|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 279, Issue 7, 5207-5215, February 13, 2004
Biophysical Characterization of the Entire Bacterial Surface Layer Protein SbsB and Its Two Distinct Functional Domains*![]() ¶![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ¶
From the
Received for publication, August 11, 2003 , and in revised form, November 17, 2003.
The crystalline bacterial cell surface layer (S-layer) protein SbsB of Geobacillus stearothermophilus PV72/p2 was dissected into an N-terminal part defined by the three consecutive S-layer homologous motifs and the remaining large C-terminal part. Both parts of the mature protein were produced as separate recombinant proteins (rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889) and compared with the full-length form rSbsB1889 (rSbsB). Evidence for functional and structural integrity of the two truncated forms was provided by optical spectroscopic methods and electron microscopy. In particular, binding of the secondary cell wall polymer revealed a high affinity dissociation constant of 3 nM and could be assigned solely to the soluble rSbsB1178, whereas rSbsB177889 self-assembled into the same lattice as the full-length protein. Furthermore, thermal as well as guanidinium hydrochloride induced equilibrium unfolding profiles monitored by intrinsic fluorescence, and circular dichroism spectroscopy allowed characterization of rSbsB1178 as an -helical protein with a single cooperative unfolding transition yielding a G value of 26.5 kJ mol1. The C-terminal rSbsB177889 could be characterized as a -sheet protein with typical multidomain unfolding, which is partially less stable as stand-alone protein. In general, the truncated forms showed identical properties compared with the full-length rSbsB with respect to structure and function. Consequently, rSbsB is characterized by its two functionally and structurally separated parts, the specific secondary cell wall polymer binding rSbsB1178 and the larger rSbsB177889 responsible for formation of the crystalline array.
Crystalline bacterial cell surface layers (S-layers),1 representing the outermost cell envelope component of many bacteria and archaea, are composed of a single species of identical protein or glycoprotein subunits forming a lattice with either oblique, square, or hexagonal symmetry (13). S-layer subunits can be isolated from cell wall fragments by disintegration with high concentrations of hydrogen bond-breaking agents (e.g. GdmHCl). The intrinsic ability of isolated S-layer subunits to recrystallize into their original regular arrays either in suspension or on surfaces (e.g. noble metals, lipid films (4)) makes S-layer proteins unique building blocks in molecular nanobiotechnology and biomimetics (59). The mature S-layer protein SbsB (10) of Geobacillus stearothermophilus PV72/p2 (11) is processed from a 920-amino acid-long preprotein by cleavage of a 31-residue-long signal peptide and assembles into an oblique (p1) lattice type. Recently, SbsB has been used to generate chimeric S-layer proteins by fusion of SbsB with streptavidin either on the N-terminal or on the C-terminal end of SbsB (12). These chimeric S-layer proteins combine both the ability to form monomolecular protein lattices on different surfaces and the binding of biotinylated compounds. Such a functional biomolecular matrix with repetitive features in the subnanometer range allows a unique approach for immobilizing compounds with defined spacing on a surface.
The second feature of S-layer proteins is their specific anchoring to the cell wall, which has frequently been assigned to S-layer homologous (SLH) motifs. SLH motifs (13) consist of a conserved sequence of 5060 amino acids and are found in triplicate at the N terminus of many S-layer proteins (10, 1419). They have also been identified at the C-terminal end of cell-associated exoenzymes and other exoproteins of Gram-positive bacteria (20), where they occur in single copies. SbsB possesses three N-terminal SLH motifs that recognize a secondary (accessory) cell wall polymer (SCWP) in the rigid cell wall as specific binding partner (21, 22). This glycan is mainly composed of N-acetylglucosamine and N-acetylmannosamine in a molar ratio of 2:1 and contains pyruvic acid residues (22). Despite their high physiological expense (S-layer protein synthesis can occupy up to 15% of the whole capacity in protein synthesis of the cell (23)) and the widespread occurrence in all major phylogenetic groups of bacteria, no structural model at atomic resolution of any S-layer protein is available. This fact may be explained by the molecular mass of the subunits being too large for NMR analysis and by their high tendency to form two-dimensional lattices preventing the formation of isotropic three-dimensional crystals required for x-ray crystallography. In addition, the very low solubility of isolated subunits is a general hindrance for both methods. Attempts like sequence-structure alignment are hindered by the absence of significant sequence similarities to proteins with known structure (1, 24). Thus, even recognition of further domains other than those formed by SLH motifs remains problematic. According to their molecular mass ranging from 40 to 200 kDa S-layer proteins are large multidomain proteins. Thus, direct determination of domain properties is not only more challenging than for small proteins, but often impossible for wild-type proteins. In the present study, the "dissection approach," frequently applied to cytoskeleton proteins, e.g. titin (2527), was applied to an S-layer protein. The aim of the study was to dissect the multidomain protein SbsB into its two functional domains, one binding the SCWP and the other one comprising the self-assembly ability. The maintenance of function and structure of the isolated domains was monitored by means of electron microscopy, circular dichroism, and fluorescence spectroscopy, which furthermore allowed a characterization of properties of the isolated parts compared with their properties in the context with the wild-type protein. This work is considered as a first step toward resolving the three-dimensional structure of an S-layer protein.
MaterialsUltrapure GdmHCl (AA grade) was obtained from Nigu (Waldkraiburg, Germany), and concentrations of GdmHCl solutions were calculated from refractive index measurements (28). All other reagents were of analytical grade. Plasmid Construction, Protein Production and PurificationThe plasmids for gene expression were cloned by inserting PCR fragments of sbsB (10), which were generated with Pwo DNA polymerase (Roche Applied Science), into the vector pET-28a(+) (Novagen). The template DNA for PCR was chromosomal DNA of G. stearothermophilus PV72/p2, which was prepared from biomass grown in continuous culture (11) using a genomic DNA isolation kit (Qiagen). The gene fragments for production of mature full-length SbsB (rSbsB1889) and N-terminally truncated SbsB (rSbsB177889) were amplified using the primer pairs F2/R1 and F3/R1, respectively, and inserted into the NcoI and BamHI sites of pET-28a(+). For production of the SLH domain (rSbsB1178), a gene fragment was amplified with the primer pair F2/R3SLH and inserted into the NcoI and XhoI sites of pET-28a(+). PCRs and cloning steps were performed according to standard procedures (29). Escherichia coli TG1 was used as a cloning host and transformed by electroporation. The following oligonucleotides were used as PCR primers (restriction sites are italicized, start and reverse complementary stop codons are underlined, and complementary regions are bold): F2, 5'-CGGAATTCCATGGCAAGCTTCACAGATGTTGC-3'; F3, 5'-CGGAATTCCATGGAAGTAACTGCGGTTAATTCG-3'; R1, 5'-GCGCGGATCCTTATTTTGTCACAGTCACATTGAC-3'; R3SLH, 5'-GACCGCTCGAGTTATACTTCAACTATTTCTGGCACTG-3'. E. coli HMS174(DE3) carrying an expression vector was used as a host for sbsB gene fragment expression. Protein production and purification were performed as described previously (30). For spectroscopic measurements protein solutions were prepared by dissolving 1 mg of lyophilized protein in 1 ml of 8 M GdmHCl and subsequent dialysis in a dialysis membrane (Biomol, cut-off: 1216 kDa) against aqua purificata at 4 °C. Dialysis was stopped after 1 h because the refractive index difference between the protein solution and water was smaller than 0.001, indicating a residual GdmHCl concentration below 10 mM. After removing self-assembly products by centrifugation (16,000 x g, 15 min, 4 °C), the supernatant was diluted immediately to the desired protein concentration to prevent further formation of self-assembly products. Protein concentrations were determined by the method of Gill and von Hippel (31) in the presence of 8 M GdmHCl. Deviations of the calculated concentrations from values of gravimetrically prepared solutions of lyophilized protein in GdmHCl were smaller than 5%. Production of Fluorescently Labeled SCWPSCWP was isolated as described previously (21). Preparation of fluorescein labeled SCWP (F-SCWP) was performed using the aldehyde group of SCWP, which was converted into a hydrazone by heating in a saturated solution of carbodihydrazide. After reduction of the hydrazone with sodium borohydride and subsequent dialysis against distilled water, fluorescein isothiocyanate in dimethyl sulfoxide was added slowly under protection of light. After incubation for 3 h at room temperature with continuous stirring, unreacted labeling reagent was removed by extensive dialysis. The degree of labeling was determined by comparing the concentration of total SCWP obtained from the binding isotherm with the concentration of attached fluorescein determined from the absorbance at 490 nm. Because there is only one aldehyde group per SCWP molecule the ratio of labeled SCWP to unlabeled SCWP was calculated to be 1:50.
Fluorescence Anisotropy Binding AssaysThis equilibrium assay is based on changes in the fluorescence anisotropy of a fluorescently labeled ligand upon binding by a macromolecule (3234). Binding assays were performed using a PerkinElmer Life Sciences LS50B spectrofluorometer thermostated at 25 °C employing a 10- x 10-mm quartz cell with a magnetic stirrer. The excitation wavelength and the emission wavelength were selected with double-grating monochromators using a 15-nm band path for high intensity. The excitation wavelength was set at 490 nm, the maximum of fluorescein absorption, and the emission was monitored at 525 nm. Scattered excitation light was suppressed in the emission channel with a 515-nm long pass filter. Solutions of F-SCWP were diluted to the desired concentration of 40 nM using a buffer containing HEPES (10 mM, pH 7.4), 150 mM NaCl, 3 mM EDTA, and 0.005% Tween 20 to reduce unspecific aggregation and adsorption. Aliquots of protein solutions with concentrations typically between 10 and 20 µM were added successively and stirred gently. The protein concentration in the cuvette was corrected for the slight dilution of protein because of added aliquots. Reported anisotropy values are the mean values of nine separate measurements with a standard deviation of 0.002 or less. Because quantum yield and fluorescence lifetime of F-SCWP remained unchanged within the error limits of measurements upon binding, the measured anisotropy values A could be considered as a sum of the anisotropies of free and bound F-SCWP, AC and ACP, weighted by their molar fractions (Equation 1)
Investigation of the Self-assembly Properties by Electron Microscopy For preparation of self-assembly products, 2 mg of lyophilized rSbsB1889 or rSbsB177889 was dissolved in 8 M GdmHCl in 50 mM Tris/HCl buffer (pH 7.2), and the solution was dialyzed against 10 mM CaCl2 in aqua purificata at 4 °C for 12 h and against aqua purificata for 24 h. For negative staining, 20 µl of the suspensions were incubated with glow-discharged, Formvar-coated copper grids for 15 min at room temperature. After that, fixation with 2.5% glutaraldehyde (Pierce) in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate buffer (pH 7.2) for 20 min was done. Then the grids were washed at least five times with aqua purificata and incubated with uranylacetate (2% in aqua purificata) for 10 min at room temperature. After drying on a filter paper, the grids were investigated in a Philips CM 100 transmission electron microscope at 80 kV using a 30-µm objective aperture. The lattice orientation was confirmed by Fourier processing (12). Proof of Complete Absence of Any Interaction between rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889To show that rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 do not associate to form the complete S-layer protein SbsB when they are denaturated and renaturated together, rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 were dissolved at a concentration of 10 µM each in 8 M GHCl, 50 mM Tris/HCl buffer (pH 7.2) and dialyzed at 4 °C against 10 mM CaCl2 for 12 h and against aqua purificata for 24 h. Then the dialysate was separated into pellet and supernatant by centrifugation (16,000 x g, 15 min, 4 °C), and each fraction was analyzed by SDS-PAGE with a 15% gel. Secondary Structure PredictionFar-UV CD spectra were measured in the range from 190 to 260 nm at 0.2-nm intervals in a cuvette with an optical path length of 2 mm at 25 °C using an Applied Photophysics Pistar-180 spectropolarimeter. Protein solutions were prepared immediately after centrifugation as described above by dilution to 0.040.08 mg ml1 to prevent any formation of scattering self-assembly products. Buffer base lines were measured under identical conditions and subtracted from the spectra. Predictions of protein secondary structures based on far-UV CD data were performed using the neural net program CDNN (35) and the algorithms SELCON, CDSSTR, and CONTIN, which were accessed through the DichroWeb website (36). Predictions of protein secondary structures based upon primary sequence data were obtained from the Network Protein Sequence analysis tool (37) using the algorithm GORIV. GdmHCl Unfolding ExperimentsProtein samples prepared as described above were diluted at least 10-fold for spectroscopic measurements adding buffer solutions containing 20 mM sodium phosphate (pH 7.4) and the indicated concentration of GdmHCl. Reversibility of unfolding was tested using an equilibrated protein sample with a high concentration of GdmHCl, which was diluted to 1/10 of the original denaturant concentration. The spectroscopic properties of the diluted sample were compared with a protein sample prepared from the native state at the same diluted GdmHCl concentration. Denaturation curves were obtained by two different methods: First, samples with fixed mixtures of protein in buffer and GdmHCl were measured. Sample solutions were prepared at least 4 h before measurements. There were neither time-dependent changes in fluorescence intensity after 1 min of sample preparation nor detectable differences in measurements taken at 4 and 24 h. Second, titrations were performed either on a sample of native protein in buffer that was mixed stepwise with a sample of the same protein concentration but containing 8 M GdmHCl or vice versa. After each addition of denaturated protein the same volume of the mixed solution was removed and used for determination of GdmHCl concentration by refractive index measurements. The concentration steps were spaced at 0.15 M GdmHCl intervals in the range from 0.2 to 7 M. Fluorescence emission was measured using a PerkinElmer Life Sciences LS50B spectrofluorometer equipped with a magnetic stirrer in a 10- x 10-mm quartz cell after a 1-min setting that allowed the protein solution to come to chemical equilibration after each change in denaturant concentration. The protein concentration was 1 µM, with an absorbance lower than 0.05 at the excitation wavelengths. The samples were excited at 275 nm and 295 nm, and emission was measured from 285 (or 305) to 450 nm at 0.5-nm intervals. The band widths of the excitation and emission monochromator were both set at 5 nm. Each spectrum was corrected by subtraction of the corresponding blank sample obtained by a second titration without protein. Far-UV CD spectra were taken alternating with fluorescence emission measurements on the same sample solutions in the 10-mm quartz cell using both methods of sample preparation as described above. Because of the strong absorption of GdmHCl, far-UV spectra were recorded only for wavelengths longer than 217 nm by averaging three wavelength scans, each obtained by signal averaging for 2.5 s at intervals of 0.2 nm. For an accurate determination of the molar ellipticity at 222 nm, an additional measurement at 222 nm with 30-s integration time was performed. Appropriate blank spectra were recorded on the buffer components and subtracted from spectra obtained on protein solutions.
Models of UnfoldingSpectroscopic data obtained in unfolding experiments were analyzed by a simple two-state model (N
Gun, the Gibbs free energy change of unfolding in the absence of denaturant, and m, the rate of change in free energy with respect to denaturant concentration. FN and FU are the fluorescence intensities of the native and unfolded states in the absence of denaturant, sN and sU are the base-line slopes for the native and unfolded regions, respectively, and D is the concentration of denaturant. Fitting procedures were performed by the Marquardt nonlinear least squares algorithm using the program Origin (Microcal).
The second scheme for unfolding includes an intermediate species (N
G1, G2, m1, and m2 for the free energies and m values for the N I and I U transitions, respectively. The denaturant concentration at the transition midpoint ci is defined by the respective ratio of Gi to mi. An analogous scheme including two intermediate species was used as a four-state model.
Thermal Stability Studies by Far-UV CD SpectroscopyThermally induced protein denaturation was monitored by far-UV CD spectroscopy. Protein concentrations used were 0.5 µM in 5 mM potassium phosphate buffer (pH 7.4). A quartz cuvette with 2-mm path length was placed into a Peltier controlled sample holder unit. Full spectra were recorded from 190 to 260 nm at 1-nm intervals and for 2 °C increments with a heating rate of 1 °C/min. Additionally, temperature profiles at the fixed wavelengths 206 and 222 nm were recorded for 1 °C increments in a cuvette with 10-mm path length. In any case a temperature probe connected to the cuvette was used to provide an accurate temperature record. The unfolding curves were analyzed using a sigmoidal curve function according to Meyer et al. (39) (Equation 5),
T is the ellipticity at temperature T, mT the slope of the curve within the transition region, and the inflection point of the curve the melting temperature Tm. At each temperature N and D can be extrapolated from the pre- and post-transition baselines, (mN*T bN) and (mD*T bD), respectively.
Design and Production of Proteins Both the genes encoding the three SLH motifs (rSbsB1178) and the SLH-truncated part (rSbsB177889) were expressed as isolated recombinant proteins and compared with the mature full-length protein SbsB (residues 1889), termed rSbsB. The design of these truncated forms was based on a domain boundary as determined by sequence analysis. Because SLH motifs have a conserved sequence of about 55 residues (13), the boundary between the SLH part (amino acid residues 1178) and the large SLH-truncated part (residues 177889) was considered as being defined by the end of the three consecutive SLH motifs (residue range 361, 62119, 120178) at the N terminus (Fig. 1).
Maintenance of Function Comparison of Binding to SCWP by Fluorescence AnisotropyThe SCWP binding activity was investigated in solution by a fluorescence-based binding assay to characterize quantitatively the interaction between the protein and its target carbohydrate polymer. F-SCWP was employed as ligand and its binding affinity to rSbsB, the two truncated forms and an equimolar mixture of them was studied. Fig. 2 shows a compilation of anisotropy-based binding isotherms of F-SCWP with rSbsB1178, rSbsB177889, an equimolar mixture of the former ones, and full-length rSbsB at 25 °C. For both rSbsB and rSbsB1178, an increase in anisotropy could be observed resulting from complex formation, which was in contrast to the SLH-truncated rSbsB177889, which did not bind at all. The anisotropy profiles for rSbsB and rSbsB1178 upon binding to F-SCWP were characterized by an initial plateau for the unbound F-SCWP followed by an anisotropy increase over a range of approximately 2 orders of magnitude in concentration, which is typical of binding in a 1:1 stoichiometry. A plateau for saturated binding concluded this increase. Because of the lower molecular mass compared with rSbsB, the final anisotropy value was lower for rSbsB1178. However, the slopes for the increase in anisotropy were identical (Fig. 2), thus reflecting equal affinity to F-SCWP. The calculated Kd values, 2.2 nM for rSbsB and 3.1 nM for rSbsB1178, can be considered identical within the S.D. ± 0.5 obtained from the fit. The binding isotherm of the equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 was completely superimposable on the rSbsB1178 isotherm (Fig. 2). In addition, adding aliquots of rSbsB177889 to a FSCWP solution saturated with rSbsB1178 did not lead to any further increase in anisotropy (not shown).
Comparison of Self-assembly Product Formation by Electron MicroscopyThe ability of rSbsB and rSbsB177889 to form self-assembly products was investigated by transmission electron microscopic analysis of negatively stained preparations of suspensions obtained after dialysis of the GdmHCl denatured rSbsB forms. As shown in Fig. 3, rSbsB and the N-terminal truncation rSbsB177889 were capable of assembling into flat sheets, which clearly exhibited the oblique p1 lattice structure. Fourier processing confirmed that the lattice constants (a = 10.4 nm, b = 7.9 nm, base angle = 81°) were the same for self-assembly products formed by either rSbsB or rSbsB177889. In contrast to self-assembly products obtained with rSbsB which were mostly monolayers, those formed by rSbsB177889 were double layers, indicating that the individual monolayers had bound to each other with inner surface where the N-terminal region had been deleted. The missing SLH domain and the formation of double layers would explain the different staining behavior as observed for the self-assembly products formed by rSbsB and rSbsB177889 (Fig. 3). In contrast, the C-terminally truncated form rSbsB1178 was water-soluble and not capable of self-assembling (not shown).
Proof of Complete Absence of Any Interaction between rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889The two S-layer protein forms rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 were dissolved in 8 M GdmHCl in 50 mM Tris/HCl buffer (pH 7.2). After renaturing by dialysis, the suspension was centrifuged, and the pellet and the supernatant were subjected to SDS-PAGE analysis. As shown in Fig. 4, almost the whole amount of rSbsB177889 was detected in the pellet, whereas rSbsB1178 was found in the fraction of the supernatant. These findings excluded that both truncated rSbsB forms had associated.
Maintenance of Structure Comparison of Secondary Structure by Far-UV CDThe far-UV CD spectra of rSbsB and of the truncated forms rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 were measured in their native state between 190 and 260 nm for each of the proteins and for an equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 (Fig. 5). The shape of the far-UV CD spectrum of rSbsB1178 pointed already at a high content in -helical structure according to the occurrence of two minima at 207 and 225 nm, which are typical of -helices. Deconvolution of the spectra by the algorithms CDNN, SELCON, CDSSTR, and CONTIN yielded -helical fractions of 3234% and values for -sheet structure of 1517%. The spectrum of rSbsB177889 displayed only one minimum at 215 nm, which is characteristic of -sheets. The obtained -sheet fraction of 3841% could be assigned mainly to antiparallel -sheets using the neuronal network program CDNN. The values for -helical structure of 46% were almost negligible. The spectrum of the full-length protein SbsB showed a broad minimum extending from 210 to 220 nm and therefore indicated a summation of the spectra of the two truncated forms. Indeed, both the algebraically summed spectra and the measured spectrum of an equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 could be superimposed on the spectrum of the full-length SbsB. The CD deconvolution algorithms gave -helical contents of 711% and -sheet contents of 3438%. All obtained values for secondary structure were in good agreement with results of the GORIV algorithm based upon primary sequence data.
Comparison of Tertiary Structure by Intrinsic Fluorescence Fluorescence spectroscopy was used as a method for reporting differences in tertiary structure by intrinsic fluorescence because intensity and wavelength of the emission maximum of tryptophan residues are strongly related to their microenvironment in the protein (40). SbsB possesses three tryptophan residues whose distribution is shown in Fig. 1: 1 tryptophan (Trp127) is located in the third SLH motif of rSbsB1178 and the 2 others (Trp260 and Trp802) in rSbsB177889. In Fig. 6A fluorescence emission spectra of rSbsB, rSbsB1178, and rSbsB177889 in their native state recorded after excitation at 295 nm were compared with an equimolar mixture of the two truncated proteins. The spectrum of the mixture was superimposable on the algebraically summed spectra of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889. The difference in intensity between the mixture and the full-length SbsB was attributed to quenching effects, which occur when the two functional domains are linked together. All spectra showed an emission maximum at 342 nm which is typical for partially solvent exposed tryptophan residues (40). Although rSbsB1178 contains only 1 tryptophan residue, the fluorescence intensity in the native state was 4.4 times higher than that of rSbsB177889 harboring 2 tryptophan residues. However, in the denatured state the ratio of fluorescence intensity was equal to the number of tryptophans. To excite both tyrosine and tryptophan residues the excitation wavelength was set to the absorption maximum of the former at 275 nm (Fig. 6B). Although tyrosine emission at 303 nm was predominant over tryptophan fluorescence in case of rSbsB177889, it was completely absent in the spectrum of rSbsB1178, even though half of the 21 tyrosine residues are concentrated in this part (Fig. 1). This is a clear indication of a high resonance energy transfer rate from tyrosine to tryptophan in rSbsB1178. The shape of the spectrum of rSbsB corresponded to the superposition of the spectra of the two truncated forms, demonstrated by the small shoulder of tyrosine emission at 303 nm. The difference in intensity is again because of quenching effects.
A compilation of all tryptophan spectra of the native and the GdmHCl denaturated states for all the proteins after 295 nm excitation is given in Fig. 7. Solvent denaturation using GdmHCl was fully reversible for all proteins. All spectra measured in the presence of 7 M GdmHCl were red-shifted to 355 nm, the wavelength typical of fully solvent exposed tryptophan residues (40). The concomitant changes in fluorescence intensity were opposite for the tryptophans of the two truncated proteins. Trp127 of rSbsB1178 showed a 3.5-fold decrease (Fig. 7B), whereas Trp260 and Trp802 of rSbsB177889 exhibited a 2.4-fold overall increase in intensity (Fig. 7D). Full-length SbsB showed a 1.5-fold overall decrease in intensity (Fig. 7A) as a consequence of the paramount quantum yield of Trp127. The same overall decrease was seen for an equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 (Fig. 7C).
Additional information on the compactness of the proteins was obtained by investigating alterations in the distance related fluorescence resonance energy transfer from tyrosine to tryptophan residues (40) upon unfolding. All spectra upon denaturation with GdmHCl after excitation at 275 nm are displayed in Fig. 8. In Fig. 8B the difference in energy transfer from tyrosine to tryptophan residues is clearly visible by appearance of a second fluorescence emission maximum at 303 nm. In contrast, the observed decrease in the predominant tyrosine emission of rSbsB177889 upon unfolding is solely a consequence of a red-shift of the underlying tryptophan emission instead of a significant change in fluorescence resonance energy transfer efficiency (Fig. 8D). The emission spectra of the equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 in Fig. 8C demonstrated again additivity as shape and intensity of all spectra were identical to those of full-length SbsB (Fig. 8A).
Comparison of Stability Thermodynamic Stability of SbsBTo characterize the stability of SbsB and of the two truncated forms, equilibrium unfolding data derived from fluorescence emission of tryptophan residues acting as local probes of tertiary structure were combined with data on global unfolding of secondary structure provided by far-UV CD spectroscopy. Equilibrium Unfolding by Intrinsic FluorescenceFigs. 7 and 8 show all spectra obtained per incremental addition of 0.15 GdmHCl between 0.2 and 7 M GdmHCl as described under "Experimental Procedures." The tryptophan emission spectra of the full-length SbsB (Fig. 7A) reflected three phases of unfolding. In a first phase (02 M GdmHCl) the emission maximum shifted from 342 to 348 nm with a decrease in intensity, whereas in a second phase the intensity increased in two steps yielding plateaus in intensity at 34.5 and 5.57 M GdmHCl accompanied by a red-shift to 352 and 355 nm. The emission spectra obtained exciting both tryptophan and tyrosine residues at 275 nm showed the same three-step unfolding (Fig. 8A). However, the first change (02 M GdmHCl) was a larger decrease in intensity with a concomitant transformation of the shoulder at 303 nm into a maximum of intensity in tyrosine emission, which has to be explained as decrease in energy transfer because of loss in tertiary structure. The following increase in intensity left the tyrosine signal nearly unchanged but red-shifted the tryptophan emission in two steps again separated by plateaus at 34.5 and 5.57 M GdmHCl from 342 to 348 and finally to 353 nm. In contrast, the emission intensity of the single tryptophan in rSbsB1178 decreased in one step accompanied by a simultaneous red-shift from 342 to 355 nm (Fig. 7B), and the occurrence of the distinct tyrosine emission at 303 nm when the excitation wavelength was set to 275 nm (Fig. 8B).
The tryptophan emission spectra (Fig. 7D) of rSbsB177889 showed only the stepwise increase phase of the full-length SbsB. The first intensity increase was simultaneous with a red-shift of the emission maximum from 342 to 350 nm leading to a plateau at 2.53 M GdmHCl. Thereafter the intensity raised again accompanied by a further red-shift to 355, ending in a plateau at 45 M GdmHCl. In contrast, the following increase in intensity was devoid of a red-shift in tryptophan fluorescence. The emission spectra recorded after excitation at 275 nm were dominated by tyrosine fluorescence (Fig. 8D) before the first phase of unfolding. The small shoulder of the tryptophan emission at Fluorescence emission spectra (Fig. 7C and 8C) upon GdmHCl denaturation for an equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 gave essentially the same spectra compared with the full-length SbsB. The plateaus of the increase phase were, however, at the lower GdmHCl concentrations characteristic of rSbsB177889. Equilibrium Unfolding by Far-UV Circular Dichroism Spectra displayed in Fig. 9 were recorded for all three SbsB forms and an equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 in the wavelength range 217260 nm on the same sample solutions alternating with the fluorescence measurements described above. In contrast to rSbsB1178 whose changes in ellipticity upon denaturation were uniform over the whole wavelength range (Fig. 9B), rSbsB177889 showed an increase in negative ellipticity above 230 nm in addition to the decrease in negative ellipticity at wavelengths lower than 225 nm (Fig. 9D). The resulting isoelliptic region near 230 nm was also observed for the denaturation of rSbsB (Fig. 9A), although changes in ellipticity were more uniform over the whole wavelength range. The same situation was observed for the equimolar mixture (Fig. 9C) of the two truncated proteins.
Comparison of Denaturation Profiles obtained by Fluorescence and Far-UV CD SpectroscopyA selection of denaturation profiles obtained by fluorescence spectroscopy to those obtained by far-UV CD spectroscopy is compared in Fig. 10. The unfolding profiles of the full-length SbsB revealed several distinct transitions almost over the whole concentration range of denaturant agent. The profile monitored by means of fluorescence emission at 355 nm with excitation at 295 nm (Fig. 10A) started with a slight linear decrease in intensity (0.251.25 M) followed by a sharp sigmoidal decrease ending in a minimum (2 M). The following rise in intensity reached a plateau (34.5 M), which was followed by a final increase (4.5 and 5.5 M). Thus, the profiles of rSbsB reflected at least three apparent transition steps with midpoints at 1.6, 2.6, and 5.0 M GdmHCl determined by global fitting using the four-state unfolding model. These transitions could also be seen at other emission wavelengths except for 320 nm, which reflected only the first transition (not shown). However, different intensity ratios at all emission wavelengths indicated the involvement of several species during unfolding. The profiles after 275 nm excitation reflected the same three-step pattern but were more pronounced in the first sigmoidal decrease (Fig. 10A). Far-UV CD unfolding profiles for the full-length SbsB at wavelengths below 230 nm (displayed for 222 nm in Fig. 10A) showed a sharp decrease in negative ellipticity between 1 and 2 M GdmHCl. The further decrease at higher concentrations was smaller and ended at 3 M in a plateau. This was in contrast to the ellipticity change between 232 and 245 nm, which showed an additional two-step increase in negative ellipticity at GdmHCl concentrations higher than 3 M GdmHCl (shown for 236 nm). Thus, two transitions midpoints at 1.6 and 2.6 M GdmHCl, respectively, could be assigned by global fitting using the three-state model.
In contrast, rSbsB1178 showed only one single sigmoidal decrease in intensity with a transition midpoint at 1.6 M GdmHCl for all fluorescence excitation/emission wavelength pairs and for all far-UV CD profiles at different wavelengths (Fig. 10B shows profiles at wavelengths corresponding to Fig. 10A). Evaluation of the unfolding profiles by global fitting to the two-state model yielded a G of 26.5 ± 1.2 kJ mol1 and an m value of 16.5 ± 0.7 kJ mol1 M1. Again, a complex unfolding behavior was observed for rSbsB177889 extending over the whole region between 0.5 and 7 M GdmHCl. In Fig. 10D the global unfolding of rSbsB177889 is contrasted by the fluorescence emission profiles regarding mainly the two tryptophan-carrying domains. The fluorescence emission profiles for rSbsB177889 are characterized by a three-step evolution. Because of the appearance of isoemissive points in the fluorescence emission spectra (Fig. 8D), the first two unfolding steps could be considered separately as a function of the emission wavelength chosen. After excitation at 275 nm the emission profile at 320 nm reports the first and last unfolding step, whereas the 335 nm emission profile is devoid of the first step (not shown). At 355 nm all three steps could be detected, which was also the case for emission profiles obtained at 355 nm after excitation at 295 nm (Fig. 10D). However, because the last step was devoid of a red-shift in tryptophan fluorescence and failed to reach a plateau, only the first two transitions were evaluated using the three-state model yielding transition midpoints at 1.6 and 3.5 M GdmHCl. Distinct steps in the far-UV CD unfolding profiles could be also observed as a function of the wavelength chosen. The ellipticity at 222 nm showed a two-step decrease with an intermediate plateau between 3 and 4 M GdmHCl. On the contrary, a decrease between 2 and 4 M GdmHCl in negative ellipticity, which was concluded by a slight increase at higher GdmHCl concentrations, was observed at 236 nm (Fig. 10D). Nevertheless, all profiles could be evaluated by global fitting using the three-state model resulting in two transition midpoints at 2.7 and 4.2 M GdmHCl, which were different from the midpoints obtained from the fluorescence profiles. Emission spectra of an equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 gave the same transition steps as for the full-length SbsB except that the second and third transitions were down-shifted to the lower concentrations of denaturant at 2.6 and 3.4 M GdmHCl corresponding to the rSbsB177889 profiles (Fig. 10C). Accordingly, the second and third transitions of the far-UV CD profile at 236 nm collapsed into one broad transition with a midpoint at 3.0 M GdmHCl.
According to these findings, analysis of the unfolding profiles yielded only apparent transition midpoints for comparison of stability but no meaningful Comparison of Thermal Denaturation by Far-UV CD Far-UV CD spectra obtained for rSbsB, rSbsB1178, and rSbsB177889 in a temperature range between 20 and 95 °C are shown in Fig. 11.
In case of rSbsB1178 (Fig. 11B) the major amount of secondary structure remained intact, as evidenced by significant negative ellipticity at 222 nm and the unchanged positive ellipticity at 190 nm. The two minima at 207 and 225 nm collapsed into one minimum at 215 nm. Although the thermal denaturation of rSbsB1178 was irreversible, the melting profile was highly reproducible and independent on the heating rate. Thus, the melting temperature Tm can be used as a semiquantitative indicator for thermostability. In contrast, rSbsB177889 showed a large spectral change ending in a minimum at 200 nm typical of random coil conformation (Fig. 11D). Precipitation of unfolded protein could be prevented, and reversibility was up to 80% as long as the concentration did not exceed 0.5 µM. The thermal denaturation of the full-length SbsB (Fig. 11A) reflected both the smaller decrease in negative ellipticity at lower temperatures in the wavelength range from 205 to 240 nm and the large increase at higher temperatures. Because of remaining structure in the N-terminal part corresponding to rSbsB1178, denaturation was only partially reversible, and the final minimum in negative ellipticity was shifted to 205 nm. However, melting profiles were again reproducible and independent of the heating rate. As a consequence of the irreversible thermal denaturation of rSbsB1178, corresponding measurements of a mixture of the two truncated proteins were not meaningful and are replaced in Fig. 11C by temperature profiles of the former proteins recorded at 206 and 222 nm. The profiles of rSbsB1178 yielded a midpoint thermal transition (Tm) of 64 ± 2 °C and were rather broad, indicating low cooperativity because of irreversible denaturation. In contrast, both melting profiles of rSbsB177889 showed a sharp increase in negative ellipticity resulting in a Tm of 71 ± 1 °C followed by a more flat increase, which resulted probably from a superposition with irreversible denaturation at higher temperatures. The melting profile recorded at 222 nm for the full-length SbsB showed a slight decrease in negative ellipticity at a temperature corresponding to the Tm of rSbsB1178 followed by a stepwise increase after 75 °C, which can be explained by the superposition of the melting profiles of the two truncated proteins and their comparable change in negative ellipticity at this wavelength. However, the profile recorded at 206 nm reflected mainly the transition of rSbsB177889 and yielded a Tm of 76 ± 2 °C for the full-length SbsB, which is significantly higher than for rSbsB177889.
To open the way for structure determination at atomic resolution, the dissection approach to the S-layer protein SbsB of G. stearothermophilus PV72/p2 was applied. The hypothesis that SbsB is a composite protein consisting of two independent functional domains could be confirmed because the C-terminal end of the three consecutive SLH motifs defined exactly the domain boundary between the N-terminal SCWP binding SLH domain and the C-terminal self-assembly domain. Accordingly, both domains could be produced as stable recombinant proteins, which were termed rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889. The specific function of both domains was maintained when they were produced as stand-alone proteins. In particular, maintenance of the SCWP binding capacity was confirmed by a solution based fluorescence anisotropy assay enabled by fluorescence end labeling of SCWP. Because binding isotherms could be obtained at submicromolar concentrations of proteins, interference with the self-assembling ability of SbsB, which occurs only at micromolar concentrations, was completely prevented. The experiments performed with SbsB demonstrated that the specific SCWP binding activity of SbsB relied only upon the three N-terminal SLH motifs without any involvement of the C terminus because rSbsB1178 bound the SCWP with affinity equal to that of the full-length rSbsB, whereas SLH-truncated rSbsB178889 showed no binding. Furthermore, because the equimolar mixture of the two truncated proteins showed the same binding isotherm as the SLH domain alone, an association of the two isolated proteins can be excluded. Previous studies have shown that SLH motifs are responsible for cell wall anchoring (13), and SLH-truncated proteins did not interact with purified cell walls as demonstrated with the S-layer proteins Sap and EA1 of Bacillus anthracis (41). Furthermore, Mesnage et al. (41) showed that the isolated three-motif SLH domain could not bind cell walls in vitro when the SCWP was removed by extraction with hydrofluoric acid. Accordingly, Ries et al. (21) have demonstrated that the SCWP is responsible for anchoring the S-layer protein SbsB to the cell wall. This was the reason why the isolated SCWP was used for binding assays in the present study. Because this true equilibrium binding assay employed both interaction partners in an isolated form, the obtained Kd values in the low nanomolar range demonstrate an interaction of high specificity between SLH domain and the SCWP. Maintenance of the self-assembly ability was demonstrated by electron microscopy of negatively stained preparations. Only rSbsB177889 but not rSbsB1178 retained the ability to self-assemble into the lattice characteristic of SbsB. Therefore, the SLH-truncated part was termed the "self-assembly" domain of SbsB. An equimolar mixture of rSbsB1178 and rSbsB177889 was easily separated when rSbsB177889 but not rSbsB1178 was removed by centrifugation of formed self-assembly products, which provided further evidence for the complete absence of any interaction between the two truncated proteins. The proven independence of the two functional domains permitted us to compare the structure of the isolated domains with their structure in context of the full-length protein by spectroscopic techniques, which report changes of the secondary and tertiary structure. In particular, far-UV CD spectroscopy was applied to monitor global changes in secondary structure, whereas fluorescence spectroscopy was used for monitoring local changes in tertiary structure. Each of the methods revealed an additivity of the spectroscopic properties of the two parts.
In particular, deconvolution by different algorithms of the far-UV CD spectrum of the three SLH motifs yielded a considerably high
The SLH-truncated part of SbsB, rSbsB177889, allowed us for the first time to address the self-assembly properties of an S-layer protein without any disturbance by parts of other functionalities. Although many S-layer proteins have been isolated, sequenced, and investigated with respect to their self-assembly properties, biophysical data concerning structural properties of S-layer proteins remain scarce. Up to now, only a few far-UV CD spectra on isolated S-layer protein samples have been reported (4244), and all of them pointed mainly to a
In summary, the present study demonstrates that the S-layer protein SbsB is composed of two distinct functional domains, namely a SCWP binding SLH domain at the N terminus and a large C-terminal self-assembly domain. Their diversity in function is continued at the structural level because a highly Thus the dissection approach might be accessible for the whole class of S-layer proteins leading to truncated forms, which are accessible for direct structure determination at atomic resolution.
* This work was supported by the Austrian Science Foundation, Project 14689, and the Competence Center "Biomolecular Therapeutics." The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
1 The abbreviations used are: S-layer(s), surface layer(s); F-SCWP, fluorescein-labeled SCWP;
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||