|
Advertisement | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 280, Issue 18, 17678-17686, May 6, 2005
Specific Kinetic Alterations of Human CaV2.1 Calcium Channels Produced by Mutation S218L Causing Familial Hemiplegic Migraine and Delayed Cerebral Edema and Coma after Minor Head Trauma*![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() **
From the
Received for publication, January 31, 2005 , and in revised form, February 25, 2005.
Mutation S218L in the CaV2.1 1 subunit of P/Q-type Ca2+ channels produces a severe clinical phenotype in which typical attacks of familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM) triggered by minor head trauma are followed, after a lucid interval, by deep (even fatal) coma and long lasting severe cerebral edema. We investigated the functional consequences of this mutation on human CaV2.1 channels expressed in human embryonic kidney 293 cells and in neurons from CaV2.1 1/ mice by combining single channel and whole cell patch clamp recordings. Mutation S218L produced a shift to lower voltages of the single channel activation curve and a consequent increase of both single channel and whole cell Ba2+ influx in both neurons and human embryonic kidney 293 cells. Compared with the other FHM-1 mutants, the S218L shows one of the largest gains of function, especially for small depolarizations, which are insufficient to open the wild-type channel. S218L channels open at voltages close to the resting potential of many neurons. Moreover, the S218L mutation has unique effects on the kinetics of inactivation of the channel because it introduces a large component of current that inactivates very slowly, and it increases the rate of recovery from inactivation. During long depolarizations at voltages that are attained during cortical spreading depression, the extent of inactivation of the S218L channel is considerably smaller than that of the wild-type channel. We discuss how the unique combination of a particularly slow inactivation during cortical spreading depression and a particularly low threshold of channel activation might lead to delayed severe cerebral edema and coma after minor head trauma.
Familial hemiplegic migraine (FHM)1 is a rare autosomal dominant subtype of migraine with aura. Apart from the characteristic transient hemiparesis, typical attacks of FHM are similar to those of the common migraine with aura (1). Some FHM patients also show atypical attacks, either with a prolonged aura or with signs of diffuse encephalopathy; moreover, 20% of FHM families show permanent cerebellar symptoms (2). In about half of the families, FHM is caused by missense mutations in the CACNA1A gene, encoding the pore-forming 1 subunit of voltage-gated neuronal CaV2.1 (P/Q-type) Ca2+ channels (FHM-1) (3). CaV2.1 channels are located at presynaptic terminals and somatodendritic membranes (4) and are expressed in all brain structures that have been implicated in the pathogenesis of migraine (5). They play a prominent role in controlling neurotransmitter release (6) and also exert postsynaptic effects, such as on neuronal excitability (7).
17 different missense mutations have been associated with FHM-1 (810). The functional consequences of 10 mutations have been investigated by expressing CaV2.1 channel subunits in heterologous systems (1115). Because CaV2.1 channel expression is almost exclusively restricted to neuronal cells, 4 of these mutations have also been analyzed in neurons from CaV2.1
Mutation S218L in the IS4-IS5 loop of the CaV2.1
Generation of Cav2.1 S218L MutantThe S218L mutation was introduced into the human full-length cDNA (GenBank accession number AF004883 [GenBank] ) encoding the CaV2.1 1 subunit, cloned in expression plasmid pGFP-, described in Refs. 13 and 20. This human CaV2.1 1 subunit lacks Val726-Ala728 and differs in this respect from the cDNA used in Ref. 14. Briefly, mutant PCR products harboring mutation S218L were generated by the "gene SOEing" technique (21). In the first round of PCR, products were generated using either primers 160 (5'-GAACCATACTTCATTGGAAT-3') and R-S218L (5'-TGATCAACTTCAGGACGACTTGTAA-3') (250 bp) or F-S218L (5'-TTACAAGTCGTCCTGAAGTTGATCATGAAGGCGAT-3') and 62 (5'-TGAATTCTGCATAGTAAAGG-3') (939 bp) using proofreading DNA polymerase (Pfu Turbo, Stratagene) and CaV2.1 1 subunit cDNA as a template. The C T nucleotide transversion (at position 889; G A in the reverse (R-S218L) primer) resulting in a S218L amino acid change is indicated in bold in the primer sequences. Subsequently, a PCR was performed using first round PCR products in combination with primers 160 and 62. Next, this 1,164-bp product containing the S218L (SL) mutation was digested with NotI (nucleotide 838)-StuI (nucleotide 1699) and cloned into NotI-StuI-digested vector pGFP-, resulting in mutant SL. Sequences of the introduced PCR fragment were verified by means of a fluorescent ABI BigDye Terminator Cycle sequencing kit (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). Nucleotide positions corresponding to AF004883
[GenBank]
are given. For transfections, plasmid DNA of CaV2.1 1 subunit wild-type (WT) or S218L mutant cDNA was isolated using a QIAfilter Plasmid Maxi kit (Qiagen, Los Angeles, CA).
Cell Culture and TransfectionHEK293 cells were grown and cotransfected with human CaV2.1 Patch Clamp Recordings and Data AnalysisWhole cell and single channel patch clamp recordings were performed as in Ref. 13. Currents were sampled at 5 kHz and low pass filtered at 1 kHz. Solutions for whole cell recordings of Ba2+ currents in both HEK293 cells and neurons were as follows. The external solution (in mM) was 5 BaCl2, 148 tetraethylammonium (TEA)-Cl, 10 HEPES (pH 7.4 with TEA-OH) (and 5 µM nimodipine and 0.1 mg/ml cytochrome c, when recording from neurons). The internal solution (in mM) was 100 cesium methanesulfonate, 5 MgCl2, 30 HEPES, 10 EGTA, 4 ATP, 0.5 GTP, and 1 cAMP (pH 7.4 with CsOH). Solutions for whole cell recordings of Ca2+ currents in HEK293 cells were as follows. The external solution (in mM) was 2 CaCl2, 140 TEA-methanesulfonate, 10 HEPES (pH 7.4 with TEA-OH). The internal solution (in mM) was 119 cesium methanesulfonate, 5 MgCl2, 30 HEPES, 0.5 EGTA, 4 ATP, 0.5 GTP and 1 cAMP (pH 7.4 with CsOH). Cells were placed into a recording chamber containing Tyrode's solution and, after attainment of the whole cell configuration, were perfused with the external recording solution.
Compensation (typically 7080%) for series resistance was used. Current-voltage (I-V) curves were obtained only from cells with a voltage error < 5 mV and, in the case of neurons, without signs of inadequate space clamping. The average normalized I-V curves were then multiplied by the average maximal current density obtained from all cells. I-V curves in HEK293 cells were obtained with voltage ramps (0.85 mV/ms) from a holding potential of80 mV. I-V ramps for leak subtraction were obtained after blockade of Ca2+ channels with 5 mM Ni2+. I-V curves were fitted with Equation 1.
Single channel recordings on HEK293 cells were obtained in cell-attached configuration. The pipette solution (in mM) was 90 BaCl2, 10 TEA-Cl, 15 CsCl, 10 HEPES (pH 7.4 with TEA-OH). The bath solution (in mM) was 140 potassium gluconate, 5 EGTA, 35 D-glucose, 10 HEPES (pH 7.4 with KOH). Single channel currents and open probabilities were obtained as in Ref. 14.
The density of functional channels in the membrane for mutant S218L (SL) relative to that of WT channels in HEK293 cells was obtained from Equation 2,
In both whole cell and single channel recordings the liquid junction potentials were such that a value of 12 mV should be subtracted from all voltages to obtain the correct values of membrane potential (23). Averages are given ± S.E.
In transfected cells expressing human CaV2.1 channels, a consistent effect of the seven FHM-1 mutations analyzed at the single channel level (T666M, R192Q, V714A, V1457L, I1811L (13, 14), D715E, and I1710T)2 was to increase the single channel Ca2+ influx, as measured by the product of single channel current, i, and open probability, po, in a broad voltage range (13). Therefore, to investigate whether the functional consequences of mutation S218L were or were not similar to those of typical FHM-1 mutations, first of all, we performed cell-attached single channel recordings on HEK293 cells transfected with human CaV2.1 1 subunits containing mutation S218L and human 2b and 2e subunits and measured i and po of the mutant channels as a function of voltage.
Fig. 1 compares representative traces of single channel activity at 20 and 30 mV (with 90 mM Ba2+ as charge carrier) and the i-V, po-V, and ipo-V relationships obtained for the wild-type and the S218L mutant channels. Mutation S218L did not significantly affect the single channel current and conductance, which was 19.6 ± 0.2 picosiemens (n = 19) for WT and 19.2 ± 0.3 picosiemens (n = 14) for the mutant (Fig. 1B). However, the mutation favored the sojourn of the channel in subconductance states, which were rarely observed for the WT channel (see inset in Fig. 1B). Moreover, the S218L mutation produced a shift of the single channel activation curve toward lower voltages and a consequent increase of the channel open probability in a broad voltage range (Fig. 1C). The voltage of half-maximal activation V1/2 (obtained by fitting the po-V relationship with a Boltzmann function) changed from the WT value of 34.1 ± 1 mV (n = 12) to 23.8 ± 1.8 mV (n = 10) for the mutant. Compared with the human FHM-1 mutants whose po-V relationship was measured previously (13, 14), the S218L is one of the mutants that activates at lower voltages (similar to those of the V714A mutant). Because some of the FHM-1 mutations, including V714A, decreased the unitary current and conductance, we considered the product ipo (the amount of Ba2+ ions entering through a single channel in a given time, i.e. the single channel Ba2+ influx) as a measure of the gain of function produced by the FHM-1 mutations at the single channel level (13). Fig. 1D shows that the single channel Ba2+ influx of the S218L mutant is much larger than that of the WT channel in a broad voltage range and similar to that of WT at higher voltages. It also shows that the gain of function in terms of the single channel Ba2+ influx of the S218L mutant tends to be larger than the average gain of function of the human FHM-1 mutants analyzed previously. The difference with respect to the average appears significant at low voltages, where the WT human CaV2.1 channel remains closed.
The whole cell current-voltage (I-V) relationship (with 5 mM Ba2+ as charge carrier) revealed a hyperpolarized shift of the voltage range of activation of the mutant channel similar to that measured with single channel recordings (Fig. 2A). Fitting of the normalized I-V curves obtained with voltage ramps gave V1/2 values of +5.0 and 5.7 mV for the WT and the S218L mutant, respectively. Thus, confirming previous findings (13), the effect of the mutation on channel activation appears independent of permeant ion concentration (but note the shift toward lower voltages for both WT and mutant channels because of the larger surface potential at 5 with respect to 90 mM Ba2+). The channel selectivity was not affected by the mutation because the reversal potential of the whole cell current was identical for the WT and mutant channel.
The activation at lower voltages and increased open probability of the mutant channel led to an increased whole cell current density at V < 0 mV in HEK293 cells expressing the mutant with respect to those expressing the WT channel (Fig. 2B). However, at higher voltages the whole cell current density in cells expressing the mutant was smaller, and the maximal current density was 40% smaller for the mutant than for the WT: 43.2 ± 8 pA/pF (n = 26) versus 71.6 ± 11.3 pA/pF (n = 31) (Fig. 2B). Given the identical unitary conductance and similar maximal po (pomx) of WT and S218L channels (Fig. 1), the reduced current density of the mutant at V > 5 mV must be mainly because of a reduced density of functional channels in the membrane. Considering the values of the ipo product measured at the peaks of the ipo-V curves obtained for the mutant and WT channel and Equation 2 under "Materials and Methods," one obtains a 46 (± 14)% reduction of functional channels in the membrane of cells expressing the mutant. A similar value was obtained by simply considering the ratio of the mutant and WT current densities at voltages where the open probability of both WT and mutant channel reaches the maximum value, and therefore the ratio becomes nearly voltage-independent (V 20 mV in Fig. 2C (ISL/IWT)sat = 0.45). Given that
To study the neuronal phenotype of the S218L mutation, we expressed WT and mutant human CaV2.1
Interestingly, we confirm here for the (VEA) splicing variant of the CaV2.1 1 human subunit the previous finding obtained for the (+VEA) variant (13) of a more than 20 mV difference in the voltage range of activation of CaV2.1 channels expressed in neurons or HEK293 cells (compare V1/2 = +5 mV in HEK293 cells with V1/2 = 19.5 mV in neurons, obtained from fitting the I-V curves in Figs. 2 and 3, respectively). However, as found previously for the other FHM-1 mutants, the hyperpolarized shift in the voltage range of activation of mutant S218L channels expressed in neurons was similar to that of the same mutant channels expressed in HEK293 cells. Further support for the conclusion that the alterations in single channel function produced by the S218L mutation are similar in neurons and HEK293 cells comes from the comparison in Fig. 3C of the relative increase in single channel Ba2+ influx of the S218L mutant, ipoSL/ipoWT, obtained from direct single channel measurements in HEK293 cells and of the same ratio in neurons, calculated from the ratio of the P/Q current densities of mutant and WT channels, ISL/IWT, divided by the ratio of the density of channels in the membrane, NSL/NWT. NSL/NWT in neurons was estimated, as described above, from the value of (ISL/IWT)sat (obtained from ISL/IWT at 0 and 10 mV = 0.58 ± 0.11) (see Ref. 13). In Fig. 3C, the values of ipoSL/ipoWT, measured in HEK293 cells with 90 mM Ba2+ as charge carrier, were shifted toward hyperpolarized voltages of 51 mV, to account for the difference in surface potential with respect to the whole cell recording solution with 5 mM Ba2+ (26 mV; see Ref. 13) and for the difference in the voltage range of activation of CaV2.1 channels expressed in neurons or HEK293 cells, mentioned above (see Figs. 2 and 3 and Ref. 13). The strikingly similar values of ipoSL/ipoWT in HEK293 cells and neurons at all voltages indicate that the S218L mutation produces a similar increase of single channel Ba2+ influx in the two expression systems. In neurons, with nearly physiological concentrations of charge carrier, the single channel influx through the S218L mutant is larger than through the WT channel for V < 10 mV, and the relative gain of function of the mutant channel increases with more negative voltages.
Given the similar gain of function of mutant S218L channels in neurons and HEK293 cells, the smaller CaV2.1 whole cell current density at V > 20 mV in neurons expressing the S218L mutant compared with that in neurons expressing the WT channel must be mainly the result of a reduced density of functional channels in the membrane. A reduced whole cell P/Q current density at V > 20 mV and a reduced density of functional channels in the membrane were consistent properties of the four human FHM-1 mutants expressed previously in cerebellar granule cells of CaV2.1
To complete the functional characterization of the S218L mutant, we studied its inactivation properties in HEK293 cells expressing human S218L CaV2.1 Different kinetics of inactivation of the S218L mutant and the WT channel were revealed by comparing the average normalized current traces recorded during depolarizations lasting 1 s at voltages close to the peak of the I-V curves (0 mV for the S218L and 10 mV for the WT) (Fig. 4A, left panel). About half of the S218L Ba2+ current inactivated quite rapidly (more rapidly than the WT), whereas the other half inactivated very slowly and gave rise to a large residual current remaining at the end of the long depolarization (about three times larger than for the WT channel). In 1 s, only 59 ± 3% (n = 18) of the S218L current inactivated, in contrast with 87 ± 2% (n = 12) of the WT current. Similar differences in inactivation kinetics were found when average normalized current traces recorded at the same voltage (either 0 or 10 mV) for both WT and mutant channels were considered (Fig. 4A, right panels). It is interesting to compare the kinetics of inactivation of S218L mutant and WT channels during long depolarizations at these voltages because during CSD (the phenomenon underlying migraine aura (5)), the membrane potential of cortical neurons becomes almost zero for about 1 min (24). For the WT channel, the time course of inactivation at 0 mV was best fit with two exponential components with time constants (and relative amplitudes) of 150 ± 11 ms (66 ± 3%) and 2.31 ± 0.37 s (34 ± 3%). On the other hand, for the S218L mutant, three exponential components were necessary for the best fit of the time course of inactivation, with time constants of 23 ± 2 ms (25 ± 3%), 108 ± 10 ms (28 ± 3%), and 6.4 ± 0.9 s (47 ± 3%). The residual current remaining after 1 s at 0 mV was 41 ± 3% of the peak current (n = 18), almost twice that remaining for the WT channel (21 ± 3%, n = 7). Similar differences in inactivation kinetics between S218L and WT were observed during depolarizations of 1 s at 10 mV (e.g. about 1.8 times larger residual current for the S218L than for the WT channel). When the duration of the depolarization was prolonged to 5 s, the relative difference in residual current at the end of the depolarization was further enhanced: the current remaining after 5 s at 10 mV was 2.3 times larger for the S218L mutant than for the WT (Fig. 4B; a similar difference was observed at 0 mV, not shown). In conclusion, mutation S218L appears to affect both slow inactivation (increasing its contribution) and fast inactivation (making it more rapid). As a result, during long depolarizations the extent of inactivation of the S218L mutant was smaller than that of the WT channel (the more the more prolonged the depolarization), whereas during relatively short depolarizations (<200 ms) the extent of inactivation of the mutant was actually larger.
Similar differences in kinetics of inactivation between S218L and WT channels during long depolarizations were observed using 2 mM Ca2+ as charge carrier, with 0.5 mM EGTA (rather than 10 mM) in the intracellular solution to highlights Ca2+-dependent inactivation (25) (Fig. 4C). In these more physiological conditions, the S218L mutant still showed a component of current that inactivated very slowly, and the residual current of the mutant was still about twice that of the WT after long depolarizations of 1 s (at 5 mV, 22 ± 3% for S218L and 12 ± 1% for WT, n = 9). Moreover, similarly different kinetics of inactivation between S218L mutant and WT channels were found during trains of 100 short pulses (10 ms, 0 mV) delivered at 50 Hz (Fig. 5A). The S218L mutant inactivated more than the WT channel during relatively short trains (<20 pulses corresponding to <200 ms total depolarization time) but inactivated less than the WT during long trains. After 100 pulses only 53 ± 3% (n = 12) of the S218L Ba2+ current inactivated, in contrast with 70 ± 3% (n = 6) of the WT current, and the current during the last pulse at 0 mV at the end of the train was 1.6 times larger for the mutant than for the WT. Thus, despite the faster inactivation of the S218L mutant during the short pulses, the ratio of the mutant and WT currents at the end of the train of pulses (of cumulative duration 100 x 0.01 = 1 s) was similar to that at the end of a 1-s depolarization.
This finding and in general the similarity in the relative kinetics of inactivation of the mutant and WT channels during long depolarizations and during trains of short pulses (Figs. 4A and 5A) can be explained by the faster recovery from inactivation of the S218L mutant compared with the WT channel shown in Fig. 5B. For the WT channel, the average time course of the recovery from inactivation (after a 1-s depolarization) was best fit with two exponential components with time constants (and relative amplitudes) of 0.88 s (36%) and 7.62 s (64%), whereas for the S218L mutant, three exponential components were necessary, with time constants of 0.17 s (24%), 1.00 s (44%), and 10.3 s (32%). The mutant channel recovered from inactivation more rapidly than the WT channel, as a consequence of both a smaller amplitude of the slow component of recovery and the presence of a component of current recovering very rapidly (more than five times faster than the WT). As a result, the time necessary to recover 80% of the current was more than three times shorter for the S218L mutant than for the WT (less than 2 s compared with 6 s at 80 mV). Although a considerably faster rate of recovery from inactivation was reported previously for other two FHM-1 mutants (V714A and I1811L) (11, 14), the combination of both a much faster rate of recovery from inactivation and a much smaller extent of inactivation during long depolarizations is unique to the S218L mutant. In general, the other FHM-1 mutations analyzed did not show consistent effects on the kinetics of inactivation of CaV2.1 channels, and their variable effects were usually small: depending on the mutation, inactivation during train of pulses (or during long depolarizations) was increased, decreased, or unaffected (11, 12, 14, 15). For both the WT channel and the S218L mutant, the amount of inactivation during a long depolarization was similar, or if anything larger, than during a train of short pulses of comparable cumulative duration. In contrast, a larger inactivation during trains of action potentials was reported previously for a different rat CaV2.1 isoform and was attributed to preferential inactivation from closed states (26). Using a two-pulse protocol as in Ref. 26 to monitor recovery from inactivation of mutant and WT channels at early time points, we did not find evidence for a phase of further decline of the current before recovery (Fig. 5C). Therefore, in contrast to the rat isoform (26), our human CaV2.1 isoform does not further inactivate during the repolarization period, and closed state inactivation seems to play a minor role in its kinetics of inactivation during trains of short pulses. Finally, we investigated the effect of the S218L mutation on steady-state inactivation of human CaV2.1 channels by measuring WT and mutant currents at different holding potentials, Vh, as illustrated in the representative experiment in Fig. 6. The almost identical inactivation curves for WT and S218L channels in Fig. 6 show that mutation S218L does not affect steady-state inactivation of CaV2.1 channels, as found previously for most FHM-1 mutations (11, 12, 14, 15).
The S218L mutation in the IS4-IS5 linker of the human CaV2.1 1 subunit produces a severe clinical phenotype, in which typical attacks of FHM triggered by minor head trauma are frequently followed, after a lucid interval, by deep (even fatal) coma and long lasting severe cerebral edema. Other common symptoms are ataxia and cerebral and/or cerebellar atrophy (18, 19). Impairment of consciousness is a known but relatively rare associated symptom of FHM-1 attacks; however, it is usually short lived and less severe than in S218L patients, and there is not such dramatic delayed association with minor head trauma (2). On the other hand, a syndrome characterized by severe, even fatal, cerebral edema and coma occurring after a lucid interval is a possible complication of minor head trauma in children (19, 27).
We have studied the functional consequences of mutation S218L on human CaV2.1 channels expressed in HEK293 cells and in neurons from CaV2.1
However, the recent analysis of CaV2.1 channels in neurons of the R192Q knock-in mouse expressing mutant channels at their endogenous level (17) suggests that the alterations in the number of functional channels in the membrane produced by the FHM-1 mutations in transfected cells (13, 14) are probably an artifact caused by overexpression. In fact, in contrast with the reduced whole cell P/Q current density found in transfected neurons overexpressing the R192Q mutant (13, 16), in both cerebellar granule cells in culture (17) and freshly dissociated cortical pyramidal neurons (28) of the R192Q knock-in mouse, the whole cell P/Q current density was larger than that in WT neurons in a broad voltage range and similar to that of WT neurons at higher voltages. The changes in P/Q current density measured in the knock-in neurons are those expected if mutant mouse CaV2.1 channels have a gain-of-function phenotype similar to that established for mutant human CaV2.1 channels (14, 13) and if the number of functional channels in the membrane is not altered by the mutation. The knock-in data suggest that one may obtain misleading answers using transfected neurons overexpressing FHM-1 mutants to study the effect of the mutations on cellular functions that depend on the number of functional channels in the membrane, such as neuronal excitability or synaptic transmission. Indeed, Cao et al. (16) found an unaltered synaptic transmission and a decreased contribution of P/Q channels in controlling release at synapses between hippocampal neurons transfected with R192Q CaV2.1
Besides leading to a particularly large increase in Ca2+ influx at low voltages, mutation S218L strongly affects the kinetics of inactivation of human CaV2.1 channels. On one hand it makes fast inactivation more rapid, and on the other hand it increases the contribution of slow inactivation, introducing a large component of current that inactivates very slowly. During long depolarizations, at voltages that are attained during CSD, the extent of inactivation of the S218L channel is considerably smaller than that of the WT channel. Moreover, the rate of recovery from inactivation of the S218L mutant is considerably faster. Compared with the other FHM-1 mutants, the combination of both a much smaller extent of inactivation during long depolarizations and a much faster rate of recovery from inactivation are unique to the S218L mutant. Can the specific functional effects of the S218L mutation account for the severe clinical phenotype? Neuroimaging findings indicate that migraine aura is caused by CSD, a wave of sustained strong neuronal depolarization, which progresses slowly across the cortex, generating a transient intense spike activity followed by a long lasting neural suppression (5, 3032). Animal studies have shown that CSD can activate the meningeal trigeminal nociceptive afferents and evoke alterations in the meninges and brainstem consistent with the development of headache (33). These studies support the idea that CSD may initiate migraine attacks (5). Interestingly, the R192Q knock-in mice show an increased susceptibility to CSD (17). Gain of function of CaV2.1 channels leads to a lower threshold for CSD induction, an increased velocity of propagation, and a longer duration of the CSD depolarization in vivo (17). On the other hand, loss of function of CaV2.1 channels in the natural Cacna1a mutant leaner mouse (34, 35) leads to a higher threshold for CSD induction, a lower velocity of propagation, and a shorter duration of the CSD depolarization in vivo (36). Similar effects on threshold, propagation, and duration of CSD in vivo are produced by NMDA antagonists, in a dose-dependent manner (24, 37). The initiation of the positive feedback cycle that almost zeros the neuronal membrane potential and ignites CSD depends critically on the local increase above a critical value of the K+ concentration in the narrow space surrounding cortical neurons and the activation of a sustained net inward current in apical dendrites (24). The pivotal role played by both NMDA receptors and CaV2.1 channels in CSD induction is consistent with a positive feedback mechanism in which excessive CaV2.1-dependent release of glutamate from synaptic terminals depolarized by high K+ and consequent activation of NMDA receptors leads to further depolarization of the postsynaptic membrane, further increase in K+ in the extracellular space, further release of glutamate, further activation of the NMDA receptor, and so on (38). Enhanced susceptibility to CSD in FHM-1 can be explained, considering that a weaker depolarizing stimulus and a lower increase of extracellular K+ are necessary to activate mutant synaptic CaV2.1 channels and to release enough glutamate to initiate the positive feedback cycle leading to CSD. Thus, a weak depolarizing stimulus, as a minor head trauma, which is without consequences in healthy individuals, may be able to initiate CSD in FHM-1 patients. Although minor head trauma is a frequent triggering factor of FHM-1 attacks (2), the dramatic delayed association with cerebral edema and coma is unique to S218L patients. We propose that the severe phenotype produced by S218L channels may be the result of their unique combination of a particularly low threshold of activation with a particularly slow inactivation during the long CSD depolarization. Our working hypothesis is that because of these unique properties, minor head trauma may lead to a longer duration of CSD in S218L patients. A longer duration of CSD and prolonged activation of NMDA receptors may have indirect damaging effects, e.g. because of excessive accumulation of intracellular Ca2+ or production of nitric oxide, arachidonic acid, and reactive oxygen species, which among other effects may lead to impairment of the blood-brain barrier (39) and enhancement of both vasogenic and cytotoxic edema. An additional effect might be impairment of mitochondrial function and ATP supply, which may lead to repetitive CSDs and enhanced neuronal vulnerability after minor head trauma. This hypothesis was suggested by the interesting findings that sublethal stretch applied to cortical neurons in culture induced mitochondrial dysfunction and a consequent delayed long lasting small neuronal depolarization and enhanced vulnerability to glutamate challenges (4042). Induction of these alterations required depolarization-induced Ca2+ entry, glutamate release, and activation of NMDA receptors. The recently generated S218L knock-in mouse will allow testing of our working hypotheses.
* This work was supported by Telethon-Italy (Grant E1297), the Italian Ministry of University and Research (Grants Prin2003, FIRB2002, St-L449/97, Fondo Integrativo Speciale per la Ricerca), and the European Community (EUROHEAD Grant LSHM-CT-2004-504837). The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
** To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel.: 39-49-827-6052; Fax: 39-49-827-6049; E-mail: daniela.pietrobon{at}unipd.it.
1 The abbreviations used are: FHM, familial hemiplegic migraine; CSD, cortical spreading depression; GFP, green fluorescent protein; HEK, human embryonic kidney; i, single channel current; NMDA, N-methyl-D-aspartate; pF, picofarads; po, open probability; SL, S218L; TEA, tetraethylammonium; WT, wild-type.
2 T. Fellin and D. Pietrobon, unpublished observations.
3 A. Tottene and D. Pietrobon, unpublished observations.
We thank Dr. J. Striessnig (University of Innsbruck, Austria) for the CaV2.1 1 cDNA, Dr. M. Williams (Merck Research Laboratories, San Diego, CA) for the 2 , 2e, and 1b cDNAs. We thank L. Broos (Leiden University Medical Center, The Netherlands) for technical assistance on generating the mutant construct and E. Andrini and S. Pagnutti for help in performing some of the electrophysiological experiments.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||