|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 280, Issue 44, 37183-37194, November 4, 2005
F110I and R278C Troponin T Mutations That Cause Familial Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy Affect Muscle Contraction in Transgenic Mice and Reconstituted Human Cardiac Fibers*![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() 1
From the
Received for publication, July 25, 2005 , and in revised form, August 22, 2005.
We have studied the physiological effects of the troponin T (TnT) F110I and R278C mutations associated with familial hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (FHC) in humans. Three to four-month-old transgenic (Tg) mice expressing F110I-TnT and R278C-TnT did not develop significant hypertrophy or ventricular fibrosis even after chronic exercise challenge. The F110I mutation impaired acute exercise tolerance, whereas R278C did not. Skinned papillary muscle fibers from transgenic mice expressing F110I-TnT demonstrated increased Ca2+ sensitivity of force and ATPase activity, and likewise an increased Ca2+ sensitivity of force was observed in F110I-TnT-reconstituted human cardiac muscle preparations. In contrast, no changes in force or the ATPase-pCa dependencies were observed in transgenic R278C fibers or in human fibers reconstituted with the R278C-TnT mutant. The maximal level of force development was dramatically decreased in both transgenic mice. However, the maximal ATPase was not different (R278C-TnT) or only slightly less (F110I-TnT) than that of non-Tg and WT-Tg littermates. Consequently, their ratios of ATPase/force (energy cost) at all Ca2+ concentrations were dramatically higher compared with non-Tg and WT-Tg fibers. This increase in energy cost most likely results from a decrease in force per myosin cross-bridge, because forcing all cross-bridges into the force generating state by substitution of MgADP for MgATP in maximum contracting solutions resulted in the same increase in maximal force (15%) in all transgenic and non-transgenic preparations. The combination of increased Ca2+ sensitivity and energy cost in the F110I hearts may be responsible for the greater severity of this phenotype compared with the R278C mutation.
Troponin T (TnT)2 plays many important roles in striated muscle contraction, providing structural stability to the troponin complex and actively participating in the Ca2+-dependent regulation of contraction (1-5). TnT was first associated with heart disease in 1994 where three mutations were reported to cause Familial Hypertrophic Cardiomyopathy (FHC) (6). Disease penetrance, however, is highly variable, with severity of heart disease ranging from asymptomatic to end-stage heart failure even in individuals having the same mutation within the same pedigree (7-9). The F110I mutation in TnT, occurring from a missense substitution in nucleotide 340 in a genomic hotspot (9), is particularly interesting because prognosis appears to rely on the gene dosage, where homozygous individuals present a more severe form of hypertrophy and a greater risk of sudden cardiac death (7). Nevertheless, the cardiac morphology again ranges from ventricular and apical hypertrophy to no detectable cardiac abnormalities among 16 individuals (within six families) with the F110I genotype (9). Two sudden deaths (33 and 52 years of age) were reported within this group of 16 individuals with the F110I genotype (9).
The R278C-TnT mutation appears to have an even lower disease penetrance than the F110I mutation (8, 10-12). Initially, R278C was described as part of a group of TnT mutations that seem to cause a high risk of sudden death, despite causing little or no significant cardiac hypertrophy. However, only one sudden death was reported (8), which occurred in a 17-year-old girl with normal ventricular wall thickness. In subsequent reports in a larger number of individuals, the R278C mutation caused hypertrophy much later in life, and no sudden deaths (10, 11, 13). Thus, the clinical significance of an isolated report of a sudden death in a carrier of the R278C mutations may be questionable. In this report, we present studies on the physiological consequences of the TnT F110I and R278C mutations in skinned papillary muscle fibers obtained from transgenic mice expressing these human cardiac TnT mutations. We also characterize human cardiac-skinned fibers reconstituted with these and other TnT mutants and evaluate them versus previously described reconstituted porcine cardiac muscle fibers (14). The F110I mutation occurs in a conserved region of TnT that interacts with actin and tropomyosin (Tm), and the R278C mutation is located in a region of positively charged residues reported to interact with Tm, troponin I (TnI), and troponin C (TnC) (15-18). In vitro studies from our laboratory, as well as others, indicated functional defects in the contractile apparatus involving these TnT mutations and suggested some mechanisms that might be involved in the F110I- and R278C-dependent pathophysiology of FHC (14, 19, 20). Utilizing skinned porcine cardiac fibers reconstituted with recombinant human cardiac F110I- or R278C-TnT mutants, we have previously shown an increase in Ca2+ sensitivity of force development and F110I-dependent alterations in the level of maximal ATPase activity in reconstituted thin filaments (14). In addition, we have suggested a decrease in binding affinity of F110I-TnT and its binding protein partners in these reconstituted skinned fibers (14). In order to have an in vivo model of these two TnT mutations and to possibly clarify some of the reconstituted skinned fiber data, we have produced several lines of transgenic mice that express the human cardiac F110I-TnT or R278C-TnT mutant proteins (F110I-Tg, R278C-Tg). Fibers from these mice were examined for Ca2+ sensitivity of force development and ATPase activity measured simultaneously under isometric conditions and for the maximal levels of force and ATPase activity. We also present physiological studies utilizing human cardiac muscle preparations reconstituted with the F110I-, R278C-, and, for comparison, I79N-TnT mutants. Both muscle systems, the transgenic animal models and the reconstituted human cardiac muscle fibers, demonstrate increased Ca2+ sensitivity of force/ATPase for F110I and I79N mutants whereas no change in the Ca2+ sensitivity of force/ATPase was observed for the R278C-TnT mutant. Our transgenic data showed that whereas the maximal level of ATPase was not very different in all experimental groups, the maximal force development was dramatically decreased in F110I- and R278C-TnT cardiac mouse fibers. Therefore, the ratio of ATPase/force (energy cost), which was nearly the same for both transgenic TnT mutants, was much higher than that observed in the cardiac fibers of non-Tg and WT-Tg littermates. In summary, our results suggest that this decrease in force and increase in energy cost observed in both F110I- and R278C-TnT mutant mice might be a key factor in triggering cardiac pathophysiology like hypertrophy as seen in human patients harboring these mutations. The combination of increased Ca2+ sensitivity and energy cost in the F110I-mutated myocardium may be responsible for the greater severity of the F110I phenotype compared with the R278C mutation.
Clone Construction The clone for the human cardiac WT-TnT has been previously described (21). The F110I- and R278C-human cardiac TnT (HCTnT) mutant cDNAs were obtained by overlapping sequential PCR (22) using the WT-HCTnT clone (14) and a set of primers specific for each mutation. The WT and mutant cDNAs were constructed to have an NcoI site at the N-terminal ATG and a BamHI site following the stop codon to facilitate cloning into pET-3d (Novagen), which was used for bacterial expression of the proteins.
Protein Expression and Purification
Transgene Construct
Generation of Transgenic Mice
RNA Analysis of Transgenic Mice Northern BlotsNorthern blots were performed on RNA extracted from tissues from Non-Tg and Tg mice. Autoradiographs of membranes with 10 µg of total RNA isolated from transgenic and non-transgenic mouse hearts were incubated with a 32P-radiolabed human growth hormone probe. Only lanes containing the transgenic transcripts have a band of the expected transcript size of 1550 nucleotides (Fig. 1C). This probe did not hybridize with RNA from non-transgenic hearts or transgenic liver (not shown). A probe to endogenous mouse GADPH was used as the internal loading control.
Protein Analysis of Transgenic Mice
Mice Exercise Protocol
Histopathology of Mouse Cardiac Tissue
Cardiac Fiber Experiments Ca2+ Concentration MeasurementsThe Ca2+ concentration in the cuvette perfusing the skinned preparation was varied by use of a gradient maker (Scientific Instruments GmbH, Heidelberg) to mix two solutions of known Ca2+ and ionic composition together. The Ca2+ concentration produced by the gradient maker was calibrated using the fluorescent Ca2+ indicator Calcium Green-2 (Molecular Probes). The Kd of Calcium Green-2 used to calculate pCa was 1055.31 M. The concentration of Calcium Green-2 in the gradient solution was 1.0 mM. Calcium Green-2 changes its fluorescence over the range of Ca2+ required for activation of contraction and ATPase activity. The Calcium Green-2 fluorescence was excited at 480 nm and the fluorescence measured with a cut-off filter at 515 nm. A complete description of the method is given in Allen et al. (29). Glycerinated Human Cardiac Fibers Reconstituted with Recombinant ProteinsPapillary muscles from the hearts of human donors void of cardiac disease were obtained by consent from Jackson Memorial Hospital, Miami and placed in an oxygenated physiological salt solution of 140 mM NaCl, 4 mM KCl, 1.8 mM CaCl2, 1.0 mM MgCl2, 1.8 mM NaH2PO4, 5.5 mM glucose, and 50 mM Hepes buffer, pH 7.4. The papillary muscles were isolated and dissected into muscle bundles of about 20 x 3 mm, and chemically skinned in 50% glycerol and 50% pCa 8 solution (10-8 M [Ca2+], 1 mM [Mg2+], 7 mM EGTA, 5 mM [MgATP2+], 20 mM imidazole, pH 7.0, 15 mM creatinine phosphate, ionic strength: 150 mM adjusted with KPr) containing 1% Triton X-100 for 24 h at 4 °C. Then the fibers were transferred to the same solution without Triton X-100 and stored at -20 °C for about 2 weeks. Reconstitution of these papillary muscle fibers with recombinant human cardiac WT-TnT and I79N-, F110I-, or R278C-TnT mutants was performed as previously described for porcine fibers (14). These reconstituted fibers were examined for Ca2+ sensitivity of force development at pH7 and at pH 6.5 (21).
Graded Treadmill Exercise Tolerance Test
Generation and Characterization of Transgenic Mice The wild-type HCTnT transgenic mice (WT-Tg) as well as I79N-Tg mice have previously been described (21). This report describes one transgenic mouse line for the F110I mutation (F110I-Tg line 1) and four lines for the R278C mutation (R278C-Tg lines 1, 3, 5, and 7). RT-PCR of heart tissue from representatives of each HCTnT transgenic line and non-transgenic littermates was performed. Two typical PCR reactions for each sample using 3 µg of cDNA and primers specific for the transgenic and non-transgenic CTnT transcript are shown on Fig. 1, A and B. A PCR product of the expected size (150 bp) was only present in the PCR reaction of transgenic animals when the specific primers against the sequence of human cardiac TnT were used (Fig. 1A). When primers specific for the mouse endogenous cardiac TnT (MCTnT) were used, the PCR reaction for all transgenic and non-transgenic littermates produced a PCR product of 120 bp, indicating the presence of endogenous MCTnT transcript (Fig. 1B). Northern blot analysis using 10 µg of total RNA isolated from transgenic and non-transgenic mouse hearts hybridized with a 32P-radiolabeled probe specific for the 3'-untranslated region of the hGH in the transgene are shown in Fig. 1C. Only RNA from transgenic animals hybridized with the transgene-specific probe. When the same membrane was stripped and rehybridized with a 32P-radiolabeled probe specific for mouse GADPH, both transgenic and non-transgenic RNA showed expected bands of 1550 bp in an autoradiograph of the membrane (Fig. 1D). Although the signal intensity of the GAPDH-radiolabeled complex appears to be consistent for all RNA examined, the intensity with the transgene-specific probe was greatest for WT and decreased progressively for R278C-5, R278C-7, R278C-3, R278C-1, with the RNA from the F110I line having the lowest signal suggesting less transgenic transcript in the F110I line.
Expression of transgenic TnT proteins was examined by Western blot analysis. Fig. 2 is representative of Western blots of the standard curve (lanes 1-5) and the samples of transgenic preparations (lanes 6-11). A total of 2 µg of cardiac protein was loaded into each lane. Different ratios of mouse to human cardiac proteins were utilized to generate the standard curve. The upper panel in Fig. 2 represents the samples stained with the anti-CTnT polyclonal antibodies whereas the lower panel shows the reaction with the anti-human CTnT monoclonal antibodies. For each point of the standard curve the ratio of the signal intensity obtained with the anti-HCTnT monoclonal antibody was divided by the signal obtained with the anti-CTnT polyclonal antibody (recognizing both human and mouse CTnT) (Fig. 2, lanes 1-5). The percent of transgenic TnT (WT, R278C, and F110I mutants) expression was calculated in the same way and determined from the standard curve (Fig. 2, lanes 6-11). An average percent of 35, 55, 50, and 52 R278C-HCTnT expression was found in the animal lines 1, 3, 5, and 7, respectively. The F110I-HCTnT protein expression was estimated at 45% whereas that of WT-Tg was calculated to be 46%. As expected, expression of the HCTnT transgene was not found in the lungs, liver, kidney, brain, psoas, soleus, or back muscle of transgenic mice (not shown). Expression of each transgene was only determined for sedentary animals.
Cardiac Morphology and Pathology of HCTnT Transgenic Mice We next examined if the mutations caused abnormalities of myocyte or tissue morphology. Microscopic examination of hematoxylin & eosin- or trichrome-stained ventricular cross-sections revealed no significant increase in focal myocyte hypertrophy, disarray, or myocardial fibrosis in any of the transgenic lines. As illustrated in TABLE ONE, even non-Tg or WT-Tg mice had focal areas of abnormalities that were rated mild on a 4 point scale (normal, mild, moderate, severe). On average, mild myocyte hypertrophy or disarray was observed with similar frequency in all groups (TABLE ONE). No excess mortality was observed in any of the HCTnT transgenic lines during the first 5 months of life. Long term survival studies were not conducted.
Effect of Chronic Swimming Exercise on HCTnT Transgenic Mice Chronic swimming exercise has been previously shown to exacerbate the pathologic phenotype of mice expressing FHC-linked mutations (25). Thus, we subjected groups from all transgenic lines to a 56-day swimming exercise program. During the exercise program, two male F110I-Tg mice died during the first week of swimming. The hearts of these animals, immediately prepared for microscopic evaluation, revealed no myocyte disarray, myocyte hypertrophy, nor myocardial fibrosis (TABLE ONE). All other animals survived the scheduled protocol. Chronic exercise significantly increased the heart to body weight ratio in all groups (p < 0.01 by two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA)). However, neither the F110I nor the R278C lines demonstrated a significantly larger hypertrophic response to exercise compared with non-Tg or WT-Tg mice, as evidenced by the lack of a statistical interaction between genotype and exercise (p = 0.08 by two-way ANOVA). Accordingly, no apparent trends in cardiac histopathology were observed (TABLE ONE). Myocyte hypertrophy ranged from normal to a few hypertrophic cells in the cardiac tissue of all lines (TABLE ONE). Myocyte disarray was typically normal to mild, occurring mostly in the free and post left ventricle area and in the septum, with no identifiable pattern between sedentary and exercised animals (TABLE ONE). No myocardial fibrosis was identified in any of the animals expressing HCTnT transgenes.
Maximum Exercise Tolerance of HCTnT Transgenic Mice Because the transgenic lines appeared to tolerate the chronic swimming exercise without difficulties, we next examined whether TnT mutants have a differential effect on acute maximum exercise tolerance. Maximum exercise tolerance provides a measure of overall cardiopulmonary function. Thus, we subjected all groups of mice to a graded exercise protocol using a motorized treadmill. Mice expressing the I79N-TnT mutation, which have a fiber phenotype of increased Ca2+ sensitivity and decreased maximum force similar to that of F110I-Tg mice (see below and Ref. 21), were also included for comparison. On average, the maximum exercise tolerance of R278C-Tg mice from two different transgenic lines, 1 (35%) and 7 (52%) was not statistically different from that of WT-Tg or non-Tg mice (Fig. 4). In contrast, I79N-Tg and F110I-Tg mice demonstrated a significant reduction of maximal exercise tolerance (Fig. 4) compared with non-Tg, WT-Tg, and R278C-Tg mice.
Fiber Studies Transgenic MiceWe next performed multiple experiments to examine the Ca2+ sensitivity of force development and ATPase activity on freshly skinned papillary muscle fibers from WT-Tg, F110I-Tg, and R278C-Tg mice. The control fibers were derived from Non-Tg littermates. Prior to measurement, the fibers (diameter of 70 ± 20 µm) were skinned with Triton X-100. As demonstrated in Fig. 5A, the Ca2+ sensitivity of the ATPase activity for WT-Tg was pCa50 = 5.199 ± 0.052 (n = 39) while that of F110I was pCa50 = 5.421 ± 0.026 (n = 20) and the difference between them, pCa50 = 0.22. There was a difference of pCa50 0.1 between the WT-Tg and Non-Tg fibers most likely because of the human TnT expressed in mouse hearts. A similar effect of the F110I mutation was seen on the steady state force development and is demonstrated in Fig. 5B. The midpoint of the force-pCa dependence of WT-Tg was pCa50 = 5.068 ± 0.019 (n = 39) whereas that of F110I was pCa50 = 5.224 ± 0.026 (n = 20), with pCa50 = 0.156. The large increase in Ca2+ sensitivity of force and ATPase of F110I-Tg compared with WT fibers was not observed for R278C transgenic fibers. As demonstrated in Fig. 6, there was no difference in either the Ca2+ sensitivity of ATPase (Fig. 6A) or force (Fig. 6B) between WT-Tg and R278C-Tg fibers. The respective pCa50 values between the WT-Tg and R278C-Tg were -0.033 (ATPase, n = 36) and -0.044 (force, n = 36). In Figs. 7 and 8, maximal ATPase rates (s-1) and maximal force (1014 N/mol) are presented for Non-Tg, WT-Tg, F110I-Tg, and R278C-Tg skinned fibers. Maximal ATPase activity was decreased in F110I-Tg fibers compared with WT-Tg (p = 0.0127). The ATPase rates were equal 6.014 ± 0.345 (n = 39) and 4.743 ± 0.139 (n = 20) for WT-Tg and F110I-Tg, respectively. In contrast, no significant changes in maximal ATPase rates were observed between WT-Tg and R278C-Tg fibers (Fig. 7). However, there was a large decrease in maximal force observed for F110I-Tg and R278C-Tg fibers (Fig. 8). The maximal force for WT-Tg fibers was 4.002 ± 0.316 (n = 39) whereas those for Tg F110I and R278C were 1.828 ± 0.086 (n = 20, p = 9.86e-6) and 2.284 ± 0.092 (n = 36, p = 3.33e-6), respectively. Fig. 9 illustrates the energy cost or rate of cross-bridge dissociation (ATPase/force). It shows that the maximum energy cost or rate of dissociation of force generating myosin cross-bridges is higher in both F110I-Tg fibers (Fig. 9A) and R278C-Tg fibers (Fig. 9B) when compared with WT-Tg fibers. This means that a higher amount of energy is going to be used per unit isometric force in both transgenic TNT mice (F110I and R278C) compared with WT-Tg mouse fibers. There were no differences in the ATPase and force measurements between the sedentary and exercised groups of mice.
Human Cardiac Fiber StudiesPrevious studies examining porcine fibers reconstituted with recombinant human cardiac WT and some of the FHC-TnT mutants including I79N-, F110I-, or R278C-TnT demonstrated an increase in Ca2+ sensitivity of force development generated by these mutants (14). We have repeated these reconstitution experiments utilizing human cardiac muscle preparations. In agreement with our previous study (14), an increase in the Ca2+ sensitivity of force was observed for the I79N- and F110I-TnT mutants (TABLE TWO). However, fibers reconstituted with R278C-TnT did not change the Ca2+ sensitivity of force and behaved similar to the R278C-transgenic fibers reported above in Fig. 6B. As shown in TABLE TWO, the pCa50 of the force-pCa relationship determined at pH 7 was 5.452 ± 0.012 for WT (n = 4), 5.657 ± 0.017 for I79N (n = 4), 5.571 ± 0.007 for F110I (n = 4), and 5.438 ± 0.021 for R278C (n = 4). The largest increase in the Ca2+ sensitivity of force at pH 7.0 was observed between the WT and the I79N mutant with
This study is the first to describe transgenic animal models for the FHC human cardiac TnT F110I and R278C mutations that have been generated under the control of the murine -myosin heavy chain promoter. All transgenic lines demonstrated similar levels of protein expression, no cardiac hypertrophy and no ventricular histopathology. A large difference in the Ca2+ sensitivity of force and ATPase activity, determined in skinned papillary muscle fibers, was observed between the F110I transgenic mice and the other lines tested including WT, R278C, or non-transgenic animals. A shift in the force-pCa dependence toward lower Ca2+ concentrations in F110I-Tg mouse fibers was also observed in reconstituted porcine (14) and human cardiac muscle fibers reconstituted with recombinant F110I-TnT protein. In contrast to F110I-Tg mouse fibers, no increase in the Ca2+ sensitivity of force and ATPase was seen for R278C-Tg mouse fibers and no change in force was observed for human fibers reconstituted with R278C-TnT protein. Our previous studies with reconstituted porcine fibers showed an increase in the Ca2+ sensitivity of force for all three TnT mutations (14). Interestingly, cardiac fibers of both F110I and R278C transgenic mice displayed dramatic decreases in maximal force, 54% decrease by F110I and 43% decrease by R278C, compared with those of WT-Tg mice. Similar decreases in maximal force were previously observed in our I79N-Tg mouse study (21).
Perhaps, all three mutations that lower force per cross-sectional area may in the long-term result in systolic dysfunction and the hearts of patients harboring these mutations will be prone to using more energy to maintain blood pressure and blood flow at normal levels. In support of this idea the ratios of ATPase/force (energy cost) at all Ca2+ concentrations for both transgenic F110I- and R278C-TnT mutants were dramatically higher than for Non-Tg and/or WT-Tg animals. A higher energy cost can be the result of at least two obvious reasons. Normally, it would be assumed to be a result of an increase in the rate of dissociation of force generating myosin cross-bridges during muscle contraction. This is because it is generally assumed that the average force per cross-bridge does not change. However, a decrease in the average force per cross-bridge could be just as effective in increasing energy cost. Because the maximum ATPase (also a measure of myosin cross-bridge turnover rate) for both mutants does not change or changes very little, one is left with the strong possibility that it is the maximum force per cross-bridge that was decreased by the TnT mutations. This possibility is supported by the fact that substituting MgADP for MgATP in the maximal contracting solutions, in order to force all cross-bridges into the force-generating state, produced only a 15% increase in force regardless of whether the skinned preparations were from the WT-TnT, R278C-TnT, F110I-TnT, or non-transgenic mice. How this could happen can only be speculated, but perhaps these TnT mutations can affect the flexibility of tropomyosin in such a way as to prevent the myosin head from rotating properly during the power stroke or the mutation alters the structure of troponin (15, 16), which in turn alters the structure of actin and this changes the actin-cross-bridge interaction.
One intriguing result of our study is that mice expressing the R278C mutation, which significantly reduces maximum force of skinned fibers, had a normal maximal exercise tolerance, (Fig. 4). This suggest that, at least in the acute setting, mice are able to compensate for a decreased maximum force and an increased energy cost of contraction imparted by the R278C mutation. This result may not be as surprising as it might appear, since it is well recognized that in the intact ventricular myocardium, peak intracellular Ca2+ concentration never reaches values that are high enough to produce maximum contractile force, even under conditions of maximum inotropic stimulation (31). For example, in intact rabbit and rat myocytes, a maximum myoplasmic free [Ca2+]of pCa 5.40 was reached during the optimum twitch. This was much lower than the free [Ca2+] necessary for the full activation of the myofilaments (pCa 4.90) (31). These results suggest that the cardiac muscle operates on the exponential range of the pCa-force and relationship probably never reaches free [Ca2+] values beyond the pCa50 of the myofilaments (compare also pCa50 values listed in Fig. 5). Furthermore, since steady-state conditions are not present in a beating cardiac muscle, effects of the mutation on dynamic properties of muscle contraction may be more important than their effects on maximum steady-state force. Consistent with this idea, mice expressing the Ca2+-sensitizing TnT mutants (I79N, F110I) demonstrated significantly impaired exercise capacity. This suggests that in vivo the impaired relaxation conveyed by the Ca2+-sensitizing effect of TnT mutants (26) is hemodynamically more important than any changes of maximal developed force, which was depressed to a similar extent by all three mutations (compare Fig. 8 and Ref. 21). Another surprising finding was that mutant transgenic lines lacked the histopathological findings (TABLE ONE) that are considered hall-marks of FHC in humans. Perhaps the expression levels of mutant protein may have been too low, since other investigators have observed an apparent "threshold" for histopathological changes around 50% of mutant protein load (32). However, since the TnT mutations cause an autosomal dominant disorder and most patients are heterozygous for the mutation, it can be predicted that expression levels of mutant TnT protein is less than 50%, although exact values are presently unknown. This would favor an alternative explanation, namely that the animals under study were simply too young to demonstrate significant histopathology. Consistent with this idea, we have recently reported preliminary data suggesting that a histopathological phenotype developed in HCTnT I79N transgenic mice aged 15-20 months (33). Studies are in progress to test whether similar changes also occur in HCTnT R278C and F110I transgenic mice.
There are studies from other laboratories examining transgenic animal models for other TnT mutations than those described in our previous (21) or current report, namely truncated TnT (34), or the R92Q-TnT mutation (32, 35). Transgenic animals expressing the truncated form of TnT demonstrated myocellular disarray and a reduced number of cardiac myocytes that were also smaller in size (34). The ventricles of mice expressing the R92Q mutation were smaller than those of WT-Tg (32). In contrast to the truncated TnT mice, the R92Q-TnT hearts demonstrated significant induction of atrial natriuretic factor and
We have also examined the effect of lowering pH, from pH 7.0 to 6.5, on the Ca2+ sensitivity of force in human cardiac muscle fibers reconstituted with the F110I, R278C mutations as well as with the previously described TnT I79N and WT proteins (21). We have shown that all of the TnT-reconstituted fibers decreased the Ca2+ sensitivity of force development as well as maximal force when the pH was lowered from 7.0 to 6.5. This desensitization to Ca2+ (rightward shift), expressed as a difference in In summary, our results show that the TnT mutations F110I and R278C, associated with FHC in humans, are characterized in skinned fibers by a decrease in force at all Ca2+ concentrations, but little or no significant effect on fiber ATPase. This phenomenon resulted in a dramatically increased energy cost for both F110I and R278C transgenic fibers at all Ca2+ concentrations. The common thread in these TnT mutation studies is that force is decreased resulting in an increased energy cost. This would suggest that the myocardium of an animal with normal blood pressure and cardiac output might have greater energy consumption than a normal animal. Perhaps these processes initiate and/or contribute to the development of FHC and cardiac failure. The mechanism for the increased energy consumption appears to result from a decrease in force per cross-bridge as judged by the fact that forcing all cross-bridges into the force generating state caused the same increase in force in wild-type, non-Tg, and mutant fibers. The decrease in force and the increase in energy cost observed in both the F110I- and the R278C-TnT mutant mice might be a key factor in triggering cardiac hypertrophy as seen in human patients harboring these mutations. However, an increase in the Ca2+ sensitivity of force as well as in energy cost that was seen with the F110I mutation compared with the R278C mutation, which did not affect Ca2+ sensitivity of force/ATPase, may be a key factor in understanding the greater severity of the F110I-mutated myocardium in humans.
* This work was supported by National Institutes of Health Grants HL42325 and HL67415 (to J. D. P.), National Institutes of Health Grant HL071778 (to D. S-C.), and National Institutes of Health Grants HL071670 (to B. C. K.) and AHA-0120319B (to O. M. H.). The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact. 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed: Dept. of Molecular and Cellular Pharmacology, University of Miami School of Medicine, 1600 N.W. 10th Ave., Miami, FL 33136. Tel.: 305-243-5874; Fax: 305-324-6024; E-mail: jdpotter{at}miami.edu.
2 The abbreviations used are: TnT, troponin T; TnI, troponin I; TnC, troponin C; WT, wild type; UTR, untranslated region; hGH, human growth hormone; RT, reverse transcriptase; Tg, transgenic; non-Tg, non-transgenic; GAPDH, glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase; FHC, familial hypertrophic cardiomyopathy; CTnT, cardiac TnT; HCTnT, human cardiac TnT; MCTnT, mouse cardiac TnT.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||