|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
J. Biol. Chem., Vol. 281, Issue 39, 28837-28849, September 29, 2006
Mapping Conformational Changes of a Type IIb Na+/Pi Cotransporter by Voltage Clamp Fluorometry*From the Institute for Physiology and the Center for Integrative Human Physiology (ZIHP), University of Zurich, CH-8057 Zurich, Switzerland
Received for publication, April 21, 2006 , and in revised form, July 5, 2006.
The fluorescence of a fluorophore depends on its environment, and if attached to a protein it may report on conformational changes. We have combined two-electrode voltage clamp with simultaneous fluorescence measurements to detect conformational changes in a type IIb Na+/Pi cotransporter expressed in Xenopus oocytes. Four novel Cys, labeled with a fluorescent probe, yielded voltage- and substrate-dependent changes in fluorescence (F). Neither Cys substitution nor labeling significantly altered the mutant electrogenic properties. Different F responses to voltage and substrate were recorded at the four sites. S155C, located in an intracellular re-entrant loop in the first half of the protein, and E451C, located in an extracellular re-entrant loop in the second half of the protein, both showed Na+, Li+, and Pi-dependent F signals. S226C and Q319C, located at opposite ends of a large extracellular loop in the middle of the protein, mainly responded to changes in Na+ and Li+. Hyperpolarization increased F for S155C and S226C but decreased F for Q319C and E451C. The labeling and F response of S155C, confirmed that the intracellular loop containing Ser-155 is re-entrant as it is accessible from the extracellular milieu. The behavior of S155C and E451C indicates a strong involvement of the two re-entrant loops in conformational changes during the transport cycle. Moreover, the data for S226C and Q319C suggest that also the large extracellular loop is associated with transport function. Finally, the reciprocal voltage dependences of the S155C-E451C and S226C-Q319C pairs suggest reciprocal conformational changes during the transport cycle for their respective local environments.
The type II sodium-phosphate cotransporters (encoded by the solute carrier SLC34A gene family) are polytopic membrane proteins that mediate thermodynamically coupled transport of inorganic Pi and Na+ across the cell membrane. Their physiological role is to facilitate cellular uptake of Pi by coupling it to the transmembrane electrochemical gradient. Three subtypes have been currently identified: NaPi-IIa and IIb are electrogenic and operate with a 3:1 Na+: stoichiometry and translocate one net positive charge per transport cycle (for review, see Refs. 1 and 2), whereas NaPi-IIc is electroneutral and operates with a 2:1 Na+: stoichiometry (3). The transport kinetics of electrogenic type II Na+/Pi cotransporters have been studied earlier by electrophysiology and uptake assays in the Xenopus oocyte expression system (reviewed in Ref. 1). Recently, we established the method of voltage clamp fluorometry (VCF)3 to gain new insights into putative conformational changes occurring during the transport cycle (4). VCF relies on the property that the fluorescence of a fluorophore is sensitive to its local environment, and thus changes in fluorescence recorded from a fluorophore attached to a particular site in a protein can be interpreted as conformational changes affecting the environment of the fluorophore. VCF was first implemented in the study of gating-related conformational changes in K+ channels (5, 6). Since then, VCF has been applied to several membrane transporter systems, including the glucose transporter SGLT1 (7, 8), the glutamate transporter EAAT3 (9), the GABA transporter GAT1 (10), the serotonin transporter SERT (11), and the Na+/K+- and H+/K+-ATPases (12, 13).
In our first study (4) we introduced a novel Cys residue in the putative re-entrant loop between transmembrane domains (TMDs) 5-6 (S448C, marked with an open triangle in Fig. 1) of the flounder NaPi-IIb isoform. Labeling S448C with a fluorescent probe allowed us to detect voltage- and substrate-dependent changes in fluorescence (F). Using the new fluorescence data we modified our earlier kinetic model of the electrogenic NaPi-II transport cycle that we derived from the interpretation of steady state and presteady state substrate-dependent currents. In the new model, two Na+ ions (instead of one) bind on the external side before a divalent
In the S448C mutant the cotransport function is blocked after labeling, however analysis of current and fluorescence data indicates that the protein is still able to bind substrate. Although the absence of a full cotransport cycle may have facilitated the analysis of the data (the protein could only occupy a subset of possible conformations), it is important to validate and extend those observations to a fully functional transporter. In the present study we mutated ten new residues individually to Cys (see Fig. 1), all of which are located in predicted linker regions that face, or are accessible to, the extracellular milieu. For each mutant, we determined whether we could measure voltage-dependent fluorescence changes (
Reagents and Solutions(2-Aminoethyl)methane thiosulfonate hydrobromide (MTSEA) was from Toronto Research Chemicals. 2-((5 (6)-tetramethylrhodamine)carboxylamino)ethyl methanethiosulfonate (MTS-TMR) was from Biotium. All other reagents were from Sigma or Fluka. The standard experimental solution (ND100) contained (mM): 100 NaCl, 2 KCl, 1.8 CaCl2, 1 MgCl2, 10 HEPES, pH 7.4 (adjusted using Tris). In Na+ replacement experiments, NaCl was replaced equimolar with choline Cl or LiCl. In the iodide experiments we replaced 50 mM NaCl with 50 mM NaI or sodium glucuronate (the latter serving as a Cl replacement control). Solutions containing the required concentrations of Pi were prepared by adding K2HPO4/KH2PO4 (pH 7.4). Modified Barth's solution for storing oocytes contained (mM): 88 NaCl, 1 KCl, 0.41 CaCl2, 0.82 MgSO4, 2.5 NaHCO3, 2 Ca(NO3)2, 7.5 HEPES, pH 7.5 adjusted with Tris and supplemented with 5 mg/liter doxycyclin. Oocyte Expression and Molecular BiologyPoint mutations were generated in WT flounder NaPi-IIb (GenBank Accession No. AAB16821 [GenBank] ) using QuikChange site-directed mutagenesis (Stratagene) with primers from Microsynth and verification by sequencing (Microsynth). Complementary capped RNA was synthesized using the T3 Message Machine kit (Ambion). Oocytes from Xenopus laevis were prepared as previously described (4), injected with 50 nl of cRNA (0.2 µg/µl), and experiments performed 3-7 days after injection. The oocytes were exposed immediately before fluorescence measurements to 0.4 mM MTS-TMR in ND100 solution for 5 min in the dark.
Conventional Two-electrode Voltage ClampThe procedure for standard two-electrode voltage clamp has been described in detail previously, as have the protocols (4, 16). Briefly, steady state Pi activation was determined by varying the Pi concentration in the presence of ND100 and subtracting the respective currents in ND100 from those in ND100 + Pi; steady state Na+ activation was similarly determined by subtracting the respective responses in NDX from those in NDX + Pi (1 mM), where X is the test Na+ concentration (in mM). Steady state Pi-induced currents (IPi) were fit with a form of the modified Hill Equation 1,
Presteady state relaxations were quantitated by fitting with a two-component exponential function. The faster component, which represents endogenous linear capacitive charging of the oocyte membrane, was subtracted from the total relaxation to yield the NaPi-II-dependent component. This was numerically integrated to obtain the charge Q moved for a step from the holding potential (Vh) to the test potential (V), as previously described (e.g. (17, 18). The Q-V data were fit with a Boltzmann function of the form in Equation 2,
Apparatus for Simultaneous Voltage Clamp and FluorometryThe apparatus for simultaneous VCF has been described in detail previously (4) and consisted of a conventional two-electrode voltage clamp with a laboratory-built fluorescence microscope. The latter comprised a x10 fluorescence objective (CFI S Fluor, 0.5 N.A., 1.2 mm W.D., Nikon) and a filter set (XF33 cube, comprising a 535DF35 excitation filter, 570DRLP dichroic mirror and 605DF50 emission filter; Omega Optical Inc). Emitted light was measured using a silicon photodiode (S1336-18BQ, Hamamatsu) connected directly to the input of an integrating headstage (CV 201, Molecular Devices) and the headstage signal was processed by a patch clamp amplifier (Axopatch 200A, Molecular Devices). The scaled output of the Axopatch 200A was further processed by a differential amplifier/filter unit (LPF-8, Warner Instruments) before digitization.
Experimental ProtocolsVoltage-dependent changes in fluorescence (
Data AnalysisFirst, each F-V recording was adjusted to zero at Vh = -60 mV to obtain F relative to -60 mV. After correction for photobleaching, the F-V data were fitted with a Boltzmann equation (Equation 2, where F is substituted for Q). Data were pooled from several oocytes after first normalizing all data to Fmax, obtained in ND100 for that oocyte. For display purposes the F-V data were shifted (by Fhyp) to the same Fmax as the ND100 condition. For statistical analysis using a paired Student's t test or ANOVA, we compared data obtained by fitting each oocyte individually, whereas slopes of regression lines were compared between pooled data. Statistical analysis was made using GraphPad Prism version 3.02 for Windows, GraphPad Software. In the graphs, data are shown as mean ± S.E.
Identification of Sites that Exhibit Voltage-dependent F using Cys Scanning We introduced novel Cys in each of the predicted external linkers and in the first intracellular loop (predicted to be re-entrant and therefore accessible to the extracellular medium) in NaPi-IIb (Fig. 1A). We characterized each mutant by electrophysiology and compared its behavior to that of the WT. All mutants were functional as evidenced by their robust Pi-induced currents (IPi) at -50 mV, 1 mM Pi, which confirmed that the Cys substitution was well tolerated (data not shown). The corresponding current-voltage (I-V) relations were similar to WT (shown in Fig. 1, B and C), with the exception of S520C. We then exposed the mutants to 1 mM MTSEA to see if this procedure would block IPi, as we had previously observed with the S448C mutant (4). Apart from S520C (see below), no major changes were seen in the IPi of any of the mutants (data not shown).
S520C, located in the fourth extracellular loop, was the only mutant that showed an altered voltage dependence of IPi. After MTS treatment the voltage dependence became more like that of the WT (not shown), a phenomenon previously reported for the G134C mutant in rat NaPi-IIa, located in the 1st extracellular loop (18). Thus, we could verify labeling of the S520C mutant from the change in the voltage dependence of IPi. Next, we examined whether we could detect voltage-dependent changes in F after incubating with the Cys-reactive fluorescent probe MTS-TMR. Only four mutants (S155C, S226C, Q319C, and E451C, indicated by open circles in Fig. 1A) showed significant
Steady State and Presteady State Kinetics of WT and Mutants
Next, we compared the steady state and presteady state currents before and after labeling with MTS-TMR (WT, S155C, S226C, E451C) or MTSEA (WT, S155C, S226C, Q319C). For the WT, no difference was observed in either IPi (not shown) or presteady state current recordings before and after incubating with MTS-TMR (Fig. 2, A-C) or MTSEA (not shown), which is consistent with the assumption that none of the 19 native Cys of the flounder NaPi-IIb protein are accessible with this reagent. Similar results were obtained with MTSEA (not shown). The results agree with previous work, which showed that the WT rat NaPi-IIa isoform could not be labeled by Cys-reactive biotinylating reagents (19) and that WT flounder NaPi-IIb did not show any voltage-dependent In addition to Qmax, the apparent valency (z) and the midpoint of the Boltzmann distribution (V0.5) were also Na+-dependent (Fig. 2C). z varied between 0.3 and 0.6, depending on the Na+ concentration. For V0.5, the most negative value was obtained with 25 mM Na+, and increasing or decreasing Na+ from this value led to more positive V0.5 values. The V0.5 data obtained in the 25-125 mM range were fitted with a straight line to yield a slope of 113 ± 11 mV/log[Na] that was comparable to the values obtained for the mutants (S155C: 104 ± 12, S226C: 91 ± 4, Q319C: 105 ± 8 and E451C: 129 ± 5). The complex Na+ dependence of the parameters obtained from the Boltzmann fit most likely results from the contributions of more than two voltage-dependent partial reactions to the overall charge distribution (recall that Equation 2 describes a two-state model; for a detailed discussion, see e.g. Refs. 16 and 17).
For the three mutants S155S, S226C, and Q319C, we documented some minor alterations in the kinetics after labeling. IPi was 10-15% reduced after labeling for S155C, Q319C, and E451C in the voltage range -140 to +20 mV. For S226C, labeling resulting in an apparent reduction in the voltage dependence of Pi cotransport, as the slope of the I-V relationship decreased by
Finally, we investigated the effect of complete replacement of external Na+ by Li+ on the Q-V distribution of the WT NaPi-IIa protein. Li+ does not substitute for Na+ as the driving cation for Pi cotransport (not shown), yet evidence for an interaction of Li+ ions with the NaPi-II protein was obtained in our previous VCF study (4) using the S448C mutant. Replacing Na+ with Li+ still resulted in significant voltage-dependent F for this mutant whereas no
Voltage- and Substrate-dependent Fluorescence Signals Recorded from S155C, S226C, Q319C, and E451C: Mutant S155C Na+ DependenceLabeling S155C with MTS-TMR resulted in a construct for which robust voltage-dependent F (total F/F 3-6%) was observed in response to changes in membrane voltage. Fig. 3A shows an original fluorescence trace recorded in ND100 and ND0 solution. Stepping the membrane potential from Vh = -60 mV to more negative potentials decreased F, whereas it increased for more positive potentials. Because F saturated at both hyper- and hypopolarizing voltages, we could satisfactorily fit the F-V distribution with a Boltzmann function (Equation 2; solid lines in Fig. 3B). The F-V distribution was strongly dependent on Na+. Reducing the external Na+ concentration shifted the midpoint of the Boltzmann curve (V0.5) to the left (Fig. 3E), and the maximum amount of fluorescence change (Fmax) predicted from the fit was essentially constant between 125 and 50 mM Na+. At very low Na+, we were no longer able to obtain saturation of F at the hyperpolarizing limit; however by constraining Fmax to be the same at all Na+ concentrations, we could improve the quality of the fit significantly. We found a linear dependence of V0.5 on log[Na] in the 10 to 125 mM range, with a slope of 140 mV ± 5/log[Na] (Fig. 3E). Furthermore the steepness of the slope of the Boltzmann distribution (z) was reduced with decreasing Na+ (Fig. 3F).
Li+ DependenceTo investigate if F was also influenced by external Li+ ions as we previously reported for the S448C mutant (4), we repeated the above ion replacement protocol with Li+ as the variable cation (Fig. 3C). The maximum voltage-induced change in F was similar in LD100 and ND100, and we fitted the F-V distribution with a Boltzmann function (Equation 2). Reducing Li+ also shifted V0.5 to the left, however at low Li+ ( 10 mM) we could no longer fit the data reliably with Equation 2 because of the lack of saturation at the hyperpolarizing limit. As for Na+, Fmax reported by the fit remained reasonably constant between 100 and 10 mM Li+ and we therefore fixed this parameter to improve the quality of the fit. We found a linear dependence of V0.5 with log[Li] in the 10-100 mM range, with a slope of 154 mV ± 4/log[Li] (Fig. 3E). However, in contrast to Na+, z was not altered between 10 and 100 mM Li+ (Fig. 3F), which indicated that there are dissimilarities in the interaction of Na+ and Li+ with the NaPi-IIb protein.
Pi DependenceFinally, we measured the effect of increasing the Pi concentration on the F-V distribution while keeping Na+ constant at 100 mM. Increasing Pi markedly reduced Fmax (Fig. 3G), but had little effect on V0.5 or the apparent valency z (not shown). We plotted Fmax as a function of Pi concentration and fitted the data with the Michaelis-Menten equation (Equation 1 with H constrained to 1). The fit yielded an apparent affinity for the Pi-dependent decrease in Fmax of 99 ± 17 µM. This value is similar to Km(Pi) determined from the Pi-induced currents in Fig. 1D. The effect of Pi on F appears to have an absolute requirement for Na+. In LD100, Pi did not affect any of the Boltzmann fit parameters in a statistically significant manner (see Fig. 3C), which indicated that although Li+ may interact with the protein, it does not support Pi binding. Moreover, adding 1 mM Pi to ND0 solution did not alter the F-V distribution, as compared with ND0 alone, which further underscored the dependence of Pi interaction on Na+ (not shown).
Mutant S226C
Li+ DependenceThe effect of Li+ on the F-V distribution was similar to that of Na+ (Fig. 4C). The main difference was that the F-V distribution was shifted to more positive voltages compared with the equivalent Na+ concentrations, so that at 100 mM Li+, V0.5 was 73 ± 7 mV, compared with 32 ± 3 mV in 100 mM Na+. Like Na+, in Li+ the relationship between V0.5 and log[Li] was linear for Li+ concentrations Pi DependenceTo determine whether the F-V distribution was affected by Pi, we measured F in ND100, ND0, and LD100 with 1 mM Pi added in each case (Fig. 4, B and C). In ND100, Pi affected neither Fmax nor V0.5. However, the apparent valency was decreased from 0.45 ± 0.02 to 0.27 ± 0.04. When we added Pi to LD100, we observed a small, but statistically significant decrease in z from 0.42 ± 0.03 to 0.36 ± 0.03. As for ND100, no other Boltzmann fit parameters were significantly affected by adding Pi to LD100. Finally, in ND0 solution, we observed no effect on the F-V distribution after adding Pi. These findings indicate that the S226C site mainly senses conformational changes associated with the empty carrier and the Na+ (Li+) binding steps that precede Pi binding.
Mutant Q319C Na+ DependenceLabeling Q319C-expressing oocytes with MTS-TMR yielded voltage-dependent fluorescence (total F/F 1-3%) which, in contrast to the two mutants described above, decreased at depolarizing potentials. The F-V distributions for Na+ and Li+ dependence (shown in Fig. 5, B and C, respectively) resembled mirror images of those for S226C (Fig. 4, B and C). F recorded from Q319C saturated at both the hyper- and hypopolarizing limits. Like the other mutants, we obtained F-V data at different Na+ concentrations and fitted it with Equation 2 (solid lines in Fig. 5B). V0.5 in ND100 was 36 ± 2 mV, which is similar to that of S226C (32 ± 3 mV). There was a linear dependence of V0.5 on log[Na] for Na+ 50 mM, and linear regression (Fig. 4D) yielded a slope of 55 ± 3 mV/log[Na], which was also similar to the value obtained for S226C (58 ± 8 mV/log[Na]). Furthermore, z decreased with decreasing Na+ (Fig. 4E), whereas Fmax remained constant. Thus, Q319C strongly resembles S226C in its response to voltage and Na+, although it presents a mirror image with respect to the effect of membrane voltage on F.
Li+ DependenceThe effect of Li+ on the F-V distribution of Q319C (Fig. 5C) was quite similar to that of Na+, and thus this mutant phenotype mirrors that of S226C. Like S226C, the F-V distribution of Q319C was shifted to more positive voltages in Li+ solutions than in Na+. In LD100 V0.5 was 64 ± 4 mV, compared with only 36 ± 2 mV in ND100. In Li+ the relationship between V0.5 and log[Li] was linear for Li+ concentrations
Pi DependenceAdding 1 mM Pi to ND100 produced statistically significant changes in some of the Boltzmann fit parameters for Q319C. We observed a decrease of
Mutant E451C
Li+ DependenceThe Li+ dependence of F recorded from E451C is shown in Fig. 6C (solid lines represent the fit with Equation 2). As for Na+, Fmax remained constant in the range 50-100 mM, but was slightly smaller ( 10%) compared with Na+. In addition, z measured in Li+ was smaller than in Na+, and was reasonably constant over the range of Li+ concentrations used. For Li+ 25 mM (not shown) the data could no longer be reliably fit with Equation 2. The F-V distribution was shifted to more positive voltages in Li+ than in Na+, as illustrated by the V0.5 data (Fig. 6E), but unlike for Na+, the Li+ data did not show a linear variation with log [Li]. In general, the poor signal-to-noise ratio of the data made interpretation for this mutant difficult, and the results should therefore be treated with some caution. Pi DependenceThe Pi dependence (measured in ND100) of the F-V distribution of E451C is shown in Fig. 6D. F saturated at hyper- and hypopolarizing limits at all Pi concentrations used, and the data were fit with Equation 2 (solid lines in Fig. 6D). The effect of Pi on the F-V distribution closely mirrors that of S155C (Fig. 3G), whereby the effects of voltage on F were opposite. As Pi concentration increased, Fmax reported by the fit decreased By plotting the Fmax data as a function of Pi (Fig. 6G) and fitting with the Michaelis-Menten equation we obtained a Km(Pi) of 81 ± 34 µM, which was very similar to the value obtained for S155C (99 ± 17 µM, Fig. 3G). Another similarity to S155C was the finding that both V0.5 and z were only slightly affected by Pi (not shown).
Effect of Iodide on F We used iodide, a collisional quencher, to gain insight into whether the changes in fluorescence observed in the four mutants involve a change in the accessibility of the tethered fluorophore to the external medium. If the fluorescence decrease is caused by movement of the fluorophore into a more polar environment, then the decrease should be enhanced in iodide solution (5, 22). Fig. 7 shows F recorded in oocytes expressing S155C, S226C, Q319C, or E451C in ND100 solution and in 50 mM iodide solution. With the exception of S155C, three mutants responded to iodide by a decrease in Fmax (Table 2). The largest decrease occurred in E451C, where Fmax was reduced by 60% and V0.5 was right-shifted by 80 mV. Replacing 50 mM NaCl with 50 mM sodium glucuronate had no effect on any of the Boltzmann fit parameters for any of the mutants (not shown), indicating that the effects seen are specific to iodide. Thus, the result that iodide decreased, rather than enhanced, the voltage-dependent fluorescence changes for three of the four mutants would argue against the hypothesis that the fluorescence decrease is caused by movement of the fluorophore into a more polar extracellular medium.
The data do not allow us to determine whether the iodide effect is stronger at depolarizing or hyperpolarizing potentials (note that the F-V curves in Fig. 7 are shifted to Fmax for display purposes only). However, for E451C the right-shift in V0.5 indicates that iodide suppresses F mainly at hyperpolarizing potentials. Because iodide is negatively charged, this effect is not because of the membrane potential alone. It is possible that hyperpolarizing potentials increase the accessibility of the fluorophore tethered to E451C to the external medium, thus blunting the fluorescence increase.
In a previous study we established the methodology of VCF to investigate conformational changes in the type IIb Na/Pi cotransporter (4). We showed that after labeling the protein at a site in the large re-entrant loop in the second half of the protein (S448C; see Fig. 1A) with a fluorophore, we could measure substrate-and voltage-dependent changes in fluorescence. These changes are evidence of conformational changes that occur in the environment sensed by the fluorophore. In this present study we have used VCF to map regions in NaPi-IIb where conformational changes occur during the transport cycle. The new findings serve to deepen our understanding of the partial kinetic steps occurring during transport. We identified four sites which, when mutated to cysteines, could be labeled with a fluorophore and which showed voltage-and substrate-dependent changes in fluorescence. Unlike the previously characterized S448C mutant, whose cotransport activity was blocked after labeling (4), all four mutants identified in the present study remained fully functional after labeling with relatively small changes in their basic kinetics. Thus, the changes in fluorescence associated with each mutant measured under the same experimental conditions could reflect conformational changes that occur in four well-defined locales in the wild-type protein during its transport cycle. S226C and Q319CUnlike all other extracellular loop regions in the NaPi-II protein, the large extracellular glycosylated loop (ECL-2) between putative TMDs 3 and 4 (Fig. 8B) has not previously been subjected to cysteine scanning accessibility studies. Thus, we had no preconceptions about the role (if any) of this large loop in the transport cycle of NaPi-IIb. The mutants S226C and Q319C are located at opposite ends of the loop. Both mutants showed voltage-dependent F in the absence of Na+, suggesting that both of them report on conformational changes that occur in response to changes in voltage in the absence of substrate (empty carrier, transition 1-8 in Fig. 8A). Because in our model the empty carrier is assumed to possess one intrinsic negative charge (see Refs. 4, 14, 16), depolarizing potentials are predicted to increase the probability of a conformation in which the substrate binding sites face inward (state 8). Thus interpreting the F-V data for S226C and Q319C in Figs. 4 and 5 suggests that state 8 (empty carrier with inward-facing binding sites) is associated with high fluorescence for S226C and low fluorescence for Q319C. Because presteady state charge movements are associated with the empty carrier transition for all electrogenic NaPi-II isoforms (14, 16, 17), we can compare the data obtained for the charge-voltage (Q-V) and fluorescence-voltage (F-V) distributions. A comparison of the Boltzmann fit parameters obtained for both methods from experiments done in the absence of Na (ND0), showed that the midpoint (V0.5) for the F-V data were shifted toward more positive potentials, compared with the Q-V data: from the F-V data we obtained 33 ± 33 mV for S226C and 15 ± 5 mV for Q319C, whereas from the Q-V distribution, we obtained -45 ± 3 mV and -54 ± 4 mV, respectively. If both parameters reported on the same hypothetical empty carrier transition (1-8), we would expect the Boltzmann fit parameters to be the same. This discrepancy is not a consequence of labeling4 the transporter with MTS-TMR, since as shown in Fig. 2D, the change in V0.5 for the empty carrier after labeling is marginal. Instead, the discrepancy most likely arises because the Q-V distribution reports on the global distribution of charge in the membrane electrical field, whereas F reports on a local event.
When we compare the effect of substrate on S226C and Q319C, we see that the two mutants behave in a similar manner. Adding Na+ did not significantly change Fmax in either mutant but it did affect the midpoint of the F-V distribution (V0.5) and its steepness (z). In both mutants V0.5 was shifted to more positive potentials with increasing Na+ with a slope of 55-60 mV/log[Na]. This is significantly shallower than the
S155C and E451CS155C lies in a predicted intracellular re-entrant loop (ICL-1) between TMDs 2-3 (see Fig. 8B). We postulated that this residue could be accessed from the extracellular medium, because in the rat NaPi-IIa isoform, the residue at the equivalent position (Ser-183), when mutated to Cys could be modified by externally applied MTS reagents.5 When labeled with MTS-TMR, S155C showed a robust
E451C lies in the predicted extracellular re-entrant loop (ECL-3) between TMDs 5-6 (Fig. 8B). Interestingly, there is considerable intrasequence homology between ECL-3 and ICL-1, where S155C lies. Previous cysteine scanning work (19, 23, 24, 25) has shown that both regions are very important for transport function. Significantly, E451C lies very close to S448C, which also gives a strong F signal after labeling, but whose transport function is blocked by labeling (4). Unfortunately, a lack of saturation precluded a Boltzmann analysis of the fluorescence signal from S448C, but the data were consistent with Pi causing a profound reduction in Fmax when applied in Na+ solution. S155C and E451C both respond to Pi by decreasing Fmax with a Ki of
The midpoint voltages (V0.5)ofthe F-V distribution of S155C and E451C were both shifted to more negative potentials, compared with V0.5 measured from the Q-V distribution, at all Na+ concentrations used (in ND100 the shift was
Conformational Topology MapUsing the information obtained in this study on the response of mobile elements in the NaPi-II protein we can begin to construct a topology map that shows conformational changes and their relationship to substrate binding and translocation. Fig. 8A shows a kinetic scheme for the transport cycle of electrogenic Na/Pi-II transporters, which is based on results from earlier electrophysiology and fluorescence studies (4, 14, 16, 17). On the extracellular side, binding of two Na+ ions (transitions 1-2a-2b) precede the binding of one
In Fig. 8B we have redrawn the topology model of NaPi-II to show the locations of the four residues from which we could record voltage-and substrate-dependent fluorescence when labeled with MTS-TMR. The protein is divided into two halves (separated by the large extracellular loop) that are known to show considerable intrasequence homology (1, 24). We have assigned the two halves different colors that correspond to those in cartoon representations shown in Fig. 8C, which depicts a scenario of conformational states adopted by the protein during its cycling through the transport cycle of Fig. 8A. The cartoons attempt to explain the differential effects that voltage and substrate have on the fluorescence changes measured at the four sites. Note that we do not know the physical mechanism causing the fluorescence change. The iodide experiments suggest that the fluorescence decrease is not caused by movement of the fluorophore into the more polar extracellular environment, leaving other mechanisms such as quench by a nearby side chain residue, as a more likely option. State 1 represents the outward-facing conformation of the empty carrier. Because the empty carrier is assumed to carry one negative charge, this conformation predominates at very negative potentials. In this state, S155C and S226C both show minimal fluorescence, whereas fluorescence is maximal for Q319C and E451C. At very positive potentials the inward-facing configuration predominates (state 8), and the fluorescence intensities for the four sites are reversed. The transition 1-2b represents binding of the first two Na+ ions. This step is associated with a shift in the midpoint voltage (V0.5) to more positive potentials and an increase in the slope (z) of the F-V relationships for all four sites (see Figs. 3, 4, 5, 6). The shift in V0.5 indicates that at a given voltage, an increase in external Na+ increases the probability of the protein adopting an outward-facing configuration, whereas the increase in z indicates that an increase occurs in the apparent valency of the charges that move in the electrical field, presumably contributed by the Na+ ions. For S226C and Q319C, z was less dependent on Na+ compared with S155C and E451C, which suggested that the voltage-dependent fluorescence changes reported by the former pair do not strongly reflect Na+-induced conformational changes. Note that although the F-V data were fitted with a single Boltzmann, which implies a model where only two states are possible, the underlying processes certainly are more complex and this is exemplified by the dependence of z on [Na]. The change in the Boltzmann fit parameters documented for the four sites therefore arise from changes in the occupancies of several possible conformational states that all contribute to the overall F-V distribution. Transition 2b-4 represents binding of one divalent Pi and the last Na+ ion to their respective binding sites that were exposed after binding of the first two Na+ ions. In the case of S226C and Q319C, adding Pi caused only minor changes in the F-V distribution recorded at the two sites. This indicates that conformational changes relating to Pi binding and substrate translocation do not significantly perturb the environment of these two sites. Whether or not the transporter undergoes the full transport cycle has only minor effects on the fluorescence recorded at these sites. For simplicity, the cartoons show that all outward-facing conformations decrease the fluorescence of S226C, and all inward-facing conformations decrease fluorescence of Q319C. In contrast, for S155C and E451C, application of Pi (in the presence of Na+) caused a concentration-dependent reduction in Fmax. This implies that in the presence of both substrates, the protein adopts conformations (states 4-5) where the fluorescence can no longer be effectively decreased by extreme hyper- or depolarizing potentials, respectively. Because the protein now is able to undergo a full transport cycle, we do not know which conformational states contribute the most to these fluorescence measurements, because the measured fluorescence arises from all possible states weighted by their respective occupancy probabilities and fluorescence intensities. We have drawn the cartoons to show that after binding of Pi and the third Na+ ion, the conformation of the protein is altered so that the fluorescence of S155C and E451C does not decrease at hyper- and depolarizing potentials, respectively. The data do not, however, allow us to identify the contribution to the fluorescence of individual states when both substrates are present.
We have identified four sites in the flounder Na/Pi-IIb protein which, when labeled with a fluorescent probe, give rise to voltage-and substrate-dependent fluorescence signals. Mutating the residues to cysteines and subsequent labeling with a Cys-reactive fluorescent probe caused only minor changes in the transport kinetics of the protein, indicating that the fluorescence reported on conformational changes of a minimally perturbed protein. The results show that at least a part of the large glycosylated loop between TMDs 3 and 4 is associated with conformational changes, and that these are mainly related to the transition of the empty carrier and the first Na+ binding step(s). In contrast, the two re-entrant loops located between TMDs 2-3 and 5-6 participate in conformational changes that additionally are influenced by Pi binding and/or substrate translocation. The results represent a first step in mapping time-resolved conformational changes of type II Na/Pi cotransporters.
* This work was supported in part by the Gebert Rüf Foundation and the Swiss National Science Foundation (to H. M.). The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact. 1 To whom correspondence may be addressed: Institute of Physiology, University of Zurich-Irchel, Winterthurerstrasse 190, CH-8057 Zurich, Switzerland. Tel.: 41-44-635-5059; Fax: 41-44-635-5615; E-mail: leilav{at}physiol.unizh.ch. 2 To whom correspondence may be addressed. E-mail: IForster{at}access.unizh.ch.
3 The abbreviations used are: VCF, voltage clamp fluorometry; WT, wild type; ANOVA, analysis of variance; TMD, transmembrane domain; MTSEA, (2-aminoethyl)methane thiosulfonate hydrobromide; MTS-TMR, 2-((5 (6)-tetramethylrhodamine)carboxylamino)ethyl methanethiosulfonate.
4 We do not know if all transporters in the membrane are labeled with the reagent, or if significant amounts of unlabeled protein remains. This is of no consequence for the fluorescence measurement, because F is only measured from labeled transporters and thus represents a homogenous population. However, when measuring presteady state currents, both labeled and unlabeled cotransporters contribute to the measurements, and since for both S155C and S226C labeling tended to shift the V0.5 values of the Q-V distribution towards those of the F-V distribution, the question rises whether the remaining difference results from contamination of the Q-V distribution with unlabeled protein. However, because we observed qualitatively similar results using MTSEA, which has a higher reactivity than MTS-TMR and therefore could be expected to react with a larger number of transporters, we assume that the contribution of unlabeled transporters to the Q-V distribution is negligible. Furthermore, the change in the Boltzmann parameters determined from presteady state currents before and after labeling with MTSEA was much smaller (Fig. 2) than the differences we documented between the Q-V and F-V data.
5 Radanovic, T., Gisler, S. M., Biber, J., and Murer, H. (2006) J. Membr. Biol., in press.
6 T. Radanovic, unpublished observation.
We thank Eva Hänsenberger for preparing oocytes.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Advertisement | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||