Cardiolipin Regulates Mitophagy through the Protein Kinase C Pathway*

Cardiolipin (CL), the signature phospholipid of mitochondrial membranes, is important for cardiovascular health, and perturbation of CL metabolism is implicated in cardiovascular disease. Although the role of CL in mitochondrial function, biogenesis, and genome stability has been studied, recent findings indicate that it is essential for functions apart from mitochondrial bioenergetics. In this study, we report that mitophagy is perturbed in CL-deficient yeast cells. Mutants of autophagy/mitophagy genes ATG8, ATG18, and ATG32 synthetically interact with CL synthase mutant crd1Δ. CL-deficient cells exhibited decreased GFP-tagged mitochondrial proteins inside the vacuole and decreased free GFP, consistent with decreased mitophagy. Both PKC and high osmolarity glycerol (HOG) MAPK pathways were shown previously to be required for mitophagy. Activation of both MAPKs was defective in CL-deficient cells. Deletion of HOG pathway genes SHO1, SSK1, STE50, and HOG1 exacerbated crd1Δ growth. 1 m sorbitol and 0.2 m NaCl, which induce the HOG pathway, rescued growth of the mutant. Activation of the MAPK Slt2p was defective in crd1Δ cells, and up-regulation of the PKC pathway by expression of the PKC1R398P gene, which encodes constitutively activated Pkc1p, rescued crd1Δ growth and mitophagy defects. These findings indicate that loss of CL impairs MAPK pathway activation, and decreased activation of the PKC pathway leads to defective mitophagy.

The anionic phospholipid cardiolipin (CL) 2 is synthesized and primarily localized in the mitochondrial inner membrane. The importance of CL is underscored by the association of CL abnormalities with various cardiovascular diseases, including the life-threatening genetic disorder Barth syndrome (BTHS), diabetic cardiomyopathy, atherosclerosis, myocardial ischemiareperfusion injury, heart failure, and Tangier disease (1). Among these, BTHS is directly linked to perturbation of CL metabolism, because it results from mutations in the CL remodeling enzyme tafazzin (TAZ/G4.5) (2,3). BTHS manifests clinically as cardiomyopathy, skeletal myopathy, neutropenia, and growth retardation. The biochemical phenotypes at the cellular level include decreased CL levels, increased monolysocardiolipin, and altered CL fatty acyl composition (4 -6). Interestingly, the clinical presentation of BTHS varies from asymptomatic to neonatal death, even among patients with identical tafazzin mutations, indicating that physiological modifiers of CL deficiency affect the clinical presentation of BTHS. Studies with yeast CL mutants indicate that CL plays an essential role in numerous cellular functions in addition to mitochondrial bioenergetics, which may be modifiers of the BTHS phenotype (7)(8)(9)(10)(11)(12).
We have shown previously that the CL synthase mutant crd1⌬, which lacks CL, exhibits enlarged vacuoles, decreased vacuolar ATPase activity and proton pumping, and loss of vacuole acidification (10). The mechanism underlying vacuolar perturbation in CL-deficient cells is not understood. Autophagy, which can result in an influx of membrane and organelle contents to the vacuole, is one important route to affect the vacuolar size (13)(14)(15). Mitophagy is the selective degradation of mitochondria by autophagy in response to different stresses (16 -18). Because the lack of CL leads to impaired mitochondrial function, including defective respiration (19), decreased mitochondrial membrane potential (20), and impaired mitochondrial protein import (12,20), it is reasonable to speculate that CL deficiency might lead to increased mitophagy to eliminate damaged mitochondria, possibly resulting in enlarged vacuoles. Alternatively, perturbation of vacuolar function in CL mutant cells may deleteriously affect autophagy.
Mitophagy is regulated by two MAPK pathways, the PKC and high osmolarity glycerol (HOG) pathways (21). In response to induction of mitophagy, the PKC MAPK Slt2p is activated by phosphorylation of threonine and tyrosine residues. Deletion of the PKC pathway genes BCK1, MKK1/MKK2, and SLT2 leads to defective mitophagy. Similarly, perturbation of the HOG pathway by deletion of HOG1, PBS2, and SSK1 results in defective mitophagy. Interestingly, CL and/or the CL precursor phosphatidylglycerol (PG) are required for Slt2p phosphorylation, which is decreased in the pgs1⌬ mutant, which cannot synthesize PG or CL (22).
Perturbation of vacuolar function and defective activation of the PKC pathway in CL mutants suggested that CL deficiency leads to perturbation of mitophagy as a result of defective MAPK activation. In the current study, we demonstrate that CL mutants exhibit defective mitophagy, which is rescued by upregulation of the PKC pathway.

Deletion of Autophagy/Mitophagy Genes Exacerbates crd1⌬
Temperature Sensitivity-We previously observed that CL mutants exhibit vacuole defects characterized by enlarged vacuoles and loss of vacuole acidification at elevated temperature (10). To test the possibility that vacuole defects in CL-deficient cells resulted in perturbation of mitophagy, we examined genetic interactions between CRD1 and autophagy/mitophagy genes. If vacuolar defects resulted from increased mitophagy, deleting mitophagy/autophagy genes in crd1⌬ would be expected to rescue temperature sensitivity of the mutant. In contrast, if crd1⌬ defects resulted from decreased mitophagy, they would be exacerbated by deletion of autophagy/mitophagy genes.
Genetic interactions focused on three mitophagy ATG genes, ATG8, ATG18, and ATG32. During macromitophagy, mitochondria are brought to the phagophore assembly site (PAS), where the double membrane of the phagophore expands and closes to form a mature mitophagosome that contains mitochondria. Macromitophagy adapts the general autophagy core machinery, which involves various autophagy-related (ATG) proteins (23)(24)(25)(26)(27)(28)(29). Among these, Atg8p and Atg18p are essential components of the general autophagy core machinery. Atg8p, the yeast homolog of mammalian LC3, is conjugated to phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) (30). Atg8p-PE coats the mitophagosome membrane during membrane elongation. Atg18p binds to phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate and regulates the retrieval of Atg9p from PAS. Normal transport of Atg9p between PAS and the peripheral site is essential for phosphatidylinositol 3-phosphate synthesis on the mitophagosome membrane (23). The mitochondrial outer membrane protein Atg32p plays a key role in selecting mitochondria as the specific cargo. When mitophagy is triggered, Atg32p is phosphorylated (31) and is involved in directing mitochondria to the PAS through interaction with other ATG machinery (31,32). Analysis of the double mutants (crd1⌬ and a mutation in ATG8, ATG18, or ATG32) indicated that deletion of these autophagy/ mitophagy genes exacerbated the temperature sensitivity of crd1⌬ ( Fig. 1) (data not shown). Deletion of general autophagy genes ATG8 and ATG18 was more deleterious than deletion of the mitophagy-specific gene ATG32. These findings suggested that mitophagy may be decreased in crd1⌬ cells.
Induction of Mitophagy Is Inhibited in crd1⌬ Cells-We directly assayed mitophagy in WT and crd1⌬ cells expressing the mitochondrial protein Idh1 tagged with GFP at the gene locus, as described previously (33). WT and crd1⌬ cells expressing Idh1-GFP (WT-IDH1-GFP and crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP) were cultured in yeast extract peptone dextrose (YPD) medium to the mid-log phase at 30°C and then switched to 39°C for 8 h and observed under fluorescence microscopy. In WT cells, increased temperature led to vacuolar accumulation of GFP. However, translocation of Idh1-GFP was not observed in crd1⌬ cells (Fig. 2).
Defective mitophagy was also observed in crd1⌬ cells in the BY4742 genetic background, which is widely used in mitophagy studies (34). WT-IDH1-GFP and crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP cells were cultured in synthetic complete (SC) medium to the mid-log phase at 30°C, harvested, washed twice, and resuspended in synthetic lactate (SL) medium for 18 h and observed under fluorescence microscopy. The accumulation of GFP was visualized in the vacuole of WT but not crd1⌬ cells, suggesting that mitophagy was inhibited in the mutant (Fig. 3A). To exclude the possibility that the observed differences were specific to the Idh1-GFP protein, we carried out similar experiments in which the GFP-tagged mitochondrial protein Idp1p was exogenously expressed from the pCu416-IDP1-GFP plasmid. Similar to the findings with Idh1 (Fig. 3B), accumulation of Idp1-GFP was observed in the vacuole of the WT but not crd1⌬ cells, consistent with decreased mitophagy in the mutant.
Protein was extracted from WT-IDH1-GFP and crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP cells in which mitophagy was induced with SL medium, and the release of free GFP from endogenous Idh1-GFP was examined by Western blotting. A GFP band was detectable in WT cells from 6 h after transferring to SL medium but was barely detectable in crd1⌬ cells (Fig. 3C). Preliminary evidence using an Idp1-GFP reporter and following a stationary phase mitophagy protocol as described previously (35) gave results consistent with a mitophagy defect in CL mutant cells (not shown). Taken together, these findings indicate that mitophagy is decreased in CL-deficient cells.
HOG Pathway Activation Is Impaired in crd1⌬ Cells-The HOG pathway is an upstream regulator of mitophagy, and deletion of HOG pathway genes HOG1 and PBS2 leads to defective mitophagy (21). We investigated the possibility that the HOG pathway is perturbed in crd1⌬ cells. Genetic interaction of CRD1 and HOG1 was assessed by growth of the crd1⌬hog1⌬ double mutant at elevated temperature. Mutants ssk1⌬, ste50⌬, sho1⌬, and hog1⌬ were synthetically lethal with crd1⌬ at ele- vated temperature (Fig. 4A). Moreover, overexpression of negative regulators of the HOG pathway, PTP2 and PTP3, were deleterious to growth of crd1⌬ cells (Fig. 4B). Because constitutive activation of the HOG pathway causes lethality (36,37), it is not feasible to determine whether up-regulating the pathway rescues the CL mutant defects. These findings indicated that down-regulation of the HOG pathway exacerbated the temperature sensitive growth defects of the CL mutant.
To determine whether the HOG pathway is impaired in crd1⌬ cells, Hog1p activation was induced with 0.5 M NaCl for 5 min, and Hog1 phosphorylation was analyzed by Western blotting as described (8,38). Compared with WT cells, Hog1 activation, as detected by phosphorylation, was decreased in crd1⌬ in response to osmotic stress (Fig. 5A). However, translocation of phosphorylated Hog1-GFP into the nucleus was not decreased in mutant cells expressing the pPS1739 plasmid con-taining HOG1-GFP (Fig. 5B). We previously demonstrated that 1 M sorbitol, which induces the HOG pathway, rescued crd1⌬ growth and vacuole defects (10). In agreement with this finding, 200 mM NaCl, which also activates the HOG pathway, similarly rescued crd1⌬ temperature sensitivity (Fig. 5C). Taken together, these findings suggest that CL deficiency leads to decreased activation of the HOG pathway due to decreased phosphorylation of Hog1.
Up-regulation of the PKC Pathway Rescues Mitophagy in crd1⌬ Cells-Similar to the HOG pathway, the PKC pathway is also a regulator of mitophagy (17). Deletion of PKC pathway genes BCK1, MKK1/MKK2, and SLT2 leads to defective mitophagy (21). As mentioned above, a previous study indicated that activation of Slt2p is decreased in pgs1⌬ cells, which lack both PG and CL (22). We wished to determine whether PG can substitute for CL for activation (dual phosphorylation) of Slt2p. Compared with WT, dual phosphorylation of Slt2p was significantly decreased in both crd1⌬ and pgs1⌬ cells after 2 h at 39°C (Fig. 6A).
Interestingly, up-regulation of the PKC pathway by expression of BCK1-20 and PKC1 R398P genes, which encode constitutively activated proteins, rescued crd1⌬ temperature sensitivity (Fig. 6B). The effect of PKC1 R398P expression on delivery of mitochondria to the vacuole in response to activation of mitophagy was investigated in WT-IDH1-GFP and crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP strains. Accumulation of GFP was observed in the vacuole of WT-IDH1-GFP cells containing either the empty vector or vector expressing PKC1 R398P . Consistent with the previous experiment (Fig. 3A), GFP accumulation was not observed in crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP cells containing the empty vector. However, expression of PKC1 R398P led to accumulation of GFP in crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP cells, consistent with restoration of mitophagy (Fig. 7A). The release of free GFP was assessed by Western blotting. After 6 h of SL induction, free GFP was observed in crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP cells expressing PKC1 R398P to a level comparable with that of WT-IDH1-GFP cells (Fig. 7B). These findings suggest that up-regulation of the PKC pathway restores mitophagy in crd1⌬ cells.

Discussion
In this study, we show that decreased activation of the MAPK Slt2 in CL-deficient cells leads to decreased mitophagy. Our specific findings indicated that 1) deletion of autophagy/mitophagy genes exacerbated crd1⌬ growth defects; 2) GFPtagged mitochondrial proteins were largely decreased in the vacuole of crd1⌬ cells in conditions that induce mitophagy; 3) activation of HOG and PKC MAPK pathways required for mitophagy were defective in crd1⌬ cells; and 4) increased activation of Slt2p phosphorylation rescued growth and mitophagy defects in the CL mutant.
Interestingly, deletion of general autophagy genes required for all forms of macroautophagy, including mitophagy, exacerbated crd1⌬ growth defects to a greater extent than deletion of mitophagy-specific genes. As seen in Fig. 1B, crd1⌬ is synthetically lethal with atg8⌬ and atg18⌬ but only synthetically sick with atg32⌬. This suggests that CL is required for mitophagy but not for nonselective autophagy. In this scenario, if nonselective autophagy functions normally in crd1⌬, damaged mito- were cultured in YPD medium to the mid-log phase at 30°C and then shifted to 39°C for 8 h and observed under fluorescence microscopy. All images were taken at the same magnification (ϫ1000). Bar, 2 m. were cultured in SC medium to the mid-log phase at 30°C and shifted to SL for 18 h. Cells were observed under fluorescence microscopy. C, WT and crd1⌬ cells carrying the GFP-tagged IDH1 gene were precultured in SC medium to the mid-log phase at 30°C and shifted to SL medium for the indicated time. Aliquots were analyzed by immunoblotting with anti-YFP antibody, and the positions of full-length Idh1-GFP and free GFP are indicated. Images in A and B were taken at the same magnification (ϫ1000). Bar, 2 m. Numbers at the bottom of C show the density ratios for GFP to Idh1-GFP in each lane. DIC, differential interference contrast. chondria may be delivered to the vacuole for degradation as cargo in the nonselective autophagosome. If nonselective autophagy is blocked by deletion of ATG8 or ATG18, cells will be unable to eliminate damaged mitochondria. If mitophagy is further impaired by the deletion of ATG32, a portion of damaged mitochondria may be eliminated by nonselective autophagy, resulting in a sick but not lethal phenotype. Consistent with this possibility, mitophagy is not completely absent from crd1⌬ cells. A small band corresponding to free GFP was detected by Western blotting in crd1⌬-IDH1-GFP extracts after induction of mitophagy (Fig. 3C), and phosphorylation of Slt2 and Hog1 upon induction by heat or osmotic stress was decreased but not completely blocked in the mutant (Figs. 5A and 6A).
Both MAPK pathways that are required for mitophagy are perturbed in the crd1⌬ mutant, which exhibited decreased phosphorylation of Hog1 (Fig. 5A) and Slt2 (Fig. 6A). Up-regulation of the PKC pathway by expressing constitutively activated PKC pathway effectors rescued the growth and mitophagy defects of crd1⌬ cells (Figs. 6B and 7). Because constitutive activation of the HOG pathway causes lethality, it is not feasible to determine whether up-regulating this pathway rescues the CL mutant defects. Physiological conditions that activate the HOG pathway, including 1 M sorbitol and 0.2 M NaCl, rescue crd1⌬ temperature sensitivity. However, because sorbitol and NaCl also regulate other parameters (e.g. osmotic and ion homeostasis), it cannot be concluded that perturbation of the HOG pathway causes defective mitophagy in crd1⌬ cells.
Several studies suggest that tafazzin deficiency, which results in decreased CL, increased monoloyso-CL, and decreased unsaturated CL species, leads to defective mitophagy. Tafazzindeficient yeast cells are synthetically lethal with mutants lacking the catalytic subunit of the mitochondrial inner membrane i-AAA protease (39). In tafazzin-deficient primary mouse embryonic fibroblasts, the formation of mitophagosomes is impaired (40). Kagan and co-workers (41) observed that exter-nalization of CL to the outer mitochondrial membrane acts as an elimination signal for the mitophagic machinery in human neuronal cells. Our findings are the first to implicate CL-mediated activation of PKC in the regulation of mitophagy.
The mechanism whereby CL deficiency impairs PKC and HOG pathway activation is not known. One possibility is suggested by the finding that, in yeast mitochondria, CL and PG specifically bind to and activate inositol phosphosphingolipid phospholipase C (Isc1), which hydrolyzes complex sphingolipids to generate ceramide (39). Similarly, mitochondria-associated neutral sphingomyelinase, the mammalian orthologue of Isc1, was shown to be activated by anionic phospholipids, especially phosphatidylserine and mitochondrial CL (42). In mammals, ceramide activates PKC-(43, 44) but inhibits PKC-and PKC-␦ in mammals (45,46). Yeast has only one PKC (Pkc1) isozyme, and its regulation by ceramide has not been studied. Thus, the role of CL in the regulation of the PKC pathway via ceramide is an exciting area for future study.
In summary, we demonstrate for the first time that loss of CL leads to decreased activation of PKC and HOG pathways, resulting in impaired mitophagy. These findings provide novel insights into the cellular functions of CL outside of mitochondrial bioenergetics.
The ATG deletion mutants were constructed as follows. The entire open reading frame of the target gene was replaced by a KanMX4 cassette via homologous recombination in WT or crd1⌬ cells. The KanMX4 cassette was amplified by PCR using the pUG6 plasmid, which contains the KanMX4 cassette as the template. The amplification primers consisted of 50 nucleo-tides that were identical to the upstream or downstream flanking region of the target gene at the 5Ј end and 21 nucleotides that annealed to the KanMX4 gene at the 3Ј end. Transformants were selected on YPD plates with 200 g/ml G418. Deletion of the target gene was confirmed by PCR using primers that amplified the original target gene.
WT and crd1⌬ cells that express the mitochondrial matrix protein Idh1p tagged by GFP at the gene locus were constructed as described previously (47). The pFA6a-GFP (S65T)-HIS3MX6 plasmid that was used as the PCR template to amplify the DNA fragment encoding GFP was kindly provided by Dr. Daniel Klionsky (University of Michigan).
Plasmid Construction and Cloning-To construct the PTP2 overexpression plasmid, a sequence of 2250 base pairs that includes the entire open reading frame of PTP2 was amplified from yeast genomic DNA using KpnI-tagged forward primer PTP2fr-f (5Ј-GG GGTACCATTGATGGATCGCATAGCA-CAG-3Ј) and XbaI-tagged reverse primer PTP2fr-r (5Ј-CGCTCTAGATTAACAAGGTAACGCGTTCTTTATC-3Ј). Following digestion with KpnI and XbaI, the PCR product was ligated downstream of the PGK1 promoter on the pYPGK18 (2 m, LEU2) plasmid. To construct the PTP3 overexpression plasmid, a sequence of 2751 base pairs that contains the entire open reading frame of PTP3 was amplified from yeast genomic DNA using EcoRI-tagged forward primer PTP3fr-f (5Ј-CCG-GAATTC GAACATGAAGGACAGTGTAGACTGC-3Ј) and BamHI-tagged reverse primer PTP3fr-r (5Ј-CGCGGATC-CGCCTAACTATTGTGGCAATTCTTTC-3Ј). Following digestion with KpnI and XbaI, the PCR product was ligated downstream of the PGK1 promoter on the pYPGK18 plasmid. The pPS1739 plasmid, which expresses HOG1-GFP, was kindly FIGURE 5. Decreased Hog1p phosphorylation in the crd1⌬ mutant. A, cells in the BY4742 genetic background were precultured in YPD at 30°C to the mid-log phase and treated with 0.5 M NaCl for 5 min. Dual phosphorylated (activated) and total Hog1 proteins were detected by Western blotting, as described previously (8). B, WT and crd1⌬ cells expressing Hog1-GFP on the plasmid pPS1739 were grown in SC ura Ϫ to an A 550 of 1, treated with 0.5 M NaCl for 5 min, and then observed using fluorescence microscopy. C, WT and crd1⌬ cells in the FGY background were precultured in YPD liquid at 30°C to the mid-log phase. 200 cells were plated on a YPD plate with or without 200 mM NaCl. Plates were then incubated at 37.5°C for 3 days. Numbers at the bottom of A show the density ratios for p-Hog1p to Hog1p in each lane. Images in B were taken at the same magnification (ϫ1000). Bar, 2 m. DIC, differential interference contrast. FIGURE 6. Up-regulation of the PKC pathway rescues the crd1⌬ growth defect. A, cells in the BY4742 genetic background were precultured in liquid YPD at 30°C to the mid-log phase, diluted to an A 550 of 0.3, and treated with increased temperature or 1 M sorbitol for 2 h. Cell extracts were prepared and activated (dual phosphorylated), and total Slt2 protein was detected by Western blotting. B, cells expressing BCK1-20 and PKC1 R398P plasmids were cultured in SC ura Ϫ medium at 30°C to the mid-log phase, diluted, spotted on SC ura Ϫ plates, and incubated at 30 or 38°C for 2 days. Numbers at the bottom of A show the density ratios for p-Slt2p to Slt2p in each lane. provided by Dr. Pamela Silver (Harvard Medical School). The PKC up-regulation plasmids pYcp50::PKC1 R398P and pRS352::BCK1-20 and corresponding empty vectors were kindly provided by Dr. Michael Hall (Biozentrum, University of Basel). The plasmids were transformed into yeast cells using the yeast one-step transformation protocol (48).
Analysis of Synthetic Lethality-The crd1⌬ mutant was crossed to sho1⌬, ssk1⌬, ste50⌬, and hog1⌬ mutants obtained from the deletion collection generated in the BY4741 (MATa) background (Research Genetics). Diploids were sporulated on sporulation media, and tetrads were obtained. Haploids were then acquired via tetrad dissection. Haploids containing mutations in both CRD1 and one of the four HOG pathway genes were selected by uracil prototrophy (crd1⌬ mutation) and Geneticin resistance (HOG pathway mutation). Growth of double mutants was examined at elevated temperature to identify synthetic lethality.
Fluorescence Microscopy and Analysis-All microscopic analyses were performed using an Olympus BX41 fluorescence microscope. Images were captured by an Olympus Q-Color3 digital CCD camera operated by QCapture2 software. All pictures were taken at the same magnification (ϫ1000). To visualize vacuolar morphology in yeast, FM 4-64 staining was performed as described previously (49) with minor revisions. To monitor mitophagy, cells expressing IDH1-GFP from the gene locus or IDP1-GFP from an exogenous plasmid were treated with different mitophagy-inducing conditions, and the increase in vacuolar mito-GFP indicative of mitophagy was determined.
Western Blotting Detection of Free GFP-Whole cell extracts were prepared as described previously (47) with minor changes. Proteins from cell pellets equivalent to 1.5 A 550 units were collected and loaded into a 12% SDS-polyacrylamide gel for electrophoresis. Proteins were then transferred to a PVDF membrane with 0.2-m pores following the standard semidry Western blotting transfer procedure. Mouse anti-YFP monoclonal antibody (JL-8, Clontech) was used as primary antibody at a 1:3000 dilution, and HRP-conjugated goat anti-mouse IgG (Santa Cruz Biotechnology, Inc.) was used as the secondary FIGURE 7. Up-regulation of the PKC pathway restores mitophagy in crd1⌬. BY WT-IDH1-GFP and crd1-IDH1-GFP cells containing either an empty vector or a vector expressing PKC1 R398P were cultured in SC ura Ϫ medium to the mid-log phase at 30°C, washed, and shifted to SL (to induce mitophagy). Aliquots were observed 18 h after shift under fluorescence microscopy (A), and full-length Idh1-GFP and free GFP were identified by Western blotting using anti-GFP antibody 6 h after shift (B). Images in A were taken at the same magnification (ϫ1000). Bar, 2 m. Numbers at the bottom of B show the density ratios for GFP to Idh1-GFP in each lane. DIC, differential interference contrast.  FBRUARY 17, 2017 • VOLUME 292 • NUMBER 7 antibody at a 1:5000 dilution. After blotting, the PVDF membrane was covered with Pierce TM ECL Plus Western blotting substrate reagent (ThermoFisher Scientific). The HyBlot ES autoradiography film was exposed to the PVDF membrane and then developed. Idh1-GFP and cleaved GFP were detected as bands of 68 and 28 kDa, respectively. Phosphorylation of Hog1p was determined by Western blotting using anti-phospho-p38 rabbit IgG antibody (3D7; Cell Signaling) as described previously (8). Phosphorylation of Slt2p was determined by Western blotting using anti-phospho-p44/42 MAPK (Thr 202 /Tyr 204 ) rabbit IgG antibody (catalog no. 9102, Cell Signaling) as described previously (22)