Nitric oxide synthases (NOSs) are flavo-heme enzymes whose electron transfer reactions are controlled by calmodulin (CaM). The NOS flavoprotein domain includes a ferredoxin-NADP+-reductase (FNR)-like module that contains NADPH and FAD binding sites. FNR-like modules in related flavoproteins have three conserved residues that regulate electron transfer between bound NAD(P)H and FAD. To investigate the function of one of these residues in neuronal NOS (nNOS), we generated and characterized mutants that had Val, Glu or Asn substituted for the conserved Asp1393. All three mutants exhibited normal composition, spectral properties, and binding of cofactors, substrates, and CaM. All had slower NADPH-dependent cytochrome c and ferricyanide reductase activities, which were associated with proportionally slower rates of NADPH-dependent flavin reduction in the CaM-free and CaM-bound states. Rates of NO synthesis were also proportionally slower in the mutants and were associated with slower rates of CaM-dependent ferric heme reduction. However, a D1393V mutant whose flavins had been pre-reduced with NADPH had a normal rate of heme reduction. This indicated that the kinetic defect was restricted to flavin reduction step(s) in the mutants, and suggested that this limited their catalytic activities. Together, our results show (1) The presence and positioning of the Asp1393 carboxylate side chain are critical to enable NADPH-dependent reduction of the nNOS flavoprotein and (2) Control of flavin reduction is important because it insures that the rate of heme reduction is sufficiently fast to enable NO synthesis by nNOS.