Introduction
Cholelithiasis, manifested by the presence of gallstones in the gallbladder, is one of the most prevalent gastroenterological diseases. Currently there are about 15% of adults with gallstones in industrial countries (
1Gallstone disease: Epidemiology of gallbladder stone disease.
,
2Mechanisms of disease: The genetic epidemiology of gallbladder stones.
). The prevalence of gallstone disease appears to increase with age (
2Mechanisms of disease: The genetic epidemiology of gallbladder stones.
,
3- Everhart J.E.
- Khare M.
- Hill M.
- Maurer K.R.
Prevalence and ethnic differences in gallbladder disease in the United States.
). Although most gallstones remain asymptomatic, symptoms can ensue in about 25% of cases, with complications ranging from biliary colic to cholecystitis to life-threatening cholangitis (
3- Everhart J.E.
- Khare M.
- Hill M.
- Maurer K.R.
Prevalence and ethnic differences in gallbladder disease in the United States.
,
4- Marschall H.U.
- Einarsson C.
Gallstone disease.
,
5Hereditary liver disease: gallstones.
). A recent study characterizes cholelithiasis as an independent risk factor for mortality in U.S. men and women (
6- Zheng Y.
- Xu M.
- Heianza Y.
- Ma W.
- Wang T.
- Sun D.
- Albert C.M.
- Hu F.B.
- Rexrode K.M.
- Manson J.E.
- Qi L.
Gallstone disease and increased risk of mortality: Two large prospective studies in US men and women.
). To date, there is no cure for cholelithiasis, except for the surgical removal of the gallstone-laden gallbladder by laparoscopic cholecystectomy (
7- Sandblom G.
- Videhult P.
- Crona Guterstam Y.
- Svenner A.
- Sadr-Azodi O.
Mortality after a cholecystectomy: A population-based study.
). In the United States alone, there are about 700,000 cholecystectomies performed per year with an annual cost of more than $6 billion (
8- Sandler R.S.
- Everhart J.E.
- Donowitz M.
- Adams E.
- Cronin K.
- Goodman C.
- Gemmen E.
- Shah S.
- Avdic A.
- Rubin R.
The burden of selected digestive diseases in the United States.
,
9Gallstone disease: From genes to evidence-based therapy.
). Apart from its huge economic burden imposed on the health care system, cholecystectomy is associated with risk of postoperative mortality (
7- Sandblom G.
- Videhult P.
- Crona Guterstam Y.
- Svenner A.
- Sadr-Azodi O.
Mortality after a cholecystectomy: A population-based study.
). Studies are warranted to better understand the mechanism underlying gallstone formation and progression for the development of nonsurgical therapies to prevent or ameliorate cholelithiasis (
10- Rebholz C.
- Krawczyk M.
- Lammert F.
Genetics of gallstone disease.
,
11- Maurer K.J.
- Carey M.C.
- Fox J.G.
Roles of infection, inflammation, and the immune system in cholesterol gallstone formation.
,
12- Wang H.H.
- Portincasa P.
- Mendez-Sanchez N.
- Uribe M.
- Wang D.Q.
Effect of ezetimibe on the prevention and dissolution of cholesterol gallstones.
,
13- Venneman N.G.
- Besselink M.G.
- Keulemans Y.C.
- Vanberge-Henegouwen G.P.
- Boermeester M.A.
- Broeders I.A.
- Go P.M.
- van Erpecum K.J.
Ursodeoxycholic acid exerts no beneficial effect in patients with symptomatic gallstones awaiting cholecystectomy.
,
14- Ferkingstad E.
- Oddsson A.
- Gretarsdottir S.
- Benonisdottir S.
- Thorleifsson G.
- Deaton A.M.
- Jonsson S.
- Stefansson O.A.
- Norddahl G.L.
- Zink F.
- Arnadottir G.A.
- Gunnarsson B.
- Halldorsson G.H.
- Helgadottir A.
- Jensson B.O.
- et al.
Genome-wide association meta-analysis yields 20 loci associated with gallstone disease.
).
Bile acids play a critical role in the pathogenesis of cholelithiasis (
15Bile acids: Regulation of synthesis.
,
16- Chiang J.Y.L.
- Ferrell J.M.
Bile acid metabolism in liver pathobiology.
). Synthesized from cholesterol primarily in the liver, bile acids are conjugated with taurine or glycine and are secreted into the bile. Conjugated bile acids, known as bile salts, are stored in the gallbladder in fasting states. After meals, bile acids are released from the gallbladder into the intestine, where bile acids function as physiochemical detergents to facilitate the absorption of dietary lipids and fat-soluble vitamins (
15Bile acids: Regulation of synthesis.
,
16- Chiang J.Y.L.
- Ferrell J.M.
Bile acid metabolism in liver pathobiology.
). In the postabsorption phase, bile acids are absorbed from the intestine and are circulated back to the liver, where bile acids inhibit their own biosynthesis in a feedback regulatory loop. About 95% of bile acids are reabsorbed in the intestine and transported back to the liver. Such enterohepatic circulation of bile acids is instrumental for preventing bile acid overproduction, as abnormally higher bile acid concentrations in the liver can damage cell membranes, impair liver function, and cause cholestasis and cirrhosis (
15Bile acids: Regulation of synthesis.
,
16- Chiang J.Y.L.
- Ferrell J.M.
Bile acid metabolism in liver pathobiology.
). Key to the feedback regulation of bile acid biosynthesis is the farnesoid X receptor (Fxr),
3The abbreviations used are: Fxr
farnesoid X receptor
HFLD
high fat–containing LD
Ir
insulin receptor
LD
lithogenic diet
nt
nucleotides
qRT
quantitative RT
TG
triglyceride.
a member of the nuclear receptor superfamily (
17- Claudel T.
- Zollner G.
- Wagner M.
- Trauner M.
Role of nuclear receptors for bile acid metabolism, bile secretion, cholestasis, and gallstone disease.
,
18- Teodoro J.S.
- Rolo A.P.
- Palmeira C.M.
Hepatic FXR: Key regulator of whole-body energy metabolism.
,
19Nuclear receptors in bile acid metabolism.
). Expressed abundantly in the liver and to lesser extent the intestine, Fxr functions as a bile acid receptor (
15Bile acids: Regulation of synthesis.
,
17- Claudel T.
- Zollner G.
- Wagner M.
- Trauner M.
Role of nuclear receptors for bile acid metabolism, bile secretion, cholestasis, and gallstone disease.
). Upon its binding by bile acids, Fxr is translocated from the cytoplasm into the nucleus, where Fxr becomes active in suppressing hepatic expression of cholesterol 7 alpha-hydroxylase (Cyp7A1), the rate-limiting enzyme in the oxidation of cholesterol for bile acid biosynthesis (
20- Chiang J.Y.
- Kimmel R.
- Weinberger C.
- Stroup D.
Farnesoid X receptor responds to bile acids and represses cholesterol 7α-hydroxylase gene (CYP7A1) transcription.
). Such Fxr-dependent feedback loop is pivotal for maintaining normal bile acid homeostasis in the body. Indeed, Fxr-deficient mice are associated with impaired bile acid metabolism and increased susceptibility to developing gallstone disease (
17- Claudel T.
- Zollner G.
- Wagner M.
- Trauner M.
Role of nuclear receptors for bile acid metabolism, bile secretion, cholestasis, and gallstone disease.
,
21- Moschetta A.
- Bookout A.L.
- Mangelsdorf D.J.
Prevention of cholesterol gallstone disease by FXR agonists in a mouse model.
). Conversely, pharmacological activation of Fxr activity by its agonists protects against the formation of gallstones in the gallbladders in animal models and at-risk human subjects (
21- Moschetta A.
- Bookout A.L.
- Mangelsdorf D.J.
Prevention of cholesterol gallstone disease by FXR agonists in a mouse model.
,
22- Magouliotis D.E.
- Tasiopoulou V.S.
- Svokos A.A.
- Svokos K.A.
- Chatedaki C.
- Sioka E.
- Zacharoulis D.
Ursodeoxycholic acid in the prevention of gallstone formation after bariatric surgery: An updated systematic review and meta-analysis.
,
23- Stokes C.S.
- Gluud L.L.
- Casper M.
- Lammert F.
Ursodeoxycholic acid and diets higher in fat prevent gallbladder stones during weight loss: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.
). Furthermore, human subjects harboring genetic mutations in the FXR gene are associated with heightened risk of developing cholelithiasis (
24- Hirobe-Jahn S.
- Harsch S.
- Renner O.
- Richter D.
- Müller O.
- Stange E.F.
Association of FXR gene variants with cholelithiasis.
,
25- Kovacs P.
- Kress R.
- Rocha J.
- Kurtz U.
- Miquel J.F.
- Nervi F.
- Méndez-Sánchez N.
- Uribe M.
- Bock H.H.
- Schirin-Sokhan R.
- Stumvoll M.
- Mössner J.
- Lammert F.
- Wittenburg H.
Variation of the gene encoding the nuclear bile salt receptor FXR and gallstone susceptibility in mice and humans.
).
Epidemiology studies associate obesity and type 2 diabetes with cholelithiasis in both men and women (
26- Katsika D.
- Tuvblad C.
- Einarsson C.
- Lichtenstein P.
- Marschall H.U.
Body mass index, alcohol, tobacco and symptomatic gallstone disease: A Swedish twin study.
,
27- Al-Jiffry B.O.
- Shaffer E.A.
- Saccone G.T.
- Downey P.
- Kow L.
- Toouli J.
Changes in gallbladder motility and gallstone formation following laparoscopic gastric banding for morbid obesity.
,
28- Shiffman M.L.
- Sugerman H.J.
- Kellum J.H.
- Brewer W.H.
- Moore E.W.
Gallstones in patients with morbid obesity. Relationship to body weight, weight loss and gallbladder bile cholesterol solubility.
,
29- Bonfrate L.
- Wang D.Q.
- Garruti G.
- Portincasa P.
Obesity and the risk and prognosis of gallstone disease and pancreatitis.
,
30- Lv J.
- Yu C.
- Guo Y.
- Bian Z.
- Yang L.
- Chen Y.
- Li S.
- Huang Y.
- Fu Y.
- He P.
- Tang A.
- Chen J.
- Chen Z.
- Qi L.
- Li L.
Gallstone disease and the risk of type 2 diabetes.
,
31- Tung T.H.
- Ho H.M.
- Shih H.C.
- Chou P.
- Liu J.H.
- Chen V.T.
- Chan D.C.
- Liu C.M.
A population-based follow-up study on gallstone disease among type 2 diabetics in Kinmen, Taiwan.
,
32Gastrointestinal morbidity in obesity.
,
33- Wang F.
- Wang J.
- Li Y.
- Yuan J.
- Yao P.
- Wei S.
- Guo H.
- Zhang X.
- Yang H.
- Wu T.
- He M.
Gallstone disease and type 2 diabetes risk: A Mendelian randomization study.
). These data have spawned the idea that insulin resistance may be a predisposing factor for the pathogenesis of cholelithiasis. However, this idea seems at variance with some clinical and preclinical studies. First, the risk of cholelithiasis becomes higher, despite the improvement of insulin sensitivity and remission of diabetes, in humans with morbid obesity and type 2 diabetes following bariatric surgery (
34- Li V.K.
- Pulido N.
- Martinez-Suartez P.
- Fajnwaks P.
- Jin H.Y.
- Szomstein S.
- Rosenthal R.J.
Symptomatic gallstones after sleeve gastrectomy.
,
35Patients developed symptomatic gallstones between 3 and 21 months after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB), neither prophylactic cholecystectomy nor treatment with ursodeoxycholic acid is necessary after open RYGB.
,
36- Cazzo E.
- Gestic M.A.
- Utrini M.P.
- Machado R.R.
- Jimenez L.S.
- da Silva A.P.
- Baracat J.
- Callejas-Neto F.
- Pareja J.C.
- Chaim E.A.
Influence of insulin resistance status on the development of gallstones following Roux-En-Y gastric bypass: A prospective cohort study.
,
37Gallstones and bariatric surgery: To treat or not to treat?.
,
38- Morais M.
- Faria G.
- Preto J.
- Costa-Maia J.
Gallstones and bariatric surgery: To treat or not to treat?.
,
39- Li V.K.
- Pulido N.
- Fajnwaks P.
- Szomstein S.
- Rosenthal R.
- Martinez-Duartez P.
Predictors of gallstone formation after bariatric surgery: A multivariate analysis of risk factors comparing gastric bypass, gastric banding, and sleeve gastrectomy.
). Second, acute weight loss, derived from a low calorie diet regimen, is associated with an increased susceptibility to developing cholelithiasis, independently of insulin resistance (
23- Stokes C.S.
- Gluud L.L.
- Casper M.
- Lammert F.
Ursodeoxycholic acid and diets higher in fat prevent gallbladder stones during weight loss: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.
,
29- Bonfrate L.
- Wang D.Q.
- Garruti G.
- Portincasa P.
Obesity and the risk and prognosis of gallstone disease and pancreatitis.
,
40- Johansson K.
- Sundström J.
- Marcus C.
- Hemmingsson E.
- Neovius M.
Risk of symptomatic gallstones and cholecystectomy after a very-low-calorie diet or low-calorie diet in a commercial weight loss program: 1-year matched cohort study.
,
41Gallstones in obesity and weight loss.
). Third,
ob/ob or
db/db mice, despite their morbid obesity and severe insulin resistance, are refractory to developing gallstones (
42- Bouchard G.
- Johnson D.
- Carver T.
- Paigen B.
- Carey M.C.
Cholesterol gallstone formation in overweight mice establishes that obesity per se is not linked directly to cholelithiasis risk.
,
43- Hyogo H.
- Roy S.
- Cohen D.E.
Restoration of gallstone susceptibility by leptin in C57BL/6J ob/ob mice.
). These data highlight a significant gap of knowledge about the molecular basis that links obesity and insulin resistance to the pathogenesis of cholelithiasis.
In this context, a preclinical study by Biddinger
et al. (
44- Biddinger S.B.
- Haas J.T.
- Yu B.B.
- Bezy O.
- Jing E.
- Zhang W.
- Unterman T.G.
- Carey M.C.
- Kahn C.R.
Hepatic insulin resistance directly promotes formation of cholesterol gallstones.
) reports that hepatic insulin resistance directly promotes the formation of gallstones in mice, when fed a lithogenic diet (LD), a dietary regimen that is shown to stimulate gallstone formation in a number of animal models (
45Animal models of cholesterol gallstone disease.
,
46- Wang T.Y.
- Portincasa P.
- Liu M.
- Tso P.
- Wang D.Q.
Mouse models of gallstone disease.
). They show that mice with conditional insulin receptor (Ir) depletion in the liver develop gallstone disease, as result of genetically inherited insulin resistance in Ir-knockout mice (
44- Biddinger S.B.
- Haas J.T.
- Yu B.B.
- Bezy O.
- Jing E.
- Zhang W.
- Unterman T.G.
- Carey M.C.
- Kahn C.R.
Hepatic insulin resistance directly promotes formation of cholesterol gallstones.
). Nonetheless, the underlying mechanism connecting Ir deficiency to gallstone disease remains undefined. It is known that the forkhead box O1 (FoxO1) transcription factor acts downstream of the Ir signaling pathway to mediate the inhibitory action of insulin on target gene expression (
47FoxOs at the crossroads of cellular metabolism, differentiation, and transformation.
,
48- Barthel A.
- Schmoll D.
- Unterman T.G.
FoxO proteins in insulin action and metabolism.
,
49FoxO1 and hepatic lipid metabolism.
). FoxO1 activity is subject to insulin inhibition. In the absence of insulin, FoxO1 is active in the nucleus, in which FoxO1 binds to target promoters and stimulates target gene expression (
47FoxOs at the crossroads of cellular metabolism, differentiation, and transformation.
,
48- Barthel A.
- Schmoll D.
- Unterman T.G.
FoxO proteins in insulin action and metabolism.
,
49FoxO1 and hepatic lipid metabolism.
). In response to insulin, FoxO1 undergoes Akt-dependent phosphorylation and translocation from the nucleus to the cytoplasm (
50FoxO integration of insulin signaling with glucose and lipid metabolism.
). This effect accounts for insulin-dependent inactivation of FoxO1 activity. As a result of insulin resistance, hepatic FoxO1 activity becomes abnormally higher, because of the inability of FoxO1 to undergo Akt-dependent phosphorylation and translocation in obesity and type 2 diabetes (
50FoxO integration of insulin signaling with glucose and lipid metabolism.
). Likewise, genetic Ir depletion in the liver is expected to intercept insulin inhibition of FoxO1 activity, contributing to constitutive FoxO1 activity in insulin-resistant liver of Ir-knockout mice, although this point was not addressed in the study (
44- Biddinger S.B.
- Haas J.T.
- Yu B.B.
- Bezy O.
- Jing E.
- Zhang W.
- Unterman T.G.
- Carey M.C.
- Kahn C.R.
Hepatic insulin resistance directly promotes formation of cholesterol gallstones.
). Together these data implicate FoxO1 at the interface of insulin resistance and gallstone disease, inspiring us to hypothesize that genetic FoxO1 depletion would protect against the development of cholelithiasis in mice. To test this hypothesis, we generated mice with conditional FoxO1 depletion in the liver, using the FoxO1
LoxP/LoxP-Albumin-Cre system. Liver-conditional FoxO1-knockout mice
versus age/sex-matched WT littermates were fed on LD, followed by the determination of the effect of hepatic FoxO1 depletion on bile acid metabolism and gallstone disease. To corroborate these studies, we developed a high fat–containing lithogenic diet (HFLD) with 60% fat content, as the low fat content (15% fat) in LD is inadequate to induce obesity (
45Animal models of cholesterol gallstone disease.
,
46- Wang T.Y.
- Portincasa P.
- Liu M.
- Tso P.
- Wang D.Q.
Mouse models of gallstone disease.
). We replicated our studies by feeding liver-conditional FoxO1-knockout mice
versus age/sex-matched WT littermates the newly customized HFLD to further test our hypothesis that FoxO1 deregulation, resulting from overnutrition and insulin resistance, is culpable for the pathogenesis of cholelithiasis in obesity.
Discussion
Cholelithiasis is characterized by the formation of cholesterol stones in the gallbladder. Although the etiology of cholelithiasis is incompletely understood, its close association with obesity and type 2 diabetes implicates insulin resistance as a predisposing factor for gallstone disease (
26- Katsika D.
- Tuvblad C.
- Einarsson C.
- Lichtenstein P.
- Marschall H.U.
Body mass index, alcohol, tobacco and symptomatic gallstone disease: A Swedish twin study.
,
27- Al-Jiffry B.O.
- Shaffer E.A.
- Saccone G.T.
- Downey P.
- Kow L.
- Toouli J.
Changes in gallbladder motility and gallstone formation following laparoscopic gastric banding for morbid obesity.
,
28- Shiffman M.L.
- Sugerman H.J.
- Kellum J.H.
- Brewer W.H.
- Moore E.W.
Gallstones in patients with morbid obesity. Relationship to body weight, weight loss and gallbladder bile cholesterol solubility.
,
29- Bonfrate L.
- Wang D.Q.
- Garruti G.
- Portincasa P.
Obesity and the risk and prognosis of gallstone disease and pancreatitis.
,
30- Lv J.
- Yu C.
- Guo Y.
- Bian Z.
- Yang L.
- Chen Y.
- Li S.
- Huang Y.
- Fu Y.
- He P.
- Tang A.
- Chen J.
- Chen Z.
- Qi L.
- Li L.
Gallstone disease and the risk of type 2 diabetes.
,
31- Tung T.H.
- Ho H.M.
- Shih H.C.
- Chou P.
- Liu J.H.
- Chen V.T.
- Chan D.C.
- Liu C.M.
A population-based follow-up study on gallstone disease among type 2 diabetics in Kinmen, Taiwan.
,
32Gastrointestinal morbidity in obesity.
,
33- Wang F.
- Wang J.
- Li Y.
- Yuan J.
- Yao P.
- Wei S.
- Guo H.
- Zhang X.
- Yang H.
- Wu T.
- He M.
Gallstone disease and type 2 diabetes risk: A Mendelian randomization study.
). Nonetheless, given the controversial data in the literature, it remains a long-standing question as to how insulin resistance contributes to the pathogenesis of gallstone disease. Our goal in this study is to address the hypothesis that FoxO1 integrates insulin resistance to gallstone disease, and hepatic FoxO1 depletion would protect against the formation of gallbladder stones in mice with insulin resistance and obesity. This hypothesis dwelled on three lines of evidence in the literature. First, hepatic FoxO1 activity becomes abnormally higher, because of an impaired ability of insulin to inhibit FoxO1 activity in insulin-resistant liver, contributing to the deregulation in glucose and lipid metabolism in obesity and type 2 diabetes (
47FoxOs at the crossroads of cellular metabolism, differentiation, and transformation.
,
48- Barthel A.
- Schmoll D.
- Unterman T.G.
FoxO proteins in insulin action and metabolism.
,
50FoxO integration of insulin signaling with glucose and lipid metabolism.
). Second, FoxO1 deregulation is associated with abnormal bile acid metabolism in mice (
63- Haeusler R.A.
- Pratt-Hyatt M.
- Welch C.L.
- Klaassen C.D.
- Accili D.
Impaired generation of 12-hydroxylated bile acids links hepatic insulin signaling with dyslipidemia.
). Third, insulin resistance, resulting from genetic Ir depletion in the liver, is associated with increased susceptibility to developing gallstone disease in mice (
44- Biddinger S.B.
- Haas J.T.
- Yu B.B.
- Bezy O.
- Jing E.
- Zhang W.
- Unterman T.G.
- Carey M.C.
- Kahn C.R.
Hepatic insulin resistance directly promotes formation of cholesterol gallstones.
). To address this hypothesis, we determined the effect of FoxO1 on gallstone disease in L-FoxO1-KO mice and sex/weight-matched WT littermates following 12 weeks of LD feeding. We detected a similar incidence rate and similar mean weight of gallstones in mice between L-FoxO1-KO and WT groups. We recapitulated these findings in both male and female mice. These results suggest that hepatic FoxO1 depletion neither affected the onset of gallstone disease nor impacted the disease progression, regardless of sex.
We noted that LD contains 15% fat. Although potent for inducing gallstone disease, LD did not induce obesity and insulin resistance in mice. We then overcame this limitation by feeding mice a newly developed HFLD with 60% fat. As expected, a 12-week HFLD feeding resulted in moderate obesity with a concomitant induction of insulin resistance in L-FoxO1-KO and WT groups. Furthermore, HFLD feeding resulted in a significant induction of hepatic fat infiltration, characteristic of nonalcoholic fat disease. However, HFLD feeding did not exacerbate the incidence rate of gallstone disease. L-FoxO1-KO and WT littermates had a similar incidence rate of gallstone formation (∼50%) and a similar mean weight of gallbladder stones. These results were reproducible in male and female mice. Taken together, our data argue against the notion that FoxO1 is culpable for linking insulin resistance to the pathogenesis of cholelithiasis.
These results, which defied our original hypothesis, were totally unexpected. An intuitive explanation is that hepatic FoxO1 depletion begot a compensatory up-regulation of FoxO3, FoxO4, or FoxO6, three other FoxO members with functional redundancy in the liver (
64- Haeusler R.A.
- Kaestner K.H.
- Accili D.
FoxOs function synergistically to promote glucose production.
). This would marginalize the effect of hepatic FoxO1 depletion on the pathogenesis of gallstone disease. However, this possibility was ruled out, as we did not detect significant increases in hepatic expression of other FoxO isoforms in L-FoxO1-KO mice. Instead, we showed that FoxO1 exerted a direct effect on hepatic bile acid metabolism, as hepatic FoxO1 depletion resulted in a significant reduction in hepatic expression of Cyp7A1, the rate-limiting enzyme in the classic bile acid biosynthesis pathway. In keeping with our findings, three independent groups reported that FoxO1 is a positive regulator of the Cyp7A1 gene in rodents (
65- Li T.
- Kong X.
- Owsley E.
- Ellis E.
- Strom S.
- Chiang J.Y.
Insulin regulation of cholesterol 7α-hydroxylase expression in human hepatocytes: Roles of forkhead box O1 and sterol regulatory element-binding protein 1c.
,
66- Zhang W.
- Patil S.
- Chauhan B.
- Guo S.
- Powell D.R.
- Le J.
- Klotsas A.
- Matika R.
- Xiao X.
- Franks R.
- Heidenreich K.A.
- Sajan M.P.
- Farese R.V.
- Stolz D.B.
- Tso P.
- Koo S.H.
- Montminy M.
- Unterman T.G.
FoxO1 regulates multiple metabolic pathways in the liver: Effects on gluconeogenic, glycolytic, and lipogenic gene expression.
,
67Insulin-dependent suppression of cholesterol 7α-hydroxylase is a possible link between glucose and cholesterol metabolisms.
). FoxO1 binds to its consensus site within the Cyp7A1 promoter and stimulates Cyp7A1 expression in the liver (
65- Li T.
- Kong X.
- Owsley E.
- Ellis E.
- Strom S.
- Chiang J.Y.
Insulin regulation of cholesterol 7α-hydroxylase expression in human hepatocytes: Roles of forkhead box O1 and sterol regulatory element-binding protein 1c.
,
67Insulin-dependent suppression of cholesterol 7α-hydroxylase is a possible link between glucose and cholesterol metabolisms.
). This effect is counteracted by insulin, a mechanism that accounts in part for insulin-dependent inhibition of bile acid biosynthesis in the liver (
68- Twisk J.
- Hoekman M.F.
- Lehmann E.M.
- Meijer P.
- Mager W.H.
- Princen H.M.
Insulin suppresses bile acid synthesis in cultured rat hepatocytes by down-regulation of cholesterol 7 α-hydroxylase and sterol 27-hydroxylase gene transcription.
). Likewise, insulin also exerts an inhibitory effect on hepatic expression of Cyp27A1 and Cyp7B1, two key enzymes that catalyze bile acid biosynthesis in the alternative pathway (
16- Chiang J.Y.L.
- Ferrell J.M.
Bile acid metabolism in liver pathobiology.
). We detected a significant reduction in hepatic expression of Cyp27A1 and Cyp7B1 in the liver of L-FoxO1-KO
versus WT mice. These results underscore the physiological importance of FoxO1 in regulating bile acid biosynthesis in the liver.
Aside from its direct impact on bile acid biosynthesis, FoxO1 appears to play an important role in regulating biliary cholesterol secretion. We showed that FoxO1 loss-of-function attenuated hepatic expression of Abcg5 and Abcg8, two cholesterol transporters that function in heterodimers to facilitate biliary cholesterol secretion was attenuated in the liver of L-FoxO1-KO mice. These results are consistent with the previous findings that FoxO1 targets the Abcg5 and Abcg8 genes for
trans-activation (
44- Biddinger S.B.
- Haas J.T.
- Yu B.B.
- Bezy O.
- Jing E.
- Zhang W.
- Unterman T.G.
- Carey M.C.
- Kahn C.R.
Hepatic insulin resistance directly promotes formation of cholesterol gallstones.
). Consistent with their functions in obligate heterodimers, Abcg5 and Abcg8 are coordinately regulated at the transcriptional level, as they share a common bidirectional promoter (374 bp), from which Abcg5 and Abcg8 genes are transcribed in opposing directions. Clinical studies indicate that human subjects harboring a common ABCG8-D19H allele are associated with increased susceptibility to developing gallstone disease (
69- Katsika D.
- Magnusson P.
- Krawczyk M.
- Grünhage F.
- Lichtenstein P.
- Einarsson C.
- Lammert F.
- Marschall H.U.
Gallstone disease in Swedish twins: Risk is associated with ABCG8 D19H genotype.
,
70- von Kampen O.
- Buch S.
- Nothnagel M.
- Azocar L.
- Molina H.
- Brosch M.
- Erhart W.
- von Schönfels W.
- Egberts J.
- Seeger M.
- Arlt A.
- Balschun T.
- Franke A.
- Lerch M.M.
- Mayerle J.
- et al.
Genetic and functional identification of the likely causative variant for cholesterol gallstone disease at the ABCG5/8 lithogenic locus.
). Preclinical studies show that elevated Abcg5 and Abcg8 expression, resulting from insulin resistance, increases biliary cholesterol secretion, translating to a significant risk of cholesterol gallstone formation (
44- Biddinger S.B.
- Haas J.T.
- Yu B.B.
- Bezy O.
- Jing E.
- Zhang W.
- Unterman T.G.
- Carey M.C.
- Kahn C.R.
Hepatic insulin resistance directly promotes formation of cholesterol gallstones.
). Indeed, FoxO1 activity becomes unchecked in insulin-resistant states (
47FoxOs at the crossroads of cellular metabolism, differentiation, and transformation.
,
48- Barthel A.
- Schmoll D.
- Unterman T.G.
FoxO proteins in insulin action and metabolism.
,
50FoxO integration of insulin signaling with glucose and lipid metabolism.
). Our data along with previous observations provide further physiological underpinning for the idea that FoxO1 is liable for coupling insulin resistance to biliary cholesterol hypersecretion in the pathogenesis of cholesterol gallstone disease.
Another significant finding derived from our studies is the revelation of the mechanism by which FoxO1 counteracts Fxr, a bile acid receptor whose function is instrumental for maintaining normal bile acid homeostasis in the body (
15Bile acids: Regulation of synthesis.
,
17- Claudel T.
- Zollner G.
- Wagner M.
- Trauner M.
Role of nuclear receptors for bile acid metabolism, bile secretion, cholestasis, and gallstone disease.
). We showed that FoxO1 binds to its consensus site within the Fxr promoter and inhibits Fxr expression in hepatocytes. We reproduced these data
in vitro and
in vivo. As a result of hepatic FoxO1 depletion, Fxr is markedly up-regulated in the liver of L-FoxO1-KO mice. These data suggest that FoxO1 counterbalances the effect of Fxr function on bile acid metabolism by inhibiting Fxr production in the liver. Although hepatic Fxr expression becomes markedly down-regulated in insulin-deficient and insulin-resistant livers, contributing in part to the alterations in bile acid metabolism in diabetes, the underlying mechanism still remains elusive (
51- Duran-Sandoval D.
- Mautino G.
- Martin G.
- Percevault F.
- Barbier O.
- Fruchart J.C.
- Kuipers F.
- Staels B.
Glucose regulates the expression of the farnesoid X receptor in liver.
). Our data provide important mechanistic insights into the mechanism by which hepatic Fxr expression is down-regulated in diabetes. In response to insulin deficiency or insulin resistance, FoxO1 activity becomes abnormally higher (
47FoxOs at the crossroads of cellular metabolism, differentiation, and transformation.
,
48- Barthel A.
- Schmoll D.
- Unterman T.G.
FoxO proteins in insulin action and metabolism.
,
50FoxO integration of insulin signaling with glucose and lipid metabolism.
), contributing to the suppression of hepatic Fxr production and impaired bile acid metabolism in diabetes (
51- Duran-Sandoval D.
- Mautino G.
- Martin G.
- Percevault F.
- Barbier O.
- Fruchart J.C.
- Kuipers F.
- Staels B.
Glucose regulates the expression of the farnesoid X receptor in liver.
).
Moreover, we found that hepatic FoxO1 depletion resulted in a significant reduction in hepatic expression of Abcb4, also known as the multidrug resistance gene (MDR3) in humans (
71- Zhao Y.
- Ishigami M.
- Nagao K.
- Hanada K.
- Kono N.
- Arai H.
- Matsuo M.
- Kioka N.
- Ueda K.
ABCB4 exports phosphatidylcholine in a sphingomyelin-dependent manner.
). Abcb4 is expressed mainly in the liver and acts as a phospholipid transporter for transporting phosphatidylcholine into the bile (
71- Zhao Y.
- Ishigami M.
- Nagao K.
- Hanada K.
- Kono N.
- Arai H.
- Matsuo M.
- Kioka N.
- Ueda K.
ABCB4 exports phosphatidylcholine in a sphingomyelin-dependent manner.
). Genetic ABCB4 variants are associated with intrahepatic cholestasis and cholesterol gallstone disease in humans (
72- Rosmorduc O.
- Hermelin B.
- Poupon R.
MDR3 gene defect in adults with symptomatic intrahepatic and gallbladder cholesterol cholelithiasis.
,
73- Weber S.N.
- Bopp C.
- Krawczyk M.
- Lammert F.
Genetics of gallstone disease revisited: Updated inventory of human lithogenic genes.
). Our data indicate that Abcb4 is down-regulated in FoxO1-deficient liver, suggesting that the Abcb4 gene is a FoxO1 target. Consistent with this interpretation is that hepatic Abcb4 expression is up-regulated, coinciding with the induction of hepatic FoxO1 activity in dietary obese mice (
74- Ghoneim R.H.
- Ngo Sock E.T.
- Lavoie J.M.
- Piquette-Miller M.
Effect of a high-fat diet on the hepatic expression of nuclear receptors and their target genes: Relevance to drug disposition.
,
75- Qu S.
- Altomonte J.
- Perdomo G.
- He J.
- Fan Y.
- Kamagate A.
- Meseck M.
- Dong H.H.
Aberrant Forkhead box O1 function is associated with impaired hepatic metabolism.
). Further investigation is needed to assess the contribution of FoxO1 signaling via Abcb4 to bile acid metabolism and risk of gallstone disease in obesity and type 2 diabetes.
In conclusion, our studies revealed that FoxO1 plays an independent role in maintaining normal bile acid homeostasis by regulating hepatic expression of key genes involved in bile acid synthesis, biliary cholesterol secretion, and phospholipid secretion. Furthermore, FoxO1 acts to attenuate bile acid signaling by counteracting Fxr activity in the liver. Although abnormally higher FoxO1 activity, resulting from insulin resistance, is associated with impaired bile acid metabolism and risk of cholelithiasis, hepatic FoxO1 deficiency did not confer a protective effect on the development of gallstone disease in mice on LD and HFLD diets, respectively. We acknowledge a limitation in the scope of our studies, as we only employed FoxO1-deficient models. Our data could not preclude the possibility that hepatic FoxO1 overproduction would predispose to developing gallstone disease in mice. Therefore, further studies are warranted to understand the molecular basis that mechanistically links insulin resistance to gallstone disease.
Experimental procedures
Animal studies
FoxO1
loxP/loxP mice encoding two LoxP sites flanking the second exon of FoxO1 were described (
76- Paik J.H.
- Kollipara R.
- Chu G.
- Ji H.
- Xiao Y.
- Ding Z.
- Miao L.
- Tothova Z.
- Horner J.W.
- Carrasco D.R.
- Jiang S.
- Gilliland D.G.
- Chin L.
- Wong W.H.
- Castrillon D.H.
- DePinho R.A.
FoxOs are lineage-restricted redundant tumor suppressors and regulate endothelial cell homeostasis.
). We rederived the FoxO1
loxP/loxP allele in the C57BL/6 mice, followed by crossing with C57BL/6 mice for more than five generations. To deplete FoxO1 in the liver, we crossed FoxO1
loxP/loxP mice with C57BL/6-Albumin-Cre mice (The Jackson Laboratory, Bar Harbor, ME). The resulting progenies were genotyped by PCR assay for the FoxO1
loxP/loxP and Albumin-Cre alleles, as described (
64- Haeusler R.A.
- Kaestner K.H.
- Accili D.
FoxOs function synergistically to promote glucose production.
). Mice were fed standard rodent chow and water
ad libitum in sterile cages with a 12-h light/dark cycle in a pathogen-free barrier facility of Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh of UPMC. To induce gallstone disease, mice were fed on LD containing 15.8% fat, 1.25% cholesterol, and 0.5% sodium cholate (Teklad Diet TD88051, Envigo). To induce both insulin resistance and gallstone disease, we developed HFLD containing 60% fat, 1.25% cholesterol, and 0.5% sodium cholate (Teklad Diet, Customized TD190158). For blood chemistry, mice were fasted for 16 h and tail vein blood was sampled. Blood glucose levels were measured, using Glucometer (Contour Next BG Monitoring System). Plasma insulin levels were determined, using the ultrasensitive mouse insulin ELISA (ALPCO, Windham, NH). Fat mass and lean mass of mice were determined using the EchoMRI-100 system (Echo Medical Systems, Houston, TX). The homeostasis model for insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) was determined by multiplying fasting blood glucose (mmol/liter) and fasting plasma insulin (μIU/ml) levels, divided by 22.5. Plasma levels of triglyceride and cholesterol were determined using Thermo Infinity triglyceride and cholesterol reagents (Thermo Fisher Scientific). Plasma phospholipid levels were measured using the phospholipid assay kit (Sigma-Aldrich). Plasma bile acid levels were determined, using the bile acid assay kit (Cell Biolabs, Inc.). Mice were euthanized to collect liver and gallbladder tissues for analysis. All procedures were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) of University of Pittsburgh.
Luciferase reporter assay
We used the Dual-Luciferase reporter system (Promega, Madison, WI) for determining promoter activity. To clone the human Fxr promoter (1.8 kb), we subjected human genomic DNA isolated from HepG2 cells to PCR assay using the primers (5′-CATCTCTGCTGGAGAGAATG-3′ and 5′-AGAGTTCCAGTGTACTGTGC-3′) that flank the human Fxr promoter (−1721/+133 nt). The Fxr promoter DNA was cloned into the pGL3-Basic plasmid (Promega) encoding the luciferase reporter gene. To determine Fxr promoter activity, HepG2 cells were transduced in 12-well plates with 50 plaque-forming units/cell of Adv-FoxO1 or Adv-Empty vector, followed by transfection with 2 μg of pFxr-Luc encoding the Fxr promoter-directed luciferase reporter system. pGL4.75 expressing Renilla luciferase (Promega) was included as control for normalizing transfection efficiency. Plasmid pGL3-basic encoding promoter-less luciferase was used as control for determining the baseline luciferase activity. After 24-h incubation in the absence or presence of Fxr agonist GW4064 (final concentration 1 μm; Sigma-Aldrich), cells were starved in serum-free medium for 6 h and were subjected to the Dual-Luciferase activity assay for determining Fxr promoter activity.
ChIP assay
ChIP assay was performed as described (
77- Kim D.H.
- Perdomo G.
- Zhang T.
- Slusher S.
- Lee S.
- Phillips B.E.
- Fan Y.
- Giannoukakis N.
- Gramignoli R.
- Strom S.
- Ringquist S.
- Dong H.H.
FoxO6 integrates insulin signaling with gluconeogenesis in the liver.
). Because of extremely low FoxO1 expression in HepG2 cells, we used HepG2 cells pretransduced with Adv-FoxO1 vector (50 plaque-forming units/cell) in the ChIP assay for determining FoxO1 interaction with the human Fxr promoter, using anti-FoxO1 or anti-β-gal IgG as control. The immunoprecipitates were subjected to PCR analysis using the primers (5′-ATCTAACCAGAGCCTGTGCT-3′ and 5′-ACTGAACTAGAAGCTGGGAG-3′) flanking the consensus FoxO1-binding site (−481/−250 nt) within the human Fxr promoter. As input control, aliquots of cell lysates (5 μl) prior to immunoprecipitation were analyzed in the same PCR assay. As off-target control, the immunoprecipitates were subjected to PCR assay, using the primers (5′-GCTCAAAGTGAACACTGCTTCT-3′ and 5′-TCATCTGTGGTAGGTAAATGGGA-3′) flanking the human Fxr cDNA region (−139/+53 nt).
RNA isolation and real-time qRT-PCR
Total RNA was prepared from the liver using the TRIzol Reagent (Invitrogen). Real-time quantitative RT-PCR was used for quantifying mRNA concentrations using the Roche LightCycler-RNA amplification kit (Roche Diagnostics), as described (
52- Kamagate A.
- Qu S.
- Perdomo G.
- Su D.
- Kim D.H.
- Slusher S.
- Meseck M.
- Dong H.H.
FoxO1 mediates insulin-dependent regulation of hepatic VLDL production in mice.
). All primers (
Table S1) were obtained commercially from Integrated DNA Technologies (Coralville, IA).
Western blotting assay
Mice were euthanized for tissue procurement. Aliquots of liver tissues (10 mg) were homogenized in 350-μl M-PER supplemented with 3.5-μl Halt Protease Inhibitor Mixture (Pierce). After centrifugation in microtubes at 13,000 rpm for 10 min, aliquots of protein lysates (20 μg) were subjected to immunoblot analysis, using rabbit anti-Fxr (Abcam cat. no. 155124) and mouse anti-actin (Sigma-Aldrich, cat. no. A1978) antibodies, respectively. Polyclonal rabbit anti-FoxO1 antibody was described elsewhere (
75- Qu S.
- Altomonte J.
- Perdomo G.
- He J.
- Fan Y.
- Kamagate A.
- Meseck M.
- Dong H.H.
Aberrant Forkhead box O1 function is associated with impaired hepatic metabolism.
).
Liver histology
Liver tissues were embedded in the HistoPrep tissue-embedding media. Frozen sections (6 μm in thickness) were stained with Oil Red O, followed by counterstaining with hematoxylin. Paraffin-embedded sections (6 μm in thickness) were stained with hematoxylin and eosin in the Biospecimen Repository and Processing Core of the Pittsburgh Liver Research Center.
Gallstone determination
Mice were euthanized after 6-h fasting. Gallbladder was procured from individual mice. Gallbladder was incised under a dissecting microscope and the gallbladder content containing gallstones was collected into individual microtubes. The gallstone sample was dried and gallstone weight was determined.
Hepatic triglyceride content
Liver tissues (10 mg) were homogenized in 200-μl HPLC-grade acetone. After incubation with agitation at room temperature for 16 h, aliquots (10 μl) of acetone-extracted lipid suspension were used for determining triglyceride concentration, using the Infinity triglyceride reagent (Thermo Fisher Scientific). Hepatic triglyceride content was defined as milligrams of triglyceride per gram of total liver proteins.
Hepatic cholesterol content
Liver tissues (10 mg) were homogenized in 200 μl of chloroform:isopropanol (7:11 in volume) at 4 °C. After centrifugation in microtubes at 10,000 rpm for 5 min, aliquots (20 μl) of hexane-isopropanol–extracted cholesterol suspension were used for determining cholesterol concentration, using the Infinity cholesterol reagent (Thermo Fisher Scientific). Hepatic cholesterol content was defined as milligrams of cholesterol per gram of total liver proteins.
Hepatic bile acid content
Liver tissues (10 mg) were homogenized in 300 μl of PBS buffer, followed by determination of bile acid concentration, using the bile acid assay kit (Cell Biolabs Inc.). Hepatic bile acid content was defined as milligrams of bile acids per gram of total liver proteins.
Fecal triglyceride content
Feces were collected from individual mice during a 24-h period under fed conditions. Aliquots of feces (50 mg) were homogenized in 200 μl HPLC-grade acetone, followed by 30-min incubation with agitation at room temperature. Fecal TG content, defined as milligrams of TG per gram of feces, was determined in acetone-extract lipid suspension, using the Infinity triglyceride reagent (Thermo Fisher Scientific).
Fecal cholesterol content
Aliquots of feces (50 mg) were homogenized in 200 μl of chloroform:isopropanol (7:11 in volume) at 4 °C. After centrifugation in microtubes at 10,000 rpm for 5 min, aliquots (20 μl) of hexane-isopropanol–extracted fecal suspension were used for determining fecal cholesterol content, defined as milligrams of cholesterol per gram of feces.
Fecal bile acid content
Aliquots of feces (50 mg) were homogenized in 200 μl of PBS buffer. After centrifugation in microtubes at 10,000 rpm for 5 min, aliquots (20 μl) of supernatants were used for determining bile acid content, using the bile acid assay kit (Cell Biolabs Inc.).
Statistics
Statistics of data were analyzed by unpaired Student's t test, using the GraphPad Prism 7.0. Data are expressed as means ± S.D. p values <0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Data availability
We state that all data are in the manuscript.
Author contributions
X. F., C. Z., S. L., J. G., P. Z., J. Y., C. P., S. S., R. M., and H. H. D. data curation; X. F., C. Z., S. L., J. G., P. Z., J. Y., and H. H. D. formal analysis; X. F., C. Z., S. L., P. Z., J. Y., C. P., S. S., R. M., S. P. M., and H. H. D. investigation; X. F., C. Z., S. L., J. G., P. Z., J. Y., C. P., S. S., R. M., S. P. M., and H. H. D. methodology; S. Q., Y. P., and H. H. D. conceptualization; S. Q., Y. P., and H. H. D. supervision; S. Q., S. P. M., Y. P., and H. H. D. writing-review and editing; R. M. and H. H. D. project administration; H. H. D. resources; H. H. D. software; H. H. D. funding acquisition; H. H. D. validation; H. H. D. visualization; H. H. D. writing-original draft.
Article info
Publication history
Published online: April 09, 2020
Received in revised form:
April 7,
2020
Received:
December 11,
2019
Edited by Jeffrey E. Pessin
Footnotes
This work was supported by UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh and NIDDK, National Institutes of Health Grant 1R01DK120310-01A1 (to H. H. D.) and P30DK120531 (to S. P. M.). C. Z. is a visiting scholar sponsored by China Scholarship Council 201806260074. The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest with the contents of this article. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
This article contains Figs. S1–S5 and Tables S1–S4.
Copyright
© 2020 Feng et al.