|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 281, Issue 32, 22707-22719, August 11, 2006
Relationship between the Oligomeric Status of HIV-1 Integrase on DNA and Enzymatic Activity*![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() 1
From the
Received for publication, March 8, 2006 , and in revised form, May 24, 2006.
The 3'-processing of the extremities of viral DNA is the first of two reactions catalyzed by HIV-1 integrase (IN). High order IN multimers (tetramers) are required for complete integration, but it remains unclear which oligomer is responsible for the 3'-processing reaction. Moreover, IN tends to aggregate, and it is unknown whether the polymerization or aggregation of this enzyme on DNA is detrimental or beneficial for activity. We have developed a fluorescence assay based on anisotropy for monitoring release of the terminal dinucleotide product in real-time. Because the initial anisotropy value obtained after DNA binding and before catalysis depends on the fractional saturation of DNA sites and the size of IN·DNA complexes, this approach can be used to study the relationship between activity and binding/multimerization parameters in the same assay. By increasing the IN:DNA ratio, we found that the anisotropy increased but the 3'-processing activity displayed a characteristic bell-shaped behavior. The anisotropy values obtained in the first phase were predictive of subsequent activity and accounted for the number of complexes. Interestingly, activity peaked and then decreased in the second phase, whereas anisotropy continued to increase. Time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy studies showed that the most competent form for catalysis corresponds to a dimer bound to one viral DNA end, whereas higher order complexes such as aggregates predominate during the second phase when activity drops off. We conclude that a single IN dimer at each extremity of viral DNA molecules is required for 3'-processing, with a dimer of dimers responsible for the subsequent full integration.
The integration of a DNA copy of the HIV-12 genome into the host genome is a crucial step in the life cycle of the retrovirus. Integrase (IN) is responsible for the two consecutive reactions that constitute the overall integration process. The first of these two reactions is 3'-processing, which involves cleavage of the 3'-terminal GT dinucleotide at each extremity of the viral DNA. The hydroxyl groups of newly recessed 3'-ends are then used in the second reaction, strand transfer, for the covalent joining of viral and target DNAs, resulting in full-site integration. IN is sufficient for catalysis of the 3'-processing reaction in vitro, using short-length oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) that mimic one viral long terminal repeat (LTR) in the presence of the metallic cofactor Mg2+. This reaction generates two products: the viral DNA containing the recessed extremity and the GT dinucleotide. One of the two products, the processed viral DNA, as well as the target DNA serve as substrates for the subsequent joining reaction.
IN belongs to the superfamily of polynucleotidyl transferases. Its catalytic core domain contains a triad of acidic residues constituting the D,D-35-E motif, which is strictly required for catalysis. The catalytic core establishes specific contacts with the viral DNA and, together with the C-terminal domain, is involved in DNA binding (14). The 3'-processing reaction is highly specific, and the terminal 13 bp of the LTR play a key role for Mg2+-dependent 3'-processing in terms of reaction specificity (4, 5). In particular, the CA sequence preceding the GT dinucleotide cleaved by IN is strictly required. Reaction specificity seems to depend on the catalytic step, because no significant difference in affinity is observed in vitro for different DNA sequences (2, 3, 5, 6). The catalytic mechanism of IN has been extensively studied, but the structural determinants of IN activity remain unclear, and controversy remains concerning the multimeric status of active IN. Single- and double-domain crystallographic structures have been produced for IN, alone or complexed with the IN-binding domain of the cellular partner lens epithelium-derived growth factor, and all these structures display a conserved dimeric structure of the catalytic core (711). Based on topological considerations concerning the distance separating the active sites of the two protomers, which is more than double the distance separating the two joining sites on the target DNA (separated by 5 bp), a multimeric state of an order higher than dimers, tetramers at least, is required for complete integration. However, it remains unclear whether such a higher order multimeric state is also required for 3'-processing activity and how this activity is modulated by the self-association properties of IN. Moreover, most enzymatic studies are carried out with an excess of IN over DNA substrate. Taking into account the low solubility of IN, we investigated whether high order multimers or aggregated forms of IN favored by high protein concentrations in solution were detrimental or beneficial for activity. We developed an assay for monitoring DNA binding and subsequent 3'-processing in the same sample. This assay makes possible the separation of binding and catalytic parameters and the study of real-time kinetics. It is based on steady-state fluorescence anisotropy (r), which is sensitive to rotational diffusion, and thus suitable for studies aiming to identify structural modifications leading to a significant change in molecular size (1215). Using a fluorescent probe covalently linked to the GT dinucleotide, this makes it possible to follow DNA binding and dinucleotide release, because both steps strongly influence molecular size of the fluorescent moiety. The anisotropy-based technique is also highly suitable for studies of the relationship between the overall size of IN·DNA complexes and activity. We found that, for low IN:DNA ratios, the r values obtained after DNA binding and before catalysis were fully predictive of subsequent IN activity, according to the fractional saturation function. For high IN:DNA ratios, anisotropy continued to increase, but 3'-processing activity decreased. Because r depends on both fractional saturation and the molecular size of complexes at saturation of DNA sites, our results show that high order multimers or aggregated states of IN are detrimental to 3'-processing activity. Activity levels were highest for non-aggregative smaller species. A more precise characterization of catalytically competent complexes by time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy (TFA) (1620), confirmed steady-state data and led to the identification of dimeric forms as the most active forms for 3'-processing. Our results also highlight that only the IN:DNA ratio but not the IN concentration per se determines the aggregation properties and thus the activity of IN and that DNA binding stimulates the self-organization of IN to give a catalytically competent non-aggregative form.
Oligonucleotides and NomenclatureUnlabeled and fluorescein-labeled single-stranded (ss) ODNs were purchased from Eurogentec (Liege, Belgium) (except for the 2'-aminouridine-containing ODN) and purified by electrophoresis in acrylamide gels. The specific HIV sequence was 5'-GTGTGGAAAATCTCTAGCAGT-3' (the bases removed by IN are underlined). This sequence was denoted a, and the complementary nonprocessed strand was denoted b. Fluorescein (F) was attached at the 5'- or the 3'-end of strand a or b, via a 6-carbon linker. As an example, the specific double-stranded (ds) ODN used to monitor activity was called HIV-a3F, indicating that fluorescein was attached to the 3'-end of strand a. HIV-GTGT-a3F was identical except that the four terminal bases at the 3'-end of strand a were GTGT rather than the canonical sequence CAGT. The nonspecific sequence, NS-TTCC, was 5'-ACCTATGCGCCGCTAGATTCC-3' (strand a). Two other nonspecific ODNs with different 3'-ends of strand a were derived: NS-CACC and NS-CAGT. ds ODNs were obtained by mixing equimolar amounts of complementary strands in 20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.2), 100 mM NaCl. The mixture was heated to 85 °C for 5 min, and annealing was allowed by slow cooling to 25 °C. The uridine-containing ODN (corresponding to strand a of the DNA substrate HIV-aUF) contains a fluorescein attached to the 2'-amino group of the 3'-terminal 2'-aminouridine. It was synthesized as follows: the solid support was prepared as previously described (21). Briefly, 2'-deoxy-5'-O-4,4'-dimethoxytrityl-2'-O-trifluoracetamidouridine (0.2 mmol) was co-evaporated with pyridine (3 x 5 ml) and dissolved in dry pyridine (2 ml). Succinylated long-chain alkylamine-controlled pore glass (500 Å) (200 mg), 2,4,6-triisopropylbenzenesulfonyl chloride (0.6 mmol), and 1-methylimidazole (1.2 mmol) were added, and the mixture was incubated for 3 h at 25°C. The support was then filtered and washed successively with pyridine, CH2Cl2, and ether. Starting from 2'-deoxy-5'-O-4,4'-dimethoxytrityl-2'-O-trifluoracetamidouridine-derivatized long-chain alkylamine-controlled pore glass (500 Å), a 21-mer ODN was assembled on an ABI394B DNA synthesizer, by the phosphoramidite method, according to the manufacturer's recommendation. Protected 2'-O-deoxyribonucleoside phosphoramidites and S-ethylthiotetrazole were purchased from Glen Research. Ammonia was used for cleavage from the support and deprotection overnight at 55 °C. The reaction mixture was then analyzed by reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography in ion-pair mode. For fluorescein labeling, 1 mg of fluorescein isothiocyanate dissolved in 20 µl of dimethylformamide was added to a solution of 40 nmol of 2'-amino ODN in 130 µl of sodium carbonate-bicarbonate (1 M, pH 9):water (v/v, 5:8) (22, 23). The mixture was incubated at 25 °C in the dark for 18 h and then loaded onto an NAP5-Sephadex G-25 column (Amersham Biosciences) pre-equilibrated in water. The ODN was eluted with water and analyzed by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography in ion-pair mode. IN Purification and Standard Analysis of the 3'-Processing ReactionHIV-1 IN (32 kDa) was purified under native conditions, as previously described (24). Standard IN assay, using 32P-labeled ODN and gel electrophoresis, was carried out as previously described (24). Gels were analyzed on a STORM 840TM PhosphorImager (Amersham Biosciences) and quantified with ImageQuaNTTM 4.1 software. The 3'-processing activity was calculated as follows: activity (%) = 19-mer/(21-mer + 19-mer) x 100.
Steady-state Fluorescence Anisotropy AssaySteady-state anisotropy values were recorded on a Beacon 2000 instrument (PanVera, Madison, WI), in a cell thermostatically held at 25 or 37 °C, for the DNA-binding step and 3'-processing reaction, respectively. Unless otherwise stated, we studied the formation of IN·DNA complexes by incubating fluorescein-labeled ds ODNs with IN in 20 mM Tris (pH 7.2), 1 mM dithiothreitol, 20 mM NaCl, 5 mM MgCl2 (the sample volume was 200 µl). The fractional saturation function (Y) was calculated as follows,
ex = 562 nm and em = 582 nm) were recorded on a Cary Eclipse spectrofluorometer (Varian, Mulgrave, Australia) in polarization mode and were compared with values obtained with the same instrument and HIV-a3F as the substrate.
Kd,app as a function of ODN length were determined by competition experiments. Fluorescein-labeled ds ODN HIV-a5F (4 nM) was preincubated with various concentrations of unlabeled ss or ds HIV ODN (from 10- to 45-mers) in 20 mM Tris buffer (pH 7.2) supplemented with 1 mM dithiothreitol, 20 mM NaCl, and 5 mM MgCl2. IN (150 nM final concentration) was then added, and r values were recorded.
Time-resolved Fluorescence ExperimentsTime-resolved fluorescence parameters (lifetimes and correlation times) were obtained from the two polarized fluorescence decays I||(t) and I||(t), using the time-correlated single photon counting technique. The instrumentation setup was essentially similar to those previously described (16, 17), with modifications: the time scaling was 19.5 ps per channel and 4096 channels were used. The excitation light pulse source was a Ti:sapphire laser (Millennia-pumped Tsunami femtosecond laser, Spectra Physics) (repetition rate: 8 MHz) associated with a second harmonic generator tuned to 490 nm. The emission monochromator (ARC SpectraPro-150) was set to 530 nm (
i is the individual rotational correlation time, and i is the associated amplitude. 0 was found to lie between 0.36 and 0.37. Normalization of for a given temperature was performed using,
is the viscosity, V is the volume of the rotating unit, k is the Boltzmann constant, and T is the temperature (K).
Monitoring 3'-Processing Activity by Steady-state Fluorescence AnisotropyFluorescence anisotropy measurements are based on the principle of photoselective excitation of a fluorophore by a polarized light, providing information about rotational motions of the fluorophore or fluorescently labeled molecule between photon absorption and emission. Some events such as overall rotational diffusion or flexibility are major causes of light depolarization. High levels of anisotropy are generally associated with large molecules or complexes characterized by slow rotational diffusion or low flexibility level. In this study, we used an extrinsic fluorophore covalently linked to DNA to monitor the binding of IN to viral DNA substrate and the subsequent 3'-processing reaction, in the same assay. Both DNA binding and 3'-processing would be expected to have a significant effect on the anisotropy parameter, because each of these steps has a major effect on the molecular size of the fluorescent moiety. The principle underlying the anisotropy-based assay is summarized in Fig. 1. The binding of IN to a ds ODN mimicking one end of the viral DNA increases the steady-state anisotropy value (r), most likely by restricting flexibility, allowing the calculation of fractional saturation function. Following DNA binding, the same sample can be shifted to a permissive temperature for 3'-processing activity. When the fluorophore is linked to the 3'-terminal GT dinucleotide, release of the dinucleotide product should significantly decrease r. The fraction of dinucleotides released can be determined from the real-time decrease in r observed during the reaction ( rreal-time, corresponding to the difference between IN·DNA complex and free dinucleotide) or after the disruption of all IN·DNA complexes by the addition of SDS ( rSDS, corresponding to the difference between unprocessed ds ODN and free dinucleotide). Unlike most standard 3'-processing assays, which are based on quantification of the processed strand (first reaction product), the anisotropy-based assay monitors the released dinucleotide (second reaction product).
We tested 21-mer DNA substrates labeled with fluorescein at one end, in all possible combinations (5'- or 3'-extremity of the a or b strand), or labeled on the 2'-amino group of a 3'-terminal 2'-aminouridine (Fig. 2A). The free ds ODNs were characterized by r values of 0.0600.130 at 25 °C (0.0450.105 at 37 °C), depending on the location of fluorescein, whereas the fluorescein-labeled dinucleotide was characterized by r = 0.02. DNA binding on the addition of IN was monitored at 25 °C and led to a significant increase in r value (>0.2 in the experimental conditions of Fig. 2). Equilibrium was typically reached after 15 min, as previously reported (12, 27). The processing reaction was started by shifting the sample to a temperature of 37 °C, and the initial r values obtained therefore correspond to rt = 0. In the presence of the divalent cationic cofactor Mg2+, all tested ODNs gave similar rt = 0 values (0.22), indicating that fluorescein position had no effect on DNA binding by IN (Fig. 2B). Experiments carried out in the absence of Mg2+ gave reproducibly larger r values (0.25). This result confirms that DNA-binding activity of IN is not strictly dependent on Mg2+, consistent with other studies (2, 28, 29). Nevertheless, the larger r value suggests that IN aggregation is favored by an absence of Mg2+, as previously reported (17).
The time dependence of r and r under real-time conditions at 37 °C is shown in Fig. 2 (B and C): only the DNA substrates HIV-a3F and HIV-aUF, with the fluorescein directly attached to the small GT reaction product, displayed significant decreases in r or r, and these decreases were strictly related to the presence of the metallic cofactor. In contrast, HIV-a5F, HIV-b5F, and HIV-b3F displayed no significant decrease in r or r value, under either real-time (Fig. 2) or fixed-time conditions (data not shown) (3'-processing activity was normally detected by a gel-electrophoresis method for HIV-b5F and HIV-b3F; HIV-a5F was not tested). The result obtained with these three ODNs indicates that anisotropy is not sensitive enough to differentiate between the DNA substrate (ds ODN 21/21) and the first reaction product (ds ODN 19/21). Furthermore, under real-time conditions, this result suggests that the processed DNA product remains tightly bound to the enzyme after 3'-processing. This tight binding together with the slow catalytic step could be responsible for the observed single-turnover property of IN, even under conditions of excess DNA substrate (25). In contrast, the terminal dinucleotide is released normally from IN·DNA complexes after 3'-processing, and our results indicate that the decrease in r is related to the formation of the GT product. Thus, anisotropy is reliable for monitoring the 3'-processing reaction, but only if fluorescein is attached to the GT dinucleotide.
The 3'-processing reaction is strongly sequence-dependent, and the endonucleolytic site includes the crucial conserved CA dinucleotide immediately preceding the GT dinucleotide. We assessed sequence specificity, using the anisotropy-based assay and the following ODNs: HIV-a3F corresponds to the wild-type (wt) sequence, whereas HIV-GTGT-a3F is a variant in which the 3'-terminal CAGT sequence is replaced by GTGT. We also tested three nonspecific sequences, NS-TTCC-a3F, NS-CACC-a3F, and NS-CAGT-a3F. We found that the DNA-binding step was not influenced by sequence. Indeed, the final r values obtained after DNA binding were similar for all ODNs, irrespective of sequence context, confirming that in vitro assays primarily reveal the nonspecific DNA binding mode of IN. In contrast, sequence had a major effect on
Altogether, our data show that the decrease in r during incubation at 37 °C is related to specific 3'-processing activity and that the anisotropy-based method is reliable for inhibitor characterization. In our experiments, strand transfer products, as quantified by gel-electrophoresis, represent 58% of the total products, regardless of fluorescein labeling (data not shown). Only, the strand transfer of one processed DNA into a fluorescently labeled DNA (not yet processed) may underestimate the 3'-processing activity determined by anisotropy. Consequently, the half-transfer reaction is more problematic at the beginning of the reaction, and its influence on r tends to disappear during 3'-processing. However, this effect is probably small, particularly in the real-time assay, in which the high r values characterizing the IN·DNA complex cannot be severely influenced by strand transfer.
Quantification Analysis and Characterization of the 3'-Processing ReactionThe 3'-processing activity of IN can be calculated by real-time assay or by quenching of the reaction with SDS. Both these approaches allow quantification of the fraction of released dinucleotides. Fig. 4A displays one example of the time course of GT release in real-time conditions. Activity increased linearly with time over 180 min. This apparent linearity is compatible with single-turnover conditions (excess of IN over DNA substrate), when the rate constant of cleavage is low (25). Under single-turnover conditions, the time course of product formation provides a measure of the actual chemical cleavage step, which is not affected by subsequent turnovers. The kinetic profile, as determined by anisotropy measurement, gave kchemistry = 0.0035 min1, consistent with the value obtained with the standard gel-electrophoresis method (kchemistry = 0.004 min1) (25). A similar result was obtained using the anisotropy method with SDS (data not shown). Indeed, Activityreal-time and ActivitySDS were well correlated (Fig. 4B). These results demonstrated that (i) all the GT dinucleotides produced by the cleavage reaction were released from the IN·DNA complexes in the real-time assay and were therefore not trapped within the complexes, (ii) the decrease in r in real-time conditions was due exclusively to the release of dinucleotides from the IN·DNA complexes, rather than another phenomenon, such as dissociation of the enzyme from the DNA substrate or product. The single-turnover rate constant, as determined with the anisotropy-based test, was similar to that determined by gel electrophoresis, suggesting that the presence of fluorescein at the DNA 3'-extremity has no effect on DNA-binding or the subsequent catalytic step. Comparison of the 3'-processing activity of non-fluorescent and fluorescein-labeled U5-substrates by gel electrophoresis confirmed that fluorescein has no influence on activity (Fig. 4C). This result sharply contrasts with that obtained using a TAMRA-labeled ODN: this ODN was also tested by both anisotropy and gelelectrophoresis methods and, although TAMRA did not influence the number of IN·DNA complexes, 3'-processing activity was significantly decreased by a factor of 5 (data not shown). Note that the r parameter is not sensitive to the precise positioning of IN on the DNA, and this positioning may be disturbed by the TAMRA probe in the absence of a strong effect on overall DNA-binding isotherms.
The Initial Steady-state Anisotropy Value Is Not Predictive of 3'-Processing ActivityThe final r value obtained after the DNA-binding step corresponds to the initial r value for activity (rt = 0) and is related, in first approximation, to the fractional saturation function (Y). Under single-turnover conditions, activity is expected to increase with Y, and the fraction of released dinucleotides should therefore be proportional to the number of IN·DNA complexes initially formed in the sample. Interestingly, a plot of 3'-processing activity against rt = 0 gave a clear bell-shaped curve (Fig. 5A). The various rt = 0 values were obtained by varying the initial IN:DNA ratio from 4.2 to 400, corresponding to different mixtures of IN (from 50 to 800 nM) and ODN (from 2 to 12 nM). The optimal ratio was found to be
To get deeper insight into the bell-shaped phenomenon, we investigated the relationship between the fraction of product obtained at the end of the reaction and the Y parameter, which is related to the number of DNA-substrate molecules initially bound to IN (at t = 0). The initial number of complexes was varied, and activity at t (corresponding to the maximum amount of released product) was determined and plotted as a function of Y (Fig. 6, AC). The fraction of product was found to increase linearly with the initial number of IN·DNA complexes, as expected under single-turnover conditions. Optimal conditions, corresponding to an IN:DNA ratio of 40 (characterized by r = 0.226), gave a final activity of 92%. This result confirms that complete saturation of the DNA substrate can be achieved at anisotropy values much lower than 0.272, and is compatible with rmax = 0.226. The activity per complex, specific activity (Â = activity/Y), was then calculated for each IN:DNA ratio (Fig. 6D). Specific activity decreased as a function of IN:DNA ratio (Fig. 6D), suggesting that aggregation occurs as soon as IN is present in excess over DNA and that the activity of large complexes (INagg·DNA) is lower than that of the lower order multimeric form (INact·DNA). At ratios exceeding 200:1, the samples contained only INagg·DNA complexes (r = 0.272; see also TFA experiments below). However, these complexes retained significant levels of 3'-processing activity ( 35% the activity of INact·DNA complexes). The number of aggregated forms of IN increased continuously with the IN:DNA ratio, suggesting that, at the peak of the bell-shaped curve, the sample already contained some INagg·DNA complexes, together with the INact·DNA complexes. From Fig. 6, we can estimate that INagg·DNA complexes in these conditions accounted for 1115% of total complexes. We made use of the additivity law of anisotropy to calculate the theoretical rmax value (0.218) characterizing the fully active complex (INact·DNA), in the absence of both free DNA and aggregated complexes. Thus, the bell-shaped curve shown in Fig. 5A results from two opposing trends: Y and [INagg·DNA] both increase as a function of IN:DNA ratio and are favorable and unfavorable, respectively, for 3'-processing activity.
Characterization of the INact·DNA and INagg·DNA Complexes Using TFAUnder site saturation conditions, r values reflect the molecular size of the complexes in a purely indicative manner. We evaluated the molecular sizes of active IN·DNA complexes in greater detail by studying representative samples corresponding to different r values, as shown in Fig. 5A, independently by TFA. This approach allows the determination of rotational correlation times (
We then applied TFA to different samples corresponding to various IN:DNA ratios. We used HIV-a5F to prevent analytical problems due to the activity-dependent decrease in r when fluorescein is linked to the GT dinucleotide. The activity observed at t for an IN:DNA ratio of 40:1 (92%) suggested that only a small amount of free ODN was present in this sample. We therefore restricted our analysis to samples corresponding to the peak of the bell-shaped curve and to the decreasing phase, so as to avoid studying mixtures of free and IN-bound ODNs. At 37 °C, two short (<2.5 ns) were resolved upon the addition of IN to ODN (Table 2). The distribution in the short domain was not dependent on the IN:DNA ratio. In contrast, the characteristic long 25 °C of 8.6 ns found for free DNA was replaced by a 25 °C 37.8 ns (26.8 ns at 37 °C), depending on the IN:DNA ratio (Fig. 8 and Table 2). The sample corresponding to the peak of the bell-shaped curve (IN:DNA 40:1; r = 0.226) was rather monodisperse, as suggested by the small difference between the maximum (26.8 ns at 37 °C) and the center of gravity (31.4 ns at 37 °C) of the peak in the distribution. As discussed above, samples corresponding to the TFA distribution shown in Fig. 8A contained mostly non-aggregated active forms of IN (8589%). These complexes are characterized by a long correlation time of 38 ns. This value is consistent with hydrodynamic properties of a dimeric form of IN on the DNA (16, 17, 31). The shift of the center of gravity toward longer values probably results from the presence of small numbers of INagg·DNA complexes. Further increases in the IN:DNA ratio displaced the distribution toward longer values (Fig. 8, BE). Our data confirmed that the sample corresponding to the highest r value (0.272) consisted essentially of aggregated forms of IN on DNA (Fig. 8E), as demonstrated by the broad distribution above 100 ns (17).
We used a continuous fluorescence assay to monitor the HIV-1 IN 3'-processing reaction. We found that the processed DNA product remained tightly bound to IN, thereby limiting enzyme turnover, whereas the other reaction product (GT dinucleotide) was rapidly released from the processed DNA·IN complex. This assay made it possible to characterize standard equilibrium/kinetic parameters and to obtain insight into the relationship between the size of IN·DNA complexes and catalytic activity. We studied 3'-processing under various IN:DNA ratio conditions: optimal activity was obtained at a ratio of 40:1. Higher ratios, associated with high r values, led to a decrease in product formation. The oligomeric status of active IN was further investigated by TFA. The best condition for 3'-processing activity corresponds to a majority of complexes in the sample characterized by a long correlation time of 38 ns. This value is compatible with a dimeric form of IN bound to one short DNA substrate mimicking a single viral DNA end. The aggregation of IN on DNA was found to be responsible for the decrease in the 3'-processing activity. Kinetic Analysis of 3'-Processing Activity by the Anisotropy-based MethodThe real-time assay described here is based on the use of a DNA duplex fluorescein-labeled on the terminal-3' GT. It allows quantification of the cleavage reaction resulting in physical separation of the processed 19/21-mer DNA (first product) and the fluorescently labeled dinucleotide (second product). IN assays based on fluorescence intensity (fluorescence resonance energy transfer or fluorescence quenching) have been described in previous studies (3235). Unlike electrophoresis-based methods, which can be used to analyze discrete time points only, fluorescence methods present the significant advantage of allowing continuous monitoring of the reaction for kinetic studies of IN in the same sample. However, only the anisotropy-based method can be used to study both the DNA-binding step and subsequent activity in the same assay. Using various DNA sequences, we showed that IN does not demonstrate highly selective binding to the viral sequence over other sequences, but, in contrast, displayed strong selectivity for catalysis (Fig. 3). This result is not subject to possible bias due to indirect comparison, as might be the case when DNA binding and catalysis are studied by different methods. It suggests that IN first binds viral DNA in a nonspecific manner and that subsequent relaxation leads to the formation of a specific and catalytically competent complex before catalysis. This relaxation step must be very slow to account for the low single-turnover rate constant as previously reported (25).
The anisotropy-based assay is reliable, because r decreased only in the presence of Mg2+ with the wt DNA sequence and only when fluorescein was attached to the GT 3'-extremity and was prevented by a competitive inhibitor of IN. The additivity law of anisotropy renders the quantification of activity easy and both real-time and fixed-time studies can be carried out. The real-time assay is possible, because IN·DNA complexes with DNA substrate (21/21-mer) or product (processed 19/21-mer) are highly stable in solution (Fig. 2), and the observed decrease in r is therefore due solely to the cleavage reaction and not to dissociation of the protein from DNA. Unlike many standard methods, which quantify the 19/21-mer product under denaturing conditions, the real-time assay allows quantification of the GT product under native conditions. Our kinetic analysis gave a catalytic rate of 0.2 h1, which is similar to the values published in previous studies (25, 36, 37). The strong correlation between real-time and fixed-time data (Fig. 4B) and similarities between the time courses of GT and 19/21-mer formation demonstrate that the GT dinucleotide is rapidly released from IN after the 3'-processing reaction. This release is consistent with the low apparent affinity expected for such a small ligand (see Fig. 7, Kd > 100 µM). This situation is very different to that for the other reaction product (19/21-mer), which remains tightly bound to IN after catalysis. Finally, kinetic analysis showed that the catalytic rate constant was not significantly affected by the presence of fluorescein at the end of the DNA molecule, whereas inhibition was observed with TAMRA. TFA showed that the local motion of fluorescein or TAMRA was more restricted when these fluorophores were covalently linked to a GT 3'-extremity, suggesting a direct interaction between the fluorophore and DNA. In the case of fluorescein, this interaction perturbed neither DNA binding nor cleavage. In contrast, the additional methyl groups and (or) charge effects of TAMRA may prevent the correct positioning of IN on the cleavage site or phosphodiester bond hydrolysis itself.
Dimeric Forms of IN Are Optimal for the 3'-Processing of One DNA ExtremityWe found that the optimal conditions for 3'-processing were obtained for a majority of dimeric forms bound to the DNA ( long = 38 ns), consistent with complementation studies between individually inactive IN mutants, suggesting that at least the dimeric form is catalytically active for 3'-processing (38, 39). The optimal IN:DNA ratio (40:1) reported here corresponds to conditions used in most IN assays: IN in excess over DNA and DNA concentration maintained below the Kd value. This ratio therefore does not indicate the final stoichiometry and is highly dependent on experimental conditions. For example, increasing ionic strength shifts the Kd toward higher values and influences the optimal ratio (data not shown). Under experimental conditions in which DNA and IN concentrations were maintained above the Kd value, an optimal ratio of 2:1 was found, consistent with the stoichiometric binding of two IN protomers per DNA end (25). We and others (12, 40) have previously observed cooperative binding of IN to DNA. Consequently, using DNA concentration below the Kd value, the IN:DNA ratio determines the number of complexes formed in solution as well as the stoichiometry of these complexes. Therefore, below the optimal ratio for activity, it is very likely that, in addition to free DNA, the solution contains a mixture of monomeric and dimeric forms of IN bound to the DNA substrate. Indeed, we have previously found that, using suboptimal IN:DNA ratios (10:1), the complexes exhibit lower values consistent with a monomer-dimer equilibrium at 37 °C (normalized long, 2427 ns) and monomeric IN at 25 °C (normalized long, 1620 ns) (16). Here, it is highly suggested that the optimal activity originates in two critical events: DNA binding and cooperativity. From this point of view, steady-state anisotropy is then particularly helpful to establish direct relationships between DNA binding parameters, the specific activity of the complexes, and their hydrodynamic properties as measured by TFA.
Our conclusion that the dimeric form of IN is active for 3'-processing under native conditions strongly parallels those obtained by Parissi and coworkers (41) with purified cross-linked multimers. The aggregation of IN on DNA was found to be strongly dependent on the IN:DNA ratio and was detrimental for 3'-processing, as previously reported for concerted integration (42). The bell-shaped curve obtained in Fig. 5 most likely originates from competition between the cooperative binding of IN on DNA leading to a dimeric form (specific IN-IN interaction, which is favored by increasing the IN:DNA ratio and enhances 3'-processing activity) and aggregation (nonspecific interactions also favored by increasing the IN:DNA ratio but detrimental for 3'-processing). The bell-shaped behavior is also compatible with the results of a recent cross-linking study (41) suggesting that monomers and tetramers display neither 3'-processing or half-strand transfer (transfer of a single viral DNA end) activity, whereas dimers are competent for both these reactions, and only tetramers catalyze full-site concerted integration. Our results suggest that, in vitro, IN aggregates do not much hinder 3'-processing under IN:DNA ratio conditions leading to the formation of dimers, but that such aggregates may impede tetrameric organization in a highly competitive manner. However, TFA experiments did not indicate whether the tetrameric form on one LTR end actually existed, because the intermediate Li and Craigie (44) recently showed that blunt-ended DNAs are more efficient substrates for concerted integration than preprocessed DNAs, whereas half-integration is more efficient with preprocessed DNA. These data, together with our results and those of Parissi et al. (41), suggest that dimers of IN are necessary and sufficient for 3'-processing and half-integration and that the 3'-processing step probably promotes a conformational change of IN compatible with concerted integration. This conformational change may play a key role in promoting the IN tetramerization required for concerted integration. IN is known to exist in a monomer-dimer-tetramer equilibrium in solution (16, 17, 24, 38). The multimeric form is modified on DNA, and the final quaternary structure depends on the IN:DNA ratio and probably also on the nature of the DNA substrate. From this point of view, the tetrameric organization of IN (a dimer of dimers) may be stabilized by the simultaneous presence of two LTR ends (47) and it highly suggested that the condensation-distortion properties of DNA play a key role in bringing the two ends of the viral DNA close enough in space for a dimer of dimers to form. A dimer at each LTR end, as described here, is consistent with current models based on cross-linking (48) or molecular dynamics data (49), and the 5-bp separation at target level is compatible with a tetrameric complex rather than a dimer. Several models of the tetrameric active complex exist for concerted integration: the 5-bp separation is directly compatible with a tetrameric complex displaying 2-fold symmetry, as modeled by McCammon and coworkers (31) or a tetrameric complex assuming target DNA bending (48, 50) or a hinging motion of the dimer interface (7). The formation of a dimer of dimers is probably mediated by the C-terminal domain, as suggested by the x-ray structure of the catalytic core/C-terminal double domain (9). Moreover, residue Trp-235 in the C-terminal domain has a significant effect on concerted integration but not on half-integration (44). The resulting symmetric organization, dispensable for 3'-processing but not for integration, may be favored or stabilized by the symmetric base sequence of the target DNA. Such symmetry in integration sites has recently been reported (51, 52).
It is noteworthy that the single-turnover rate constant of IN is particularly slow, for example about one thousandth that for restriction enzyme HincII (53). This indicates that a pre-catalysis step has a limiting effect independent from that for product release. We found that dimers were the major oligomeric forms of IN on one LTR end. IN free in solution was mostly tetrameric in the 100200 nM concentration range and aggregated at concentrations above 250 nM (24). This suggests that the dissociation of high order multimeric forms precedes or occurs simultaneously to DNA binding, as previously reported (16) (Fig. 9). Parissi and coworkers (41) carried out a kinetic analysis of the IN·DNA complexes formation and found that the presence of one LTR induces the binding of one IN monomer (M) prior to formation of the IN dimer (D). The conversion of high order multimeric forms of IN into monomers may account for the rather slow DNA-binding step (12, 25, 27). We have previously shown that IN binds cooperatively to DNA with a Hill number compatible with the binding of monomers and the presence of a dimeric form of IN on DNA (12). We suggest that relaxation of the conformation of the IN·DNA complex leading to the formation of a competent and specifically bound dimeric form (D*) is probably the limiting step accounting for the slow single turnover of 3'-processing. High IN concentrations lead to aggregation on DNA, as shown here by TFA and in other studies by means of a fluorescence correlation spectroscopy approach (54). However, we found that maximum 3'-processing activity was not controlled by absolute IN concentration but instead depended on the IN:DNA ratio. The critical IN concentration for solubility is valuable only for a given DNA substrate concentration, because aggregation properties on DNA are controlled mainly by the IN:DNA ratio. Mostly dimeric forms bound to DNA were found with, for example, a 500 nM IN solution in the presence of 12 nM DNA substrate, although DNA-free IN essentially formed aggregates at concentrations >250 nM. This does not imply that this solution is monodisperse, because IN concentration exceeds DNA concentration, but this result is consistent with the dissociation effect of DNA on high multimeric forms of IN reported in conditions of DNA excess (16). Thus, the solubility of IN may be increased by increasing DNA concentration or, alternatively, DNA binding may promote a specific conformation of IN compatible with catalysis.
* This work was supported by grants from the TrioH European Project (FP6 Grant 503480), the CNRS, the French National Agency for Research against AIDS, and the Russian Foundation for Basic Research (Grants 04-04-22000 and 05-04-48743). The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact. 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel.: 33-147-40-23-94; Fax: 33-147-40-76-84; E-mail: deprez{at}lbpa.ens-cachan.fr.
2 The abbreviations used are: HIV, human immunodeficiency virus; IN, integrase; LTR, long terminal repeat; ODN, oligodeoxynucleotide; ds, double-stranded; ss, single-stranded; r, steady-state fluorescence anisotropy; TFA, time-resolved fluorescence anisotropy; TAMRA, carboxytetramethylrhodamine; wt, wild-type.
We thank Dr. H. Leh for helpful discussions and G. Mbemba for technical assistance.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||