|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 279, Issue 50, 52300-52311, December 10, 2004
The Expression of Lactate Dehydrogenase Is Important for the Cell Cycle of Toxoplasma gondii*![]() ![]() ||
From the
Received for publication, August 11, 2004 , and in revised form, September 30, 2004.
In Toxoplasma gondii, lactate dehydrogenase is encoded by two independent and developmentally regulated genes LDH1 and LDH2. These genes and their products have been implicated in the control of a metabolic flux during parasite differentiation. To investigate the significance of LDH1 and LDH2 in this process, we generated stable transgenic parasite lines in which the expression of these two expressed isoforms of lactate dehydrogenase was knocked down in a stage-specific manner. These LDH knockdown parasites exhibited variable growth rates in either the tachyzoite or the bradyzoite stage, as compared with the parental parasites. Their differentiation processes were impaired when the parasites were grown under in vitro conditions. In vivo studies in a murine model system revealed that tachyzoites of these parasite lines were unable to form significant numbers of tissue cysts and to establish a chronic infection. Most importantly, all mice that were initially infected with tachyzoites of either of the four LDH knockdown lines survived a subsequent challenge with tachyzoites of the parental parasites (104), a dose that usually causes 100% mortality, suggesting that live vaccination of mice with the LDH knockdown tachyzoites can confer protection against T. gondii. Thus, we conclude that LDH expression is essential for parasite differentiation. The knockdown of LDH1 and LDH2 expression gave rise to virulence-attenuated parasites that were unable to exhibit a significant brain cyst burden in a murine model of chronic infection.
Toxoplasma gondii is a ubiquitous protozoan parasite that has the ability to infect a variety of warm-blooded vertebrates including humans (1). This parasite has a complex life cycle involving both sexual and asexual multiplication. The sexual cycle occurs exclusively in feline intestinal epithelial cells. In humans and other intermediate hosts, the parasite exists in the following two asexual forms: rapidly dividing tachyzoites and slowly replicating bradyzoites. Initial and acute infection is characterized by the presence of tachyzoites that are normally cleared by the host immune response. In most cases of human toxoplasmosis, infection ultimately becomes chronic when tachyzoites differentiate into bradyzoites. The bradyzoites can remain dormant within tissue cysts protected from the host immune response (2). In patients with immunodeficiencies such as AIDS or other malignancies, bradyzoites that differentiate into tachyzoites after release from the cysts can give rise to a recurrent infection that can prove fatal. Congenital malformations are observed when an acute infection is acquired during pregnancy (3). At present, no effective treatment for chronic toxoplasmosis is available. Therefore, cell culture and animal models for the study of chronic Toxoplasma infection are crucial. The differentiation of tachyzoites to bradyzoites can be induced in vitro, although the genetic regulatory signals that control this differentiation are still unknown (2, 4). Several studies have identified stage-specific proteins including the cyst wall glycoprotein 1 (5, 6), surface antigen SAG4A1 (7), metabolic enzymes, lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), enolase (ENO) (810), and the stress-response protein bradyzoite surface antigen 1 (11). Some of these genes are developmentally regulated and suspected to be crucial for T. gondii differentiation (12, 13).
Lactate dehydrogenase is a glycolytic enzyme that catalyzes the interconversion of pyruvate to lactate. This enzyme plays an indispensable role when glycolysis becomes the only pathway to provide energy under anaerobic conditions (14). LDH is considered as a potential anti-parasitic drug target because its unique structural and kinetic properties differ from those of human host cells (1416). Among the reported LDH sequences, those of T. gondii and all members of the Plasmodium genus carry a pentapeptide insertion into the enzyme-active site (16). The activity of LDHs is generally inhibited by an excess of pyruvate. However, this property is greatly reduced in the LDHs from Plasmodium and Toxoplasma (15, 16). In T. gondii, two LDH isoforms are present, LDH1 and LDH2. The genes encoding the isoforms show 64% nucleotide sequence identity, and their gene products share 71% amino acid sequence identity (17). The genes encoding LDH1 and LDH2 isoforms are developmentally regulated. The mRNA of LDH2 is detected in the bradyzoite stage only, whereas the transcript of LDH1 is found in both bradyzoites and tachyzoites. The LDH1 gene product is only expressed in tachyzoites, whereas that of LDH2 is expressed in only bradyzoites. It is speculated that LDH1 is replaced by LDH2 during development from tachyzoites to bradyzoites as a consequence of post-transcriptional induction of LDH2 (8, 17). During differentiation, T. gondii modifies its morphology and energy metabolism to adapt to its surrounding environment. Aerobic respiration and glycolysis are functional in tachyzoites, whereas glycolysis is the only energy source in bradyzoites (15, 18). Therefore, LDH, which is important for anaerobic respiration, might be a promising target for developing drugs for chronic toxoplasmosis. Over the last few years, effective methods of transfection and targeted disruption of genes has made T. gondii amenable to genetic manipulations (19, 20). In addition to these conventional gene manipulations, we previously reported that the introduction of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), presumably via RNAi, can lower the expression of T. gondii genes (21, 22). Here we report the first success in knocking down the expression of the essential genes LDH1 and LDH2 in T. gondii. Significantly, we have provided the evidence that the expression of LDH1 and LDH2 is essential for parasite development. The knockdown of LDH1 and LDH2 expression gave rise to virulence-attenuated parasites that were unable to exhibit a significant brain cyst burden in a murine model of chronic infection.
T. gondii All experiments were carried out using human foreskin fibroblasts (HFF) that were grown in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium, supplemented with 10% cosmic calf serum (Hyclone, Logan, UT), 5 µg/ml streptomycin, and 5 units/ml penicillin in a 5% CO2 atmosphere. Generation of LDH knockdown parasites was performed using the HXG-PRT-deficient ( HXGPRT) T. gondii, strain PLK (23) (AIDS Research and Reference Reagent Program, National Institutes of Health, catalogue number 2860). Parasites were maintained as tachyzoites using HFF monolayers grown in minimum Eagle's medium supplemented with 1% dialyzed fetal bovine serum (Wisent, Montreal, Quebec, Canada). To differentiate the parasites into bradyzoites, freshly lysed parasites were allowed to invade HFF for 4 h. The media were subsequently replaced with RPMI containing 10 mM HEPES and 5% fetal bovine serum, pH 8.2. The medium was replaced every 2 days to maintain the pH (6). Parasites were harvested immediately after they had lysed out of HFF monolayers. After 46 days of bradyzoite differentiation using the alkaline method (7), cysts were freed from cells by scraping and digestion with 170 mM NaCl-pepsin (0.1 mg/ml) to 60 mM HCl for 1 min at 37 °C followed by neutralization with 94 mM Na2CO3. Collected parasites were passed through a 27-gauge needle twice and filtered through a 3-µm filter (Nucleopore). Filter-purified parasites were then collected by centrifugation at 15,000 rpm for 10 min and washed twice with Dulbecco's phosphate-buffered saline.
Plasmid Construction and Transformation Tachyzoite-specific Expression PlasmidsThe plasmid p30/11UP30/11, which contains the ORF of uracil phosphoribosyltransferase (UPRT, 21), was removed by digestion with NsiI and AgeI. The LDH1 and LDH2 ORF portions were then cloned separately by blunt end ligation to replace the UPRT cDNA. The resultant plasmids had two modified SAG1 promoters arranged in a head-to-head fashion flanking either LDH1 or LDH2 coding region. The 1.8-kb HXGPRT minigene was cloned at SacII site to give rise to plasmids p30/11LDH130/11 and p30/11LDH230/11.
Generation of Stable Parasite Lines
Southern and Northern Blot Analysis DIG-labeled DNA probes specific to UPRT and ROP1 were produced by PCR as described previously (22). For the detection of ENO2 mRNA, primers 5ENOx and 3ENOx were used for the synthesis of an ENO2-specific probe. The oligonucleotides LDH15'-UTR and LDH2 5'-UTR specific to LDH1 and LDH2 mRNA were synthesized (Sigma Genosys) and subjected to tailing reactions using terminal transferase. The reactions were performed at 37 °C for 1 h in a 20-µl volume containing 100 pmol of the oligonucleotide, 25 mM Tris-HCl, pH 6.6, 0.2 M potassium cacodylate, 5 mM CoCl2, 50 µM DIG-dUTP, 0.5 mM dATP, and 25 units of terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase (Roche Applied Science).
RT-PCR
Synthesis of dsRNA and Hairpin RNA by in Vitro Transcription The sequence of the T7 RNA polymerase promoter (17 nt long) was incorporated into the 5'-end of the DNA templates by PCR using the T7 promoter containing oligonucleotides specific to the targeted genes (Table I). For the synthesis of dsRNA homologous to LDH1 and LDH2, plasmids pMAL-C2-LDH1 and pMAL-C2-LDH2 (17) were used as templates. For the synthesis of dsRNA homologous to ROP1, UPRT, and GFP, pBS-ROP1 (obtained from NIH-AIDS reagents), pUPRT (obtained from Dr. Ullman, Oregon Health and Science University), and pGFP-N1 (Clontech) were used, respectively, as template plasmids. The primer pairs, T7on5'LDH1 and T7on3'LDH1, T7on5'LDH2 and T7on3'LDH2, T7on5'ROP1 and T7on3'ROP1, T7on5'UPRT and T7on3'UPRT, and T7on5'GFP and T7on3'GFP, were used in individual PCRs for the production of the T7 RNA polymerase promoter-bearing DNA templates. Resultant DNA templates were then transcribed in vitro into the corresponding dsRNAs at 37 °C in 100-µl reaction mixtures containing 100 nmol of DNA templates, 40 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 6 mM MgCl2, 10 mM NaCl, 10 mM dithiothreitol, 50 units of RNase inhibitor, 2.5 mM rNTP, 200 units of T7 RNA polymerase, and 1:100 dilution pyrophosphate. The dsRNAs homologous to LDH1 (nt 1487, GenBankTM accession number U35118 [GenBank] ), LDH2 (nt 1487, GenBankTM U23207 [GenBank] ), ROP1 (nt 1502, GenBankTM AA037935 [GenBank] ), UPRT (nt 1724, GenBankTM U10246 [GenBank] ), and GFP (nt 1500, GenBankTM AF420592 [GenBank] ) were obtained. ROP1, UPRT, and GFP genes were used as controls. The ROP1 gene was chosen because it is an endogenous housekeeping gene that does not share any sequence similarity with LDH1 nor LDH2. The UPRT gene was included because it is an endogenous nonessential gene that was successfully knocked down in previous studies (21). The GFP gene was used because it is exogenous and completely unrelated to T. gondii genes. The hairpin RNA (hpRNA) is an RNA structure that consists of a 21-bp-long RNA duplex with a 5'-hydroxyl terminus and a 2-nt 3'-overhang. For the synthesis of hpRNA homologous to LDH1, the oligonucleotides hpLDH1 and T7 were heated at 95 °C for 2 min in a buffer containing 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, and 10 mM MgCl2 and were slowly cooled down to allow for annealing. The annealed oligonucleotides were subsequently used to produce hairpin RNA by in vitro transcription. Similarly, the oligonucleotides hpLDH2 and T7 were used to produce hairpin RNA homologous to LDH2.
dsRNA Transfection and Measurement of T. gondii Growth
Immunofluorescence Assay
Enzymatic Assays
SDS-PAGE and Western Blot Analysis
Experimental Infections in Mice In vivo cyst formation was determined by harvesting mouse brain at 8 weeks after infection. Cysts were purified using Percoll gradients. After resuspension of the pellets in PBS in a final volume of 100200 µl, the purified cysts were counted using inverted phase microscopy.
Transient Silencing of the LDH ExpressionWe first verified whether the expression of LDH1 and LDH2 can be down-regulated following the introduction of dsRNA. Transient down-regulation assays as reported previously (21, 22) were used. Briefly, equal amounts of tested dsRNAs (4 µg) specific to LDH1, LDH2, ROP1, GFP, or UPRT were individually introduced into filter-purified parasites by electroporation. 24 h following electroporation, the total RNAs were isolated, and Northern blot analysis was used in the assessment of the down-regulation of the target genes. A control electroporation (mock) was performed using the buffer lacking dsRNA. When the steady state levels of the constitutively expressed and non-target gene enolase 2 (ENO2) were analyzed by Northern blot, single bands were revealed (Fig. 1A, upper panel). When the ENO2 probe was removed and the blot was hybridized to the probe specific to LDH1, transcripts of 1.8 kb were revealed from all samples. The sample isolated from LDH1 dsRNA electroporation exhibited relatively less abundance, as compared with other samples (Fig. 1A, 2nd panel). When the probe specific to LDH2 was used on the same blot following the LDH1 probe removal, no signal was detected in all samples tested (Fig. 1A, 3rd panel), confirming that LDH2 was not expressed at this growth stage. Again, the LDH2 probe was removed prior to the next hybridization. The probe specific to ROP1 revealed transcripts of 2.1 kb in all samples tested, and the hybridization signal was lower in the sample isolated from ROP1 dsRNA electroporation (Fig. 1A, 4th panel). Similarly, the UPRT-specific probe showed a 2.2-kb band corresponding to UPRT transcripts, with the signal of the sample isolated from the UPRT dsRNA electroporation having less intensity (Fig. 1A, bottom panel). Hence, we demonstrated that this transient down-regulation exhibited high specificity toward target genes.
Reduced Parasite Growth with Lowered LDH ExpressionWe consequently verified whether the lowered expression of LDH1 or LDH2 would affect the parasite viability and proliferation. Nucleotide incorporation assays with [3H]uracil or [3H]hypoxanthine were used for this assessment. It has been reported that a single-stranded RNA with a hairpin structure (hpRNA) can be used in place of dsRNA, to invoke RNAi in other systems (24, 25). Thus, we also designed and synthesized hpRNA containing the sequence specific to the unique region of the LDH1 or LDH2 ORF, called hpLDH1 and hpLDH2, respectively. These hpRNAs have the nucleotide sequences homologous to LDH1 (nt 251272) and LDH2 (nt 248269), respectively. Equal amounts (4 µg) of tested RNAs were individually introduced into the parasites via electroporation. After 24 h, the incorporation of [3H]hypoxanthine or [3H]uracil was monitored. Mock electroporations with the buffer alone were performed as controls. The mock electroporated parasites were able to infect HFF cells and incorporate both [3H]hypoxanthine and [3H]uracil (64,000 ± 4900 and 70,200 ± 6100 cpm, respectively, Fig. 1B, mock), whereas the host HFF could not incorporate [3H]hypoxanthine nor [3H]uracil (420 ± 17 and 583 ± 12 cpm, respectively, HFF, Fig. 1B). Parasites electroporated with dsRNA homologous to LDH1 assimilated less [3H]hypoxanthine and [3H]uracil compared with the mock (44,400 ± 3200 and 42,000 ± 3500 cpm, respectively, Fig. 1B, LDH1 dsRNA). The reduction in nucleotide assimilation indicated that intact LDH1 gene expression is needed for optimal parasite growth. In contrast, electroporation with dsRNA homologous to LDH2 did not lower [3H]hypoxanthine nor [3H]uracil incorporation (62,000 ± 5800 and 72,500 ± 7800 cpm, respectively, Fig. 1B, LDH2 dsRNA), whereas electroporation with either hpLDH1 or hpLDH2 had no effect on the uptake of both [3H]hypoxanthine and [3H]uracil (Fig. 1B). An equal amount of dsRNA homologous to ROP1 was assayed for its effect on parasite growth. The electroporation of dsRNA homologous to ROP1 had an insignificant effect on [3H]hypoxanthine and [3H]uracil incorporation (62,000 ± 7300 and 64,100 ± 5100 cpm, respectively, Fig. 1B, ROP1 dsRNA). This is as expected because ROP1 knockout has no effect on tachyzoite growth (26). We reported previously (21) that transient down-regulation upon the introduction of dsRNA is dose-dependent. Hence, it is interesting to know if the effect of LDH1 down-regulation could be enhanced by increasing the amount of dsRNA. When 10 µg of LDH1 dsRNA were electroporated into purified tachyzoites, no enhancement of the down-regulation was observed (Fig. 1C). When the concentrations of LDH1 dsRNA were lowered (as low as 0.04 µg), the nucleotide incorporation was similar to that of the mock electroporation, thus indicating that the threshold of LDH1 knockdown is reached when 4 µg of dsRNA was used (Fig. 1C). LDH Knockdown Parasite LinesTo investigate the physiological roles of LDH1 and LDH2 in parasite development, we primarily aimed to lower LDH1 expression in a tachyzoite-specific manner and to lower LDH2 expression in a bradyzoite-specific manner. The two transgenic parasite lines generated for this purpose were TL1T and BL2B, respectively. However, to gain a better insight into the knockdown effect and the LDH expression pattern, we generated two additional transgenic parasite lines, BL1B and TL2T. In BL1B, LDH1 expression was knocked down in the bradyzoite conditions, whereas in TL2T, LDH2 expression was knocked down in the tachyzoite conditions. The genomic arrangement of these transgenic parasite lines was investigated by using Southern blot analyses. Fig. 2A shows a Southern blot analysis using the LDH1 probe. A 12.2-kb DNA band was detected in the sample isolated from the parental parasites and digested with BamHI (Fig. 2A, lane 1). This single band corresponds to the digested genomic locus of the LDH1 gene. Additional bands were detected in the BamHI-digested DNA samples isolated from the transgenic parasite lines (Fig. 2A, lanes 25). Similar results were obtained when the PstI-digested DNA samples were used for the analysis. A single 3-kb band was revealed for the sample isolated from the parental parasites (Fig. 2A, lane 6), whereas additional bands were detected for the samples isolated from the transgenic parasite lines (Fig. 2A, lanes 710). The LDH1 probe was removed, and the blot was hybridized with the LDH2 probe. A 9.2-kb band of the BamHI-digested LDH2 genomic locus was detected in the sample isolated from the parental parasites (Fig. 2B, lane 1), indicating no cross-hybridization of the LDH2 probe to LDH1 fragment. In addition to this band, the digested samples obtained from the transgenic parasite lines showed extra bands (Fig. 2B, lanes 25). Likewise, the PstI-digested samples isolated from the parental parasites showed three different bands of 1.3, 1.8, and 2.2 kb in size (Fig. 2B, lane 6). The samples isolated from the transgenic parasite lines and digested with the same restriction endonuclease showed additional random bands (Fig. 2B, lanes 710). The digestion patterns revealed by the LDH1 and LDH2 individual probes indicated that the transgenes, expressing dsRNA, were integrated into the genomes of the parasite lines. An additional hybridization with an HXGPRT-specific probe using the same blot also confirmed the integration (data not shown).
Consequently, we investigated whether the corresponding dsRNA was expressed in the transgenic parasite lines and in a stage-specific fashion as designed. In order to detect specifically the expressed antisense RNA strands of the dsRNAs, total RNA was isolated from tachyzoites or bradyzoites of the transgenic parasite lines and the parental parasites, and then subjected to the RT reactions. The RT reactions were carried out using a specific primer, which allowed only the antisense strands of LDH1 or LDH2 to be reverse-transcribed into cDNAs, which were then subjected to PCR. No band of expected size (487 bp) was detected when the samples isolated from the parental parasites were tested, clearly indicating that there was no natural LDH1 antisense (Fig. 2C, lanes 2 and 3) or natural LDH2 antisense (lanes 8 and 9) present in T. gondii. The expected band corresponding to the designed antisense LDH1 RNA was detected in samples from TL1T tachyzoites and TL1T bradyzoites (Fig. 2C, lanes 4 and 5) and in BL1B bradyzoites (lane 7). An unexpected band ( 200 bp) was detected in BL1B tachyzoites (Fig. 2C, lane 6), when the conditions for the specific detection of the antisense LDH1 RNA were used. The expected band corresponding to the designed anti-sense LDH2 RNA was detected in the samples from TL2T tachyzoites (Fig. 2C, lane 10) and in BL2B bradyzoites (lane 13) but not TL2T bradyzoites (lane 11), BL2B tachyzoites (lane 12), nor in samples from TL1T and BL1B (data not shown). Unexpected bands (400 and 200 bp) were observed in the sample from BL2B bradyzoite (Fig. 2C, lane 13). These bands (Fig. 2C, lanes 6 and 13) are presumably nonspecific PCR products.
The steady state levels of the LDH1 and LDH2 mRNAs in the knockdown parasite lines were then assessed. The dot blot analyses were performed by using LDH1 and LDH2 gene-specific probes (Fig. 3A). The ROP1-specific probe was used to allow a normalization of signals obtained from LDH1- and LDH2-specific probes. For comparison, the ratios of LDH1/ROP1 and LDH2/ROP1 were calculated for each sample. It was observed that the ratio between LDH1/ROP1 remained constant (1:1) for the tachyzoites (T) and bradyzoites (B) of the parental, TL2T, and BL2B parasites and for the TL1T bradyzoites and the BL1B tachyzoites. It was as expected because LDH1 mRNA is expressed constitutively in tachyzoites and bradyzoites, although the LDH1 product is formed only in tachyzoites (17). Reduced LDH1/ROP1 ratios of 1.0:0.26 and 1.0:0.29 were observed for the TL1T tachyzoites and the BL1B bradyzoites, respectively, indicating gene- and stage-specific knockdown of LDH1 expression (Fig. 3A). When the signals from the LDH2-specifc probe and ROP1 probe were measured and calculated, we detected negligible levels of LDH2 mRNA in the tachyzoites of all parasites including the parental, TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B parasites (Fig. 3A, bottom panel). The calculated ratios of LDH2/ROP1 at
Phenotypic Studies of the LDH Knockdown Parasite Lines In order to monitor the expressed gene products in the parental and knockdown parasite lines, Western blot analyses were performed by using polyclonal antibodies raised against LDH1- or LDH2-expressed isoforms (8). Protein extracts obtained from the tachyzoites of tested parasites were immunoblotted and incubated with the LDH1 antiserum (Fig. 3B, upper panel). The lysate of the TL1T tachyzoites showed a decreased level of the expressed LDH1 isoforms compared with those of the parental and other parasite lines (Fig. 3B, TL1T, upper panel). In parallel, the protein extracts obtained from the bradyzoites were immunoblotted and incubated with the LDH2 antiserum (Fig. 3B, lower panel). The extracts of TL2T and BL2B contained less of the LDH2 isoform. No significant difference was detected for the LDH2-expressed isoform in the samples of TL1T and BL1B bradyzoites. These findings clearly indicate that the knockdown of LDH expression is gene-specific. To confirm further the attenuation of the LDH protein expression, the LDH enzymatic activity of the generated parasite lines and their parental parasites was compared. Cell-free lysates were prepared from the tachyzoites and bradyzoites of tested parasites. In order to standardize the obtained data, the LDH activity was calculated per mg of protein in the lysate (nmol·min1·mg1). The values of 809 ± 142 and 2730 ± 529 nmol·min1·mg1 were obtained for the tachyzoites and bradyzoites of the parental parasites, respectively. The LDH activity of TL1T tachyzoites was 349 ± 68 nmol·min1·mg1 and significantly lower than those of the parental parasites. The values of 763 ± 124, 794 ± 138, and 738 ± 132 nmol·min1·mg1 were obtained for the tachyzoites of TL2T, BL1B, and BL2B parasite lines. The bradyzoite extracts showed an LDH activity of the values 1482 ± 232 and 2730 ± 529 nmol·min1·mg1 for the BL2B and parental parasites, respectively. The TL1T, TL2T, and BL1B bradyzoites exhibited values of 2712 ± 518, 2059 ± 502, and 3008 ± 635 nmol·min1·mg1, respectively. These values are similar to that of the parental parasites. The human LDH is a secreted protein, and its activity can therefore be detected in the cell media (27). We thus tested whether the obtained data were partly derived from the secreted LDH upon cell lysis. The LDH assays were conducted using the parasite washes (i.e. prior to cell lysate preparation), and showed negligible values, indicating no host LDH contamination. To characterize the phenotype of the LDH knockdown parasite lines, we examined the multiplication rates of tachyzoites and bradyzoites. Because T. gondii divides by a unique binary division, the number of parasites per vacuole reflects the division rate. The parental, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B tachyzoites multiplied at similar rates, of which 8 and 64 parasites/vacuole were obtained for most vacuoles, at times 48 and 96 h after infection (Fig. 4, A and B, respectively). TL1T tachyzoites grew more slowly. Values of 2 and 8 parasites/vacuoles at 48 and 96 h post-infection were scored. Under bradyzoite growth conditions, 32 parasites/vacuole were counted in most vacuoles of the parental parasites (Fig. 4C). It was detected that 8 parasites/vacuole for BL2B and TL1T bradyzoites and 26 parasites/vacuole for TL2T and BL1B bradyzoites were formed.
In Vitro Parasite DifferentiationIn order to evaluate whether the lowered LDH gene expression affects parasite differentiation, we investigated whether the LDH knockdown parasite lines could differentiate and form cysts in vitro. FITC-conjugated D. biflorus lectin, which specifically binds to the N-acetylglucosamine moiety within the cyst wall, was used as a marker for the cyst wall development. The localization and abundance of LDH1 and LDH2 were monitored, along with the presence of the cyst wall, by immunofluorescence using LDH1- and LDH2-specific polyclonal antisera, raised in rabbits. A rhodamine-conjugated secondary antibody was used to reveal the signals of LDH1 and LDH2. The parasite lines were first grown as tachyzoites and subjected to immunofluorescence using the LDH1 antiserum (Fig. 5A, images 2 and 4). In order to estimate LDH1 protein level, the intensity of the fluorescence signal for the parental and transgenic tachyzoites was quantified and normalized with reference to the fluorescence signal for background. The ratio of the LDH1 signals from the tachyzoite parasite lines over those from the parental was calculated and plotted for each parasite line (Fig. 5B). We observed that the LDH1 ratio remained almost constant (1:1) for the parasites of TL2T, BL1B, and BL2B lines. The ratio was reduced for TL1T tachyzoites (1.0:0.32), indicating lower LDH1 protein expression (Fig. 5, A, images 2 and 4, and B). In parallel experiments, the transgenic parasite lines were cultured under bradyzoite-induced conditions and stained with the LDH2 antiserum in conjunction with FITC-labeled D. biflorus lectin. The fluorescence signals for LDH2 were calculated, and the ratios were plotted for all parasite lines (Fig. 5C) as described for LDH1. The ratios of fluorescence signal for parasites of TL2T and BL1B were similar (1:1). For parasites of TL1T and BL2B lines, we observed lowered LDH2 ratios (1:0.8 and 1:0.28, respectively). Under these growth conditions, all parasite lines were positively stained with Dolichos, indicating that these parasites were surrounded by cyst walls. The parasites of the BL2B line showed a similar Dolichos staining pattern to that of the parental parasites, despite the reduced LDH2 signal (Fig. 5A, images 9 and 10), indicating cyst formation in vitro.
We then further investigated whether TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B bradyzoites could convert back to tachyzoites. The TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B cysts were collected and treated with pepsin (0.1 mg/ml) for 10 min to digest the cyst walls. The treated parasites were then counted and allowed to infect the HFF monolayers. Released bradyzoites of the parental strain showed 89% survival, as determined by trypan blue staining of 2 x 105 parasites. The viability of the released TL1T and BL2B bradyzoites was significantly reduced compared with that of the parental (49 and 53%, when 6 x 104 and 7 x 104 parasites were stained, respectively). As for TL2T and BL1B bradyzoites, their survival scores were 61 and 68%, when 1 x 105 and 2 x 105 parasites were stained, respectively. When we used an equal number of the released bradyzoites for infection, the parental parasites were able to completely lyse their host fibroblasts in 56 days. For TL1T and BL2B, the parasites were able to infect and lyse HFF monolayers in 1213 and 1516 days, respectively. We observed that the TL2T- and BL1B-released bradyzoites completely lysed the monolayers in 910 and 89 days, respectively. The Knockdown Expression of LDH Attenuates the Parasite Virulence in MiceTo explore the effect of LDH1 and LDH2 knockdown on parasite growth in vivo, TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B parasites were inoculated into female BALB/c mice at doses up to 103 tachyzoites. After 45 days of infection, all mice infected with the parental parasite and LDH knockdown parasites showed the same characteristic symptoms of disease. However, the groups of mice infected with the four knockdown parasite lines recovered faster than those infected with the parental parasite. At 14 days post-inoculation, infection with TL1T, BL1B, and BL2B tachyzoites was not lethal to the mice, whereas the infection with TL2T tachyzoites and the parental parasites caused 20 and 60% mortality, respectively (Fig. 6A). When an independent experiment using a dose of 104 tachyzoites per mouse was performed, 40 and 100% mortality rates were observed at day 11 in mice infected with TL2T tachyzoites and the parental parasite, respectively. In this case, 100% survival was again obtained in the groups of mice infected with TL1T, BL1B, or BL2B (Fig. 6B), suggesting that LDH knockdown attenuated T. gondii virulence in mice. In order to ensure that the surviving mice had truly been infected, serum was collected 30 days post-inoculation and was tested in Western blot. A pool of the pre-immune sera from these same mice was also tested and failed to detect T. gondii antigens as expected. Numerous antigens of molecular masses ranging from 14 to 90 kDa were recognized by sera from mice surviving infection with TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B tachyzoites (Fig. 6C). Similar antigenic profiles were observed when the sera from the two mice surviving infection with 103 tachyzoites of the parental parasites (Fig. 6A) were tested (Fig. 6C, panel P, lanes 1 and 2). Except for an antigen with an apparent molecular mass of 43 kDa, which was not observed in four out of five mice infected with TL1T (Fig. 6C, panel TL1T, lanes 14), and one of the parental parasite (lane 1), numerous antigens of the same molecular masses were detected in all sera tested. To determine whether the surviving mice had developed protective immunity 30 days post-infection, mice initially infected with TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B were challenged with 104 parental parasite tachyzoites. As shown in Fig. 6B (arrows), all mice infected with the LDH knockdown parasites (TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, and BL2B) survived a subsequent challenge with 104 tachyzoites of the parental parasite, a dose that usually causes 100% mortality, suggesting that live vaccination of mice with the LDH knockdown tachyzoites can confer protection against T. gondii.
To determine whether in vivo cyst formation could occur in the LDH knockdown parasite lines, the surviving mice infected with 103 parasites from TL1T, BL1B, TL2T, BL2B, and parental parasites, as described in Fig. 6A, were examined for the presence of cysts in the entire brain. Approximately 25 cysts per brain were detected in TL1T-, BL1B-, BL2B-infected mice, whereas about 20 cysts/brain were detected in TL2T-infected mice. The mice infected with the parental strain contained an average of 200 cysts per mouse brain (Fig. 6D). Identical results were obtained when the surviving mice infected with 104 tachyzoites were analyzed for the presence of cysts in the brain. Again, only very few cysts were detected, suggesting that unlike the parental strain, the LDH knockdown parasite lines were unable to produce a significant number of cysts in vivo.
Differentiation and encystation of T. gondii involves the coordinated expression of several genes. A broad spectrum of induction and suppression of gene expression could be observed as developmental dynamics. Despite the amenability of T. gondii to genetic manipulation, silencing the expression of essential genes has proven difficult. Our previous studies (21, 22) have indicated that the introduction of dsRNA is likely to invoke an RNAi mechanism and can be used as a powerful genetic tool for lowering the steady state level of gene expression. In this study, we demonstrated that a similar approach can be used successfully for lowering LDH1 and LDH2 expression. Such effort was reported unattainable via conventional genetic manipulations (6). The ability to lower LDH expression has allowed us to investigate their significance in parasite development. We initially demonstrated that the transient knockdown of LDH expression gave rise to an altered growth pattern for tachyzoites, as shown by the nucleotide incorporation assays (Fig. 1). The inhibition of LDH1 gene expression in tachyzoites clearly decreased viability and proliferation. As expected, the LDH2 dsRNA electroporation did not affect tachyzoite viability because LDH2 is not expressed at this stage. This finding indicated that the introduction of dsRNA, without the presence of the target LDH2 mRNA, did not interfere with the cell viability. The hpRNAs which targeted a unique sequence on either LDH1 or LDH2 mRNA did not invoke an effective RNAi and did not cause the lowering of LDH expression. However, this finding was not indicative of an ineffectiveness of hpRNAs. We chose only a single site, which might not be accessible to the RISC complex. If other sites had been chosen, the knockdown might have occurred. We have attempted to transiently down-regulate LDH2 expression in the bradyzoite stage by electroporation. However, no conclusive data were obtained. It is likely that the introduction of dsRNA directly into bradyzoites by electroporation was not as efficient as that for tachyzoites.
Four transgenic parasite lines were generated and used for the investigation of the physiological roles and significance of LDH1 and LDH2 in the parasite development. TL1T and BL2B parasite lines were generated to monitor the down-regulation effect of LDH1 and LDH2 in a stage-specific manner, following the pattern of the expressed isoforms. The BL1B parasite line was used for investigating the outcome of lowering untranslated LDH1 mRNA in bradyzoites. TL2T, on the other hand, was a control parasite line for the dsRNA expression in the absence of the target mRNA. Prior to the phenotypical studies, we characterized these parasite lines, in comparison to their parental line, T. gondii, strain PLK TL1T Parasite LineTL1T tachyzoites exhibited impaired replication in the HFF monolayer. The doubling time of TL1T tachyzoites was twice that of the parental tachyzoites. It was recently reported that upon inhibiting LDH1 enzymatic activity by gossypol, the tachyzoite growth was reduced in cultured fibroblasts (14, 15). Therefore, the TL1T phenotype is in concordance with these previous enzymatic and inhibition studies. Inhibiting LDH1 enzymatic activity gave rise to slower replication and growth. The finding that the TL1T parasites were unable to kill the mice with a dose that causes 100% mortality in the parental strain and were unable to develop a significant number of cysts in vivo indicated that the host immunity could clear these TL1T parasites more effectively and rapidly after an infection than wild-type parasites. More importantly, the infection with TL1T conferred protection against a new challenge with the parental strain at a dose that kills 100% of infected mice. BL2B Parasite LineIt is not surprising that BL2B tachyzoites exhibited relatively normal growth similar to the parental parasites (Fig. 4, A and B). As expected, BL2B bradyzoites multiplied significantly slower than those of the parental parasites (Fig. 4B). The percentage survival of the pepsin-released parasites of the BL2B parasite line was low (49%), as compared with the parental parasite (89%). BL2B parasites were unable to develop a significant number of cysts in vitro (Figs. 4C and 5A) and in vivo (Fig. 6D), indicating that the BL2B parasites may be defective in the differentiation process. The fact that few mature cysts (only 25 cysts in the whole brain extract) were detected suggests that differentiation is likely completed by this parasite line but at very low efficiency. It was reported that an LDH activity, especially that of LDH2, could be required to acidify the cytosol and keep the parasite in its bradyzoite stage (9, 18). The levels of expressed LDH2 and the steady state LDH2 mRNA were lowered in BL2B, as compared with those of the parental parasites (Fig. 3, B and A). Thus, it is possible that normal functioning of the parasite requires sufficient levels of LDH2. The down-regulation of LDH2 expression in BL2B bradyzoites might be due to a combination of both RNAi and antisense effect. It is thus possible that lowered LDH2 expression might have lead to (i) an insufficient energy supply and (ii) suboptimal conditions required for the bradyzoite development and maintenance. In a murine model system, low efficiency in bradyzoite formation would have left some parasites in the tachyzoites stage to be cleared by the immune system. As observed for this parasite line, BL2B parasites could cause typical symptoms of disease, but they are not lethal. Because only a few cysts were obtained, we were unable to determine by electron microscopy whether they display a normal morphology. The fact that BL2B infection could confer protection against re-infection by T. gondii indicates that the BL2B infection allows a protective immunity to develop. BL1B Parasite LineThe expression of LDH1 dsRNA in a bradyzoite-specific manner gave rise to the lowered LDH1 mRNA (Fig. 3A), indicative of the RNAi-knockdown of LDH1 expression in the bradyzoite stage. BL1B exhibited a phenotype almost identical to that of the parental parasites. The BL1B tachyzoites and bradyzoites grew at a similar rate as those of the parental parasites. When Dolichos staining was used as the differentiation marker, BL1B was found to differentiate in vitro, similar to that of the parental parasites. Dolichos staining is specific to the cyst wall formation that takes place very early in the differentiation process (2, 4). However, parasites released from the BL1B cysts exhibited less viability (only 68% viability), as compared with the parental parasite (89% viability), suggesting an impairment in cyst development. In addition, the BL1B parasite line also failed to develop a significant number of cysts in the brains of mice. These findings suggest that the maintenance of LDH1 mRNA level may be associated with the differentiation process, perhaps through maintenance of a micro-environmental balance. When we lowered LDH1 mRNA in the bradyzoite stage, we might have offset the level of LDH1 mRNA essential for (i) an optimal interaction with other cellular components important for the parasite differentiation, and/or (ii) parasite readiness to convert to tachyzoites. This notion requires further investigation. Approaches such as those of proteomics and microarray analysis would give better insight into the differences between the BL1B and parental bradyzoites. TL2T Parasite LineTL2T tachyzoites produced LDH2 dsRNA in the absence of the target mRNA (Fig. 2C). This parasite line has a similar growth pattern as the parental parasite line, indicating that the presence of dsRNA does not cause any harmful effect to the parasite growth (Fig. 4). The priming of the RNAi system was not effective in lowering the LDH2 expression, as seen by the absence of change in the level of LDH2 mRNA in the TL2T bradyzoites as compared with other three transgenic parasite lines (Fig. 3A). Nonetheless, the LDH2 protein expression levels in the TL2T were lower than that in the parental line (Fig. 3B). The fact that the steady state level of LDH2 mRNA was unchanged, whereas expression of LDH2 isoform was lowered, suggests that the down-regulation of LDH2 expression in TL2T might not be due to the RNAi down-regulation but instead because of an antisense effect. With an antisense effect, translation of the target mRNA is blocked, without significant degradation of the message. This may explain why the mice infected with TL2T yielded fewer cysts in mice as compared with the mice infected with the parental strain. It should be noted that the number of cysts obtained in mice infected with TL2T was slightly higher than those generated by TL1T, BL1B, and BL2B infection. The translational suppression by this putative antisense effect seems to be sufficient to attenuate the virulence of the parasite infection but is not as efficient as that induced by mRNA degradation. It is important to further investigate how LDH2 dsRNA expression, particularly in the TL2T parasite line, initiates an antisense effect, not an RNAi effect. It has been reported that post-transcriptional regulation via antisense and RNAi share a common pathway, as those observed for the miRNA and siRNA, respectively (28). The degree of complementarity between the siRNAs or miRNAs and the mRNA target is the sole determinant of their function in mRNA degradation and/or translational repression (29). siRNAs recognize mRNA targets by precise complementary base pair interactions leading to subsequent degradation of the target via an RNAi mechanism. On the other hand, miRNAs inhibit the translation of mRNAs via imprecise base pair interactions (30). Both pathways share similar protein partners, RNase III and Argonaute family members (31). It has been recently reported that T. gondii has RNAi-related genes, Dicer and Argonaute family members (32). We have obtained the cDNA encoding putative Dicer and Argonaute and are currently characterizing these genes. Thus, it is highly likely that miRNA as well as siRNA pathways exist in T. gondii. Because all LDH knockdown parasites are virulence-attenuated in the tested animal model, we question whether the transforming elements and their products (i.e. constructed plasmids and expressed dsRNAs) could be virulence attenuating factors. In order to answer this question, we could further investigate whether other parasite lines expressing dsRNA unrelated to LDH1 and LDH2 are virulence-attenuated. However, this possibility is less likely because a parasite line expressing dsRNA homologous to UPRT exhibits normal growth and differentiation (21). In conclusion, we have shown that the expression of LDH1 and LDH2 is essential for parasite development and growth. The generation of LDH knockdown parasites that are defective in their abilities to form cysts in vivo verifies the great potential of LDH as a target for designing future drugs that could block tissue cyst formation. The knockdown parasites might also serve as a useful basis for the development of vaccine strategies, especially for livestock.
* This work was supported by grants from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (to S. A.), the Ministry of Colleges and Universities of Ontario (to F. A.), and the CNRS (to S. T.). The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact. || To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel.: 519-253-3000 (ext. 3550); Fax: 519-973-7098; E-mail: anans{at}uwindsor.ca.
1 The abbreviations used are: SAG4A, surface antigen 4A; DIG, digoxigenin; dsRNA, double-stranded RNA; ENO, enolase; FITC, fluorescein-isothiocyanate; GFP, green fluorescent protein; HFF, human foreskin fibroblasts; hpRNA, hairpin RNA; LDH, lactate dehydrogenase; nt, nucleotide; ORF, open reading frame; RNAi, RNA interference; ROP1, rhoptry protein 1; RT, reverse transcription; UPRT, uracil phosphoribosyltransferase; UTR, untranslated region; PBS, phosphate-buffered saline.
We thank Drs. James Gauld and Antonin Gauthier for critical reading of the manuscript, Dr. Kristin Hager for help with the fluorescence microscopy, Marlène Mortuaire for technical assistance, and Gabrielle Oria for iconography. The T. gondii host strain P(LK)HXGPRT was obtained from Dr. David Roos through the AIDS Research and Reference Reagent Program, Division of AIDS, NIAID, National Institutes of Health.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||