Originally published In Press as doi:10.1074/jbc.M004232200 on June 13, 2000
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 275, Issue 45, 35413-35423, November 10, 2000
Kinesin Has Three Nucleotide-dependent
Conformations
IMPLICATIONS FOR STRAIN-DEPENDENT RELEASE*
Jun
Xing
,
Willy
Wriggers§,
Geraldine M.
Jefferson¶,
Richard
Stein
,
Herbert C.
Cheung
, and
Steven S.
Rosenfeld¶**
From the Departments of
Biochemistry and Molecular
Genetics and ¶ Neurology and the
Graduate Program in Cell
and Molecular Biology, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham,
Alabama 35294 and the § Department of Molecular Biology,
Scripps Research Institute, La Jolla, California 92037
Received for publication, May 17, 2000, and in revised form, June 9, 2000
 |
ABSTRACT |
Although crystallographic information is
available on several nucleotide-induced states in myosin, little is
known about the corresponding structural changes in kinesin, since a
crystallographic model is only available for the kinesin:ADP complex.
This makes it difficult to characterize at a molecular level the
structural changes that occur in this motor through the course of its
ATPase cycle. In this study, we report on the production of a series of
single tryptophan mutants of a monomeric human kinesin motor domain,
which demonstrate nucleotide-dependent changes in microtubule affinity that are similar to wild type. We have used these mutations to
measure intramolecular distances in both strong and weak binding states, using florescence resonance energy transfer. This work provides
direct evidence that movement of the switch II loop and helix are
essential to mediate communication between the catalytic and
microtubule binding sites, evidence that is supported as well by
molecular modeling. Kinetic studies of fluorescent nucleotide binding
to these mutants are consistent with these distance changes, and
demonstrate as well that binding of ADP produces two structural transitions, neither of which are identical to that produced by the
binding of ATP. This study provides a basis for understanding current
structural models of the kinesin mechanochemical cycle.
 |
INTRODUCTION |
A thorough understanding of the mechanism of action of molecular
motors requires molecular-level detail on the structures of the
intermediates in the motor's chemomechanical cycle. Such information
is now available through the use of crystallographic models of the
molecular motor myosin in various nucleotide states, and this has
provided direct evidence that small conformational changes induced by
nucleotide hydrolysis and product release are amplified by a segment
that connects the motor and regulatory domains (1), and that drives
translational movement of the latter (2). A similar level of
understanding of the mechanism of the motor kinesin is not available,
since crystallographic information is only available in the ADP-bound
state (3, 4). Nevertheless, a variety of methods have been used to
examine the structural transitions that this motor undergoes through
its ATPase cycle. Fluorescence anisotropy decay studies of labeled
kinesin dimer constructs, for example, demonstrated the presence of a hinge connecting the motor domains to the tail, whose flexibility varied with the nucleotide present in the active site (5). Likewise,
image reconstructions of kinesin-decorated microtubules were
interpreted to show a nucleotide-dependent change in
orientation in the kinesin motor domain when attached to a microtubule
(6).
A combination of spectroscopic and imaging techniques have more
recently been used to address the nature of the conformational changes
that kinesin undergoes in its ATPase cycle (7). Both spin resonance and
fluorescence resonance energy transfer studies of single cysteine
mutants of the motor domain demonstrated conformational differences
between nucleotide-free and
AMPPNP1-saturated kinesin
motor domains, but only when the kinesin motor domain was bound to
microtubules. Image reconstructions of cryoelectron micrographs of
gold-labeled kinesin constructs also demonstrated a change in the
orientation of the carboxyl terminus. However, EM studies also revealed
that, although the carboxyl terminus of microtubule-bound
kinesin:AMPPNP or kinesin:ADP:AlF4 assumed a single
orientation, that for either nucleotide-free kinesin or kinesin:ADP
could assume one of two discrete orientations while bound to the
microtubule. If the equilibrium constant between these two states were
to have a large temperature dependence, the free energy for this
transition could provide additional force or movement. Thus, structural
models of the kinesin mechanochemical cycle need to be consistent with
information on the number of nucleotide-dependent kinesin
states and on the equilibrium and rate constants that connect them.
In this study, we have addressed this issue by generating a series of
single tryptophan mutants of human kinesin. We have measured
intramolecular distances between these tryptophan residues and a
fluorophore in the catalytic site in various kinesin:nucleotide states,
by using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). Results of FRET
studies are consistent with kinetic studies of nucleotide binding to
these mutant kinesins, and demonstrate that kinesin can assume three
discrete conformations. The relevance of these conformations to models
of strain-dependent release and processivity will be discussed.
 |
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES |
Materials--
Oligonucleotide primers used in the mutagenesis
were synthesized by Life Technologies, Inc. The QuikChange
site-directed mutagenesis kit was obtained from Stratagene, Inc. (La
Jolla, Ca.). Media components were obtained from Difco Laboratories
(Detroit, MI). Protease inhibitors,
isopropyl-
-D-thiogalactopyranoside, and reagents for
buffers and agarose gel electrophoresis were obtained from Sigma.
Ribonuclease A and deoxyribonuclease I were purchased from Roche
Molecular Biochemicals. Pre-packed Sephadex G25 columns were purchased
from Amersham Pharmacia Biotech. Nickel-nitrilotriacetic acid-agarose
was obtained from Qiagen (Chatsworth, CA). Chemicals used for
SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis were from Bio-Rad. Centriprep-10
concentrators were purchased from Amicon, Inc. (Cherry Hill, NJ).
Site-directed Mutagenesis and Kinesin
Preparation--
Mutagenesis was carried out by using a clone of human
kinesin kindly provided by Dr. Ron Vale (University of California, San Francisco, CA). Mutagenesis was performed according to the QuikChange kit protocol, and mutations were verified by DNA sequencing. The mutated plasmid was transformed into XL1-Blue Escherichia
coli. Transformants were selected on plates of LB with 100 µg/ml
ampicillin. The mutants were analyzed by agarose electrophoresis and
sequenced. Positive DNA was transformed into E. coli
BL21(DE3) for expression of each mutant. Transformants were selected on
plates of LB with 100 µg/ml ampicillin. For purification of Val-238,
Ala-260, Phe-318, and Val-329, 12 liters of culture were grown at
30 °C and 250 rpm in LB with 200 µg/ml ampicillin for 48 h.
For preparation of Tyr-228, cultures were grown at 37 °C and induced
for 3 h by the addition of
isopropyl-
-D-thiogalactopyranoside to 1 mM.
Cells were harvested by centrifugation and stored at
70 °C.
For preparation of the kinesin mutant proteins, the frozen cells were
thawed and resuspended in 3 ml of cold Lysis Buffer (50 mM
Tris, pH 7.9, 10% sucrose, 0.3 M NaCl, 5 mM
MgCl2, 0.5 mM ADP, 1 mM
phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride, 2 µg/ml leupeptin, 1 µg/ml pepstatin
A, 2 µg/ml aprotinin)/g of cells. Lysozyme was added to 1 mg/ml, and
the suspension was kept cold on ice for 30 min with occasional mixing.
The sample was sonicated, ribonuclease A was added to 10 µg/ml,
deoxyribonuclease I was added to 5 µg/ml, and the suspension was
incubated on ice for 15 min, followed by centrifugation at 15,000 × g for 20 min. The clarified sample was filtered and added
to 12 ml of a 1:1 suspension of nickel-nitrilotriacetic acid-agarose
pre-equilibrated in Lysis Buffer. The sample was nutated at 4 °C for
2 h. The resin was pelleted and loaded into a 0.5 × 3-cm
column at 4 °C. The column was washed for 2 h at 0.6 ml/min
with Wash Buffer (20 mM Tris, pH 7.9, 0.5 mM
NaCl, 5 mM MgCl2, 0.5 mM ADP, 1 mM phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride). The kinesin was eluted
with a gradient of 40-500 mM imidazole in Wash Buffer.
Microtubule ATPase and Binding Assays--
The microtubule
activated ATPase activity of kinesin constructs was measured by mixing
20-30 nM kinesin with a greater than 20-fold molar excess
of taxol-stabilized microtubules in 20 mM HEPES, 50 mM potassium acetate, 5 mM MgCl2, 1 mM dithiothreitol, 0.1% bovine serum albumin, 2 mM ATP, pH 7.20. ATP hydrolysis was monitored by the
oxidation of NADH in an enzyme-linked assay, as described (8). Binding
affinities of kinesin constructs in the presence of ADP ± aluminum fluoride were determined by an centrifugation assay, as
described (9).
Kinetic Measurements--
Rates of binding of 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP
and 3'-deoxy-mant-ATP to nucleotide-free kinesin constructs were made
in a Hi-Tech stopped flow spectrometer with instrument dead time of 1.6 ms. Kinesin samples were made nucleotide-free immediately prior to the
experiment with apyrase, as described (10). Binding of nucleotide was
monitored by energy transfer, using an input monochromator to generate
an excitation wavelength of 295 nm and a 400-nm long pass filter for
the output, as described in prior studies (11, 18).
For studies of phosphate release rates, kinesin samples were made
nucleotide-free with apyrase, as described (10), and mixed in one
syringe of the stopped flow with a 2-fold molar excess of MDCC-labeled
phosphate-binding protein. Varying concentrations of ATP were placed in
the other syringe, and both syringes contained 100 µM 7 methylguanosine, 0.5 unit/ml purine nucleoside phosphorylase. The rate
of phosphate binding to the MDCC-labeled phosphate binding protein was
measured by setting the excitation monochromator to 425 nm and by using
a 450-nm long pass filter over the output photomultiplier. The
absorbance profile of the 450-nm output filter demonstrated negligible
transmission at the exciting wavelength.
Time-resolved Fluorescence Measurements--
Complexes of
2'-deoxy-mant-ADP ± aluminum fluoride with kinesin mutants were
made as described previously (9). The fractional binding of the mant
nucleotide to kinesin was determined by equilibrium filtration
through Centricon tubes (Amicon). This information was used to correct
for the less than complete labeling of construct with fluorescent
nucleotide. In fact, labeling ratios were in the range of 0.84-0.96
for the various constructs. Complexes of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP with
aluminum fluoride were prepared as described previously (9). In brief,
a 10-fold molar excess of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP was added to each
construct, and allowed to bind for 20 min at 4 °C. AlNO3
was added to 1 mM, NaF was added to 5 mM, and
the complex was allowed to equilibrate at room temperature for an additional 20 min. Excess nucleotide was removed by gel filtration on
pre-poured Sephadex G25 columns (PD10, Amersham Pharmacia Biotech).
All fluorescence measurements were made at 20 ± 0.1 °C. Steady
state emission spectra were recorded on an ISS PCI photon-counting spectrophotometer. These spectra were corrected for variation of the
detector system with wavelength. Quantum yields of tryptophan residues
were determined with the comparative method, as described (12).
Fluorescence intensity decay of tryptophan was measured in the time
domain with an IBH 5000 photon-counting lifetime system equipped with a
very stable flash lamp operated at 40 kHz in 0.5 atmosphere of
hydrogen. For FRET studies, the intensity decay data of the donor
tryptophan collected from donor-alone and donor-acceptor samples were
used to calculate the distribution of interprobe distances as described
previously (12, 13). The distributions of the distances were calculated
using the program CFS_LS/GAUDIS, assuming the probability distribution
to be a Gaussian function. The distance distribution is characterized
by two parameters: the mean distance R and the half-width of
the distribution. The value of the half-width is related to the
standard deviation of the distribution (
) by the relationship:
half-width = 2.354
. The Forster critical distance
Ro was determined for each donor-acceptor pair
and for both strong and weak binding states. Because the two recovered
distance parameters, R and the half-width, are highly correlated, the goodness-of-fit values of
R2 depend on the entire
set of parameters, not just a single one (14). An additional problem is
that the variance space is usually non-linear. The joint confidence
intervals for a given determined parameter can be judged by examining
the
R2 surfaces calculated
by the support plane procedure (14). These surfaces were calculated for
the mean distance and half-width as has been done in previous analyses
of distance distributions (12, 13, 15).
Simulations of Kinesin Mutant Structure--
The simulations
were carried out with the program X-PLOR (36) using the CHARMM force
field (37), version 24, and simulation parameters as described (29).
2'-Deoxy-mant-ADP and ATP were parametrized by combining standard
CHARMM parameters and atomic charges for the nucleotides with those of
phenylalanine, methylated COOH terminus from methyl acetate, and
N-methylamide COOH terminus (for the fluorophore). The
stereochemistry of the resulting model was validated by
energy-minimization and visual inspection. The force field for
2'-deoxy-mant-ADP and ATP is available from the authors.
We modeled mant-ADP and mant-ATP kinesin starting from the ADP crystal
structure of rat kinesin (4), including the crystallographic water
molecules. The triphosphate of the nucleotide for the ATP case was
constructed based on our earlier model (29). In addition to the
modification of the nucleotide, side chains corresponding to the five
tryptophan mutants (human kinesin numbering: 228, 238, 260, 318, 329)
were replaced with tryptophan side chains (rat kinesin numbering: 229, 239, 261, 320, 331). To account for the effect of surface water,
kinesin was immersed in a shell of explicit water molecules of 6-Å
thickness, which corresponds to approximately two layers of water
molecules. The total size of solvated (mant) ADP-kinesin was 10,017 atoms (1545 water molecules), and the total size of solvated (mant)
ATP-kinesin was 9,988 atoms (1534 water molecules).
The kinesin structures were refined by simulated annealing (29), using
a maximum temperature of 500 K. After an initial energy minimization,
the systems were heated up to 500 K in steps of 10 K by Langevin
dynamics (36, 38) over a 50-ps time period, using a uniform friction
constant of 50 ps
1 for heavy atoms and 0 for
hydrogen atoms. The temperature was held constant (at 500 K) from 50 to 80 ps. Subsequently the systems were cooled down from in
steps of 1.5 K over a 200-ps time period. The annealing was stopped at
the low temperature of 200 K, which quenched the mobility of the cooled
system. The final structures were energy-minimized after a total of 280 ps of simulation.
We employed distance constraints in certain simulated systems to
stabilize desired conformations or to induce desired conformational transitions. First, the nucleotide sugar and base were anchored to the
protein by constraining six atom pair distances to their crystallographic values using a Hookean potential (force constant 5.0 kcal mol
1 Å
2):
N6-CZ14, N7-CA91, C2-NE294,
C2-CB16, C5'-CB16, C5'-CG94
(following Protein Data Bank nomenclature; the first atom refers to the
nucleotide, and the second, including the subscript residue number,
refers to the protein). This procedure was necessary to prevent a
detachment of the nucleotide after invoking FRET-based distance
constraints. The phosphate and fluorophore were allowed to move freely.
Also, as described elsewhere (29), we enforced the proper coordination of the
-phosphate in ATP-kinesin by constraining the distance between the
-phosphorus and the
-carbon of rat Gly-235 (= human Gly-234) to 3.9 Å using a Hookean potential (force constant 5.0 kcal
mol
1Å
2). Finally,
FRET distance constraints were enforced in certain simulated annealing
simulations between the centroids of the resonant side chains of the
tryptophan residues and those of the mant fluorophore. The constraints
were enforced using XPLOR NOE constraints (37), ramped linearly from
zero to their maximum value of 5.0 kcal mol
1
Å
2 during 30-80 ps of simulation time, and
subsequently held constant during the 80-280-ps cooling period. In
this work we present results of enforcing a single constraint at
residue 239 in the human kinesin sequence (39).
 |
RESULTS |
Steady State Binding and Enzymatic Properties of Kinesin
Mutants--
The motor domain of wild type human kinesin is devoid of
tryptophans. We have taken advantage of this by generating five mutants with trytophan substituting for Tyr-228, Val-238, Ala-260, Phe-318, and
Val-329. These residues are located in
7, L11,
4,
6, and the
neck linker, as defined by the crystal structure of kinesin:ADP (3, 4).
Each mutant was cloned into the pET 21D vector, generating a protein
consisting of the 332 amino-terminal residues of human kinesin, which
constitute the motor domain, followed by a hexahistidine sequence for
affinity purification (9). Hence, each mutant contains only one
tryptophan residue, located in the above-defined positions. These
mutants were generated in order to look at changes in FRET efficiencies
as a function of microtubule binding state. The microtubule affinity of
kinesin is modulated by the nucleotide occupying its catalytic site,
with ADP generating a "weak" binding conformation and ATP
generating a "strong" binding conformation (9, 16). In order to
ensure that these mutants are still capable of demonstrating a
strong-to-weak transition, we measured binding of these mutant kinesin
constructs to microtubules by a cosedimentation assay, as described
previously (9). Binding was measured in the presence of 1 mM ADP, to generate a weak binding state, and in the
presence of 1 mM ADP, 1 mM AlNO3, and 5 mM NaF, to produce a strong binding state (9, 10). As
Table I demonstrates, Y228W, F318W, and
V329W bind to microtubules in the presence of ADP with affinities
similar to wild type, whereas the affinity of A260W is 3.5-fold lower.
In the presence of 1 mM ADP, maximal binding for these
constructs was 0.86-0.92. No appreciable binding of V238W could be
demonstrated in the presence of 1 mM ADP. By contrast,
addition of AlF4 + ADP enhanced the affinities of each
construct, including V238W to values similar to wild type. In the
presence of AlF4 + ADP, maximal binding was 0.82-0.94 for
these constructs. Mutation of Ala-260 and Val-238 to tryptophan appears
to selectively reduce the microtubule affinity of kinesin:ADP, while
having little effect on the affinity of the kinesin:ATP state.
Nevertheless, the data in Table I demonstrates that each mutant is able
to undergo a weak-to-strong conformational change, as evidenced by the
marked increase in microtubule affinity induced by addition of aluminum
fluoride.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table I
Dissociation constants for microtubule:kinesin binding in ADP ± AlF4
Conditions: 20 mM HEPES, 50 mM potassium
acetate, 5 mM MgCl2, 1 mM
dithiothreitol, 0.1% bovine serum albumin, 4 mM ATP, pH
7.20. Values are ± 1 standard deviation.
KD(ADP), dissociation constant for
microtubule binding in the presence of 1 mM ADP.
KD(ADP+AlF4), dissociation
constant for microtubule binding in the presence of 1 mM
ADP, 1 mM AlNO3, and 5 mM NaF. Values
are ± 1 standard deviation.
|
|
The MgATPase activity of each mutant was measured (8) in the absence
and presence of microtubules, and data were fitted to a hyperbolic
dependence of rate on microtubule concentration. Table
II summarizes the values of
kcat, K0.5(MT), and
kcat/K0.5(MT) for wild
type K332 and for each of the single tryptophan mutants. Each of the
mutants demonstrates a basal MgATPase activity, which varies from
0.03 ± 0.01 s
1 for F318W to 0.08 ± 0.04 s
1 for V238W, and compares to
0.03 ± 0.01 s
1 for wild type.
Microtubule activation is minimal for V238W, reaching only 20-fold at
30 µM microtubules, and making measures of
kcat as well as K0.5(MT)
highly unreliable. Our previous study (9) had demonstrated that the
value of K0.5(MT) is a measure of the microtubule affinity of the predominant species under steady state conditions, which for wild type kinesin is an ADP-bound state. Values
of K0.5(MT) for Y228W and F318W are also similar
to wild type. For A260W, the binding affinity in the presence of ADP is consistent with the increase in K0.5(MT). In
addition, the value of
kcat/K0.5(MT) is 10-fold
lower than wild type, and suggests that there is a defect in the
binding of the predominant steady state intermediate with microtubules.
Similar results have been noted with S246F, a mutation in nearby L11
(34). By contrast, although kcat and
K0.5(MT) are lower in V329W,
kcat/K0.5(MT) is similar
to wild type and suggests that the binding of the predominant nucleotide intermediate of this mutant to microtubules is normal.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table II
ATPase properties of kinesin mutants
Conditions were as described in Table I. Values are ± 1 standard
deviation.
|
|
Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer Distance
Measurements--
We have utilized the spectroscopic properties of
these five single tryptophan mutants to measure intramolecular
distances in strong and weak binding states using the technique of FRET (12, 13, 15). FRET distances were measured by determining the effect of
a fluorescent ADP analogue (2'-deoxy-mant-ADP) in the catalytic site on
the time-dependent fluorescence decay of the tryptophan
residues. Table III summarizes values of
the quantum yield (Q), overlap integral (J), and
the Forster critical distance (Ro) for the five
tryptophan-mant donor-acceptor pairs in the presence of ADP ± aluminum fluoride. As can be seen from the table, in the presence of
ADP, four of the five tryptophan mutants have quantum yields lower than
that for tryptophan in solution (Q = 0.14); and all of
them are lower than 0.14 in the presence of ADP + AlF4.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table III
Steady state tryptophan fluorescence properties of the five kinesin
mutants
Conditions were as described in Table I. Q, tryptophan
quantum yield in the absence of FRET acceptor; J, overlap
integral between donor (tryptophan) emission and acceptor (mant)
absorption spectra, in units of M 1 cm 1
nm4; R0, Forster critical transfer distance.
|
|
A donor-acceptor distance in a protein may not have a unique value
because of protein dynamics. Instead, a more accurate approach is to
describe the distance between donor and acceptor as a distribution of
distances, with a mean distance, R, and a half-width of the distribution. The latter is thus a measure of the magnitude of the
oscillation of the donor and acceptor around R. Table
IV lists the values of R and
half-widths for samples in the presence of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP ± AlF4. As Table IV demonstrates, the transition from the
weak binding to the strong binding state is accompanied by distance
changes that range from less than 1 Å to over 3.5 Å. Because of the
strong correlation of the two parameters, R and the
half-width, it is necessary to determine the range of mean distances
consistent with the data by examining the
R2 surfaces of the mean
distances (14, 15). The range of mean distance is defined by the values
of
R2 in the
R2 surface with random
noise in 68% of repetitive measurements (one standard deviation). The
calculated surfaces for R were sharp, as indicated by the
narrow half-widths of the distributions. These surfaces for the
half-widths were also sharp. If the
R2 surfaces of
R for two distributions are sharp and intersect at
R2 values above the 68%
cutoff, the distributions can be considered to be distinct (15). Using
this criterion, we find differences in R between strong and
weak binding states are significant for Y228W, F318W, and V329W.
Likewise, the
R2 surfaces
of the half-widths are also sharp, indicating narrow ranges in the
recovered values. Differences in half-width values between strong and
weak binding states are significant for only V238W, A260W, and
V329W.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table IV
FRET distances and half-widths in kinesin in strong and weak states
RADP, FRET distance, in angstroms, between
tryptophan residue and mant fluorophor of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP.
RADP+AlF4, FRET distance, in angstroms,
between tryptophan residue and mant fluorophor of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP in
the presence of aluminum fluoride. Half-width (ADP), halfwidth of
distance distribution between tryptophan and mant fluorophor for
kinesin samples in the presence of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP. Half-width
(ADP + AlF4): corresponding halfwidth in the presence of
2'-deoxy-mant-ADP + aluminum fluoride.
|
|
Transient Kinetic Studies of 2'-Deoxy-mant-ATP Binding to Kinesin
Mutants--
In the FRET measurements discussed above, it has been
assumed that the kinesin motor domain assumes an "ATP"-like
conformation in the presence of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP + aluminum fluoride.
In order to confirm this, we have examined the kinetics of the
2'-deoxy-mant-ATP binding to each of the kinesin mutants, by monitoring
mant fluorescence through energy transfer from the tryptophan residues.
The distance changes summarized in Table IV, along with the values of
Ro summarized in Table III, can together be used
to predict changes that occur in the steady state emission of the mant
fluorophore in the strong-to-weak transition. In particular, if
2'-deoxy-mant-ATP is mixed with nucleotide-free F318W in the stopped
flow under conditions of energy transfer excitation, the resulting
fluorescence transient should consist of two phases, reflecting changes
in the tryptophan-mant distance during nucleotide hydrolysis. There
should be an initial rising phase, due to binding of 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP
to the active site, and the rate of this rising phase should
demonstrate a hyperbolic dependence on nucleotide concentration.
Hydrolysis of the bound 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP, however, will cause the
tryptophan in position 318 to move away from the mant fluorophore by
1.2 Å, which would be associated with a decrease in the fluorescence
emission intensity by 28%. Furthermore, the rate of this falling phase
should not demonstrate a nucleotide concentration dependence, and
should match the rate of nucleotide hydrolysis and/or phosphate
release. The fluorescence transient depicted in Fig.
1A demonstrates that this is
the case. The fluorescence transient demonstrates both a rising and
falling phase. The rate of the first phase demonstrates a hyperbolic
dependence of rate on ligand concentration, whereas the second phase
does not (Fig. 2A). Finally,
the rate of the falling phase matches the
rate of phosphate release, measured with MDCC-labeled phosphate-binding
protein (Fig. 3A, Table V). In
this experiment, a mixture of nucleotide-free F318W was mixed in the
stopped flow with an excess of ATP, with an equal concentration of
MDCC-labeled phosphate binding protein in each syringe. The rate of the
initial fluorescence rise, indicating phosphate release in the first
turnover, was plotted as a function of final ATP concentration. The
data fit a hyperbolic dependence with a maximum rate of 5.2 s
1, very close to the rate of the falling
phase in Fig. 2A (7.6 s
1).

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1.
Fluorescence transient produced by mixing
F318W (A), Y228W (B), and V238W
(C) with 2'dmT and monitoring by energy transfer.
The jagged curve is the fluorescence tracing, and the
smooth curve is a fit to two exponential processes
(A and B) or one (C). For F318W
(A) and Y228W (B), the fluorescence transient
consists of a rising phase followed by a falling phase. By contrast,
the transient for V238W (C) is monophasic.
|
|

View larger version (12K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
Rates of the two phases of the fluorescence
transient produced by mixing F318W (A), Y228W
(B), and V238W (C) with 2'dmT,
plotted as a function of [2'dmT]. Conditions were as follows: 20 mM Hepes, 50 mM potassium acetate, 1 mM MgCl2, 1 mM dithiothreitol, pH
7.2, 20 °C. For F318W (A) and Y228W (B), the
rate of the rising phase demonstrates a hyperbolic ligand concentration
dependence (closed squares), whereas the rate of
the falling phase is independent of ligand concentration
(open squares). By contrast, the transient for
V238W (C) is monophasic, and the rate of this transient
demonstrates hyperbolic ligand concentration dependence. The hyperbolic
concentration dependence of the rates define apparent second order rate
constants and maximum rates summarized in Table V.
|
|

View larger version (23K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
A, rate of phosphate release from Y228W,
V238W, A260W, F318W, and V329W plotted as a function of [ATP].
Phosphate release rates were measured by mixing kinesin construct + MDCC-labeled phosphate-binding protein with ATP in the stopped flow.
Conditions were as in Fig. 1. Data were fitted to a series of
hyperbolas, defining maximum rates of phosphate release of 6.8 s 1 (Y228W), 5.6 s 1
(V238W), 3.3 s 1 (A260W), 5.2 s 1 (F318W), and 7.0 s 1 (V329W). Apparent binding constants
derived from the hyperbolic fits range from 9.6 µM
(V238W) to 26.5 µM (Y228W). B, rate of
phosphate release from complexes of microtubule with Y228W, V238W,
F318W, and V329W, plotted as a function of [ATP]. Conditions were as
in A. Maximum rates of microtubule-activated phosphate
release in the first turnover are 39.2 ± 2.9 s 1 for Tyr-228, 9.9 ± 0.7 s 1 for Val-238, 22.9 ± 1.4 s 1 for Phe-318, and 72.6 ± 4.6 s 1 for Val-329. Apparent binding constants
range from 77 µM (V329W) to 244 µM (F318W),
consistent with a reduction in nucleotide affinity induced by
microtubule binding.
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table V
Kinetic constants for binding of 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP to kinesin
constructs and comparison to rates of phosphate release
Data for binding of 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP to kinesin constructs were fitted
to a rapid equilibrium binding step, followed by two sequential steps
as follows,
where T is ATP or 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP, K is the kinesin
construct, D is ADP, and Pi is inorganic phosphate. The
apparent second order rate constant for nucleotide binding is
ka = K0 ( 1), where
1 is the maximum rate of the first phase in the fluorescence
transient, obtained by fitting the dependence of rate to a hyperbolic
function. The rate of the second phase, when present, is defined as
2. It is compared to the rate of phosphate production
( Phos), monitored by mixing kinesin constructs + MDCC-labeled phosphate-binding protein with ATP. dmT,
2'-deoxy-mant-ATP.
|
|
Data in Table IV also predict that mixing Y228W with 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP
should likewise produce a biphasic transient with the amplitude of the
second, falling phase approximately 17% of the first, and with the
rate constant of the first, rising phase also demonstrating a
hyperbolic ligand concentration dependence. By contrast, a similar
experiment with V238W would be predicted to produce only a single phase
in the fluorescence transient, whose rate depends hyperbolically on
ligand concentration. The fluorescence transients depicted in Fig. 1
(B and C), and the corresponding plots of rates
versus [2'dmT] (Fig. 2, B and C)
demonstrate that this is also the case. Furthermore, both constructs
produce a phosphate release transient that has a rate similar to that
for F318W (Fig. 3A). Mixing of nucleotide-free A260W with
2'-deoxy-mant-ATP produced results similar to that for V238W, whereas
the corresponding experiment with Val-329 produced results similar to
Y228W (data not shown).
The effect of microtubules on the phosphate release transient was also
examined for Tyr-228, Val-238, Phe-318, and Val-329 by mixing 1 µM construct+ 4 µM tubulin with ATP. In
each case, the maximum rate of the fluorescence transient was at least
8-10-fold faster than the steady state rate, indicating phosphate
release in the first turnover. Under saturating concentrations of ATP, the maximum rates of the transient were 39.2 ± 2.9 s
1 for Tyr-228, 9.9 ± 0.7 s
1 for Val-238, 22.9 ± 1.4 s
1 for Phe-318, and 72.6 ± 4.6 s
1 for Val-329 (Fig. 3B).
Transient Kinetic Studies of 2'-Deoxy-mant-ADP Binding to Kinesin
Mutants--
As shown above, monitoring of 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP binding
to the single tryptophan constructs by energy transfer produces
transients that are directly related to domain movements, and which
vary in their nature depending on the construct studied. We therefore examined the kinetics of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP binding to our constructs, monitored by energy transfer. Unlike the case for 2'-deoxy-mant-ATP, the resulting fluorescence transient for binding of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP was found to consist of two phases of increasing fluorescence for each
construct. Examples of such fluorescence transients are illustrated in
Fig. 4A for V238W and Fig.
4B for F318W. In each case, the rate constant of the first
phase varied with ligand concentration, whereas that for the second
phase showed minimal ligand concentration dependence (Fig.
5, A and B).
For V238W, the rate of the faster phase demonstrated a clear hyperbolic
dependence on ligand concentration, defining a maximum rate of 612 s
1 (Fig. 5A). The deviation from a
hyperbolic fit at the lowest ligand concentrations may be due to
difficulty in extracting from the transient two rates that differ by a
factor of only 2-4. By contrast, the other constructs showed a linear
dependence of the rate of the first phase on ligand concentration, and
a maximum rate could not be extrapolated. A representative plot is
shown in Fig. 5B for F318W, and similar results were seen
with Y228W, A260W, and V329W (data not shown). In each case, the final
fluorescence intensity produced by mixing construct with 2'dmD was very
similar to the final fluorescence intensity produced by mixing
construct with 2'dmT. This is illustrated in Fig. 4B, which
demonstrates convergence of the two fluorescence transients for the
case of F318W mixed with either 2'dmT or 2'dmD. Table
VI summarizes values of the apparent
second order rate constant (ka), the maximum
rate (
1) for the first phase of the fluorescence
transient, and the rate of the second phase (
2). The
kinetics of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP release from kinesin were also monitored
by energy transfer, by mixing a complex of construct+ 2-fold molar
excess of of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP with 2 mM ADP in the stopped
flow. The resulting fluorescence transient fit a single exponential
decay for each construct (Table VI).

View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Fluorescence transients produced by mixing
V238W (A) and F318W (B) with
2'dmD. For both constructs, the transient consists of two phases
of increasing intensity, unlike the case for mixing with 2'dmT (Fig.
1). In panel B, the transient for mixing F318W
with 2'dmD is superimposed on that for mixing F318W with 2'dmT, and
demonstrates that the final fluorescence level is the same in both
cases.
|
|

View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5.
Rates of the two phases of the fluorescence
transient produced by mixing V238W (A) and F318W
(B) with 2'dmD, plotted as a function of
[2'dmD]. Conditions were as in Fig. 2. For both constructs, the
rate of the first phase demonstrates a ligand concentration dependence,
which for V238W (A) varies hyperbolically, defining a
maximum rate of 612 s 1. For F318W
(B), the rate of the first phase does not reach a maximum
value over the ligand concentration range. For both constructs, the
second phase shows little ligand concentration dependence of rate. The
apparent second order rate constants defined by the dependence of rate
on ligand concentration are summarized in Table VI.
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Table VI
Kinetic constants for binding and release of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP to
kinesin constructs
Data for binding of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP was fitted to the following
kinetic scheme,
where D is 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP and K is the kinesin
construct. As in the case of ATP binding (Table V), the model predicts
two phases in the fluorescence transient, where the rate of the first
phase would vary with ligand concentration, and where
ka = K0 ( 1). The rate
of the second phase would be predicted to be independent of ligand
concentration.
|
|
Molecular Simulations of the Effect of the V238W Mutation on
Kinesin Structure--
Residue Val-238 is located in L11, adjacent to
a portion of the kinesin molecule that is referred to as the switch II
loop and helix (30). This region has been proposed to mediate
communication between the catalytic site and the microtube binding
domain. In particular, it has been suggested that this region undergoes
a movement of several angstroms in response to nucleotide which would
lead to a change in microtubule affinity (29, 32). Mutation of this
position to tryptophan produces a kinesin construct that binds
microtubules very weakly in the presence of ADP. This suggests that in
this mutant, communication between the catalytic site and the
microtubule binding domain is blocked. Our finding that the distance
between position 238 and the catalytic site does not change in response
to a change of microtubule affinity (Table IV) is consistent with this,
and provides the first direct demonstration that movement of this
region is necessary for normal motor function. We have expanded on this
observation by performing molecular modeling of rat kinesin bound to
mant-ADP and ATP, utilizing simulated annealing (29), coupled to
FRET-derived distance constraints between the mant fluorophore and the
side chain of residue Trp-239 (equivalent to position 238 in human kinesin).
As can be seen from Fig. 6A,
kinesin exhibits significant nucleotide-dependent changes
in the switch I (
3a/L9) and switch II (
4/L12) regions. These
changes are induced by the closure of the nucleotide binding pocket
through additional contacts with ATP that are mediated by the
-phosphate-sensing residues: Ser-203 in switch I and Gly-235 in
switch II (rat sequence). The direction and the magnitude (4.5 and 2.8 Å, for
3a/L9 and
4/L12, respectively) of the positional shifts
agree very well with the results of earlier simulations of
nucleotide-dependent effects in human kinesin (29), except
for the magnitude of the
3a/L9 movement, which was smaller (2 Å) in
the earlier model. The motions of the switch I region are a direct
result of the placement of the adjacent
-phosphate, whereas those of
the distant
4/L12 microtubule binding site (35) are communicated and
amplified by small shifts at the base of loop L11 toward the
-phosphate. Although the movements of the two switch regions have
been rendered separately in Fig. 6A for clarity, they are in
fact coupled and are part of an allosteric mechanism that controls the
shape of the microtubule binding site (29), and presumably, microtubule
affinity. Motions in the solvent-exposed loop L11 are not expected to
be significant since this loop exhibited a purely thermal variability
of 5 Å in the earlier simulations (29) and was disordered in the
original human kinesin crystal structure (3).

View larger version (104K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6.
Computer modeling of the structural effect of
the V238W distance constraint. ATP-kinesin models (see
"Experimental Procedures") are shown in brown, and
ADP-kinesin models are in green. Rat Tp-239 (equivalent to
position 238 in human kinesin) and the mant nucleotides are shown as
van-der-Waals spheres in red (ATP cases) and blue
(ADP cases). Triangles mark the position of the mant fluorophores bound
to the nucleotides. The orientation of kinesin is equivalent to that in
Fig. 11B in Ref. 29. Secondary structure elements (3, 4)
involved in conformational changes are labeled in panel
A and are shown in solid ribbon representation. The
remainder of the protein is rendered transparent for clarity.
A, control simulations of rat kinesin with mant nucleotides
in the absence of the V238W distance constraint. The two
solid black arrows illustrate
nucleotide-dependent positional shifts exhibited by the
3a/L9 region (4.5 Å) and the 4/L12 region (2.8 Å).
B, simulations of rat kinesin with mant nucleotides in the
presence of FRET-derived distance constraints (dashed lines)
between the mant fluorophore and the side chain of Trp-239. The
two solid black arrows illustrate
nucleotide-dependent positional shifts exhibited by the
3a/L9 region (2.8 Å) and the 4/L12 region (2.0 Å).
|
|
The magnitude of the nucleotide-dependent movements seen in
the switch I and switch II regions is significantly reduced when the
FRET distances between the nucleotides and Trp-239 are enforced in the
model (Fig. 6B). For both ATP and ADP kinesin, the FRET distance between Trp-239 and the mant fluorophore is about 10 Å smaller in the constrained model (Fig. 6B) compared with
that in the unconstrained model. This produces a directional
"pulling" of the fluorophore into a position pointing toward loop
L11 (see triangular markers in Fig. 6, A and
B). This in turn would reduce the movement of the
4/L12
microtubule binding site by nearly 1 Å, due to the stabilization of
the mediating loop L11. Finally, simulations reveal that the mant
fluorophore appears to sterically restrain the
nucleotide-dependent motions of the
3a/L9 region, with
the nucleotide-induced positional shift reduced by 1.7Å.
 |
DISCUSSION |
Crystallographic models of myosin in various nucleotide states
have provided direct evidence that small conformational changes induced
by nucleotide hydrolysis and product release are amplified by a segment
which connects the motor and regulatory domains (1), and which drives
translational movement of the latter (2). By contrast, the crystal
structure of kinesin is available in only one state, in which ADP
occupies the active site (3, 4), and structural models of the kinesin
mechanochemical cycle have therefore been based on spectroscopic and
image reconstruction data (5, 6). More recently, Rice et al.
(7) examined the effect of nucleotide on intramolecular distance,
segmental flexibility, and conformation. Nucleotide could modulate the
mobility and energy transfer efficiency of spectroscopic probes
attached to the carboxyl terminus of a monomeric kinesin construct, but only when the motor domain was bound to microtubules. This was taken to
imply that microtubule binding is required for the nucleotide-induced structural changes in kinesin. Furthermore, cryo-electron microscopic images of microtubule-bound, labeled kinesin in the presence of various
nucleotides demonstrated a single, unique orientation in the presence
of AMPPNP or ADP+AlF4 but two discrete orientations in the
absence of nucleotide or in the presence of ADP. This was interpreted
to suggest that kinesin:ADP was an equilibrium mixture of two states
which are both appreciably populated at low temperatures.
However, our previous study demonstrated that even in the absence of
microtubules, nucleotide could produce measurable changes in the
structure of kinesin (5). We had demonstrated, utilizing fluorescence
anisotropy decay, that nucleotide alone could alter the flexibility of
a segment of the kinesin dimer that was located at the junction of the
catalytic domain and the proximal tail, within the vicinity of the neck
linker region. This led us to conclude that the strategic placement of
intrinsic fluorescent probes in the kinesin motor domain might provide
additional insight into the nature of the conformational changes that
this motor undergoes during its mechanochemical cycle. Consequently, we
generated five single tryptophan mutants of human kinesin, each with a
tryptophan residue in regions implicated in nucleotide or
microtubule binding or in force transduction (3, 4). Each of these
mutants demonstrated a weak-to-strong transition that was similar to
wild type, as evidenced by the pronounced enhancement in microtubule
affinity of the kinesin:ADP construct produced by addition of aluminum fluoride (Table I).
FRET measurements on these mutants were made to determine if changes in
intramolecular distance occur with this weak-to-strong transition even
in the absence of microtubules. As Table IV demonstrates, statistically
significant intramolecular distance changes were seen in three
locations as a consequence of the strong-to-weak transition: in
Tyr-228, located in
7; in F318W, located in
6; and in V329W,
located in the neck linker. The largest change was seen in the neck
linker region, consistent with previous measurements of
microtubule-bound kinesin (7).
Our conclusion of residue movements during the strong-to-weak
transition is based on small changes in the mean distances between tryptophan and the bound mant. These observed conformational changes predicted corresponding changes in the mant fluorescence emission when
monitored by energy transfer in the stopped flow experiments. The
energy transfer-generated kinetic results (Figs. 1 and 2) and the
measured rate of phosphate release (Fig. 3A) unequivocally corroborated the FRET results. The generation of these mutants thus
allows us to measure domain movements in real time that are directly
related to the hydrolysis and/or phosphate release steps. They are also
consistent with previous kinetic studies (19-21), which showed binding
of ATP occurs via formation of an initial collisional complex, followed
by an isomerization, with hydrolysis following these two
transitions.
K is kinesin, T is ATP, K(T) is a collisional complex,
Pi is inorganic phosphate, and K and
k are equilibrium and rate constants, respectively. The
apparent second order rate constant for the first fluorescent
transition (ka) is equal to
Kok1, assuming that k-1 is negligible, and the maximum rate is
approximately k1. Values of
ka and k1 for the various
constructs are similar to those previously measured for wild type K332
(ka = 9 µM
1
s
1, k1 = 500 s
1; Ref. 10). Likewise, the rate of the
second phase in the transient (Fig. 2, A and B)
is very similar to that produced by mixing wild type K332 with mant-ATP
and monitoring through direct excitation (7 s
1; Refs. 10 and 19).
When monitored by energy transfer, binding of 2'-deoxy-mant-ADP
produced two transitions of increasing fluorescence for each construct,
unlike the case for 2'dmT. The final fluorescence intensity when each
construct was mixed with 2'dmD was essentially identical to that after
mixing with 2'dmT, implying that the final conformations are the same.
Kinetic data are consistent with the following model:
The two kinesin:ADP states are indicated by subscripts. The
presence of a single phase in the 2'dmD release transient implies that
K2 is large, and that k-2 is
rate-limiting in the release reaction.
The presence of two ADP states implies that there are three discrete
kinesin:nucleotide conformations: one with ATP (mimicked by the complex
with ADP + AlF4), and two with ADP. Furthermore, if
KD1 and KD2 differ in their microtubule
affinities ("strong" and "weak," respectively, for purposes of
this discussion), then the affinity of kinesin:ADP for microtubules, as
measured by steady state techniques, would depend not only on the
microtubule affinities of KD1 and KD2, but also
on the effect that microtubule binding has on their distribution. This
is summarized in the following reaction pathway.
M stands for microtubule, and the other abbreviations are as
defined above. If Ka > Kb
(e.g. KD1 is strong binding), then
K2' < K2, the
MKD1 state would be favored, and the microtubule
affinity measured by steady state techniques would be greater
than Kb. Conversely, if communication between the
microtubule and nucleotide binding domains were blocked
(e.g. K2
K2'), then the measured kinesin:ADP affinity
would approach Kb and would therefore be much
lower. The low affinity of V238W:ADP for microtubules could thus be
explained by a blocking of this microtubule-induced redistribution, and
this in turn implies that this mutation uncouples communication between
the catalytic site and the microtubule binding domain in the presence
of ADP.
The existence of two kinesin:ADP states is directly relevant to models
of processivity. A key feature of previous models is that the two heads
of kinesin dimer are out-of-phase in their mechanochemical cycles,
e.g. whereas one head is in a strong microtubule binding
state, the other is in a weak state (23-25, 27). Our data,
demonstrating a two-state equilibrium for kinesin:ADP, would be
consistent with this if these two states were to differ in their
microtubule affinity and if this two state equilibrium applied as well
to kinesin:ADP:Pi. Prior to hydrolyzing its ATP, kinesin is
in a single, strong binding conformation (9), characterized by the high
fluorescence state seen with the single tryptophan mutants (Figs. 1A,
B). Kinesin ADP:Pi ultimately relaxes into a weak binding,
ADP conformation, coincident with phosphate release (Fig.
4B). This implies that, during the course of its ATPase cycle, kinesin ADP:PI, like kinesin:ADP, transitions from a
strong to a weak microtubule binding conformation. We propose that in the absence of applied strain from the second, attaching head, this
transition would be slow or its equilibrium would be unfavorable, and
phosphate and ADP release could occur before dissociation from the
microtubule. This would explain the superstoichiometric phosphate burst
for monomeric kinesin constructs, as described by Moyer et
al. (26). Conversely, rapid attachment of the second, ADP
containing head would place strain on the kinesin:ADP:Pi
head, shifting its equilibrium to weak binding and producing
coordinated dissociation.
The role of strain in shifting a dynamic equilibrium is illustrated in
the model depicted in Fig. 7. We start
the cycle with both heads of kinesin:ADP in a weak binding
state-corresponding to KD2 in the above scheme. Weak
attachment of the first (blue) head is followed by an
isomerization, corresponding to formation of KD1 and
symbolized by the change in shape of the blue head, compared
with the red. ADP rapidly dissociates (
300
s
1; Ref. 26), and its release is rapidly followed by
binding of ATP. This is associated with change in the
orientation of
6 and the neck linker region (solid
black line in Fig. 7), consistent with our
demonstration of the change in intramolecular distances of Phe-318 and
Val-329 (Table IV). The change in conformation produced by binding of
ATP allows for weak binding of the second, ADP containing head
(red in Fig. 7). This is rapidly followed by isomerization
of the ADP-containing head (red in the figure), as
above, to a strong binding conformation, followed by ADP release. Hydrolysis of ATP by the first (blue) head follows. At this
point, we propose that the head with ADP+Pi remains in a
strong binding state, and that the rate-limiting step in this cycle is
the conversion of this head to a weak binding conformation, leading to
dissociation from the microtubule and release of phosphate. Strong
binding by the second head (red in the figure) would
introduce strain into the system, and we propose that this strain
accelerates the isomerization of the first head into a weak binding
ADP·Pi state. Release of phosphate would allow kinesin to
re-enter the cycle, this time with the role of the two heads reversed,
as has been previously pointed out by Moyer et al. (26).

View larger version (17K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 7.
Model of strain-dependent release
mechanism. The role of strain in shifting a dynamic equilibrium is
illustrated in this model. The cycle is entered with both heads
of kinesin:ADP in a weak binding state. Weak attachment of the first
(blue) head is followed by an isomerization and symbolized
by the change in shape of the blue head, compared with the
red. ADP rapidly dissociates, and its release is rapidly
followed by binding of ATP. This is associated which change the
orientation of 6 and the neck linker region (solid black
line), consistent with results from FRET studies (Table IV). The
change in conformation produced by binding of ATP allows for weak
binding of the second, ADP containing head (red). This is
rapidly followed by its isomerization to a strong binding conformation,
followed by ADP release. Hydrolysis of ATP by the first
(blue) head follows. At this point, the head with
ADP·Pi is proposed to be in a strong binding state, and
that the rate-limiting step in this cycle is the conversion of this
head to a weak binding conformation, leading to dissociation from the
microtubule and release of phosphate. Strong binding by the second head
(red) would introduce strain into the system, and this
strain is proposed to accelerate the isomerization of strain into the
system, and this strain is proposed to accelerate the isomerization of
the first head into a weak binding ADP·Pi state. Release
of phosphate would allow kinesin to re-enter the cycle, this time with
the role of the two heads reversed.
|
|
This model also explains the effects of microtubules on the phosphate
release transient (Fig. 3B). If V238W:ADP is "locked" in
a weak binding conformation, then it follows that
V238W:ADP:Pi is also locked in this conformation. Thus,
with each ATPase cycle, this construct would dissociate from the
microtubule once its bound ATP had been hydrolyzed. The rate-limiting
step for this construct's ATPase cycle would be dissociation from the
microtubule at 9.5 s
1
(k4 in their Scheme I, Ref. 26), nearly
identical to what we measure from the phosphate transient (Fig.
3B). The relatively slower phosphate release rate for F318W
could reflect a much more subtle impairment in microtubule mediated
communication, and may explain as well the slightly lower affinity that
F318W:ADP has for microtubules (Table I).
Similarities in the crystal structures of kinesin and G proteins have
led to the suggestion that position 238 in human kinesin is part of the
switch II helix and loop, whose function is to mediate communication
between the catalytic site and the microtubule binding domain (3, 30).
Furthermore, comparisons of the crystal structures of human and rat
kinesins, as well as of Drosophila ncd and yeast Kar3 have
led to a model in which this region translates and rotates in response
to nucleotide hydrolysis and phosphate release (3, 4, 30-32). A recent
model, utilizing simulated annealing, also predicts that position 238 moves several angstroms in response to ATP hydrolysis and phosphate
release (29). It follows that blocking the movement of position 238, as
occurs in V238W (Table IV), should uncouple microtubule binding
affinity from nucleotide state. The result would be a microtubule
binding site that is completely "locked in" a weak binding
conformation in the presence of ADP. However, the relatively normal
affinity of V238W for microtubules in the presence of
ADP+AlF4 (Table I) suggests that movement of the switch II
helix functions, at least in part, to mediate the interconversion of
the two post-hydrolytic states, and emphasizes the importance of these
two states in kinesin function.
We have utilized simulated annealing to see if this approach can
explain how the V238W mutation might uncouple microtubule affinity from
conformational changes in the catalytic site. The distance of the
mutation site from the nucleotide observed in FRET experiments, when
enforced in the simulation, suggests that the V238W mutant reduces the
nucleotide-dependent variability of the switch II region
and that of the
4/L12 microtubule binding site. The inclusion of the
FRET distance constraints provides a first model of the unknown
conformation of the Val-238 mutant that explains its abnormal
microtubule binding behavior. The modeling results lend further
credibility to the hypothesis that the switch I and II regions
communicate directly with each other and with the microtubule binding
regions and suggest that computer simulations are capable of predicting
the ATP state of kinesin in the absence of a crystal structure.
Simulations involving constraints based on the other four tryptophan
mutants presented in this work are currently under way that should
shed light on the more distant conformational changes in the neck linker.
 |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
We thank Dr. Matthew Mayo (Department of
Biostatistics, University of Kansas Medical Center) for assistance in
the modeling, and Dr. Susan Gilbert (University of Pittsburgh) for
thoughtful review of the manuscript. Assistance in the construction of
the kinesin mutants was provided by Sylvia and David MacPherson of <