yielded, for all of them, the sequence of MAFp3 (PLFTVPI).
Accumulation of MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA--
Northern blots of sponge
total RNA showed variable amounts of the MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA (Fig.
6a). The use of probe I
revealed a main transcript of ~12 kb, in accordance with a translated
~400-kDa protein, which might correspond to full-length MAFp4 as
suggested by the Alcian blue-stained gel in Fig. 3a. Often,
the MAFp3-specific probe recognized abundant RNAs below 12 kb (Fig.
6a, top), suggesting the existence, under still
undetermined conditions, of a great variability of MAFp3-related
sequences. Occasionally, bands of ~1 kb were also observed, which are
thought to represent small transcripts containing only the MAFp3
sequence (14). Accordingly, the use of probes corresponding to MAFp4
revealed the ~12-kb band, but never any signal around 1 kb (data not
shown). To study the effect of tissue grafting on the transcription of
MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA, we chose those individuals whose levels of
expression in non-grafted controls were constant and low during the
duration of the experiment. A typical result is presented in Fig.
6b. Grafting of isogeneic or allogeneic tissue coincides
with an accumulation of the MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA. As shown by the
The correlation between the variability of MAF proteins as deduced
from restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis and the
allogeneic behavior within a sponge population supports a possible
involvement of the cell adhesion system in sponge histocompatibility reactions (1). The accumulation in grafts of the mRNA coding for
the protein core of the main adhesion molecule of the sponge adds to
this hypothesis. The phenomena occurring in M. prolifera grafts can be first identified under the microscope ~1 h after grafting, when the pinacoderm begins to be disrupted in both rejecting and accepting grafts (data not shown). It is also at this moment when
MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA starts to accumulate. The function of MAF in
tissue grafts is at present obscure, although the increased transcription of its mRNA under adverse conditions such as necrosis in nearby tissue suggests some role in defense processes. The observations that a cell function such as transcription is so homogeneous in areas of the animal separated by >10 cm and that it can
change dramatically in a time scale of hours indicate that sponges,
despite lacking circulatory and nervous systems, must have an efficient
way to quickly exchange information between cells separated by large distances.
In different individuals, the polymorphic MAFp3 forms were isolated in
variable amounts relative to each other (see 51- and 49-kDa bands in
individuals 1-3; Fig. 5, a and b), an unexpected result if all the cells of the species were always producing the same
type of MAF. This result could indicate that the production of a given
MAFp3 type depends on particular physiological states of the sponge,
and therefore, certain MAFp3 forms would be preferentially present at
different times of the life cycle. An alternative explanation suggests
that different types of cells within the same individual produce
different types of MAF, and therefore, different dosages of cell types
in each preparation would explain the fluctuations in the relative
amounts of MAFp3 forms. Atomic force microscope studies have shown that
Block 2 binds, with very different affinities, individual AF molecules
that were purified from a single sponge (32), and this is in agreement
with the assumption that different types of AF molecules exist that
exhibit distinct specific activities. Peptides containing sequences
exclusive of MAFp3D or MAFp4D have never been found in the many AF
preparations analyzed. The presence in sponge cell membranes of a
68-kDa protein related to the core protein of a highly
glycan-substituted component of the extracellular AF would substantiate
the hypothesis of the existence of proteins phylogenetically related to
those in the AF, but that might have a function other than promoting
species-specific cell adhesion. The appearance in allogeneic grafts of
a cell layer turned on to express an epitope recognized by polyclonal
antibodies raised against MAFp3 could represent the tissue distribution
of the elusive 68-kDa protein. The absence of colocalization with
monoclonal antibodies against MAF glycans suggests that the protein
being detected does not belong to MAF and might be expressed only under particular physiological conditions such as allogeneic contact.
Mixtures of cells dissociated from different individuals of the
freshwater sponge Ephydatia fluviatilis segregated into
clumps containing cells of only one individual several days after a
mixed aggregate was formed (33). Such individual specificity could be
also observed between cell fractions containing only one cell type
(34). Different sponge cell types also show selective reaggregation and
different adhesive properties (35). Therefore, dissociated sponge cells
exhibit species-, individual-, and cell-type specificities in their
reaggregation properties. In rejection studies done by grafting
in situ a population of the marine sponge
Hymeniacidon sp., "interaction modulation factors" were
purified from each individual, and measurements of their adhesion
efficiency were made on cells of all the sponges among which grafting
had been done (36). While the adhesiveness of those cells treated with a factor preparation made from the same sponge or from another strain
whose grafts were accepted was always appreciable, factor from those
strains that were not graft-compatible with the strain type of the
cells led to a very considerable decrease in cell adhesion. The
procedure described to prepare the interaction modulation factors was
equivalent to the method used to extract MAF, suggesting that both
molecules are analogous. If, then, AFs were directly involved in
allorecognition, would they have any structural features resembling
histocompatibility molecules of higher animals?
The reiterated domain found in MAFp4 has several features that vaguely
recall Ig-like domains. It remains a consensus that, to be included in
the Ig superfamily, a molecule has to fulfill certain criteria (37).
Although the first condition sine qua non is the presence of
a domain-sized sequence with significant similarity to Ig-related
domains, there should also be the probability that the sequence shares
key structural characteristics of the Ig fold. Although an adequate
statistical test like the Dayhoff scoring matrix (38) is widely
available to evaluate sequence homologies, structural proof for an
Ig-related domain can only be convincingly established by tertiary
structure determination. Ig chains are thought to have evolved from a
primordial gene coding for ~100 amino acids, with a characteristic
intrachain disulfide bond. Preceding this, there may have been a
half-domain structure, as suggested by the existence of genes that have
introns in the sequence between the conserved cysteines. Genes with the
intradomain introns might therefore be more directly derived from
ancient ancestor genes. The disulfide bond of the Ig fold stabilizes
two The positions of introns in the carboxyl-proximal region of MAFp4 were
determined in our previous work (1). The introns are placed in the
boundaries between domains and, interestingly, in the middle of the
domains (Fig. 7). The reiterated motifs
in MAFp4 are not classical Ig-like domains, but the short
The similarities in the domain structure and sequence between the
sponge adhesion protein MAFp4 and a bacterial endoglucanase reinforce
the hypothesis that the reiterated domains might be involved in the
binding of other proteins and in the attachment of the endoglucanase to
the bacterial surface (29). Such modular nature is a common feature of
many cell adhesion proteins (42). MAFp3, on the other hand, does not
have significant similarities either to the A. caulinodans
endoglucanase or to any other protein or translated DNA sequences in
data bases. In our previous work, however, we reported the existence of
human nucleic acids hybridizing with MAFp3-specific probes on Southern
and Northern blots (1). As a rule, DNA regions can be identified by
annealing if the nucleotide sequences are <30% different (38), thus
suggesting that still unknown proteins that are highly homologous to
MAFp3 exist in higher vertebrates.
Although the role of AFs in species specificity has been clearly
established, we propose here that also individual specificity might be
based on AF-related molecules or even on the AF itself. This scenario
suggests that modern histocompatibility systems might have evolved from
primitive cell adhesion molecules, a hypothesis supported by the
occurrence of putative ancestors of typical Ig domains in MAFp4, a
protein involved in sponge cell adhesion. If, on the other hand, the
histocompatibility system of sponges developed after their split from
the vertebrate evolutionary line, it would represent a fascinating
alternative to allorecognition strategies.
We thank Juliane Alt-Mörbe and Renate
Matthies for DNA and amino acid sequencing, respectively; Peter
Müller for oligonucleotide synthesis; Michelle McCafferty for
histological preparations; Neil Barclay for helpful discussions on
protein sequence analysis; and Ruth Chiquet and Ulrich Müller for
critical comments on the manuscript.
*
The costs of publication of this
article were defrayed in part by the
payment of page charges. The article
must therefore be hereby marked
"advertisement" in
accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section
1734 solely to indicate this fact.
§
Supported by a fellowship from the Human Capital and Mobility
Program (supported by European Union Grant ERBCHBICT930332). To whom
correspondence should be addressed: Friedrich Miescher-Institut, P. O.
Box 2543, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland. Tel.: 41-61-6976954; Fax:
41-61-6973976; E-mail: fernande{at}fmi.ch.
The abbreviations used are:
AFs, aggregation
factors; MAF, Microciona aggregation factor; RACE, rapid
amplification of cDNA ends; kb, kilobase pair(s); LC-MS, liquid
chromatography-mass spectrometry.
Accumulation in Marine Sponge Grafts of the mRNA Encoding the
Main Proteins of the Cell Adhesion System*
§,
,
Marine Biological Laboratory,
Woods Hole, Massachusetts 02543
![]()
ABSTRACT
Top
Abstract
Introduction
Procedures
Results
Discussion
References
![]()
INTRODUCTION
Top
Abstract
Introduction
Procedures
Results
Discussion
References
![]()
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
Top
Abstract
Introduction
Procedures
Results
Discussion
References
80 °C. Peripheral membrane proteins were extracted
by incubation of dissociated sponge cells in 70 mM NaCl on
ice for 1 h (15). After removing the cells by a short
centrifugation, the resulting supernatant was immediately analyzed by
Western blotting, which was performed as described (1). The rabbit
polyclonal antibody raised against squid actin was provided by Prof.
Dr. Ute G. Stewart (Institut für Zoologie, Technische Hochschule,
Darmstadt, Germany).
![]()
RESULTS
Top
Abstract
Introduction
Procedures
Results
Discussion
References

View larger version (96K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 1.
Partial cDNA-deduced protein sequence of
MAFp4. a, alignment of forms C and D of MAFp3/MAFp4
(GenBankTM accession numbers AF020902 and AF020903,
respectively). The boxed carboxyl-terminal region
corresponds to MAFp3, and the rest to MAFp4. Gaps introduced by the
alignment program Gap (Genetics Computer Group, Inc., Madison, WI) are
represented by dots. Boxed peptides correspond
tothose reported in Figs. 3 and 5, identified after trypsin
digestion. Polyclonal anti-MAFp3 IgYs were raised against the sequence
marked in boldface. Sequence C was chosen to design probes I
(between amino acids 1883 and 2205) and III (between amino acids 1 and
207) and the RNA sense and antisense probes for in situ
hybridization (between amino acids 2053 and 2205). The antisense RNA
corresponding to probe I was also generated for its use in Northern
blotting. b, alignment of the 16 tandem repeats in MAFp4C.
The scheme at the top shows the relative positions of the 16 consecutive repeats in the partial cDNA-deduced MAFp4 sequence.
Bars indicate lengths in amino acid residues. In
yellow are marked the positions where at least 8 of 16 residues are identical. c, alignment of repeat 6 from
A. caulinodans endoglucanase (Egl 6;
GenBankTM accession number Z48958), repeat 2 from MAFp4C
(MAFp4C 2), and a region in the rat
Na+-Ca2+ exchanger (NaCa rat;
GenBankTM accession number P70549). In yellow
are marked the positions where at least 2 of 3 residues are
identical.

View larger version (133K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 2.
Restriction fragment length polymorphism
analysis of M. prolifera genomic DNA using MAF-related
probes. 1 µg of DraI-digested genomic DNA from each
of 23 different individuals previously studied for their allogeneic
behavior (1) was loaded per lane. The Southern blot was hybridized
first with probe I (a) and later with probe III
(b), corresponding to MAFp3 and MAFp4, respectively. The
insets show two examples of conflictive bands that could be
resolved in longer runs.

View larger version (53K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 3.
Polyclonal antibodies against MAFp3.
a, trifluoromethanesulfonic acid
(TFMS)-deglycosylated MAF was electrophoresed on a gradient
SDS-polyacrylamide gel (3-20%), transferred to a polyvinylidene
difluoride membrane, and decorated with polyclonal IgYs raised against
the amino-terminal half of MAFp3 (anti-MAFp3). An identical
gel was stained first with Coomassie Blue and later with Alcian blue to
reveal protein- and glycan-containing bands, respectively. The
~400-kDa Alcian blue-stained band was subjected to peptide mass
fingerprinting. b, the sequences of the most
prominent tryptic peptides were determined either by MS analysis and
comparison with the cDNA-deduced sequences (in italics)
or by direct sequencing (all others). The residues found in the
sequence of MAFp4C (Fig. 1a) are indicated in
boldface. Dashes indicate blanks in the sequence
probably due to the presence of a modified amino acid. c,
Western blots of M. prolifera cell membrane proteins
(Membranes) and of peripheral cell membrane proteins
(70 mM NaCl extract) fractionated on
a 12.5% SDS-polyacrylamide gel and stained with Amido Black or
decorated with anti-MAFp3 IgYs (anti-MAFp3) or with rabbit
polyclonal antibodies raised against squid actin
(anti-actin). d, alignment of the complete actin
sequence from the sea urchin Strongylocentratus purpuratus
(GenBankTM accession number P53472) with the main tryptic
peptides obtained from M. prolifera actin excised from SDS
gels. Nonconserved amino acids are boxed in the sponge
sequence.

View larger version (92K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 4.
Immunohistochemistry. Sections of
contact areas of allografts (allo) and isografts
(iso) were incubated either with anti-MAFp3 polyclonal
antibodies or with the monoclonal antibody Block 2, raised against a
carbohydrate epitope in MAF. The times indicate hours between grafting
and fixation of the tissues. Arrows show the direction of
the line of contact between grafts. Arrowheads mark the
pinacoderm. Magnification × 40.

View larger version (58K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 5.
Individual variability of MAFp3
sequences. Deglycosylated MAF from five different individuals was
fractionated by 10% SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and the
protein bands were detected either by anti-MAFp3 IgYs on Western blots
(a; ~40 µg of protein/lane) or by Coomassie Blue
staining (b; ~0.4 mg of protein/lane). The eight main
bands between 52 and 38 kDa identified with both methods were excised
from Coomassie Blue-stained gels and trypsinized, and the resulting
peptides were analyzed by LC-MS (c). Peak intensities are
represented in arbitrary A280 nm units. Tryptic
digests yielding chromatograms whose main peaks coincided with those of
the 49-kDa band are indicated in parentheses. We could not
obtain enough material for a reliable analysis from the 39-kDa band.
Those peptides identified in the sequences from Fig. 1a are
indicated. The two forms of peptide T4 were sequenced for confirmation
(c, bottom), and the exchanged residue is
underlined.
-actin control, this does not seem to be the consequence of a
generalized enhanced transcription. Occasionally, the control samples
removed at the end of the experiment from parts of the animal ~10 cm
apart showed a dramatic accumulation of the MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA
throughout the body, whereas tissue separated from the animal at the
beginning of the experiment and kept under the same conditions as the
grafts exhibited relatively constant low levels (Fig. 6c).
Such accumulation was generally observed in the healthy areas of sponge
individuals with patches of decaying tissue. In situ
hybridization (Fig. 6, d and e) showed that the
MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA was homogeneously distributed in the grafted
tissues.

View larger version (75K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 6.
Detection of MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA in grafted
tissue. a, different transcription levels in three
different individuals. b, accumulation of MAFp3/MAFp4
mRNA from individual 69 in grafted and non-grafted tissues. Control
total RNA was isolated from two different parts of the sponge body
before the experiment started (C0) and after 24 h
(C24), when the RNA of the last time point had been
isolated. Control non-grafted papillae (NOT GRAFTED) were
incubated under the same conditions as those used for the grafts. Total
RNA was separately isolated and analyzed from each papilla of isografts
(ISOGENEIC). To observe the transcription levels of
individual 69 in allografts (ALLOGENEIC), papillae of
individual 62 were used as allogeneic tissue. Total RNA was isolated at
the specified times after grafting. c, accumulation of
MAFp3/MAFp4 mRNA from individual 65 in grafted and non-grafted
tissues. The experimental setup was as described for b. As
controls, total RNA was isolated from four different parts of the
sponge before the experiment started (C0) and from five
different parts after the RNA of the last time point had been isolated
(C23). d and e, in situ
hybridization of 7-h isograft sections with sense and antisense
MAFp3-specific RNA probes, respectively. Arrows mark the
line of contact. The dark areas in the sense control are due to light
refracted by the sponge spicules.
![]()
DISCUSSION
Top
Abstract
Introduction
Procedures
Results
Discussion
References
-sheets that consist of anti-parallel
-strands containing
5-10 amino acids. Last, but not least, Ig-related molecules diverge very rapidly, as indicated by the percentage of identity between species. For instance, the variable-like domain of CD8 chain I is only
42% identical between rodents and humans.
-strand-forming regions in the MAFp4 repeats (Fig. 7) could evolve
toward the
-barrel of the most classical Ig folds with just a few
mutations, easily achievable during the period of time between the
appearance of sponges 600 million years ago and the earliest occurrence
of a typical Ig domain, identified by sequence analysis in the insect proteins fasciclin II (39) and amalgam (40). An evolutionary connection, however, is difficult to prove with only the basis of
protein sequence comparison due to the enormous variability of the
molecules belonging to the Ig superfamily. Considerable variation in
sequence length of typical Ig domains occurs between the conserved
disulfide bond, ranging from 40 to 75 amino acids. Often,
-sheets
contain
-breaking residues like a proline in
-strand D of several
C1 set sequences (37). Some Ig folds like those in the T cell adhesion
molecules CD2 and LFA-3 even lack the disulfide bond. Finally, despite
that most of the superfamily consists of membrane-bound members,
non-cell surface molecules like
1B-glycoprotein and the
basement membrane link protein are also included. Based on simple
alignment programs, polymorphic Ig-like featuring genes have been
described in the marine sponge Geodia cydonium (41),
suggesting that the evolutionary origin of the Ig fold might have to be
pushed back to the lowest contemporary invertebrate phylum, if not
beyond. Alternatively, the Ig system may have arisen independently, and
the similarity of the Ig domain may be the result of convergent
evolution imposed by its functional properties.

View larger version (44K):
[in a new window]
Fig. 7.
Intron placement and putative
-strands in
the tandem repeats of MAFp4C. Cysteines are boxed.
Stretches of at least 5 amino acids that form or do not break
-strands are shaded. Intron positions in repeats 10-16
are marked with arrowheads.
![]()
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
![]()
FOOTNOTES
![]()
REFERENCES
Top
Abstract
Introduction
Procedures
Results
Discussion
References
Copyright © 1998 by The American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Inc.
![]()
CiteULike
Complore
Connotea
Del.icio.us
Digg
Reddit
Technorati What's this?
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. Sabella, E. Faszewski, L. Himic, K. M. Colpitts, J. Kaltenbach, M. M. Burger, and X. Fernandez-Busquets Cyclosporin A Suspends Transplantation Reactions in the Marine Sponge Microciona prolifera J. Immunol., November 1, 2007; 179(9): 5927 - 5935. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Garcia-Manyes, I. Bucior, R. Ros, D. Anselmetti, F. Sanz, M. M. Burger, and X. Fernandez-Busquets Proteoglycan Mechanics Studied by Single-molecule Force Spectroscopy of Allotypic Cell Adhesion Glycans J. Biol. Chem., March 3, 2006; 281(9): 5992 - 5999. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
W. J. Kuhns, D. Rusciano, J. Kaltenbach, M. Ho, M. Burger, and X. Fernandez-Busquets Up-regulation of Integrins {alpha}3 {beta}1 in Sulfate-Starved Marine Sponge Cells: Functional Correlates Biol. Bull., October 1, 2001; 201(2): 238 - 239. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||