|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 279, Issue 44, 46096-46103, October 29, 2004
Novel DNA Bis-intercalation by MLN944, a Potent Clinical Bisphenazine Anticancer Drug*![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ¶||
From the
Received for publication, April 12, 2004 , and in revised form, August 9, 2004.
The new bisphenazine anticancer drug MLN944 is a novel cytotoxic agent with exceptional anti-tumor activity against a range of human and murine tumor models both in vitro and in vivo. MLN944 has recently entered Phase I clinical trials. Despite the structural similarity with its parent monophenazine carboxamide and acridine carboxamide anticancer compounds, MLN944 appears to work by a distinct mechanism of inhibiting DNA transcription rather than the expected mechanism of topoisomerase I and II inhibition. Here we present the first NMR structure of MLN944 complexed with d(ATGCAT)2 DNA duplex, demonstrating a novel binding mode in which the two phenazine rings bis-intercalate at the 5'-TpG site, with the carboxamide amino linker lying in the major groove of DNA. The MLN944 molecule adopts a significantly unexpected conformation and side chain orientation in the DNA complex, with the N10 on the phenazine ring protonated at pH 7. The phenazine chromophore of MLN944 is very well stacked with the flanking DNA base pairs using the parallel base-stacking intercalation binding mode. The DNA sequence specificity and the groove recognition of MLN944 binding is determined by several site-specific hydrogen bond interactions with the central G:C base pair as well as the favorable stacking interactions with the 5'-flanking thymine. The specific binding site of MLN944 is known to be recognized by a number of important transcription factors. Our electrophoretic gel mobility shift assay results demonstrated that the c-Jun DNA binding to the AP-1 site is significantly inhibited by MLN944 in a dose-dependent manner. Thus, the exceptional biological activity of MLN944 may be due to its novel DNA binding mode leading to a unique mechanism of action.
The systemic therapies currently available for the treatment of various solid tumors of adult life, including those of lung, colon, breast, prostate, and ovary, remain primarily palliative, and there is an urgent need for more effective therapies. Although recently there has been a significant effort in developing molecular targeted therapies, cytotoxic agents remain the major form of therapy for the majority of cancers. Moreover, there is reason to believe that a therapeutic advantage remains to be gained from cytotoxic drugs with novel mechanisms of action, with improved safety profiles and different spectra of anti-tumor activity. The bisphenazine MLN944 (XR5944) (Fig. 1a) is a novel cytotoxic agent with exceptional anti-tumor activity against a range of human and murine tumor models both in vitro and in vivo (1). It has recently entered Phase I clinical trials. Although initial reports showed that MLN944 can bind strongly to DNA (2) and that it may interfere with the normal function of topoisomerase I and II in vitro (1), recent studies have indicated that topoisomerase I and II may not be its primary cellular target and that it works by a novel mechanism of action. The mechanistic novelty of MLN944 is suggested by the fact that in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, modulation of topoisomerase I, II, and III levels did not alter the efficacy of the compound. Moreover, the functional genomics profiles of MLN944-treated yeast were unlike the profiles from yeast treated with known inhibitors of topoisomerase I and II (3). Studies in mammalian cells have also indicated a novel mechanism of action of MLN944. For example, exposure of human tumor cells to MLN944 causes arrest in both G1 and G2 phases of the cell cycle, whereas compounds that inhibit topoisomerase I or II characteristically lead to cell cycle arrest in S/G2 phase even when cells are exposed to these agents simultaneously (3). MLN944 also exhibits activity against both quiescent and proliferating tumor cells and has the ability to kill cells following only a brief exposure period (4) with a corresponding lack of schedule dependence in its in vivo anti-tumor efficacy, as is characteristic for topoisomerase inhibitors (1). The novel mechanism of action of MLN944 has recently been shown to be related to the inhibition of DNA transcription (5, 6).
The parent compounds of MLN944, phenazine carboxamides (such as MLN576 and MLN612) as well as the closely related acridine carboxamides (such as N-(2-(dimethylamino)ethyl)acridine-4-carboxamide (DACA),1 are both DNA intercalators and dual DNA topoisomerase I/II inhibitors (79). Crystal structures of 9-amino-DACA·DNA complexes showed that acridine rings intercalate duplex DNA at a CpG site (10, 11). MLN944 has also been shown to be an efficient DNA intercalator by its induction of dose-dependent supercoiling of plasmid DNA. Moreover, MLN944 has been shown to bind doublestranded DNA with high affinity and to have a strong G-C sequence preference (2). Therefore, it is surprising that MLN944 works by a distinct mechanism of action other than that of topoisomerase I/II inhibition. It is possible that the exceptional biological activity of MLN944 may be related to a distinct DNA binding mode and hence its novel mechanism of action. In this study, we determined the structure of a complex between MLN944 and DNA duplex d(ATGCAT)2 using a combination of NMR spectroscopy and molecular dynamics calculation. The result shows that MLN944 does indeed have a novel binding mode with a duplex DNA. The drug bis-intercalates at the 5'-(TpG):(CpA) site, with the aminoalkyl linker lying in the major groove of the DNA. This not only is the first structure of a phenazine derivative binding with DNA but is also the first solution structure of a DNA complex among all of the closely related acridine carboxamide compounds. A number of novel features of drug binding with DNA in the solution state that have not been reported before are also shown in our study.
Sample PreparationThe DNA oligonucleotides were synthesized using -cyanoethylphosphoramidite solid-phase chemistry on an ExpediteTM nucleic acid synthesis system (Applied Biosystems, Inc.) with the DMT-ON setting and were purified using C18 reverse-phase high pressure liquid chromatography. MLN576 (XR11576) and MLN944 (XR5944) were provided by Millennium Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Cambridge, MA) and Xenova Ltd. (Slough, UK). The NMR samples were prepared by dissolving DNA oligonucleotide powder into 50 mM sodium phosphate buffer at pH 7 in either pure D2O (98%) or D2O/H2O (10%/90%). The D2O samples were lyophilized and resuspended in 99.98% D2O two more times. The DNA-drug complexes were prepared by adding an appropriate amount of drug stock solution to the DNA sample, followed by lyophilization and redissolution in D2O. The final concentrations of DNA oligonucleotides were 14 mM. NMR ExperimentsBoth one- and two-dimensional NMR experiments were carried out on a Bruker Avance 600-MHz spectrometer. Standard homonuclear two-dimensional NMR experiments were used to assign the nonexchangeable proton chemical shifts of the complex, including DQF-COSY, TOCSY, and NOESY. The mixing times were set at 50, 100, 150, and 200 ms for NOESY and at 30 and 60 ms for TOCSY. The NMR experiments for samples in water solution were performed with WATERGATE or jump-return (NOE11) water suppression techniques. The relaxation delay was set to 2 s. The acquisition data points were set to 4096 x 512. The 60° shifted sine bell functions were applied to both dimensions of NOESY and TOCSY spectra. The 5 order polynomial functions were employed for the base-line corrections. The final data points were 4096 x 1024. Peak assignment and integration were achieved using Sparky (University of California, San Francisco). Distances between nonexchangeable protons were assigned based on the NOE cross-peaks integrated at 50200-ms mixing times. The peak volumes were referenced using the distance H5H6 of cytosine (2.45 Å). Unsolved protons were replaced by pseudoatoms, and the appropriate correction was applied to the measured distance. Distance-restrained Molecular Dynamics SimulationStructure calculations were performed using NOE-restrained molecular dynamics simulation in the program X-PLOR (version 3.851) (12). The starting model of the DNA d(ATGCAT)-MLN944 complex was constructed in Insight II 2000.1 (Accelrys), with the intercalation site conformations deduced from the NOE data. The partial charges were obtained from X-PLOR or from the representative fragments in Insight II. The CHARMM force field was used for the calculation. The skewed biharmonic energy function was used for distance constraints from NOE data. A total of 161 distances were used in the NOE-restrained dynamics calculations. A distance-dependent dielectric constant was used in the calculations to simulate the aqueous environment. Noncrystallographic symmetry restraints were maintained throughout the computations for the 2-fold symmetry of the complex. Each cycle of restrained MD simulation was carried out at 300 K with a time step of 0.25 fs. The system was first equilibrated for 0.5 ps, with the force constants of 1 kcal/mol·A2 for all restraints. The force constants were gradually scaled to the final values of 30, 30, and 60 kcal/mol·A2 for NOE, noncrystallographic symmetry, and hydrogen bond restraints, respectively, during the subsequent 10-ps simulation. The system was then equilibrated for 12 ps. The coordinates saved during the last 5.0 ps were averaged. The resulting average structure was further subjected to 3000 steps of energy minimization.
Electrophoretic Gel Mobility Shift AssaysThe AP-1 binding probe 5'-AAAGATCCCATGAGTCAGGTACCAC (the core sequence is underlined) was custom-made (Qiagen, Alameda, CA) and purified through a denaturing polyacrylamide gel. The upper strand was end-labeled using T4 polynucleotide kinase and [
The specificity of inhibitory activity of MLN944 compared with other DNA intercalators was determined by using 25 µM ethidium bromide or 25 µM topotecan instead of MLN944 in the above assay. The activity of MLN944 against other DNA-binding proteins was examined by a similar assay using an NF-
Sequence-specific Binding of MLN944 with d(ATGCAT)It has been shown in initial DNA binding studies that MLN944 displays a strong sequence preference of poly(G-C) over poly(A-T) (2) and that the two planar phenazine chromophores of MLN944 allow for the possibility of bis-intercalation. Hence, we initially investigated the binding of MLN944 to a series of DNA sequences with two GpC or CpG binding sites by monitoring 1H NMR spectra. Over a dozen such DNA sequences were tested without detecting a specific binding site of MLN944. Broadening the DNA sequence range leads to the discovery of a strong sequence-specific binding of MLN944 to the DNA duplex d(ATGCAT)2 at pH 7 (Fig. 1b). A new set of resonances emerged in the 0.5:1 drug-DNA duplex mixture, and these co-existed with the resonances from free DNA. This indicated that a stable complex had formed between DNA and the drug and that the binding equilibrium is in the slow exchange process on the NMR time scale. In the 1:1 drug-DNA mixture, resonances from free DNA completely disappeared, leaving only one resonance per proton. The presence of a single set of resonances indicates that a strong binding of drug occurs to a specific binding site in the DNA duplex and that the unique drug-DNA complex retains the 2-fold symmetry for both drug and self-complementary DNA. The symmetrical complementary DNA strand is referenced using the prime sign (Fig. 1b).
NMR Spectroscopic AnalysisAll proton resonances of MLN944 and DNA have been assigned by using two-dimensional NOESY, TOCSY, and COSY data. Standard sequential assignment has been used to assign the resonances of DNA. The drug phenazine ring proton H8 (Fig. 1a) was assigned by a strong NOE cross-peak with the drug C9 methyl group. This led to the assignment of its vicinal proton H7 and then of H6. The drug H3 proton was clearly identified by having two COSY cross-peaks with both H2 and H4, whereas H2 was assigned by its NOE cross-peak with the carboxamide linker and was further confirmed by a number of NOE cross-peaks with its neighboring DNA bases. The exchangeable protons of both DNA and drug were assigned by using two-dimensional NOESY. The chemical shifts of all resonances are tabulated in Table I
Free DNA hexamer d(ATGCAT)2 forms a regular B-type double helix in solution, as indicated by standard sequential connectivities and intrasugar interactions in NOESY and COSY spectra. The exchangeable proton NMR spectrum in H2O revealed two clear imino proton resonances at 12.6 (G3HN1) and 13.65 (T2HN3) ppm, suggesting Watson-Crick type base pairing (Table I The MLN944-DNA complex retains the 2-fold symmetry. The glycosidic torsion angles of all nucleotides are in the anti configuration in the d(ATGCAT)2-MLN944 complex, as indicated by the intraresidue H6/H8-H1' NOE intensities (Fig. 2). However, there are a number of unusual features in the spectra. The sequential NOE cross-peak connectivities of the aromatic H6/H8 protons to the H1'/H2'/H2'' protons typical for double-helical B-DNA are interrupted at the T2pG3 and C4pA5 steps. Specifically, the cross-peaks of T2H1'/H2'/H2''-G3H8, G4H1'/H2'/H2''-C5H6 are very weak (Fig. 2). This indicates that the drug MLN944 bis-intercalates at the T2pG3 and C4pA5 steps in the complex (Fig. 1b), breaking the normal base-stacking interactions in free B-DNA at these positions by pushing the two adjacent base pairs apart.
The imino protons are clearly observable in the exchangeable proton NMR spectra of DNA-drug complex, indicating that the base-pairing scheme is retained in the complex. Moreover, the imino proton G3HN1 is still detectable at 25 °C in the complex, whereas it is not observable at 15 °C in the free DNA, implying a more stable DNA duplex upon drug binding; this is also confirmed by the increase in the melting temperatures of DNA-drug complex in comparison with the free DNA ( 45 and 30 °C, respectively). Furthermore, both DNA imino protons T2HN3 and G3HN1, as well as A5H2 and G3H1', are the DNA protons that are most affected by drug binding and undergo large upfield shifts (3.1, 2, 1.2, and 0.8 ppm, respectively) (Table I
Protonation of MLN944 Phenazine RingThe exchangeable proton NMR spectrum in H2O of the DNA-MLN944 complex at pH 7 also reveals a very interesting proton resonance in the imino region at 11.22 ppm. Inspection of the two-dimensional NOESY spectra indicates that this proton is not an imino proton of any DNA nucleotide. It has a much slower exchange rate with water than that of the DNA imino protons of both T2 and G3. This proton has NOE interactions with several other protons of MLN944, including 9-methyl protons (strong), linker proton H
NMR Structure DeterminationMany intermolecular NOE cross-peaks between MLN944 and DNA are observed in two-dimensional NOESY, as summarized in Fig. 3. The strong NOE interaction between C4H5 and MLN944-M9 places the methyl group of the drug phenazine ring position 9 (Fig. 1a) in the major groove of the DNA double helix. In the meantime, the NOE interactions between the DNA T2 methyl group and MLN944-H
A starting model of the d(ATGCAT)2-MLN944 complex constructed using the above mentioned information was subjected to NOE-restrained molecular dynamics calculation in X-PLOR (12). A total of 161 distance restraints, of which 51 are from intermolecular NOE interactions between MLN944 and DNA, were incorporated into the restrained molecular dynamics calculation. The restrained molecular dynamics calculation produced a very stable, converged family of structures (Fig. 4 and Table II, Protein Data Bank accession number 1X95 [PDB] ), indicating a well defined binding conformation. The pairwise root mean square deviation of the refined structures is 0.38 Å.
Global Complex Structure and DNA ConformationA representative model of refined complex structures with MLN944 and DNA hexamer d(ATGCAT)2 is shown in stereo view in Fig. 5a. The two phenazine chromophores of MLN944 bis-intercalate at the TpG and CpA steps of the DNA, wrapping the two central G:C base pairs, with the long axes of chromophores parallel to the long axes of the flanking DNA base pairs. The carboxamide aminoalkyl linker lies in the major groove of the DNA duplex. The 2-fold symmetry of both DNA and drug are retained. The linker runs diagonally across the major groove such that the drug has the appearance of a backward "Z" when viewed from the major groove. The drug exhibits a left-handed twist counter to the right-handed twist of the DNA helix.
In the intercalation pocket, the rise between two intercalated T2:A5 and G3:C4 base pairs is 6.32 Å, much larger than that of the perpendicular intercalation binding site, as exemplified by anthracycline drugs (14, 15). The DNA double helix is unwound throughout the DNA hexamer in the drug complex, compared with regular B-DNA with an average helical twist of 36° per step, with the overall extent of unwinding of the DNA hexamer in the drug complex of 48°. The TpG step at the intercalation site is unwound by 10°, and the terminal ApT step is unwound by 13°. The central G3pC4 steps, wrapped between the two phenazine rings of MLN944, maintain relatively good base pair conformation and hydrogen bonding interactions as observed in regular B-DNA. In contrast, conformational distortions at the intercalation site T2pG3 and C4pA5 steps are more significant, with the T2:A5' base pairs displaying a significant large negative roll angle (-13°) and propeller twist (-8°) and buckling (6°). This is consistent with the fact that the TpG:CpA steps are particularly flexible (16, 17).
The two central G3:C4 base pairs are pulled toward the major groove via interactions with the drug linker, making the major groove significantly shallower compared with that of the regular B-DNA. The DNA duplex is kinked by
Effect of MLN944 on the c-Jun DNA Binding to the AP-1 Site by Electrophoretic Gel Mobility Shift Assay (EMSA)The AP-1 family of transcription factors are dimeric complexes that specifically bind to a consensus DNA promoter region, namely the AP-1 binding site 5'-TGAGTCA. c-Jun is a major member of the AP-1 transcription factors, whose activity has been implicated in cell proliferation/transformation and cancer development (18, 19). We carried out electrophoretic gel mobility shift assays (EMSAs) of c-Jun DNA binding to the AP-1 site in the absence and presence of MLN944. The EMSA results demonstrated that the c-Jun DNA binding to the AP-1 site is significantly inhibited by MLN944 in a dose-dependent manner. Specifically, the DNA binding of c-Jun was clearly inhibited by MLN944 at the 50 nM concentration and was almost completely blocked by the drug at the 25 µm concentration (Fig. 6, a and d). In contrast, MLN944 does not block the DNA binding of transcription factor NF-
To demonstrate the specificity of the MLN944 activity, we also tested the inhibitory activity of other known DNA intercalators, including ethidium bromide and topotecan (topoisomerase I inhibitor), on the DNA binding of c-Jun to the AP-1 site. No evident inhibition of c-Jun DNA binding was shown by these two other DNA intercalating compounds at the 25 µM concentration (Fig. 6b).
Unexpected MLN944 ConformationThe MLN944 molecule adopts a significantly unexpected conformation and side chain orientation. The N10 of the phenazine ring of MLN944 is protonated (Fig. 1a) in the DNA complex at pH 7, and this HN10 proton is clearly observed in the NMR data. The carbonyl group of carboxamide forms an internal hydrogen bond to the protonated phenazine ring N10, with the N10 being the hydrogen bond donor (HN-O distance of 2.0 Å). It is striking that the MLN944 phenazine ring is protonated at pH 7, since the pKa value of the N10 is only 1.01.3 (13).2 This unexpected drug phenazine conformation, which could not possibly exist in the bulk solution, is clearly induced and stabilized by the microenvironment of DNA binding pocket. It has been observed in the crystal structure that 9-amino-6-bromo-DACA can adopt both the acid (protonated, positively charged N10) and conjugate base (nonprotonated neutral N10) forms at pH 6.5 (11); however, the acridine ring pKa of 9-amino-DACA is 8.3 (13), much higher than that of the phenazine ring of MLN944. Furthermore, the protonated phenazine ring configuration is the only drug conformation observed in our DNA complex, since there is no sign of a second conformation or an exchange process in the NMR data. Although it is well accepted that the negatively charged microenvironment of DNA could stabilize an otherwise unstable conformation, our result is very significant, since it provides for the first time direct experimental evidence, in solution state, of how dramatically DNA local environment can affect the physical property and conformation of a ligand. MLN944 Base-stacking Interactions with DNA and Binding Site Specificity of 5'-TBoth the phenazine chromophores of MLN944 are deeply inserted into the flanking DNA base pairs (Fig. 5b). Each drug aromatic phenazine ring is very well stacked with both the central G3:C4' (or G3':C4) base pair and the T2 (or T2') base of the T2:A5' (or T2':A5) base pair at the intercalation site (Figs. 1b and 5c). The long axis of the phenazine chromophore of MLN944 is almost completely aligned with that of the central G:C base pair (G3:C4' or G3':C4). In the interaction with the central G:C base pair, the six-member ring of the guanine G3 (or G3') base is stacked on the drug phenazine A ring, whereas its base pair partner, cytosine C4' (or C4), is stacked on the drug C ring. In the interaction with the T:G base pair (T2:A5' or T2':A5) on the other side of the same phenazine chromophore, the thymine T2 (or T2') base is completely stacked very well on the drug A ring, whereas the adenine A5' (or A5) base is unstacked with the drug chromophore.
There is a very strong
The drug aromatic chromophore resembles a B-DNA base pair when viewing into the minor groove, with the N5 of the diazine of MLN944 located right above the N2 of the central guanine G3 in the minor groove. Moreover, the electronegative sugar O4' atom of G3 at the binding site is in close contact (2.74 Å) with the
MLN944 Linker-DNA Interactions and Sequence Specificity The carboxamide aminoalkyl linker of MLN944 plays a major role in DNA groove recognition as well as in sequence specificity of drug binding. The two
When the ring A end of MLN944 is deeply inserted into the intercalating pocket and is in close proximity to the DNA sugar backbone, the site-specific interactions of the drug carboxamide aminoalkyl linker with the two central guanines, G3 and G3', are facilitated. The two
The parallel base-stacking intercalation binding mode has been observed in a number of drugs (10, 11, 21, 24). Although the chromophore structure of MLN944 is similar to that of the acridine carboxamides such as 9-amino-DACA, the base-stacking interactions of the two drugs with DNA base pairs is somewhat different (10, 11). The phenazine ring of MLN944 is shifted more toward the major groove side of DNA compared with the acridine ring of DACA. The long axis of the phenazine ring is almost completely aligned with that of the central G:C base pair, whereas the acridine ring in 9-amino-DACA bisects the angle between the long axes of the intercalated base pairs. In addition, the protonated conformation of the drug phenazine ring, which occurs unexpectedly in the microenvironment of the DNA, indirectly induces a favorable side chain orientation to form a site-specific hydrogen bond interaction with the two central guanines (Fig. 5, c and e). In contrast to the carboxamide plane of 9-amino-DACA being co-planar with the acridine chromophore, the plane of the MLN944 carboxamide group is about 15° with the phenazine plane, so that the amide proton HN is 2.8 Å to the N7 of guanine G3 (or G3'), to form a possible hydrogen bond. Furthermore, the N-H···N angle is The existence of two hydrogen bond acceptors at the major groove side of guanine, the above mentioned site-specific interactions between drug and DNA, and the favorable charge-charge interactions between the drug linker and the DNA major groove are important determinants in the sequence specificity and the binding groove selectivity of MLN944. MLN944 Inhibits the c-Jun DNA Binding to the AP-1 Site The AP-1 family of transcription factors has been implicated in cell proliferation and transformation and can be induced by many stimuli, including growth factor, cytokines, and oncoproteins (see Refs. 18 and 19 and references therein). The main AP-1 components in mammalian cells are JUN and FOS proteins, where c-Jun and c-Fos are closely related with the development of various types of cancer. The AP-1 dimeric transcription factors specifically recognize a consensus DNA promoter region, the AP-1 binding site, with a palindromic base sequence of 5'-TGA(C/G)TCA, whose core subset is the TpG site that MLN944 appears specifically to bind; therefore, it is interesting to test whether the DNA binding of the AP-1 proteins can be inhibited by MLN944.
Our EMSA results demonstrated that MLN944 remarkably inhibits the c-Jun DNA binding to the AP-1 site. The DNA binding of c-Jun was clearly inhibited by MLN944 at the 50 nM concentration and was almost completely blocked by the drug at the 25 µM concentration (Fig. 6, a and d). However, MLN944 does not block the DNA binding of transcription factor NF- To demonstrate the specificity of the inhibitory effect of MLN944, we have also carried out the EMSA experiments on other known DNA intercalative compounds, including the well known DNA intercalator ethidium bromide and the topoisomerase I inhibitor topotecan (26, 27). In contrast, although they both are DNA intercalators, these compounds do not display evident inhibition of c-Jun DNA binding to the AP-1 site at the 25 µM concentrations (Fig. 6b). These results clearly demonstrate that the effect of MLN944 is not simply due to its DNA intercalation. The inhibitory effect of MLN944 on the AP-1 protein DNA binding can be explained by the available structure data. The AP-1 transcription factors, including Jun, Fos, and activating transcription factor proteins, are basic region leucine zipper proteins that selectively dimerize using their leucine zipper regions. The DNA binding specificities of the AP-1 proteins are imparted by the DNA major groove interactions of the AP-1 half-site (5'-(T-4G-3A-2C-1):(G1T2C3A4)) by using the conserved basic DNA-binding regions (2831). The positioning of the MLN944 linker in the DNA major groove will clearly block the DNA binding of the AP-1 proteins. In particular, the site-specific interactions of the AP-1 proteins involved in the DNA binding include the hydrogen-bonding interactions of the invariant protein Asn side chain with the N4 atom of the AP-1 half site cytosine 3 and the O4 atom of thymine -4 as well as the van der Waals contacts between the protein Ala and Ser residues and the 5-methyl group of DNA thymine -4, specifically at the 5'-(TpG):(CpA) site. Hence the binding of MLN944 at the TpG site will interfere with these conserved, site-specific protein-DNA interactions, since 1) the N4 of cytosine 3 is completely blocked by the linker of MLN944 and 2) the DNA thymine -4 is now separated by the drug binding and therefore impossible to contact for both the hydrogen bonding and van der Waals interactions. Whereas our EMSA results have demonstrated that the in vitro c-Jun DNA binding to the AP-1 site is remarkably blocked by MLN944, it will be of primary interest to test whether the in vivo activity of the AP-1 proteins can also be blocked by MLN944. Biological ImplicationsThe parent monophenazine compound MLN576 and the closely related DACA family of acridine carboxamide anticancer agents are both DNA intercalators and dual DNA topoisomerase I/II inhibitors (79). Although the bisphenazine MLN944 is structurally related to these agents, recent studies have indicated that its primary mode of action may involve inhibition of DNA transcription rather than inhibition of topoisomerase I and II (3, 5, 6). The unique mechanism of action of MLN944, distinct from those of its structurally related monophenazine and acridine carboxamide compounds, is very likely due to the novel DNA binding mode of MLN944. Most transcription factors bind DNA in the major groove, using basic region helix-loop-helix, basic region leucine zipper, or zinc-containing binding motifs. The TpG site, or the so-called TG-motif (32), that MLN944 appears specifically to bind to has also been reported to occur in the consensus DNA sequences of a number of transcription factors, including the AP-1 and NF-1 families of transcription factors (19, 33). Furthermore, the TpG site is known to have a high propensity for structure deformation and flexibility, such as poor stacking and high bendability (16, 17). Indeed, the adenine of the (TpG): (CpA) step in our structure is completely unstacked with the intercalating MLN944 chromophore and displays a large negative roll angle (-13°). Therefore, the TpG site is the preferred binding position for transcription factors to introduce the desired DNA structure distortions, such as bending and curvature (3436). It will be of great interest to test if MLN944 could block the DNA binding of any other transcription factors and thus inhibit their biological activities. In summary, the exceptional in vitro and in vivo anti-tumor activity displayed by MLN944 against a range of human and murine tumor models is most likely due to its novel DNA binding mode leading to a unique mechanism of action.
The atomic coordinates and structure factors (code 1X95 [PDB] ) have been deposited in the Protein Data Bank, Research Collaboratory for Structural Bioinformatics, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ (http://www.rcsb.org/).
* This research was supported by National Institutes of Health Grants 1K01CA83886-01 and 1S10 RR16659-01. The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact. || To whom correspondence should be addressed: College of Pharmacy, University of Arizona, 1703 E. Mabel St., Tucson, AZ 85721. Tel.: 520-626-5969; Fax: 520-626-6988; E-mail: yangd{at}pharmacy.arizona.edu.
1 The abbreviations used are: DACA, N-(2-(dimethylamino)ethyl)acridine-4-carboxamide; NOE, nuclear Overhauser effect; NOESY, NOE spectroscopy; EMSA, electrophoretic mobility assay.
2 W. Denny, personal communication.
We thank Xenova Ltd. (Slough, UK) and Millennium Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Cambridge, MA) for providing the MLN944 compound. We thank Dr. Megan Carver for proofreading the manuscript.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||